Bradbury v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Bradbury v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2023] QCAT 466

PARTIES:

WAYNE NEVILLE BRADBURY  
(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION
(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR113-22

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

HEARING DATE:

2 August 2023 and later written affidavit material and submissions delivered by the parties.  

DELIVERED ON:

5 December 2023

DECISION OF:

Member Roney KC

ORDERS:

1. Pursuant to section 24(1)(a) of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act (2009) the decision of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission made on 3 March 2022 to disallow a claim under the Queensland Home Warranty Scheme is confirmed.

2.      The Application for review of a decision is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – BUILDERS – STATUTORY INSURANCE SCHEME – where  applicant sought review of decision by Commission to disallow claim under the Queensland Home Warranty Insurance Scheme – where Commission’s expert found structural defects resulting in damage to surrounding building elements and causing loss a loss of amenity for the property occupants – when the defect first became evident to an owner or insured –  whether defect first became evident after 6 years and 6 months of both the date of entering into the contract for the performance of the work and the date the insurance premium was paid  and – whether on a the proper construction of the Policy Conditions, the applicant was entitled to benefits under the statutory insurance scheme where a  defect was evident to the former owner or occupier of the property, within 6 years and 6 months of the date of payment of the insurance premium, or the date of entering into the contract – where the claimant under the policy did not have such knowledge in time – whether Commission’s decision to refuse indemnity  ought be set aside

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 3, s 7, s 28

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 20, s 24

Fane v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2017] QCAT 59

Harley v. Department of Justice and Attorney-General [2012] QCAT 620

Kehl v Board of Professional Engineers of Queensland [2010] QCATA 58

Lange v Queensland Building Services Authority [2012] 2 Qd R 457

Reiterer v Queensland Building Services Authority [2007] QCCTB 177

Van Kampen v Queensland Building And Construction Commission [2017] QCAT 163

Ross Barry Winter & Debra Anne Winter v Queensland Building and Construction Commission unreported 5 April 2022

Orlanski v Queensland Building Services Authority [2011] QCAT 35

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Self- represented

Respondent:

Ms G Yates of Counsel instructed by the respondent

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The Applicant, who owns a home at Norfolk Drive, Hidden Valley, Queensland has applied pursuant to sections 86(1)(h) and 87 of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (the QBCC Act) for review of the respondent Commission’s decision made on 3 March 2022 to wholly decline Mr Bradbury’s claim under the statutory insurance scheme in respect of defective waterproofing to an ensuite shower at the home…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bradbury v Queensland Building and Construction Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCAT 466
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Bradbury v Queensland Building and Construction Commission, the applicant sought a review of a decision by the Queensland Building and Construction Commission to disallow a claim under the Queensland Home Warranty Insurance Scheme. The Commission found structural defects in a building, which caused damage to surrounding elements and resulted in a loss of amenity for the occupants. The key issue was whether the defect first became evident to the applicant within six years and six months of both the date of entering into the contract for the performance of the work and the date the insurance premium was paid. The applicant argued that the defect first became evident after this period, and therefore they were entitled to benefits under the statutory insurance scheme. The court had to decide whether the Commission’s decision to refuse indemnity should be set aside.

The court found that the statutory insurance policy was a limited policy with strict timeframes, which could not be extended. The court emphasised that the defect must have become apparent or "evident" to the homeowner within six years and six months from the date of commencement of the policy of insurance. The court noted that the policy was not intended to cover defects that became evident long after the construction period. The court further held that if the applicant's interpretation of when a defect becomes evident were to prevail, it would create a policy of insurance with unlimited cover, which was not the intention of the policy.

Based on the court's reasoning, the decision of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission made on 3 March 2022 to disallow a claim under the Queensland Home Warranty Scheme was confirmed. The court dismissed the application for review of the decision.

ORDERS:
1. Pursuant to section 24(1)(a) of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act (2009), the decision of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission made on 3 March 2022 to disallow a claim under the Queensland Home Warranty Scheme is confirmed.
2. The Application for review of a decision is dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to section 24(1)(a) of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act (2009) the decision of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission made on 3 March 2022 to disallow a claim under the Queensland Home Warranty Scheme is confirmed.

2. The Application for review of a decision is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In construing the relevant policy, it is not my task to decide whether there are financial or political or social policy considerations which a legislator might think were relevant. The notion that in a case such as this, where the defect which was always there, became evident to the Insured a matter of weeks outside the 6 year six month limit, and could if the latent defect had led to the inevitable failure in the ensuite a month earlier, would is impose a burden upon the Commission to insure against and respond to ongoing and indefinite complaints and that this burden would be inevitably passed on to other builders and home owners through the cost of higher insurance premiums and increased building costs is hyperbolic. It is only by an accident of fate that the water damage of 23 September 2021 did not occur between 1 April and 28 April 2021, and if it had, it would have become demonstrably evident within the relevant 6-year 6-month time frame, and while the Applicant was an insured.The “expiry of policy” argument from Clause 4.4, and other decisions As I have said, Clause 4.4, makes reference to the expiry of cover and timing from when the defect became evident., Hence although Clause 4.4 of the policy does not reference a particular insured, or reference an insured at all, in the context of that event of disclosure. If as its heading suggests, it is identifying the “expiry of cover” and more particularly, the circumstances in which an Applicant insured will be covered under the relevant policy, it cannot have that effect if an earlier disclosure of the defect to someone else than this insured, can satisfy the requirement for it to have become evident. Again, the construction of it is not assisted by the fact that the clause itself does not say anything about when cover expires. Earlier decisions of this Tribunal have treated equivalent clauses as providing a time limit under the policy of 6 years and 6 months. In Orlanski v Queensland Building Services Authority [2011] QCAT 35 Member Howard said, in dealing with a similar earlier version of the clause 4.4 provision (my emphasis) It should be noted that the strict and very limited limitation time for complaint of three months from becoming aware of the defect was introduced by the 2016 amendments to the policy. In Van Kampen v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2017] QCAT 163 the member held as follows; (again my emphasis)Upon this Application for Review Ms Van Kampen agrees that the central issue is clause 2.4 in the insurance policy and the wording therein where it says that the BSA is only liable to pay for a loss where the defect within six years and six months after the defect “becoming evident”. Yet, Ms Van Kampen submits that the defect became “evident” on the day of construction, by reason that a defective building technique undertaken at that stage caused the creation of a latent problem and that the defect was not then “visible” until much later when engineering experts hired by the Van Kampen’s revealed the true nature of the problem for them. I do not accept this construction. It is not sufficient for the defect to exist as a latent defect within six years and six months and for awareness of it to occur much later. Rather, the defect must have become apparent (or “evident”) to the homeowner within the period of six years and six months from the date of commencement of the policy of insurance. As identified in Orlanski v Queensland Building Services Authority the statutory policy of insurance is a limited policy of insurance, with strict time frames, that cannot be extended. Expressed another way, the claimant homeowner must know about the problem within six years and six months if they are to have any redress under the time limited To adopt the Applicant’s interpretation of when a defect becomes evident would be to create a policy of insurance with unlimited cover. If that interpretation were to prevail, then a problem arising even 100 years after construction (if per chance traceable to some defective building technique during construction) would still be covered by the Home Warranty Scheme.This cannot be the intention of the policy.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.