BPS16 v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BPS16 v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2019] FCCA 411
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Protection (Class XA) visa – review of decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) – where the Applicant seeks impermissible merits review – no basis for the Applicant’s assertion that the AAT was biased – ground of denial of procedural fairness not made out – where the AAT understood and applied the real chance test – where the AAT considered the Applicant’s claims against the complementary protection criterion – AAT was not required to put independent country information to the Applicant for comment – adverse credibility findings of the AAT were legally reasonable and had a logical, rational or probative basis – application dismissed with costs.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.36, 65, 424A, 476

Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth), sch.1, pt.3

Cases cited:

Abebe v Commonwealth of Australia (1999) 162 ALR 1

BJB16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 49
CED15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 451
Chan Yee Kin v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1989) 87 ALR 412
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZAI & Anor (2009) 259 ALR 429
SZSGA v Minister for Immigration, Multicultural Affairs and Citizenship [2013] FCA 774

Applicant: BPS16
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION 
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: MLG 1379 of 2016
Judgment of: Judge C.E. Kirton QC
Hearing date: 7 May 2018
Date of Last Submission: 7 May 2018
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 26 February 2019

REPRESENTATION

The Applicant appeared in person
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr Goodwin
Solicitors for the First Respondent: Sparke Helmore Lawyers
Solicitors for the Second Respondent: The Second Respondent filed a submitting notice save as to costs

ORDERS

  1. The Application is dismissed.

  2. The Applicant pay the First Respondent’s costs of the proceeding fixed in the sum of $5,500.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT MELBOURNE

MLG 1379 of 2016

BPS16

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. The Applicant is an asylum seeker from Bangladesh who arrived in Australia on 5 May 2013.  On 27 October 2014 a delegate of the First Respondent (Delegate) refused to grant the Applicant a protection visa under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Act).

  2. On 2 June 2016 the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) affirmed the decision of the Delegate. This is an application under s.476 of the Act to review the decision of the Tribunal.

Synopsis

  1. I have determined that each of the four grounds of the application should be dismissed with costs of $5,500 to be paid by the Applicant to the First Respondent (Minister).

Background

  1. The Applicant is a citizen of Bangladesh, was born on 7 July 1988 and is now 30 years old.

  2. The Applicant departed Bangladesh in March…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BPS16 v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCCA 411
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) to affirm a delegate's decision not to grant a visa to the applicant, who claimed to fear harm in Bangladesh as a supporter of the Bangladesh National Party (BNP). The applicant's claims were based on allegations of political persecution by supporters of the opposing Awami League, including extortion, the burning of his shop, and threats against his family. The delegate had made adverse credibility findings against the applicant due to vague, inconsistent, and implausible evidence. The Tribunal affirmed this decision, finding the applicant's evidence on central aspects of his claims to be vague, unsubstantiated, and inconsistent.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Tribunal erred in law in affirming the delegate's decision, specifically concerning the Tribunal's assessment of the applicant's credibility and the evidence presented. The Tribunal was required to determine whether the applicant had discharged his burden of proof in establishing a real chance of suffering harm if returned to Bangladesh, based on his political affiliation and the alleged actions of the Awami League. This involved scrutinising the applicant's evidence regarding his political activities, the alleged protest and destruction of his property, and subsequent threats.

The Tribunal's reasoning was grounded in detailed adverse credibility findings against the applicant. It identified numerous inconsistencies in the applicant's evidence concerning his business, the alleged extortion payments, the protest he claimed to have organised, and the events immediately following his departure from Bangladesh. The Tribunal also found the applicant's claims regarding his political affiliation with the BNP to be not credible, noting his lack of detailed knowledge about the party's principles and membership. Furthermore, the Tribunal did not accept the applicant's claims of threats to his family, particularly as he failed to provide supporting documentation after being given an opportunity to do so. The Tribunal applied the principles of assessing credibility by considering the vagueness, unsubstantiated nature, and inconsistencies within the applicant's evidence, ultimately concluding that his claims were not credible.

The court dismissed the application for judicial review. The Tribunal's findings of fact and credibility were open to it on the evidence before it, and it did not make any errors of law in its assessment.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of BPS16 v Minister for Immigration concerns the visa application of an individual, referred to as the Applicant, from Bangladesh. The Applicant claimed to fear harm as a supporter of the Bangladesh National Party (BNP), citing his family’s involvement with the BNP and his own increasing political activism. The Applicant's primary basis for his claim was detailed in a Statutory Declaration accompanying his visa application, in which he stated that he had owned a shop from 2010 to 2013 and paid extortion money to the Awami League, the opposing party to the BNP. He alleged that in retaliation for arranging a protest against these extortion payments, his shop and others were burnt down by Awami League supporters in March 2013. He further claimed that while he managed to escape without injury, he subsequently fled Bangladesh due to fear of further harm from the Awami League.

The Applicant was interviewed by a Delegate on 14 October 2014, and on 27 October 2014, the Delegate decided not to grant the visa, citing vagueness and inconsistencies in the Applicant’s evidence, as well as the implausibility of some of his claims. On 31 October 2014, the Applicant filed an application for review of the Delegate’s Decision with the Refugee Review Tribunal. The Tribunal hearing took place on 17 May 2017, during which the Applicant raised a new claim that his younger brother and father were in hiding due to threats from the Awami League. The Tribunal affirmed the Delegate’s Decision on 2 June 2016, finding that the Applicant’s evidence was vague, unsubstantiated, and often inconsistent with his earlier evidence, leading to a conclusion that his claims were not credible.

This case involves the affirmation of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) concerning the visa application of the Applicant, BPS16, against the Minister for Immigration. The Applicant originally filed a visa application and was subsequently interviewed by a Delegate on 14 October 2014. Following this interview, the Delegate decided on 27 October 2014 not to grant the visa, a decision which the Applicant challenged by filing an application for review in the AAT on 31 October 2014. The AAT hearing took place on 17 May 2017, and following this hearing, the Applicant provided a letter from the President of the Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) in Upazila-Chowgacha, in the Jessore District. The AAT affirmed the Delegate’s decision on 2 June 2016, finding that the Applicant's claims were not credible due to inconsistencies and vagueness in his evidence. This case is an example of a judicial review application where the AAT reviewed the Delegate's decision and considered new evidence provided by the Applicant.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal affirmed the Delegate’s Decision on 2 June 2016 (Tribunal Decision)[6]. The Tribunal Decision commenced by setting out the law relevant to the Visa application and the claims made by the Applicant, which were made primarily in the Statutory Declaration[7]. The Tribunal referred to a new claim raised by the Applicant at the hearing, that the Applicant’s younger brother and father were in hiding due to threats from the Awami League[8]. [6] CB 119-129.[7] Tribunal Decision at [4]-[13].[8] Ibid., at [12]; CB 123. The Tribunal found that the Applicant was a citizen of Bangladesh[9]. In considering the Applicant’s claims to fear harm, the Tribunal made the following finding:The applicant’s evidence on central aspects of his claims was variously vague, unsubstantiated, as well as often inconsistent with his earlier evidence… the Tribunal is not satisfied that the claims of the applicant are credible[10].[9] Ibid., at [13]; CB 123.[10] Ibid,, at [15]; CB 123. The reasons for that finding were:a)The Applicant provided inconsistent evidence about the shop he said that he operated in Chowgacha. The Applicant gave conflicting evidence before the Delegate and the Tribunal concerning the number of rooms that comprised the shop and how many shops were on the relevant street in Chowgacha[11]. [11] Ibid., at [16]; CB 124.b)The Tribunal found that the Applicant gave inconsistent evidence about the extortion money paid to the Awami League and his business turnover. The Applicant also gave inconsistent answers to the Delegate and the Tribunal in relation to the period that he had paid extortion money, the amount paid and the number of people who would attend at his shop to demand money. The Tribunal did not accept that the Applicant had a satisfactory explanation for these inconsistencies[12].[12] Ibid., at [17]; CB 124.c)The Tribunal considered that there were inconsistencies in the Applicant’s evidence in relation to his reports to police and his claims of harm prior to March 2013[13]. At the Tribunal hearing the Applicant said that he had been physically assaulted by supporters of the Awami League three months prior to the protest and the burning of his shop in March 2013. The Tribunal noted that these claims had not been previously made in the Visa application or before the Delegate. It was not accepted by the Tribunal that the Applicant reported any threats from the Awami League to the police or that he was ever harmed as claimed[14]. [13] Ibid., at [18]; CB 124.[14] Ibid., at [18]; CB 125.d)The Tribunal found that the Applicant’s evidence concerning the protest that he said he organised was also “[…] vague and lacked detail” and was inconsistent with his previous evidence[15]. There were discrepancies concerning how many shopkeepers were involved, how many Awami League supporters attacked them and the injuries suffered by the other shopkeepers. The Tribunal also considered the BMP President’s letter and noted the discrepancy in the dates provided in relation to the protest. The Tribunal concluded that it did not accept that the Applicant was involved in organising or attended a protest or that his shop was burnt down by the Awami League in March 2013. [15] Ibid., at [19];CB 125. e)The Tribunal found that the Applicant gave conflicting details of events immediately following the protest regarding:i)The location of the Hotel where he stayed in Dhaka; and ii)The circumstances in which supporters of the Awami league came looking for him.The Tribunal did not accept that the Applicant was required to flee Dhaka in 2013 or that he was pursued by the Awami League[16].f)The Tribunal did not consider that the Applicant’s claims of his association with the BNP were credible. The Applicant told the Tribunal that he was a member of the BNP, whereas he had stated on the Statutory Declaration that he was only a supporter. The Applicant gave unsatisfactory evidence concerning how a person became a member of the BNP and the circumstances of his membership. Further, the Applicant was unable to recall the main principles of the BNP or describe the BNP flag[17]. The Tribunal concluded:[…] the Tribunal would expect someone in the applicant’s claimed circumstances, who has been interested in the BNP since he was young and whose father was a member, and whose uncles and friends where members, and who attended meetings often, would have more detailed knowledge of the BNP than the applicant displayed during the hearing[18].The Tribunal therefore did not accept that the Applicant was a supporter of the BNP or involved in meetings, political discussions, rallies or electioneering for the BNP[19].g)The Tribunal found that the Applicant had manufactured claims of threats of harm to his family since he had departed Bangladesh[20]. The Applicant told the Tribunal that he could obtain documents in support of his evidence regarding threats of harm to his father and brother. The Tribunal afforded the Applicant an opportunity to provide these documents after the hearing, however none were submitted to the Tribunal by the Applicant. The Applicant also failed to satisfactorily explain the lateness of raising these new claims[21]. [16] Ibid., at [20]; CB 125.[17] Ibid., at [21] and [22]; CB 126.[18] Ibid., at [22]; CB 126.[19] Ibid., at [22]; CB 127.[20] Ibid., at [23]; CB 127.[21] Loc. cit.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant claimed to fear harm as a supporter of the Bangladesh National Party (BNP) and set out the primary basis for that claim in a Statutory Declaration that accompanied his Visa application (Statutory Declaration)[2]. The Applicant stated that he had a number of prominent family members involved with the BNP and that he had become more politically active over the years preceding his departure from Bangladesh. In particular the Applicant said that from 2010 to 2013 he had owned a shop and paid extortion money to the Awami League, the opposing party to the BNP. The Applicant said that he arranged a protest against making these extortion payments and in retaliation in March 2013, his shop and many others were burnt down by supporters of the Awami League. The Applicant stated that the Awami League supporters tried to physically beat him but that he managed to escape without injury. The Applicant subsequently fled to Dhaka, where he heard Awami League members were at his hotel asking for him. The Applicant then left Bangladesh for Australia. [2] CB 56-58. The Delegate interviewed the Applicant on 14 October 2014 and on 27 October 2014 decided not to grant the Visa (Delegate’s Decision)[3]. [3] CB 75-89. The Delegate’s reasons for decision indicate that the Delegate made adverse credibility findings against the Applicant based on his vague evidence, a number of inconsistencies in the evidence and the implausibility of some of that evidence. The Delegate accepted that the Applicant was a supporter of the BNP as a result of his family connections and that he had paid extortion money to people associated with the Awami League. The Delegate did not accept that the Applicant organised a protest, that his shop had been burnt down, that anyone was assaulted or that his family was subsequently extorted or threatened. On 31 October 2014 the Applicant filed an application for review of the Delegate’s Decision in the Refugee Review Tribunal (now the Administrative Appeals Tribunal)[4] (Tribunal). The hearing took place on 17 May 2017. Following the hearing the Applicant provided the Tribunal with a letter from the President of the BNP in Upazila-Chowgacha, in the Jessore District (BNP President’s Letter)[5]. [4] CB 90-97.[5] CB 118. The Tribunal affirmed the Delegate’s Decision on 2 June 2016 (Tribunal Decision)[6]. The Tribunal Decision commenced by setting out the law relevant to the Visa application and the claims made by the Applicant, which were made primarily in the Statutory Declaration[7]. The Tribunal referred to a new claim raised by the Applicant at the hearing, that the Applicant’s younger brother and father were in hiding due to threats from the Awami League[8]. [6] CB 119-129.[7] Tribunal Decision at [4]-[13].[8] Ibid., at [12]; CB 123. The Tribunal found that the Applicant was a citizen of Bangladesh[9]. In considering the Applicant’s claims to fear harm, the Tribunal made the following finding:The applicant’s evidence on central aspects of his claims was variously vague, unsubstantiated, as well as often inconsistent with his earlier evidence… the Tribunal is not satisfied that the claims of the applicant are credible[10].[9] Ibid., at [13]; CB 123.[10] Ibid,, at [15]; CB 123.