BRC Group Pty Ltd v Watagan Park Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S EAPCI 2024 0136
BRC GROUP PTY LTD (ACN 620 080 659) AS TRUSTEE FOR THE BRC GROUP UNIT TRUST Applicant
v
WATAGAN PARK PTY LTD (ACN 128 663 749) AS TRUSTEE FOR THE CLANCY FAMILY TRUST MKT2 Respondent

---

JUDGES: KENNEDY, ORR and KENNY JJA
WHERE HELD: Melbourne
DATE OF HEARING: 2 February 2025
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 14 March 2025
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2025] VSCA 36
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: [2024] VSC 563 (Barrett AsJ)

---

CORPORATIONS – Statutory demand based on loan agreement – Application to set aside demand pursuant to s 459G of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – Applicant’s affidavit filed with application alleged that loan agreement was not finalised – Applicant seeks to raise additional ground of dispute that there was a loan on different terms with a different repayment date which had not arisen (‘additional dispute’) – Whether the initial affidavit was an affidavit ‘supporting the application’ with respect to the additional dispute – Leave to appeal refused.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 9, 459G, 459H.

Sceam Construction Pty Ltd v Clyne (2021) 64 VR 404; Malec Holdings Pty Ltd v Scotts Agencies Pty Ltd (in liq) [2015] VSCA 330; GoConnect Ltd v Sino Strategic International Ltd (in liq) [2016] VSCA 315; NA Investments Holdings Pty Ltd v Perpetual Nominees Ltd [2010] NSWCA 210, considered.

---

Counsel

Applicant: Dr O Bigos KC with Mr PR Miller
Respondent: Mr SL Freire

Solicitors

Applicant: Colin Biggers & Paisley
Respondent: Kalus Kenny Intelex

KENNEDY JA
ORR JA
KENNY JA:

  1. On 12 March 2024 the respondent served a statutory demand on the applicant which alleged that the applicant owed it a debt pursuant to a loan agreement. The applicant applied to set that statutory demand aside. That application was supported by an affidavit filed within the relevant statutory period of 21 days after the demand was served (the ‘21 day affidavit’). On 11 September 2024, an associate judge dismissed the applicant’s application to set aside the demand.

  2. The judge found that the 21 day affidavit raised a ground of dispute that there was no concluded loan agreement that would give rise to the alleged debt. He rejected the submission that it raised an additional ground of dispute that the terms of the loan agreement differed from that contended by the respondent. More particularly that, under those different terms, the repayment date had not arisen because the loan was not to be repaid until the respondent was able to elect to exercise its equity option under an equity right agreement (the ‘additional dispute’).

  3. The applicant now seeks leave to appeal on the following proposed grounds:

    (a)the judge erred in holding that there was no serious question or plausible contention on a ground raised in the 21 day affidavit;

    (b)the judge erred in holding that, if there were a serious question or plausible contention on a ground raised in the 21 day affidavit, the dispute was not genuine; and

    (c)further…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BRC Group Pty Ltd v Watagan Park Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] VSCA 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of BRC Group Pty Ltd v Watagan Park Pty Ltd concerned a statutory demand issued under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The demand was based on a loan agreement which the applicant, BRC Group, claimed was never finalised. Watagan Park sought to set aside the statutory demand under s 459G of the Corporations Act, arguing that there was a genuine dispute over the amount of the alleged debt. BRC Group attempted to raise an additional ground of dispute regarding a different loan agreement with different terms and repayment date, which had not yet arisen.

The legal issues before the court included whether the initial affidavit supporting the application to set aside the statutory demand was sufficient in relation to the additional dispute raised by BRC Group. The court had to determine if the additional ground of dispute was adequately covered by the initial affidavit and whether this was an affidavit 'supporting the application' within the meaning of s 459H of the Corporations Act.

The court found that the initial affidavit did not adequately address the additional dispute regarding the different loan agreement with different terms and repayment date. The court noted that the affidavit primarily focused on the alleged loan agreement that was never finalised and did not sufficiently cover the new dispute. The court held that the initial affidavit was not sufficient to support the application in relation to the additional dispute, and therefore, the application to set aside the statutory demand could not proceed on that basis. Consequently, the leave to appeal was refused.

No specific final orders were made by the court in the provided excerpt, but the refusal of leave to appeal effectively upheld the statutory demand, leaving the issue of the alleged debt payable under the initial loan agreement unresolved in this instance.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

After making reference to the debt the subject of the statutory demand (being the ‘Alleged Debt’) and the affidavit in support of the statutory demand, the 21 day affidavit relevantly reads as follows:11.It is the position of the Plaintiff that:(a)the Alleged Debt is not payable to the Defendant as demanded; and(b)there is a genuine dispute as to the amount of the Alleged Debt as alleged.12.The facts and correspondence upon which the Plaintiff relies in support of the existence of a genuine dispute are set out below.Background13.The amount of $900,000 was an equity investment by Sean Clancy, beginning on or around 1 January 2021. This was to be accompanied [sic] a consultancy agreement on the same date (Consultancy Agreement). The terms of which are confidential. 14.In order to obtain an improved purchase price, an equity right agreement was arranged, the funds were not advanced by the Defendant as agreed in early January 2021.15.It was intended that the maturity dates of the loan agreement and the Consultancy Agreement be aligned to ensure that when the loan ended the equity component would commence. 16.The Defendant then requested that BRC Group enter into a loan agreement. This loan agreement was never finalised and as such, a final agreement as to the terms of the loan agreement was never reached.17.In as late as September 2021, the parties were still engaging in negotiations about the terms of the loan agreement by email. A true copy of the email chain is available from page 29 of MD-1.Payments made to BRC Group18.The BRC Group received the following payments:(a)$250,000 on or about 3 September 2021.(b)$150,000 on or about 30 November 2021.(c)$250,000 on or about 31 August 2022.19.In the Affidavit in Support, Mr Clancy deposes that a $250,000 payment was made on 30 June 2022 to BRC Group (Donation). This is not correct.20.The Donation was made to the University of Melbourne. It was intended that the [sic] this amount be an offset against the ultimate equity right payment that would become due.21.The Plaintiff alleged that the Alleged Debt is due and payable pursuant to a purported loan agreement dated 1 January 2021 (Alleged Loan Agreement). The Alleged Loan Agreement was never entered into and the parties never finalised the terms of this agreement.22.I note that:(a)the dates Watagan Park allege that it advanced the amounts to the Company within the Statutory Demand are different from the dates alleged within the Letter.(d)Schedule 3 of the Alleged Loan Agreement (as noted below) had proposed that the amounts (highlighted in yellow) would be payable on different dates than actually advanced at paragraph 19 above. Watagan Park was in breach as it agreed to advance the funds.“Schedule 3 — Further AdvancesDuring the Second Advance Period, further advances broadly as follows:(a)An advance of A$150,000 on or about the month of September 2021;(b) An advance of A$150,000 on or about the month of October 2021;(c) An advance of A$150,000 on or about the month of November 2021; and(d) An advance of A$200,000 on or about the month of December 2021”;(e)The alleged Interest Rate and Default Interest Rate (Total Interest Amount) sought by Watagan Park was not agreed between the parties. A true copy of the email chain is available from page 29 of MD-1. In light of the dispute raised in relation to the Donation and the Total Interest Amount, the total amount of the debt, as described in the Schedule to the Statutory Demand is not correct.(f)I am informed by Ms Mustafa-Ay that section 459J(1)(a) of the Act states that a statutory demand may be set aside if the Court is satisfied that because of a defect in the demand, substantial injustice will be caused unless the demand is set aside. A defect in relation to a statutory demand is defined to include an irregularity, a misstatement of an amount or total, a misdescription of a debt or other matter and a misdescription of a person or entity.23.BRC Group disputes that the interest is due and payable on the Alleged Debt as alleged,[2] and that even if interest is payable, which is not admitted, it was not agreed between BRC Group and Watagan Park that it would be calculated in the manner set out in the schedule to the Statutory Demand.24.The Repayment Date of 23 December 2021[3] formed part of the terms of the Alleged Loan Agreement but was not ultimately agreed, given the timing of the advance.25.In all of the above circumstances there is a genuine dispute as Watagan Park seeks to rely on the Alleged Loan Agreement in repayment of the Alleged Debt.[2]The applicant did not press a submission that there was a genuine dispute as to the interest payable before the judge: BRC Group Pty Ltd (ACN 620080659) as trustee for BRC Group Unit Trust v Watagan Park Pty Ltd (ACN 128663749) as trustee for Clancy Family Trust MKT2 [2024] VSC 563 (‘Reasons’), [86]. [3]This date was said to be a typographical error, with the correct date being 31 December 2023.…Application to set aside Statutory Demand27.I believe that:(a)the Alleged Debt is not payable by the Plaintiff as demanded; and(b)there is a genuine dispute as to the amount of the Alleged Debt as alleged.28.On the basis of the matters set out in this affidavit, I request that this Honourable Court set aside the Demand on the grounds set out in the Originating Process filed on behalf of the Plaintiff in this proceeding.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.