Brendan King Pty Ltd v Toseska

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read
CITATION: BRENDAN KING PTY LTD v TOSESKA - COSTS [2006] NSWSC 487
HEARING DATE(S): 8 June 2006
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

29 August 2006
JUDGMENT OF: Hulme J at 1
DECISION: See paragraph 14
PARTIES: Brendan King Pty Ltd
Liljana Toseska
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 10480/04
COUNSEL: Plaintiff: MW Young
Defendant: MB Duncan
SOLICITORS:

Bransgroves
135 King Street
SYDNEY

Tony Vella
38-40 George Street
PARRAMATTA
15a Belmore Street
BURWOOD

- 4 -

      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      HULME J
                              Tuesday 29 August 2006

      10480/04

      BRENDAN KING PTY LTD v Liljana TOSESKA
      JUDGMENT

1 HULME J: In this matter, I delivered reasons on 26 May last and on 8 June made substantive orders to give effect to those reasons. Sacrificing some accuracy for brevity, at the instigation of the Defendant and on grounds of unconscionability, I set aside a mortgage she had granted in favour of the Plaintiff. As is common in that situation, there were terms imposed or orders made resulting in some payments being received by the Plaintiff.

2 These reasons are concerned with what order or orders for costs should be made.

3 The Defendant was substantially successful in the litigation and, prima facie, should be entitled to the costs associated with that success.

4 However the Defendant pleaded and also gave evidence in support of a case of fraud and on this she was unsuccessful. The time expended on that claim was not insignificant and prima facie, her entitlement to costs should be decreased by, and she should bear the costs of, that claim.

5 The litigation did not follow an orderly path prior to the hearing and the Plaintiff submitted that the Defendant should be ordered to pay the Plaintiffs' costs of the proceedings prior to the 4th or 5th April 2005, the time at which the Defendant first filed a Defence and Cross-Claim. A consideration of this submission requires some attention to the earlier events in the proceedings. I do not think it necessary to refer to all of these but the following chronology provides some indication of the more significant events.

      23/2/04 Statement of Claim filed
      11/8/04 Judgment for Possession entered
      23/8/04 Requisitions from Court registry
      7/9/04 Writs of Possession issued
      19/11/04 Order staying Writs of Possession After at least one extension this stay seems to have lapsed on about 2/12/05
      24/12/05 Order extending 2 caveats lodged by D After a number of extensions, these seem to have lapsed on 12/1/05
      24/12/04 The D files an affidavit in which she alleges having been told the interest rate was 7.2 not 72% per annum
      4/1/05 Injunction restraining P from dealing with the conveyance of 2 of D’s properties
      12/1/05 Injunction dissolved
      Order that proceeds of sale of 2 properties be held by P's solicitor as trust funds pending further order
      Costs reserved.
      Directions that D file & serve within 28 days any application re moneys held
      10/2/05 N/M by P seeking that D account for funds received from P or…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brendan King Pty Ltd v Toseska and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWSC 487
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Brendan King Pty Ltd v Toseska, the parties involved were Brendan King Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, and Liljana Toseska, the defendant. The case concerned the setting aside of a mortgage on grounds of unconscionability, with subsequent claims of fraud by the defendant being unsuccessful. The primary issue before the court was the determination of costs associated with the litigation. The defendant was successful in the main claim, but her unsuccessful fraud claim necessitated a reduction in her entitlement to costs. The court also considered the costs incurred prior to the defendant filing her defence and cross-claim, noting that some costs were due to her delays and unsuccessful applications.

The court deliberated on the chronology of the proceedings and the reasons for the costs incurred during various stages. The judge observed that while the defendant was largely successful, her failure to lodge a defence and cross-claim timely, along with unsuccessful applications, contributed to some of the costs. The judge also highlighted the plaintiff's conduct, including full knowledge of factors leading to unconscionability, which contributed to the defendant's delay in obtaining legal advice. The court concluded that some costs should be borne by the defendant, while others should be borne by the plaintiff, particularly those related to the unsuccessful fraud claim. The judge proposed a notional set-off approach, allowing each party to bear their own costs up until 5 April 2005, and ordered the plaintiff to pay 65% of the defendant's costs from that date onwards.

Hulme J ordered that each party should bear their own costs up to and including 5 April 2005, and the plaintiff should pay 65% of the defendant's costs from that date. This decision was based on the assessment of costs incurred during various stages of the litigation, considering the contributions of both parties to the overall costs. The court's ruling aimed to balance the costs between the parties while accounting for the defendant's successful claim and the unsuccessful fraud allegation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.