FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Bridging Capital Holdings Pty Ltd v Self Directed Super Funds Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 1625
File number: NSD 1065 of 2021 Judgment of: STEWART J Date of judgment: 21 December 2021 Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – valuation of shares pursuant to an order made to purchase shares under s 233(1)(d) of the Corporations Act 2001 – where order for majority shareholder to purchase shares of minority shareholder made by consent – where no finding of oppression by majority shareholder – where shareholders’ relationship has broken down – whether a minority discount on valuation should be applied Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 233 Cases cited: Re Abbey Leisure Ltd [1990] BCLC 342
Re Bird Precision Bellows Ltd [1984] Ch 419
Re Bird Precision Bellows Ltd [1986] Ch 658
Dynasty Pty Ltd v Coombs [1995] FCA 610; 59 FCR 122
Martis Cork & Rajan Pty Ltd v Benjamin Corporation Pty Ltd [2004] FCAFC 153; 204 ALR 136
Division: General Division Registry: New South Wales National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency Number of paragraphs: 26 Date of hearing: 20 December 2021 Counsel for the Plaintiff: M Karam and A Reid Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Bartier Perry Counsel for the First and Fifth Defendants: R Ross-Smith Solicitor for the First and Fifth Defendants: DW Fox Tucker Lawyers ORDERS
NSD 1065 of 2021 BETWEEN: BRIDGING CAPITAL HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 645 613 994
Plaintiff
AND: SELF DIRECTED SUPER FUNDS PTY LTD ACN 606 004 077
First Defendant
WHISBEE NOMINEES PTY LTD ACN 639 807 391
Second Defendant
EXELSUPER PTY LTD ACN 124 648 193 (and others named in the Schedule)
Third Defendant
ORDER MADE BY:
STEWART J
DATE OF ORDER:
21 DECEMBER 2021
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
Referee’s report and valuation of the plaintiff’s interests
1.Pursuant to r 28.67(1) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the report of the referee Mr Nicholas Navarra dated 8 December 2021 be adopted.
2.With reference to Order 1 of the orders made on 22 November 2021 and subject to any adjustment in value as provided for in Orders 8 – 12 below:
(a)the provisional value of the plaintiff’s shares in the third defendant is $236,173; and
(b)the first and fifth defendants pay the amount of $236,173 to the plaintiff within 28 days of these orders.
3.With reference to Order 2 of the orders made on 22 November 2021 and subject to any adjustment in value as provided for in Orders 8 – 12 below:
(a)the provisional value of the plaintiff’s shares in the fourth defendant is $46,066; and
(b)the fifth defendant pay the amount of $46,066 to the plaintiff within 28 days of these orders.
4.Upon the plaintiff receiving payment of the amount referred to in Order 2(b) above, the plaintiff provide to the first defendant an executed share transfer (in a registrable form) in respect of the plaintiff’s shares in the third defendant.
5.Upon the plaintiff receiving payment of the amount referred to in Order 3(b) above,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bridging Capital Holdings Pty Ltd v Self Directed Super Fund... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] FCA 1625
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the provisions of the Corporations Act relevant to the purchase of shares by consent and the valuation of those shares. The court noted that while a minority discount may be appropriate in cases of oppression, it is not necessarily applicable in all cases where there is a breakdown in relationships between shareholders. The court found that the relationship between the parties had deteriorated significantly, but there was no finding of oppression by SDSF. The court concluded that a minority discount should not be applied in this case because the oppression provisions were not engaged, and the strained relationship alone did not warrant a discount. The court emphasised that the primary consideration should be the fair market value of the shares at the time of purchase.
The court adopted the referee's valuation of BCH's shares in Exelsuper and Exelsuper Advice and ordered that the defendants pay the provisional values to BCH. The court also set out a timetable for the parties to address the outstanding issues of costs and potential adjustments to the share values based on the operation of indemnities in the Share Sale Agreement. The court scheduled a hearing for these issues and noted agreements between the parties regarding the resignation of Mr Ari Ben Moses as a director of Exelsuper and Exelsuper Advice upon payment to BCH.
Orders
Orders of the court
Referee’s report and valuation of the plaintiff’s interests
1. Pursuant to r 28.67(1) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the report of the referee Mr Nicholas Navarra dated 8 December 2021 be adopted.
2. With reference to Order 1 of the orders made on 22 November 2021 and subject to any adjustment in value as provided for in Orders 8 – 12 below:
(a) the provisional value of the plaintiff’s shares in the third defendant is $236,173; and
(b) the first and fifth defendants pay the amount of $236,173 to the plaintiff within 28 days of these orders.
3. With reference to Order 2 of the orders made on 22 November 2021 and subject to any adjustment in value as provided for in Orders 8 – 12 below:
(a) the provisional value of the plaintiff’s shares in the fourth defendant is $46,066; and
(b) the fifth defendant pay the amount of $46,066 to the plaintiff within 28 days of these orders.
4. Upon the plaintiff receiving payment of the amount referred to in Order 2(b) above, the plaintiff provide to the first defendant an executed share transfer (in a registrable form) in respect of the plaintiff’s shares in the third defendant.
5. Upon the plaintiff receiving payment of the amount referred to in Order 3(b) above, the plaintiff provide to the first defendant an executed share transfer (in a registrable form) in respect of the plaintiff’s shares in the fourth defendant.
6. Prayers 4 – 11 of the plaintiff’s amended originating process filed on 8 November 2021 be dismissed.
7. The plaintiff’s notice to produce dated 3 November 2021 be set aside.
Costs of the proceeding and outstanding valuation issue
8. By 18 February 2022, the plaintiff file and serve:
(a) any written submissions (of no more than 5 pages) on the costs of the proceeding (the costs issue) and any evidence in support; and
(b) any written submissions (of no more than 5 pages) on any adjustment of the share values in orders 2 and 3 arising from the issues identified in sections 5.4.4 and 5.4.7 of the report of the referee Mr Nicholas Navarra dated 8 December 2021 regarding the operation of the indemnities provided under the Share Sale Agreement and consequential orders giving effect thereto (the indemnities issue), and any evidence in support.
9. By 11 March 2022, the first, second and fifth defendants file and serve:
(a) any written submissions (of no more than 5 pages) on the costs issue and any evidence in support; and
(b) any written submissions (of no more than 5 pages) on the indemnities issue and any evidence in support.
10. By 18 March 2022, the plaintiff file and serve:
(a) any written submissions (of no more than 2 pages) and evidence in reply on the costs issue; and
(b) any written submissions (of no more than 2 pages) and evidence in reply on the indemnities issue.
11. By 25 March 2022, the parties jointly provide to the Associate to Stewart J:
(a) a list of the evidential material to be relied on at the hearing referred to in Order 12; and
(b) the authorities to be relied on at the hearing referred to in Order 12, with each authority being a separate PDF word-searchable document.
12. The proceeding be listed for hearing at 10:15 am on 6 April 2021 for the determination of the costs issue and the indemnities issue.
AND THE COURT NOTES THAT:
13. Upon the plaintiff receiving payment of the amount referred to in Order 2(b) above, the parties have agreed that Mr Ari Ben Moses will provide written notice to the third defendant of his resignation as a director.
14. Upon the plaintiff receiving payment of the amount referred to in Order 3(b) above, the parties have agreed that Mr Ari Ben Moses will provide written notice to the fourth defendant of his resignation as a director.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
By originating process dated 14 October 2021, the plaintiff, Bridging Capital Holdings Pty Ltd (BCH), applied for interlocutory orders pursuant to s 472(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) that provisional liquidators be appointed to the third defendant, Exelsuper Pty Ltd, or, alternatively, orders pursuant to s 233(1) of the Corporations Act or s 57(1) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (FCA Act) for the appointment of receivers and managers to Exelsuper and ancillary relief. BCH also applied for final orders that Exelsuper be wound up pursuant to ss 461(1)(k) or 233(1)(a) of the Corporations Act, or alternatively orders that the first and/or second defendant (SDSF and Whisbee Nominees Pty Ltd respectively) purchase BCH’s interests in Exelsuper. On 20 October 2021, the proceeding was listed for interlocutory hearing on 8 November 2021 and orders were made for the exchange of further evidence and submissions in relation to the application for interlocutory relief. In its written submissions for the interlocutory hearing filed on 4 November 2021, SDSF indicated that it was prepared to purchase BCH’s shares in Exelsuper at their market value as a means of resolving the application for interlocutory relief. By 8 November 2021, it was also agreed between the parties that upon the joinder of the fourth and fifth defendants (Exelsuper Advice Pty Ltd and Mr Christopher Harris respectively), SDSF and Mr Harris would consent to orders being made for the purchase of BCH’s shares in both Exelsuper and Exelsuper Advice at market value. By way of background, Exelsuper operates a financial planning and self-managed superannuation administration business together with Exelsuper Advice, which holds an Australian Financial Services Licence. BCH, SDSF and Whisbee are the shareholders of Exelsuper. Mr Ari Ben Moses and Mr Harris are joint directors of Exelsuper. BCH and Mr Harris are the shareholders of Exelsuper Advice. Mr Moses and Mr Harris are also joint directors of Exelsuper Advice. BCH acquired its shares in each of Exelsuper and Exelsuper Advice pursuant to the terms of a Share Sale Agreement entered into in March 2021. Its equity interest in Exelsuper amounts to 43.61%, and its equity interest in Exelsuper Advice amounts to 45%. Since that time, the relationship between the directors and shareholders of these entities has been strained, and Mr Moses complains that he has been deprived of complete access to the business records of Exelsuper and Exelsuper Advice, including financial records required to verify the nature of various payments from Exelsuper’s bank accounts. It appears to be common ground that the directors and shareholders are at loggerheads and that the companies cannot survive unless there is a parting of ways. Between 8 and 22 November 2021, the parties corresponded regarding the appropriate form of orders to implement the purchase of BCH’s shares and determine their market value. On 22 November 2021, consent orders were made pursuant to s 233(1)(d) of the Corporations Act for the purchase of BCH’s shares in Exelsuper and Exelsuper Advice by SDSF and/or Mr Harris and the question of the value to be applied to BCH’s shareholdings was referred to a referee, Mr Nicholas Navarra, pursuant to r 28.61 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth).