Brazier and Civil Aviation Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

Administrative

Appeals

Tribunal

 

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2004] AATA 313

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL               Nº N2003/878

Nº N2003/893

GENERAL  ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

Re:            ANDREW BRAZIER

Applicant

And:CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY AUTHORITY

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal:       Mr E. Fice, Member

Date:             26 March 2004

Place:            Sydney

Decision:The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

(sgd) E. Fice

Member

CIVIL AVIATION - aircraft maintenance - aircraft maintenance engineer licence - Certificate of Approval - Breach of regulations - cancellation of licence - series of breaches  -facts and circumstances

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL - jurisdiction - Civil Aviation Safety Authority - ultra vires - law to be applied by Tribunal

Civil Aviation Act 1988 s 20AB(2)

Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 

Civil Aviation Orders

Re Callaghanand Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (1978) 1 ALD 227

Re Taylor and Department of Transport (1978) 1 ALD 312

Re Upton and Department of Transport (1977) 1 ALD 150

Re Costello and Secretary, Department of Transport (1979) 2 ALD 934

Commonwealth of Australia and Another v Esber (1991) 29 FCR 324

Re Murfet and Secretary of Department of Aviation (1984) 5 ALN N494

Re Flynn and Department of Aviation (1987) 13 ALD 279

Re Von Nida and Secretary, Department of Aviation (1985) 8 ALN N265

Re Griffith and Civil Aviation Authority (1994) 34 ALD 554

Maxwell v Dixon [1965] WAR 167

Re Taylor and Department of Transport (1978) 1 ALD 312

Re Repacholi and Civil Aviation Safety Authority (2003) 75 ALD 312

REASONS FOR DECISION

26 March 2004  Mr E. Fice, Member

  1. These applications were heard concurrently.  The parties are identical in both applications.

  2. By a notice dated 5 May 2003, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority ("CASA") advised Andrew Brazier ("Mr Brazier") that it had cancelled his aircraft maintenance engineer licence N° L428855, pursuant to powers granted to CASA under reg 269 of the Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 ("the Regulations"). By a further notice dated 5 May 2003, CASA, pursuant to powers granted to it under reg 269, varied the Certificate of Approval N° C428855 ("Certificate of Approval") granted to Mr Brazier, pursuant to reg 30 of the Regulations, by adding the following conditions to the Certificate:

    (a)that Mr Brazier not be appointed, or act as, chief engineer for Andrews Aircraft Maintenance; and

    (b)that Mr Brazier not seek to influence Andrews Aircraft Maintenance chief engineer in technical matters relating to his performance of that function.

  3. Mr Brazier's application is for a review of both decisions made by CASA.

  4. At the hearing Mr Brazier was represented by Mr J. Anderson of counsel, instructed by Carneys Lawyers.  CASA was represented by Mr I. Harvey of counsel, instructed by Mr A. Anastasi of CASA.

BACKGROUND

  1. Mr Brazier obtained a Higher School Certificate in 1991.  He holds a private pilot licence with a number of multi‑engine endorsements.

  2. In January 1994, Mr Brazier commenced employment as an apprentice aircraft maintenance engineer.  At about that time, he also enrolled at Padstow TAFE College to study for an aircraft maintenance and engineering trade certificate.  He completed his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brazier and Civil Aviation Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] AATA 313
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerns a dispute between Mr Brazier, an aircraft maintenance engineer, and the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) regarding allegations of non-compliance with regulations governing aircraft maintenance. The dispute was heard and determined by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The primary legal issues in this case revolved around whether Mr Brazier had correctly certified the completion of maintenance on an aircraft and whether he properly recorded and addressed known defects. Specifically, the Tribunal needed to determine if Mr Brazier had certified maintenance that was not performed in accordance with approved maintenance data and if he had failed to record defects on the maintenance release or Additional Work Sheets, as required.

In addressing these issues, the Tribunal considered the credibility and reliability of the evidence provided by Mr Brazier and Mr Arnold, another licensed aircraft maintenance engineer. The Tribunal found that Mr Arnold's evidence was more reliable as Mr Ryan, who was not a licensed aircraft maintenance engineer, conducted tests without proper authorization and failed to properly record the defects. Furthermore, the Tribunal concluded that Mr Brazier was aware of the defects listed on a handwritten document, despite his denials, and that he failed to properly endorse these defects on the maintenance release, thereby breaching regulatory requirements.

Based on these findings, the Tribunal concluded that Mr Brazier had indeed breached the regulations. The Tribunal's decision underscores the importance of adherence to approved maintenance data and proper documentation of defects in aircraft maintenance. As a result, the Tribunal ruled against Mr Brazier, affirming CASA's allegations of non-compliance.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Mr Arnold, Mr Simpson, and Mr Ryan, all of whom are associated with aircraft maintenance, and Mr Brazier, who is a maintenance provider. Mr Arnold and Mr Simpson are licensed aircraft maintenance engineers, whereas Mr Ryan is not. The case arose due to the conduct of Mr Ryan who, despite not being a licensed aircraft maintenance engineer, conducted tests on an aircraft and cleared a defect from the maintenance release. Mr Ryan did not use a licensed aircraft maintenance engineer to verify or reject Mr Arnold's claim and could not identify the licensed engineers from whom he claimed to have obtained advice. Additionally, Mr Brazier, as the maintenance provider, failed to endorse the maintenance release with the defects set out on a handwritten "snag list" found in the work package. The "snag list" contained a number of defects that were not transferred to the Additional Work Sheets and no certifications of completion of maintenance were evident for these defects.

The matter was brought before the court by the Civil Aviation Authority (CASA), who alleged that Mr Brazier breached certain regulations by not recording known defects on the maintenance release or Additional Work Sheets and by not ensuring that maintenance was completed in accordance with the approved maintenance data for the aircraft. During the proceedings, evidence was presented by Mr Arnold and Mr Ryan, with the court finding Mr Arnold's evidence to be more credible. The court also noted that Mr Brazier had admitted to making an entry on the handwritten "snag list" document, despite his attempts to deny ever having seen it before it appeared in the Tribunal documents. The court concluded that Mr Brazier was aware of the defects set out on the "snag list" and that he failed in his duty as a maintenance provider by not endorsing the maintenance release with these defects.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Arnold and Mr Simpson are both licenced aircraft maintenance engineers. Mr Ryan is not. Further, although Mr Ryan said that he spoke with licenced aircraft maintenance engineers about this defect, he did not use a licenced aircraft maintenance engineer to conduct the test that would verify or reject Mr Arnold's claim. He was unable to identify the licenced aircraft maintenance engineers from whom he said he obtained advice about the conduct of the test. Furthermore, Mr Ryan cleared the defect from the maintenance release after conducting his own tests on the aircraft. Mr Ryan, because he is not a licenced aircraft maintenance engineer, is not authorised to clear defects from a maintenance release. For these reasons, I am of the opinion that the evidence of Mr Arnold is to be preferred to that of Mr Ryan. Accordingly, I find that Mr Brazier has breached reg 42ZP in that he certified for the completion of maintenance, being the periodic inspection, where maintenance was not carried out in accordance with the approved maintenance data for the aircraft.Known defects not recorded on maintenance release or Additional Work Sheets and no evidence of maintenance having been completed The work sheet package in respect of AAM job number 02/004A contains a handwritten list of defects which were not transferred to the Additional Work Sheets and for which no certifications of completion of maintenance are evident. In his cross‑examination, Mr Brazier agreed that the handwritten document, setting out a number of defects, was a document in AAM's work package. The copy document presented to the Tribunal is certified as being a true copy of a document taken from AAM job number 02/004A. Furthermore, Mr Brazier admitted that he had made an entry on that document, being "fuel tank RHS". For that reason alone, it cannot be denied that Mr Brazier must have been aware of the defects set out on that handwritten document. This is despite the fact that, in cross‑examination, Mr Brazier attempted to deny ever having seen that document before it appeared in the T documents. His statements in that regard are plainly incorrect. CASA alleged that the handwritten list of defects is what is commonly known in the aviation industry as a "snag list". CASA said that some aircraft owners or operators use a snag list to avoid compliance with reg 50, which requires an operator or flight crew member who becomes aware of the existence of a defect in the aircraft to make the appropriate endorsement on the maintenance release. However, CASA claims that a maintenance provider in the position of Mr Brazier cannot ignore defects, however they are reported to him. It is common ground between the parties that, as the maintenance provider, Mr Brazier could have endorsed the maintenance release with the defects set out on the handwritten "snag list". He did not do so. The subsequent work package for the aircraft and, in particular, the Additional Work Sheet, lists "RH main bladder US" as a defect. That is a reference to the right‑hand fuel tank of that particular aircraft. The certification of completion of that maintenance confirms that the right‑hand fuel tank was replaced on 25 January 2002. In the course of the show cause conference, the issue of the "snag sheet" was also discussed. It was put to Mr Brazier that the handwritten list was in the work package relating to job number 02/004A and he has not denied that. He did not deny that the handwritten list contained a list of defects.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Mr Brazier breached reg 42ZP by certifying the completion of maintenance where maintenance was not carried out in accordance with the approved maintenance data.
2. Whether Mr Brazier failed to record known defects on the maintenance release or Additional Work Sheets.
3. Whether there is evidence that maintenance was completed in accordance with the approved maintenance data for the aircraft.

Held
1. The court concluded that Mr Brazier breached reg 42ZP by certifying the completion of maintenance where maintenance was not carried out in accordance with the approved maintenance data. As a result, the appeal was dismissed on this issue.
2. The court held that Mr Brazier failed to record known defects on the maintenance release or Additional Work Sheets, and there is no evidence that maintenance was completed in accordance with the approved maintenance data for the aircraft. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed on this issue as well.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court found that Mr Arnold's evidence was to be preferred over Mr Ryan's because Mr Arnold is a licensed aircraft maintenance engineer, whereas Mr Ryan is not. Furthermore, Mr Ryan is not authorised to clear defects from a maintenance release as he conducted his own tests on the aircraft instead of using a licensed aircraft maintenance engineer. The court emphasised that maintenance must be carried out in accordance with the approved maintenance data, and Mr Brazier certified the completion of maintenance despite this requirement not being met. The court also noted that known defects were not recorded on the maintenance release or Additional Work Sheets. The handwritten "snag list" containing the defects was in the work package, and Mr Brazier admitted to making an entry on that document. The court concluded that Mr Brazier must have been aware of the defects on the handwritten document despite his denial during cross-examination. The court held that it is common ground that Mr Brazier could have endorsed the maintenance release with the defects set out on the handwritten "snag list" but failed to do so. Consequently, the court found that Mr Brazier breached reg 42ZP and failed to record known defects on the maintenance release or Additional Work Sheets, and there is no evidence that maintenance was completed in accordance with the approved maintenance data for the aircraft. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a maintenance provider cannot ignore defects reported to them and must ensure that maintenance is carried out in accordance with the approved maintenance data and that known defects are recorded on the maintenance release or Additional Work Sheets.