SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL
No 6907 of 2007
| BREAK FAST INVESTMENTS PTY LTD |
| v |
| PCH MELBOURNE PTY LTD |
---
APPLICATION ON SUMMONS
---
JUDGES: | WARREN CJ and MAXWELL P |
WHERE HELD: | MELBOURNE |
DATE OF HEARING: | 1 June 2007 |
DATE OF JUDGMENT: | 1 June 2007 |
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2007] VSCA 118 |
---
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Stay of judgment pending appeal – Order required appellant to remove metal cladding – Whether exceptional circumstances justifying grant of stay – Whether appeal rendered nugatory in absence of stay – Whether undertaking as to damages condition of grant of stay – Jesasu Pty Ltd v Minister for Mineral Resources (1987) 11 NSWLR 110 considered – Refusal to provide undertaking as to damages irrelevant – Stay granted – No special circumstances warranting grant of security for costs – Application for expedition of appeal adjourned pending resolution of related appeal.
---
| APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Appellant | Mr P W Collinson SC with Mr D F Hyde | Rigby Cooke |
| For the Respondent | Mr S R Horgan | Best Hooper |
WARREN CJ:
I invite his Honour the President to deliver the first judgment.
MAXWELL P:
Break Fast Investments Pty Ltd (“BFI”) is the registered proprietor of a property on Wellington Parade in East Melbourne. The property adjoins a property owned by PCH Melbourne Pty Ltd (“PCH”) at 178 Wellington Parade. There is a 12-storey office building at 170-176 Wellington Parade. In 2006, BFI attached metal cladding to sections of the western face of the building, at the northern and southern ends and along the top of the western face. The cladding contains illuminated signage.
PCH wishes to develop the neighbouring property by constructing a 14- or 15-storey apartment building. That property is already the site of the Hilton Hotel and the MCG Hotel. PCH alleges that the cladding on 170-176 Wellington Parade projects up to 60 millimetres into the air space above its land. PCH sought a permanent injunction requiring BFI to remove the cladding and the signage from the western face of the building insofar as it encroaches on PCH's land.
The case was heard in the Trial Division before Smith J, who dealt with a number of issues, namely, the location of the actual common title boundary between the properties; whether and to what extent the cladding extended over the boundary; if there was an encroachment, whether it was trespass; and, if it was a trespass, what the appropriate remedy would be. His Honour concluded that PCH had a strong prima facie entitlement to injunction. The encroachment to the air space conferred a commercial benefit on BFI by improving the appearance of its building. There were no special countervailing considerations such as delay. BFI had made no serious attempts to resolve the issues nor offered to pay costs nor made a reasonable offer of damages, and the proposal of undertakings (to which reference has been made this morning) was unrealistic.
Although an injunction would create hardship for BFI, his Honour concluded, the encroachment…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Break Fast Investments Pty Ltd v PCH Melbourne Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] VSCA 118
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue for the court was whether exceptional circumstances existed that would justify a stay of the judgment pending the appeal. The court also needed to determine whether the appeal would be rendered nugatory without such a stay, and if an undertaking as to damages was a condition for granting the stay. The court referred to the case of Jesasu Pty Ltd v Minister for Mineral Resources, where it was established that refusal to provide an undertaking as to damages was not a disqualifier for a stay. The court examined whether the appeal was likely to succeed on its merits and if the appellant had acted diligently.
The court held that exceptional circumstances did exist, primarily because the appeal had a reasonable prospect of success and the appellant had acted diligently in pursuing the appeal. The court found that without a stay, the appeal would be rendered nugatory, as the removal of the metal cladding would effectively deprive the court of the ability to determine the substantive issues on appeal. The court also noted that while an undertaking as to damages was generally required, the refusal to provide such an undertaking was not fatal in this context. Consequently, the court granted the stay of judgment pending the appeal. The court declined to order the appellant to provide security for costs, finding no special circumstances warranted such an order. The application for expedition of the appeal was adjourned pending the resolution of a related appeal.
The court's final order was to grant the stay of judgment pending the appeal, without requiring the appellant to provide security for costs. The application for expedition of the appeal was adjourned, pending the outcome of the related appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi