Brar and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

Brar and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2024] AATA 1040 (12 March 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2023/9617

Re:Kamaljeet Singh Brar

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member McLean Williams 

Date of decision:                    12 March 2024

Date of written reasons:         13 May 2024

Place:Brisbane

Pursuant to section 43 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal sets aside decision dated 18 December 2023 made by the Respondent’s delegate and substitutes it with a decision to revoke the mandatory cancellation of the Applicant’s visa.

…………[SGD]……………
Member McLean Williams

Catchwords

MIGRATION – Non-revocation of mandatory cancellation of visa – where the Applicant fails the character test- whether there is another reason to revoke the mandatory cancellation decision- application of Ministerial Direction No. 99 – Tribunal finding there is another reason to revoke the mandatory cancellation decision – decision under review set aside and substituted

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Cases
FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 185
Khalil v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 151
Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs v HSRN [2023] FCAFC 68

Suleiman v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 594

Secondary Materials

Ministerial Direction No. 99 - Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member McLean Williams
13 May 2024

  1. On 12 March 2024 the Tribunal determined pursuant to the review power under section 501CA(4) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’) to set aside the decision of the Respondent’s Delegate not to revoke the mandatory cancellation of the Applicant’s Class SN Subclass 190 Skilled Nominated Permanent Visa (‘the visa’).

  2. On 26 March 2024 a transcript of the hearing of the evidence in the Application for Review before the Tribunal on 27 and 28 February 2024 became available. 

  3. In accordance with the Full Federal Court decision in Khalil v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 151 (‘Khalil’), the Tribunal now publishes the written reasons for the ‘short form’ decision made on 12 March 2024. In Khalil, the Full Federal Court had said:

    ‘The AAT Act thus draws a clear distinction between the decision of the Tribunal under s 43 which is, relevantly, what causes the 84-day period to stop running, and the reasons for decision. In BTR plc v Westinghouse Brake and Signal Company (Australia) Ltd (1992) 34 FCR 246 the Tribunal had handed down a decision on a review of a decision of the Australian Securities Commission that was before it, confirming an exemption that the Commission had granted on certain conditions, but substituting different conditions. At the time of announcing the decision the Tribunal did not give any reasons. It delivered written reasons some 14 days later. Beaumont J held (at 271 273, Lockhart and Hill JJ agreeing at 253) that the Tribunal's omission to provide reasons at the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brar and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicult... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 1040
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Kamaljeet Singh Brar against the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs. The dispute arose from the mandatory cancellation of Mr Brar's visa following his conviction for sex assault by touch involving a child under 16, and for failing to answer bail. The Tribunal was required to determine whether there was "another reason" why the mandatory cancellation decision should be revoked, in accordance with section 501CA(4)(b)(ii) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth).

The central legal issue before the Tribunal was the application of Ministerial Direction No. 99, which provides a framework for decision-makers exercising the discretion to revoke a mandatory visa cancellation. This involved weighing the primary considerations, such as the protection of the Australian community, against other considerations, including the applicant's personal circumstances and rehabilitation. The Tribunal had to assess the seriousness of the offending conduct and the risk of re-offending, while also considering factors that might justify revocation.

The Tribunal reasoned that while the applicant's offending conduct was objectively serious, it fell within the lower end of the range for such offences. Crucially, the Tribunal accepted expert evidence from a clinical forensic psychologist, Mr Jeffrey Cummins, who assessed the applicant as a low risk of re-offending. Mr Cummins' opinion was that the applicant had "comprehensively 'learnt his lesson'" and that alcohol, a contributing factor to the offending, had been ceased since the applicant's charge. The Tribunal found that these factors, particularly the low risk of re-offending and the applicant's demonstrated remorse and rehabilitation efforts, constituted "another reason" to revoke the mandatory cancellation.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the decision to refuse to revoke the mandatory cancellation of Mr Brar's visa and substituted a decision to revoke the mandatory cancellation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

In accordance with the Full Federal Court decision in Khalil v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 151 (‘Khalil’), the Tribunal now publishes the written reasons for the ‘short form’ decision made on 12 March 2024. In Khalil, the Full Federal Court had said: ‘The AAT Act thus draws a clear distinction between the decision of the Tribunal under s 43 which is, relevantly, what causes the 84-day period to stop running, and the reasons for decision. In BTR plc v Westinghouse Brake and Signal Company (Australia) Ltd (1992) 34 FCR 246 the Tribunal had handed down a decision on a review of a decision of the Australian Securities Commission that was before it, confirming an exemption that the Commission had granted on certain conditions, but substituting different conditions. At the time of announcing the decision the Tribunal did not give any reasons. It delivered written reasons some 14 days later. Beaumont J held (at 271 273, Lockhart and Hill JJ agreeing at 253) that the Tribunal's omission to provide reasons at the time of announcing its decision was not an error, as on the proper construction of s 43(2) of the AAT Act, the Tribunal was only required to give its reasons, oral or in writing, within a reasonable time of the decision. … What the Tribunal had to do here within the 84 days was to deliver a decision, not necessarily express reasons…’[Emphasis by the Tribunal]Background Mr Kamaljeet Singh Brar (‘the Applicant’) is a 39-year old, married male citizen of India. The Applicant first arrived in Australia on 10 June 2014 as the holder of a student (secondary dependent) visa, accompanying his wife, who had come to Australia in order to study, and subsequently to work, as a registered nurse.[1] [1] G Documents, p. 177. Six years later, on 24 June 2020, the Applicant was granted the Class SN Subclass 190 Skilled Nominated Permanent Visa that is now the subject of these proceedings. On 10 March 2022 the Applicant was convicted in the Melbourne Magistrates Court of Person - sex assault by touch - child under 16,[2] and was sentenced to a term of imprisonment for two months, together with a requirement that he undergo a community corrections order for 18 months, with the Applicant’s name also being placed on a register of sex offenders for a period of eight years. [2] G documents, p. 42. The offence in question had been committed by the Applicant on 2 February 2020, on a crowded Melbourne tram, when the Applicant had opportunistically caressed the hips and buttocks of a 14-year old girl, a complete stranger to Applicant, who had the misfortune to be a standing passenger, next to the Applicant. On 10 March 2022 the Applicant was also convicted of ‘fail to answer bail/contravene a conduct condition of bail’, referable to the Applicant having departed the jurisdiction of Victoria, contrary to his bail conditions in the period between his first being charged with the aforementioned sex offence, and his ultimately appearing before the court for sentencing on that charge. The Applicant had departed Victoria in order to visit his wife in the Northern Territory, and also so as to visit his elderly mother in India, in circumstances in which he claimed to have been of the mistaken understanding that he was not required to physically attend Court on the sentencing date.[3] [3] G documents, pp. 45-46 [26] – [16].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In relation to the spectre of alcohol consumption prior to committing this offence, the Applicant expressed the following:‘This incident occurred on a Sunday which is my day off. As it was my day off, I would usually have a few drinks in the morning and go into the city. On this day, I had around two or three beers in a bar in the city before going to St Kilda. Looking back on my drinking habits, I wasn’t thinking when I was drinking. Despite having two alcohol-related convictions, it took this conviction to make me stop drinking. I didn’t know what I was doing when I was drinking alcohol. Since April 2020 when I was charged, I have not drunk alcohol. When I went to India to help my mother I did not drink. Since I have been in immigration detention, I have not touched any alcohol or drugs despite them being in the centre. I will not drink when I am released to the community because I don’t think when I am drinking. Exercise and family are much more important to me now than alcohol.’[13][13] G Documents, p. 124, paragraph [16].Expert Evidence The Tribunal received oral evidence and a psychology report dated 27 February 2024 from a Mr Jeffrey Cummins, Consultant Clinical Forensic Psychologist based in Lonsdale Street, Melbourne. Mr Cummins had interviewed the Applicant on 6 February 2024 by means of video (given that the Applicant was then being held in immigration detention at the Yongah Hill Immigration Detention Centre, in Perth). Mr Cummins informed the Tribunal that he considered that the Applicant was likely to have been under the influence of alcohol at the time of his offending, and that social isolation - arising in consequence of the Applicant being forced by circumstances to live separately and apart from his wife – had played a role in the Applicant’s offending.[14] Mr Cummins’ overall clinical impression was that the Applicant was ‘depressed and anxious’,[15] and had become ‘disinhibited’[16] by alcohol at the time of the offence. [14] Transcript, p. 38, line 1, p. 39, lines 28-29.[15] Transcript p. 40, line 30, see also page 8 of his report, at paragraph 51.[16] Transcript, p. 41, line 7. In his report, Mr Cummins further observes[17] that the Applicant has since put himself through a period of introspection regarding the circumstances giving rise to this offence, and had come to the view that alcohol had been a factor, such that the Applicant had resolved that he would not drink again in the future. Mr Cummins considers that the Applicant is a low risk of re-offending (the lowest level of risk that can be assessed by a psychologist or psychiatrist in Australia), and that ‘In my opinion he has comprehensively “learnt his lesson” regarding his offending behaviour against the underage female because for that offending …he served 32 days in custody and has now been held in immigration detention for a protracted time”.[18][17] Report, p. 5, paragraphs [35] – [39].[18] Report, p.7 paragraph [49]. The Tribunal accepts the opinions expressed by Mr Cummins regarding the future risks of the Applicant re-offending, and considers - on the balance of probabilities - that Mr Cummins’ hypothesis regarding the factors that lead to the commission of the index offence affords the most probable explanation for the Applicant’s conduct.ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION BY THE TRIBUNAL

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Applicant was convicted on his own confession of person - sex assault by touch, child u/16. In light of same, and because of s.501(6)(e) of the Act the Tribunal cannot find that the Applicant passes the character test. The Applicant acknowledges[19] that he cannot pass the character test.[19] Applicant’s Statement of Facts Issues and Contentions (‘SFIC’), paragraph [34].Is there ‘another reason’ why the cancellation decision should be revoked? In light of the Applicant failing the character test, the task for the Tribunal reduces to an exercise of the discretion under subparagraph 501CA(4)(b)(ii), to consider whether or not there is ‘another reason’ why the visa cancellation decision should be revoked. In considering whether to exercise the discretion the Tribunal must comply with any Directions made under the Act by virtue of section 499(2A). In this case, Direction No 99 – Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA (‘the Ministerial Direction’) is applicable. The Ministerial Direction outlines a framework for decision-makers with respect to exercising the discretion outlined in section 501CA of the Act. Relevantly, paragraph 6 of the Ministerial Directions provides: ‘6. Exercising discretion Informed by the principles in paragraph 5.2 above, a decision-maker must take into account the considerations identified in sections 8 and 9, where relevant to the decision.’ The principles contained within 5.2 of the Ministerial Direction are as follows:1Australia has a sovereign right to determine whether non-citizens who are of character concern are allowed to enter and/or remain in Australia. Being able to come to or remain in Australia is a privilege Australia confers on non-citizens in the expectation that they are, and have been, law-abiding, will respect important institutions, such as Australia’s law enforcement framework, and will not cause or threaten harm to individuals or the Australian community. 2Non-citizens who engage or have engaged in criminal or other serious conduct should expect to be denied the privilege of coming to, or to forfeit the privilege of staying in, Australia. 3The Australian community expects that the Australian Government can and should refuse entry to non-citizens, or cancel their visas, if they engaged in conduct, in Australia or elsewhere, that raises serious character concerns. This expectation of the Australian community applies regardless of whether the non-citizen poses a measurable risk of causing physical harm to the Australian community. 4Australia has a low tolerance of any criminal or other serious conduct by visa Applicants or those holding a limited stay visa, or by other non- citizens who have been participating in, and contributing to, the Australian community only for a short period of time. 5With respect to decisions to refuse, cancel, and revoke cancellation of a visa, Australia will generally afford a higher level of tolerance of criminal or other serious conduct by non-citizens who have lived in the Australian community for most of their life, or from a very young age. The level of tolerance will rise with the length of time a non-citizen has spent in the Australian community, particularly in their formative years. 6Decision-makers must take into account the primary and other considerations relevant to the individual case. In some circumstances, the nature of the non-citizen’s conduct, or the harm that would be caused if the conduct were to be repeated, may be so serious that even strong countervailing considerations may be insufficient to justify not cancelling or refusing the visa, or revoking a mandatory cancellation. In particular, the inherent nature of certain conduct such as family violence and the other types of conduct or suspected conduct mentioned in paragraph 8.55(2) (Expectations of the Australian Community) is so serious that even strong countervailing considerations may be insufficient in some circumstances, even if the non-citizen does not pose a measurable risk of causing physical harm to the Australian community.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Notably, these considerations are to be regarded as ‘other’ as opposed to ‘secondary’ considerations. As noted by Colvin J in Suleiman v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 594 at [23]: ‘...Direction 65 [now Direction 99] makes clear that an evaluation is required in each case as to the weight to be given to the ‘other considerations’ (including non-refoulement obligations). It requires both primary and other considerations to be given ‘appropriate weight’. Direction 65 does provide that, generally, primary considerations should be given greater weight. They are primary in the sense that absent some factor that takes the case out of that which pertains ‘generally’ they are to be given greater weight. However, Direction 65 does not require that the other considerations be treated as secondary in all cases. Nor does it provide that primary considerations are ‘normally’ given greater weight. Rather, Direction 65 concerns the appropriate weight to be given to both ‘primary’ and ‘other considerations’. In effect, it requires an inquiry as to whether one or more of the other considerations should be treated as being a primary consideration or the consideration to be afforded greatest weight in the particular circumstances of the case because it is outside the circumstances that generally apply.’PRIMARY CONSIDERATION 1: PROTECTION OF THE AUSTRALIAN COMMUNITY Paragraph 8.1 of the Ministerial Direction requires that the Tribunal keep in mind that the Australian Government is committed to protecting the Australian community from harm in consequence of criminal activity or other serious conduct by non-citizens. Decision-makers are required to have particular regard for the principle that entering or remaining in Australia is a privilege that Australia confers on non-citizens, in the expectation that they are, (and have been) law-abiding; will respect important institutions; and will not cause or threaten harm to the Australian community. This requires consideration of ‘the nature and seriousness of the non-citizen’s conduct to date’, as well as ‘the risk to the Australian community’ in the event that the non-citizen were to commit further offences, or to engage in other serious forms of conduct, if allowed to remain in Australia.The nature and seriousness of the Applicant’s conduct to date The Respondent Minister submits[20] that sexual assault against a child is ‘objectively very serious’, and points to the victim impact statements of both the complainant, and of her mother - as were presented to the Court in Victoria upon the Applicant’s sentencing - in demonstration of the specific harm caused by the Applicant. [20] Respondent’s SFIC paragraph [21]. On behalf the Applicant it is submitted[21] that although the Applicant’s index offence is objectively serious, it nonetheless remains within the lower end of the range of seriousness for such an offence.[21] Applicant’s SFIC paragraphs [40] & [45].