Branch v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

[2019] QCA 19

COURT OF APPEAL

HOLMES CJ PHILIPPIDES JA McMURDO JA

CA No 92 of 2018
DC No 2984 of 2017

BRANCH, Brian David  Applicant

v

COMMISSIONER OF POLICE  Respondent BRISBANE

WEDNESDAY, 13 FEBRUARY 2019 JUDGMENT

McMURDO JA: The applicant, Mr Branch, was charged with a traffic offence involving what is called unlawful edge filtering. The rider of a motorbike is edge filtering if the motorbike travels to the outside of the edge line of a road while passing one or more vehicles which are on that road.

Edge filtering is unlawful in any one of several circumstances, of which two were alleged in this case. One was that the speed limit was less than 90 kilometres per hour. The other was that the motorbike was travelling at more than 30 kilometres per hour.

The offence was alleged to have occurred one morning on the Centenary Highway at Jamboree Heights.          The prosecution witness was a police motorcyclist, Senior Constable Kelly, who

followed Mr Branch for some length along the road and said that he saw Mr Branch riding to the left of the left lane at a speed of about 80 kilometres per hour and where the speed limit varied from 60 to 80 kilometres per hour.

Mr Branch gave evidence that he was riding his motorbike on the Centenary Highway but that at no point did he enter the edge of the road. The magistrate accepted the evidence of the police officer and rejected Mr Branch’s evidence to the contrary. Mr Branch was convicted and fined

$500.

Mr Branch appealed against that conviction to the District Court under s 222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Qld). He argued that the hearing before the magistrate had been unfair because he was provided with the brief of evidence only on the morning of the trial. He said that the policeman’s evidence should not have been accepted because it was inconsistent with traffic data which he had obtained and a recording tendered at the trial.

He was permitted by the judge to tender new evidence which consisted of records of the Department of Transport and Main Roads as to the extent of traffic congestion and the speed limits which were current at various places along the Centenary Highway on the morning in question. His appeal to the District Court was dismissed. The judge found there had been no procedural unfairness because Mr Branch, who throughout has been without legal representation, chose to proceed on that day rather than accepting the magistrate’s offer of an adjournment.

The judge said that the new evidence could not have undermined the police officer’s evidence. The magistrate had found that the offence was committed in a location shown in photograph 3 of exhibit 1 in the hearing where the magistrate said the speed limit was 60 kilometres per hour. The data from the department showed that the speed limit was, indeed, 60 kilometres per hour, although the District Court judge said that the limit was 80…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Branch v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCA 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Branch v Commissioner of Police, the Court of Appeal was asked to consider an application for leave to appeal a decision of the District Court of Queensland. The applicant, Mr Branch, had been charged with the traffic offence of unlawful edge filtering. Mr Branch appealed his conviction to the District Court, arguing that the hearing before the magistrate had been unfair and that the police officer's evidence should not have been accepted due to inconsistencies with traffic data and a recording tendered at the trial. The District Court dismissed the appeal, finding that there had been no procedural unfairness and that the new evidence could not have undermined the police officer's evidence.

The appeal to the Court of Appeal centred on the principles governing applications for leave to appeal. The Court noted that leave should not be granted lightly, particularly given that Mr Branch had already had the benefit of two judicial hearings. The Court also noted that an appeal is usually only necessary to correct a substantial injustice to the applicant. In this case, the new evidence from the department indicated that the police officer was mistaken about his recollection of the speed limit at various points along the road, although his evidence as to the speed limit at the relevant location was accurate. The Court found that this inaccuracy was not a substantial basis for the rejection of his evidence overall.

The Court of Appeal found that the District Court judge had conducted a rehearing of the case and reached his own conclusions. The magistrate's decision was based on his findings of the credibility of the two witnesses, and the Court was required to make proper allowance for the advantages of the magistrate in seeing and hearing the evidence as it was given. The Court found that the police officer's evidence was not inconsistent with the evidence from the department about traffic congestion and that there was nothing to suggest that the officer was seeking to fabricate or exaggerate the facts or that he was mistaken. The Court found that the District Court judge did not err in his conduct of the rehearing or in his findings of fact. The application for leave to appeal was refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established