Bridges Health & Community Care Ltd v Workers' Compensation Regulator

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Bridges Health & Community Care Ltd v Workers' Compensation Regulator [2020] QIRC 009

PARTIES:

Bridges Health & Community Care Ltd (Appellant)

v

Workers' Compensation Regulator
(Respondent)

&

Angela Walters
(Interested Party)

CASE NO:

WC/2019/61

PROCEEDING:

Application in existing proceedings

DELIVERED ON:

January 22 2020

HEARING DATE: 

On the papers

MEMBER:

O'Connor VP

ORDERS:

1.     Application granted.

2.     Full orders as per last page of decision.

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS' COMPENSATION – APPEAL – Application by Appellant for order that the claimant worker submit for medical examination - whether Commission should exercise its discretion to make an order pursuant to s 556 Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003

LEGISLATION:

CASES:

Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2016 (Qld) s 556

Atlas Marine International Pty Ltd v Q-COMP (WC/2013/104)

Darius Adair Carter AND Q-COMP (2007) 185 QGIG 245

Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator) v Mahaffey [2016] ICQ 010 (C/2015/30)

Reasons for Decision

  1. Bridges Health & Community Care Ltd is a community based not-for-profit provider of mental health and drug and alcohol services in Hervey Bay. At the relevant time, Ms Angela Walters was employed as an Administrative Support Officer.  

  2. On 31 July 2018, Ms Walters lodged an application for compensation in respect of a work-related psychological injury. On 2 October 2018, WorkCover rejected Ms Walters' application for compensation on the basis that the evidence did not support the allegation of workplace bullying. It was further found that s32(5) of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 operated to exclude Ms Bridges' psychological condition from the definition of injury in s32(1).

  3. Ms Walters filed an application for review of the WorkCover decision to the Regulator on 20 December 2018. The Regulator by decision dated 13 March 2019 set aside the decision of WorkCover finding that Ms Walters' psychological injury was compensable. It is against this decision that the employer seeks to appeal.

  1. The Appellant has made an interlocutory application for an order under s556 of the WCR Act seeking to have Ms Walters submit to a medical assessment by Dr Elnike Brand a Consultant Psychiatrist.

  2. All parties, including Ms Walters, were given leave to provide written submissions and agreed that the matter be determined on the papers. The Regulator has advised that it neither consents to or opposes the application. Ms Walters advised the Industrial Registry in an email dated 10 January 2020 that "I do not consent to the orders requested by the appellant, but I will submit to an independent medical assessment if the Commission considers it appropriate and orders that I attend."

    Background

  3. In short, the Regulator found that Ms Walters suffered an injury described as "acute stress reaction" and "anxiety" said to have arisen following two discrete workplace events on 7 and 12 June 2018. On those two dates, Ms Walters was said to have been confronted by Mr Hamish Watt, her direct supervisor. On those occasions, it is contended that Mr Watt used abusive language, was shouting, agitated and aggressive. As a consequence of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bridges Health & Community Care Ltd v Workers' Compensation... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QIRC 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Bridges Health & Community Care Ltd v Workers' Compensation Regulator, the applicant sought an order under section 556 of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld) that the claimant worker, Ms Walters, submit for an independent medical examination. The dispute arose from an alleged injury Ms Walters sustained during her employment with the applicant, specifically an acute stress reaction and anxiety resulting from workplace incidents on 7 and 12 June 2018. The applicant contested the nature and extent of Ms Walters' injury, asserting that her conditions were pre-existing and unrelated to her employment. The core legal issue before the court was whether the Workers' Compensation Regulator should exercise its discretion to order an additional medical examination under section 556 of the WCR Act, considering the disputed nature of Ms Walters' injury.

The court determined that the Regulator should exercise its discretion to order an independent medical examination. This decision was based on the statutory provision allowing such an order when the cause, nature, or extent of an injury is relevant to the appeal, and in this case, the cause and nature of Ms Walters' injury were in dispute. The court also noted that the applicant bore the onus of proving that Ms Walters' conditions were pre-existing and not work-related. The medical records revealed a history of anxiety-related mental illness dating back to 2009, which the applicant argued undermined Ms Walters' claims. The court concluded that an independent medical assessment would be beneficial to resolve the dispute, as it would provide a fresh perspective and potentially reduce contention between the parties.

The court granted the application, ordering Ms Walters to undergo an independent medical examination. The order was intended to facilitate a clearer understanding of the cause and nature of Ms Walters' injury, thereby aiding in the resolution of the appeal. The court emphasized the importance of such assessments in cases where there is significant dispute regarding the claimant's medical condition and its relation to employment. The final orders mandated Ms Walters to attend the medical examination as specified in the decision, thereby allowing the appeal to proceed with a more definitive medical understanding of her condition.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Application granted.

2. Full orders as per last page of decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

All parties, including Ms Walters, were given leave to provide written submissions and agreed that the matter be determined on the papers. The Regulator has advised that it neither consents to or opposes the application. Ms Walters advised the Industrial Registry in an email dated 10 January 2020 that "I do not consent to the orders requested by the appellant, but I will submit to an independent medical assessment if the Commission considers it appropriate and orders that I attend." Background In short, the Regulator found that Ms Walters suffered an injury described as "acute stress reaction" and "anxiety" said to have arisen following two discrete workplace events on 7 and 12 June 2018. On those two dates, Ms Walters was said to have been confronted by Mr Hamish Watt, her direct supervisor. On those occasions, it is contended that Mr Watt used abusive language, was shouting, agitated and aggressive. As a consequence of the encounters on 7 and 12 June, Ms Walters was upset, felt shaken and was in a state of shock. She said that Mr Watt's behaviour "scared her". On 14 June 2018, Ms Walters consulted Ms Heather Downes, a Psychologist. The consultation was in respect of what was described as "verbal and emotional abuse by supervisor 7/6/18 and 12/6/18." On 18 June 2018, Ms Walters consulted Dr Medhi Noori Koopie, a general practitioner. The clinical notes relevantly record the reason for the consultation as: "Her boss shouteing (sic) and swearing at the office/her last week. Two incidents." The reason for the visit was described as: "Acute stress reaction." Ms Walters further consulted Dr Koopie on 27 July 2018. The clinical records for that consultation record: "Anxiety". "She has seen psychologist and her psychologist thinks she has PTSD." However, in the Capacity Certificate dated 27 June 2018, Dr Koopie identifies the diagnosis as "anxiety/PTSD".The Application So far as is relevant, the form of the orders sought by the Appellant are as follows: Section 556 of the WCR Act provides as follows:556 Additional medical evidence(1) This section applies if -(a) the condition of a claimant or worker who has, or is said to have, sustained an injury is relevant to the appeal; or(b) the cause, nature or extent of the injury or incapacity arising from the injury is relevant to the appeal.(2) The appeal body may, at any time before or after the start of the hearing, order the claimant or worker to submit to a personal examination by 1 or more specified registered person.… The basis for the application is that the Appellant does not accept that the claimant suffered a psychological injury during the course of her employment. The Appellant's position is that any anxiety suffered by the claimant was a pre-existing condition. It is submitted that Ms Walters has not been independently medically assessed nor is there a psychological report. The Respondent relies upon, amongst other things, the letter from Ms Walters' psychologist which states a diagnosis of PTSD but provides no supporting assessment or analysis.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 556 of the WCR Act provides as follows:556 Additional medical evidence(1) This section applies if -(a) the condition of a claimant or worker who has, or is said to have, sustained an injury is relevant to the appeal; or(b) the cause, nature or extent of the injury or incapacity arising from the injury is relevant to the appeal.(2) The appeal body may, at any time before or after the start of the hearing, order the claimant or worker to submit to a personal examination by 1 or more specified registered person.… The basis for the application is that the Appellant does not accept that the claimant suffered a psychological injury during the course of her employment. The Appellant's position is that any anxiety suffered by the claimant was a pre-existing condition. It is submitted that Ms Walters has not been independently medically assessed nor is there a psychological report. The Respondent relies upon, amongst other things, the letter from Ms Walters' psychologist which states a diagnosis of PTSD but provides no supporting assessment or analysis. Further, the Appellant takes issue with the diagnoses in the work capacity certificate provided by Dr Koopai of 27 July 2018 and Dr Singh of 30 March 2019 on the basis that the claimant's full medical history was not disclosed. The gravamen of the Appellant's submission is that in circumstances where it is disputed that Ms Walters even suffered an injury and causation is a live issue, the Appellant's ability to discharge its onus of proof would be unfairly inhibited without an independent medical assessment being undertaken. Ms Walters' submissions Ms Walters submissions are short in compass. She makes the following two submissions:1.I have been diagnosed with anxiety/PTSD by Dr Koopai and with post-traumatic stress disorder by psychologist, Heather Downes. A further examination as proposed by the appellant is repetitious and unnecessary. 2.Heather Downes is well placed to provide a diagnosis because she has been appraised of my relevant history of mental illness and I have been consulting wither her since 16 February 2017. Consideration Section 556 of the WCR Act gives the Commission the discretion[1] to order additional medical evidence if "the cause, nature, or extent of the injury or incapacity arising from the injury is relevant to the appeal". In this appeal, the cause and the nature of Ms Walters' injury are in dispute. [1] Darius Adair Carter AND Q-COMP (2007) 185 QGIG 245, 246. It is clear from the Statement of Facts and Contentions filed by the Appellant that it will be argued at the hearing of the appeal before the Commission that Ms Walters was suffering from a number of pre-existing psychological issues unrelated to her work and, as consequence, her employment was not causative of the injury. It is the Appellant which bears the onus to produce sufficient medical evidence to support those contentions. Through non-party disclosure, the medical records of Ms Walters have been obtained. Dr Koopai's clinical notes record on 27 July 2018 that Ms Walters had a "history of depression in the past but she took escitalopram for 2 weeks only/was 3 years ago she was fully recovered", the clinical records obtained from the Murphy Street Medical Centre reveal a long history of anxiety-related mental illness dating back to a diagnosis of depression in December 2009. The clinical records reveal, for example, that in April 2017, Ms Walters was placed on a mental health care plan. The plan under the hand of Dr Richard James notes "suicidal ideation", a history of witnessing domestic violence and having previously received specialist mental health care. Ms Walters was referred to the psychologist, Ms Downes for further care.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Walters submissions are short in compass. She makes the following two submissions:1.I have been diagnosed with anxiety/PTSD by Dr Koopai and with post-traumatic stress disorder by psychologist, Heather Downes. A further examination as proposed by the appellant is repetitious and unnecessary. 2.Heather Downes is well placed to provide a diagnosis because she has been appraised of my relevant history of mental illness and I have been consulting wither her since 16 February 2017. Consideration Section 556 of the WCR Act gives the Commission the discretion[1] to order additional medical evidence if "the cause, nature, or extent of the injury or incapacity arising from the injury is relevant to the appeal". In this appeal, the cause and the nature of Ms Walters' injury are in dispute. [1] Darius Adair Carter AND Q-COMP (2007) 185 QGIG 245, 246. It is clear from the Statement of Facts and Contentions filed by the Appellant that it will be argued at the hearing of the appeal before the Commission that Ms Walters was suffering from a number of pre-existing psychological issues unrelated to her work and, as consequence, her employment was not causative of the injury. It is the Appellant which bears the onus to produce sufficient medical evidence to support those contentions. Through non-party disclosure, the medical records of Ms Walters have been obtained. Dr Koopai's clinical notes record on 27 July 2018 that Ms Walters had a "history of depression in the past but she took escitalopram for 2 weeks only/was 3 years ago she was fully recovered", the clinical records obtained from the Murphy Street Medical Centre reveal a long history of anxiety-related mental illness dating back to a diagnosis of depression in December 2009. The clinical records reveal, for example, that in April 2017, Ms Walters was placed on a mental health care plan. The plan under the hand of Dr Richard James notes "suicidal ideation", a history of witnessing domestic violence and having previously received specialist mental health care. Ms Walters was referred to the psychologist, Ms Downes for further care. Dr Koopie was either unaware of the previous medical history of Ms Walters or he did not consider the clinical records from the Murphy Street Medical Centre, which the Appellant believes, are forensically important. In Atlas Marine International Pty Ltd v Q-COMP the Commission was called on to determine whether grant an order under s556 of the WCR Act. It was held that:In making my decision that this is an appropriate occasion where the worker, Mr Kent, should be directed to attend a medical assessment I also noted the fact that Dr Ljubisavljevic is (now) the only medical practitioner who is not treating Mr Kent. While the Employer might have (and might still) seek his re-consideration of his earlier reports in light of any new and additional material which the Employer might draw to his attention, it is also the case that there is some merit in having a fresh clinical psychiatrist, armed with the potential matters in dispute, to undertake an assessment of the type proposed. This is because, at the end of the day, such an assessment is likely to lead to less disputation between the parties to the foreshadowed appeal proceedings.[2][2] Atlas Marine International Pty Ltd v Q-COMP (WC/2013/104) [12].