BRANDER v RYAN & MESSENGER PRESS PTY LTD
[2000] SASC 446
Full Court: Prior, Lander and Bleby JJ
1................ PRIOR J:......... I agree with the orders proposed by Lander J for the reasons he has prepared.
2................ LANDER J. ....
Introduction
This Court has before it both an appeal and a cross appeal from a decision of a single Judge of this Court, who allowed an appeal by the plaintiff against the dismissal of the plaintiff’s action in the Magistrates Court. I shall continue to refer to the parties as plaintiff and defendants.
The plaintiff is and was at all material times the Chairman of a political party known as Australian National Action.
The first defendant is the Editor of nine newspapers entitled “The Messenger’ circulating in Adelaide and suburban metropolitan areas and published by the second defendant.
The plaintiff brought action on 4 October 1995 against both defendants in respect of an article published in all nine of the Messenger newspapers on 26 April 1995 claiming that the article was defamatory of him. The first defendant was the author of the article and as I have already said Editor of the newspapers which published it.
The Article
It would be as well to set out the article upon which the plaintiff based his proceedings;
“It’s Little Mikey and the big bad racists
How did little Mikey Brander get to be the leader of the racist gang National Action?
Did he beat all the other, bigger NA chaps in a peeing contest or something?
It is hard to imagine how you can piddle higher than everyone else if you sit down to take a pee.
There must be a simple explanation. Perhaps he is on steroids. Growth hormones certainly can make you edgy and irritable.
And why does he look so miserable all the time? Do you have regular bowel movements at the same time every morning, Mikey?
Or perhaps you are taking your medication in the wrong order. I honestly don’t know if you’re on anything, Mikey, but it’s time you had a urine test.
For a leader, little Mikey always looks the odd one out alongside the other chaps, doesn’t he? So neat, so tidy, so freshly-scrubbed. So very white.
The bigger lads really should do something about their personal hygiene and dress standards if their intention is to panic the populace by frightening them.
Frankly, chaps, the old shaved heads, mirrored sunnies, grunge t-shirts, bovver boots and beer guts have become rather ho-hum. Imagine if you were out there in bell-bottom trousers and pink paisley shirts with stingray collars? Now that is a truly frightening thought.
You could even work up a baton twirling routine among yourselves, with Mikey out front doing the splits in a delicious green leotard. With a ‘Have a nice day’ button pinned to his chest, screaming: ‘I hate Asians!’ Terrifying.
Selecting the right music might be a problem. The chaps look like they’re into heavy metal but try telling me…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Brander v Ryan and Messenger Press Pty Ltd No. Scgrg-99-119 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] SASC 446
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter before the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia is an appeal and cross appeal from a decision of a single Judge of the same Court. The plaintiff, Brander, originally brought action against the defendants, Ryan and Messenger Press Pty Ltd, in the Magistrates Court, claiming that an article published in the Messenger newspapers was defamatory of him. The Magistrates Court dismissed the plaintiff's claim, but the plaintiff appealed to the single Judge of the Supreme Court, who allowed the appeal and ordered judgment for the plaintiff. The defendants then appealed to the Full Court, and the plaintiff lodged a cross appeal. The Full Court must now determine the appeal and cross appeal, focusing on whether the imputations in the article were defamatory, whether the publication was protected by qualified privilege, and whether the costs order was appropriate.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did any of the imputations contended for by the plaintiff arise from the article?
2. If the imputations that the plaintiff is a racist and hates Asians arise, were they defamatory of the plaintiff?
3. If the imputations that the plaintiff is a racist and hates Asians were defamatory, were they true in substance and fact?
4. If the imputations that the plaintiff is a racist and hates Asians were defamatory, were they published on an occasion of qualified privilege?
5. If the imputations that the plaintiff is a racist and hates Asians were defamatory, were they protected by a plea of fair comment?
6. Whether any of the other imputations contended for by the plaintiff arose?
7. If any of the other imputations arose and were defamatory of the plaintiff, whether the words were published on an occasion of qualified privilege?
Held
1. The court concluded that the imputations contended for by the plaintiff did not arise from the article, except for the imputation that the plaintiff was motivated by juvenile attention seeking.
2. The court did not reach a conclusion on whether the imputations that the plaintiff is a racist and hates Asians were defamatory of the plaintiff as it was not challenged by the defendants on appeal.
3. The court did not reach a conclusion on whether the imputations that the plaintiff is a racist and hates Asians were true in substance and fact as it was not challenged by the defendants on appeal.
4. The court did not reach a conclusion on whether the imputations that the plaintiff is a racist and hates Asians were published on an occasion of qualified privilege as it was not challenged by the defendants on appeal.
5. The court did not reach a conclusion on whether the imputations that the plaintiff is a racist and hates Asians were protected by a plea of fair comment as it was not challenged by the defendants on appeal.
6. The court concluded that the imputations that the plaintiff engaged in a feminine or female-like behaviour and that the plaintiff displayed homosexual behaviour did not arise from the article.
7. The court concluded that the imputation that the plaintiff takes drugs did not arise from the article.
8. The court concluded that the imputation that the plaintiff was motivated by juvenile attention seeking arose from the article and was defamatory of the plaintiff.
9. The court concluded that the publication of the words was protected by an occasion of qualified privilege, and that the defence of qualified privilege was not defeated by malice.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining whether any of the imputations contended for by the plaintiff arose from the article. The court determined that only the imputations that the plaintiff was a racist, hated Asians, and was motivated by juvenile attention seeking arose from the article. The court rejected the plaintiff's claims that the article imputed that he engaged in effeminate or female-like behavior, displayed homosexual behavior, or consumed drugs. The court held that the article as a whole was intended to ridicule the plaintiff, but this was not sufficient to establish the specific imputations claimed by the plaintiff.
Next, the court considered whether the imputations that the plaintiff was a racist and hated Asians were defamatory of the plaintiff. The court found that these imputations were defamatory of the plaintiff, as they would lower him in the estimation of right-thinking members of society.
The court then assessed whether these imputations were true in substance and fact. The court found that the plaintiff was indeed a racist and hated Asians, and therefore these imputations were true.
The court next considered whether the imputations were published on an occasion of qualified privilege. The court found that the article related to political matters and was therefore protected by qualified privilege, as established in Lange v Australian Broadcasting Corporation. The court determined that the defendants' conduct in publishing the article was reasonable, as they had reasonable grounds to believe the imputations were true and had taken proper steps to verify the accuracy of the material.
Finally, the court examined whether the imputations were protected by a plea of fair comment. The court found that the defence of fair comment only applied to the imputations that the plaintiff was a racist and hated Asians, which were found to be true. Therefore, the defence of fair comment did not apply to the other defamatory imputations found by the court.
In summary, the court found that the imputations that the plaintiff was a racist, hated Asians, and was motivated by juvenile attention seeking arose from the article and were defamatory of the plaintiff. These imputations were also true in substance and fact, published on an occasion of qualified privilege, and protected by the plea of fair comment for the imputations that the plaintiff was a racist and hated Asians.