Brian and Minister for Immigration, and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

Brian and Minister for Immigration, and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2025] ARTA 457 (23 April 2025)

Review Applicant:               Roy Brian

Visa Applicant  Aysun Gunes

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration, and Multicultural Affairs

Tribunal Number:                2024/9918

Tribunal:General Member J Cipolla

Place:Sydney

Date:23 April 2025

Decision:The decision under review is set aside, and in substitution, the refusal of the Visa Applicant’s visa is revoked

……………[SGD]……………………

General Member J Cipolla

CATCHWORDS

MIGRATION – refusal of Visa Applicant’s Partner (Provisional)(Class UF visa-not meet character test-substantial criminal record – decision under review is set aside and substituted.

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

CASES

FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 185

Godley v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2004) 83        ALD 411

HZXP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] FCAFC 202

Irving v Minister (1996) FCA 663

JYVY and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2024] AATA 3617

NZYQ v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] HCA 37

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Direction No. 110, Visa refusal under section 501(1) failure to meet character test under section 501(6)(a)

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND AND OFFENDING HISTORY

  1. The Visa Applicant applied for a Partner (Provisional) (Class UF) visa on 15 April 2020.

  2. On 17 July 2024, during the processing of the visa application, the Department of Home Affairs (“the Department”) issued the Visa Applicant with a Notice of Intention to Consider Refusal of the Partner Visa application on character grounds, on the basis that the Minister’s delegate (“the delegate”) had formed a view that the Visa Applicant may be a person that does not pass the character test.

  3. It is clear from the evidence before the Tribunal that the Department had concerns about the Visa Applicant’s character during the processing of her partner visa application. This is evidenced by a response that Mr Brian (the Review Applicant) provided to the Department, dated 18 November 2022.

  4. In this response to the Department Mr Brian stated that:

    “upon finding out that my wife Aysun Gunes’s file was transferred to the Character Consideration Unit, my wife and I immediately made contact with the Department of Home Affairs through our Solicitor. The Character Consideration Unit responded to our correspondence in a very speedy manner and informed that my wife Aysun Gunes’s Criminal History were of concern to the Department of Home Affairs, in that, she had committed an offence of ‘larceny’ in 2018 and, that, this may lead the Department of Home Affairs assess her as a person who is not of ‘good character’ that is, she is not a ‘fit and proper person’ for grant of a visa. While the Department of Home Affairs having noted its concerns about my wife Aysun Gunes’s Criminal History, it also gave her and I the opportunity to provide respond to their concerns and provide explanations and evidence as to why it should be concluded that my wife is of ‘good character’ and that she is a ‘fit and proper person’ and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brian and Minister for Immigration, and Multicultural Affair... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 457
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the tribunal involves a 37-year-old Turkish citizen, the Visa Applicant, who has applied for a Partner (Provisional) visa under subclass 820/830. The Minister for Immigration, and Multicultural Affairs refused the visa application on the basis that the Visa Applicant did not meet the character test under section 501(6) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) due to her substantial criminal record. The Visa Applicant had been convicted of theft in a public place in Turkey in 2018 and sentenced to a term of imprisonment of two years and six months, which was suspended. The primary issue before the tribunal was whether it should exercise its discretion under section 501(1) of the Act to refuse the visa application.

The tribunal considered the relevant Direction 110, which outlines the primary considerations for determining whether to exercise the discretion to refuse a visa, including the protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct. The tribunal found that while the Visa Applicant’s conduct was serious, it was an isolated incident driven by anxiety and depression. The tribunal noted that the Visa Applicant had no prior criminal record, had worked as a high school teacher in Turkey and a teaching assistant in France without incident, and had a long-term relationship with an Australian citizen. The tribunal concluded that the Australian community would likely view the Visa Applicant’s conduct as an aberration and that the protection of the Australian community did not weigh heavily in favour of refusing the visa application.

The tribunal set aside the decision to refuse the visa application and substituted a decision to grant the visa. The tribunal found that the Visa Applicant’s conduct fell outside the parameters of serious offending as contemplated by Direction 110 and that there was a low likelihood of reoffending. The tribunal also noted that the sentence imposed by the court in Turkey was wholly suspended and that the Visa Applicant had expressed remorse for her conduct.

In conclusion, the tribunal exercised its discretion under section 501(1) of the Act to grant the Visa Applicant a Partner (Provisional) visa under subclass 820/830. The tribunal found that the Visa Applicant’s isolated incident of theft in a public place did not warrant a refusal of the visa application and that the protection of the Australian community did not weigh heavily in favour of refusal. The tribunal also noted the Visa Applicant’s remorse for her conduct and the absence of any criminal antecedents since her relocation to France.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

With respect to the expectations of the Australian community the submission notes that the conduct, although serious, was driven by anxiety and depression. The submission contends having regard to the totality of the relevant facts and circumstances and consideration of those matters, the subject of consideration in Direction 110, that the appropriate course would be for the Tribunal to exercise discretion and revoke the refusal of the Visa Applicants Partner visa.RESPONDENTS STATEMENT OF FACTS ISSUES AND CONTENTIONS The Tribunal has duly considered the Respondent’s SFIC dated 10 March 2025 prepared by Ms McNeil, Counsel, for the Minister. The submission notes that the Visa Applicant did not pass the character test under section 501(6) of the Act on the basis of her “substantial criminal record” and that the respective issue for the Tribunal to determine is whether the Tribunal should exercise the discretion in section 501(1) of the Act to refuse to grant the Visa Applicant the visa. The submission notes that the Visa Applicant is a 37-year-old citizen of Turkey. The submission notes that on 29 January 2018, the Visa Applicant committed the offence of “theft in a public place” and was convicted of the said offence on 5 June 2018. The Visa Applicant was sentenced to a term of imprisonment for the offence of 2 years and 6 months. The submission notes that “the Applicant has stated that the execution of the sentence imposed on her by the court in Turkey was “postponed”, with the last delay deadline being 28 January 2020”. The submission makes reference to the inception and development of the relationship between the Visa Applicant and her partner, Mr Brian, an Australian citizen by conferral. The submission notes that the Visa Applicant applied for protection in France on 2 October 2020 on the basis of her having been engaged in pro-Kurdish activities in Turkey. She was found by the French government to be owed protection obligations and was granted asylum in France on 31 December 2021. The submission notes that the Visa Applicant does not pass the character test on the basis of her “substantial criminal record”, having been sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 12 months or more (paragraphs 501(6A) and 501(7)(c) of the Act). The submission notes that the sole issue for the Tribunal to determine is whether to exercise its discretion to revoke the visa refusal, having regard to Direction 110. With respect to protection of the Australian community, reference is made to the relevant considerations in Direction 110, which requires consideration of the nature and seriousness of the non-citizen’s conduct to date, and the potential impact on the Australian community should the non-citizen commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct. The submission contends that the primary consideration of the protection of the Australian community weighs heavily in favour of refusing the visa application. The submission notes that the Applicant has said that the one incident of offending was driven by psychological disturbance at the time and notes that the psychological evidence used to support this assertion postdates the offending, and hence should not be given weight. The submission contends “there is no independent evidence to support the contention that ‘the criminal conduct of the [Visa Applicant] was an aberration driven by psychological disturbance which has since been remediated by treatment”. The submission also notes that there have been shifting accounts of the circumstances surrounding the offence. The submission notes that in the submission advanced on behalf of the Visa Applicant on 29 July 2024, it was asserted that the items at the Visa Applicant stall were men’s neckties to the value of AUD$160. The submission notes that this assertion is contradicted by the reasons of the court dated 5 June 2018, and the Visa Applicant’s statement of 10 February 2021 which indicates that when the Visa Applicant was searched by the police and that they found stolen items from Zara, Pull and Bear and Stradivarius stores in the Applicant’s possession.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

With respect to expectations of the Australian community, the submission notes that the Visa Applicant committed one single offence of larceny in a department store. The submission notes that the available evidence suggests that the offending was completely out of character. Prior to the offending, the Visa Applicant had worked as a high school teacher in Istanbul with no adverse police record and has since worked in France as a teaching assistant without incident. The submission notes that a significant time has elapsed since the offending occurred in January 2018. The submission notes the long-term nature of the Visa Applicant’s relationship with the Review Applicant. The submission notes that the Australian public, with respect to the circumstances of this case would be of the view that the Visa Applicant deserved some degree of leniency and that only a tiny minority of the Australian population would conclude that the Visa Applicant should be refused a partner visa on the basis of the theft of AUD $160 worth of men’s neckties from a department store six years ago.Delegates Decision The Tribunal has had regard to the delegates decision record dated 18 November 2024. With respect to the delegates consideration of the nature and seriousness of the Visa Applicant’s conduct the delegate stated that “I take the view that offences such as shoplifting can be viewed seriously. Such offences deprive businesses of their property, causing them significant financial harm. However, it is society as a whole that ultimately shoulders the financial burden of such crimes. Business owners must increase prices to cover expenses associated with pursuing such crimes through the courts, and with the implementation of anti-theft measures. Taxpayers fund the law enforcement costs associated with dealing with this crime. In addition, individuals that witnessed such crimes can experience psychological harm as a result, particularly if such individuals are employees of the business”. Of note in the delegate’s decision record is the finding at paragraph 36, that with respect to the Visa Applicant’s offence it was a deliberate act as she had money on her person at the time. However, the delegate concedes that “I accept her actions may have been influenced by her mental health at the time”. At paragraph 47 of the decision record, the delegate noted that “on balance, I consider there to be a low likelihood that Ms Gunes will reoffend or further engage in serious conduct. Nevertheless, I considered that, should Ms Gunes engage in similar conduct again it may result in psychological and/or financial harm to members of the community.”APPLICANTS STATEMENT OF FACTS ISSUES AND CONTENTIONS The Tribunal received a Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions from the Review Applicant’s representative Mr Christopher Levingston, solicitor, dated 16 December 2024. The submission makes reference to the delegate’s decision of 18 November 2024 pursuant to the exercise of powers arising under section 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) with respect to the criminal conduct of the Visa Applicant and her subsequent conviction on 5 June 2018. The submission notes that the offence was theft in a public place for which the Applicant was sentenced to a term of imprisonment of two years and six months’. The submission notes that the Visa Applicants offending behaviour is described by a psychologist as isolated, corroborated by the fact that she had no criminal antecedents in Turkey and an absence of any criminal antecedents since her relocation to France. The submission notes that the Visa Applicant’s crime falls outside the parameters of serious offending as contemplated by Direction 110. The submission notes that the sentence imposed by the court in Turkey was wholly suspended.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Direction 110 sets out Primary Considerations and Other Considerations. These are addressed under their respective headings below.PRIMARY CONSIDERATION 1: PROTECTION OF THE AUSTRALIAN COMMUNITY FROM CRIMINAL OR OTHER SERIOUS CONDUCTThe Nature and Seriousness of the Applicant’s Conduct to Date When assessing the nature and seriousness of a non-citizen’s criminal offending or other conduct to date, paragraph 8.1.1(1) of the Direction specifies that decision-makers must have regard to a number of factors, which the Tribunal will now address. Sub-paragraph (a) of paragraph 8.1.1(1) of the Direction provides that, without limiting the range of conduct that may be considered very serious, violent and/or sexual crimes; crimes of a violent and/or sexual nature against women or children (regardless of the sentence imposed); or acts of family violence (regardless of whether there is a conviction for an offence or a sentence imposed) are viewed very seriously by the Australian Government and the Australian community. The Visa Applicant who was born on 1 March 1988 had no criminal antecedents prior to her one act of offending conduct, which occurred on 29 January 2018, at Marmara Park Shopping Centre in Istanbul. On the day in question, the translated judgement of the Civil Court of First Instance indicates that the Visa Applicant entered the Zara store, and as she was leaving the store, the security alarm went off and the Visa Applicant was found to be in the possession of four items consisting of shoes and clothing belonging to the Zara store, two pieces of clothing belonging to the Pull & Bear store and one piece of clothing belonging to the Stradivarius store. The items were concealed in the Visa Applicant’s bag. It was determined that the alarms with respect to the products had been removed, and that the security alarm was only triggered due to a hidden alarm in the shoes stolen by the Visa Applicant. The court noted that the total value of the goods stolen by the Visa Applicant was 973 Turkish liras. The Visa Applicant is recorded to have stated in her defence before the court that “I accept the accusation. I was not in a good economic situation, I even took the tie even though it was useless for me. It is true that I stole goods from the stores mentioned in the indictment. I regret this. I have no other statements to add. I will compensate for any damages”. The court found that the fact that the Visa Applicant had €1000 in her possession negated her evidence that she was not in a good economic situation, and the court noted that her culpability with respect to the offending was heightened by the fact that she had removed alarms from the items. The evidence before the Tribunal indicates that in a statement that the Applicant provided to the Character Consideration Unit of the Department, dated 15 November 2022 and located at G-15, page 75 indicates that:“In 2018, I experienced an incident in a shopping centre which still does not make any sense to me. I had money with me, and I took these things I really did not need at all. Although I was not aware of what I did, I owned up my responsibility and expressed my remorse in the court. It was the worst time of my life, and I could not recover after the experience I had. I was helpless four days because of the feeling of remorse and the embarrassment. Because of the embarrassment I felt for what I did, I could not go to a lawyer to seek legal help”.