Brewer v Colonial Portfolio Services Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 3 min read

BREWER & ANOR -v- COLONIAL PORTFOLIO SERVICES LTD & ORS [2004] WASC 153 (S)



SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIACitation No:[2004] WASC 153 (S)
Case No:CIV:2538/200122 JUNE 2004
Coram:MASTER SANDERSON8/07/04
2/03/05
4Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: Inspection allowed
B
PDF Version
Parties:KEVIN CHARLES BREWER
DIANNE MERRILYN BREWER
COLONIAL PORTFOLIO SERVICES LTD (ACN 066 649 241)
WESTGATE PROPERTY INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 008 713 175)
SAVOY MANAGEMENT PTY LTD (ACN 008 684 820)
ANDREW PAGE
IAN WILSON

Catchwords:

Supplementary decision

Legislation:

Nil

Case References:

Re Briamore Manufacturing Ltd (In Liq) [1986] 3 All ER 132
Nil

JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
    IN CHAMBERS
CITATION : BREWER & ANOR -v- COLONIAL PORTFOLIO SERVICES LTD & ORS [2004] WASC 153 (S) CORAM : MASTER SANDERSON HEARD : 22 JUNE 2004 DELIVERED : 8 JULY 2004 SUPPLEMENTARY
DECISION : 2 MARCH 2005 FILE NO/S : CIV 2538 of 2001 BETWEEN : KEVIN CHARLES BREWER
    DIANNE MERRILYN BREWER
    Plaintiffs

    AND

    COLONIAL PORTFOLIO SERVICES LTD (ACN 066 649 241)
    WESTGATE PROPERTY INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 008 713 175)
    First Defendants

    SAVOY MANAGEMENT PTY LTD (ACN 008 684 820)
    Second Defendant

    ANDREW PAGE
    Third Defendant

    IAN WILSON
    Fourth Defendant


(Page 2)

Catchwords:

Supplementary decision




Legislation:

Nil




Result:

Inspection allowed




Category: B


Representation:


Counsel:


    Plaintiffs : Mr S G Leslie
    First Defendants : Ms F A Skrzypek
    Second Defendant : No appearance
    Third Defendant : No appearance
    Fourth Defendant : No appearance


Solicitors:

    Plaintiffs : Wilson & Atkinson
    First Defendants : Minter Ellison
    Second Defendant : No appearance
    Third Defendant : No appearance
    Fourth Defendant : No appearance



Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Re Briamore Manufacturing Ltd (In Liq) [1986] 3 All ER 132

Case(s) also cited:



Nil

(Page 3)

1 MASTER SANDERSON: On 8 July 2004 I published reasons in this matter indicating that I would order the defendant to provide copies of certain discovered documents. Subsequent to the publication of those reasons counsel has advised that they contained an error of fact. The error is of some significance and warrants the publication of these supplementary reasons.

2 In par 2 of the reasons I quoted extensively from an affidavit of Frances Angela Skrzypek. In par 7 of that affidavit, Ms Skrzypek says that Mr Leslie, of the plaintiffs' solicitors, inspected the First Discovered Documents at the first-named first defendant's solicitors' offices. In fact, it seems that Mr Leslie only inspected two documents. These were documents numbered 92 and 229. It was subsequent to this first inspection that Mr Leslie was advised by Ms Skrzypek that further inspection of documents would not be permitted. This position was reflected by the orders sought in par 2 of the application: see par 3 of the reasons. The question now is whether the outcome of the application is affected by the error of fact contained in the original reasons.

3 The ratio of my original decision was found in par…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brewer v Colonial Portfolio Services Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] WASC 153 (S)
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Brewer v Colonial Portfolio Services Ltd, which was heard by Master Sanderson in the Supreme Court of Western Australia, revolves around the issue of document inspection. The plaintiffs, Kevin Charles Brewer and Dianne Merrilyn Brewer, sought to inspect certain discovered documents held by the defendants, Colonial Portfolio Services Ltd, Westgate Property Investments Pty Ltd, Savoy Management Pty Ltd, Andrew Page, and Ian Wilson. The plaintiffs' application was to compel the defendants to provide copies of specific documents, as they believed the inspection process had been improperly restricted. The court's task was to determine whether the defendants were justified in limiting the inspection of documents, and if the plaintiffs were entitled to inspect and copy the discovered documents as requested.

The legal issues in this case primarily concerned the scope of document inspection rights under the court's rules and the proper procedure for amending a list of discovered documents. The plaintiffs argued that the defendants had improperly restricted the inspection of documents and that they were entitled to inspect all documents listed in the first affidavit of discovery. The defendants, on the other hand, contended that they had the right to limit the inspection process and that the plaintiffs' request for inspection was excessive and unnecessary. The court had to assess whether the inspection rights of the plaintiffs were being unduly restricted and whether the defendants' actions were justified under the circumstances.

Master Sanderson, in his decision, acknowledged an error in the initial reasons for judgment regarding the number of documents inspected by the plaintiffs' representative. Despite this error, the court determined that the plaintiffs were indeed entitled to inspect the discovered documents. The court reasoned that although only two specific documents were inspected, the initiation of the inspection process established the plaintiffs' right to inspect all documents listed in the first affidavit of discovery. The court further held that the defendants were not permitted to amend their list of documents once it had been filed, as it appeared the defendants had changed their stance on the discoverable documents. Consequently, the court ruled that the plaintiffs should be allowed to inspect and take copies of the discovered documents as requested.

The final outcome of the case was that the plaintiffs, Kevin Charles Brewer and Dianne Merrilyn Brewer, were granted permission to inspect and copy the discovered documents listed in the defendants' first affidavit of discovery. The court's decision emphasised the importance of adhering to the proper procedure for document inspection and highlighted the limitations on amending a list of discovered documents once it has been filed. The court's ruling ensured that the plaintiffs' rights to inspect relevant documents were upheld, thereby facilitating the fair conduct of the legal proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute over the inspection of certain documents, specifically those listed as the First Discovered Documents, between the plaintiffs, Kevin Charles Brewer and Dianne Merrilyn Brewer, and the defendants, Colonial Portfolio Services Ltd, Westgate Property Investments Pty Ltd, Savoy Management Pty Ltd, Andrew Page, and Ian Wilson. The plaintiffs' counsel, Mr Leslie, initially inspected two documents at the first defendant's solicitors' offices. However, it was later discovered that only two documents were inspected, contrary to the claims made in the original reasons for the decision. This error prompted a supplementary decision to correct the misstatement.

The matter was heard by Master Sanderson on 22 June 2004, with reasons for the decision published on 8 July 2004. An error of fact in the original reasons was identified subsequently, leading to the publication of supplementary reasons on 2 March 2005. The primary issue addressed in the supplementary reasons was whether the outcome of the application for inspection of documents was affected by the error in the original reasons. The court found that despite the error, the plaintiffs should still be entitled to inspect and take copies of the First Discovered Documents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the outcome of the application for inspection of documents is affected by the error of fact contained in the original reasons.
2. Whether the defendant should be permitted to amend its list of documents after filing the first affidavit of discovery.
3. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to inspect and take copies of the First Discovered Documents.

Held
1. The outcome of the application for inspection of documents is not affected by the error of fact contained in the original reasons. The error does not change the decision to order inspection and copying of the First Discovered Documents.
2. The defendant should not be permitted to amend its list of documents after filing the first affidavit of discovery. The court found it inappropriate for the defendant to change its mind about the documents to be discovered.
3. The plaintiffs are entitled to inspect and take copies of the First Discovered Documents as ordered.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court found that the error of fact in the original reasons did not alter the decision to allow inspection of the First Discovered Documents. Despite the error stating that more documents were inspected than actually were, the court concluded that inspection had commenced, and the plaintiffs had a right to inspect and copy the documents. The court relied on the principle that once a party files an affidavit of discovery, it cannot later change its mind about the documents to be discovered. The error of fact was deemed not significant enough to warrant allowing the defendant to amend its list of documents. The binding legal principle established is that parties cannot amend their list of documents after filing the first affidavit of discovery once inspection has commenced. The court distinguished this case from situations where an amendment might be possible due to inadvertence, as suggested by Hoffman J in Re Briamore Manufacturing Ltd (In Liq) [1986] 3 All ER 132, but found no such inadvertence in this case.