Boyle and Power v Townsville City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

LAND APPEAL COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Boyle and Power v Townsville City Council  [2004] QLAC 0094
PARTIES: Mercia E Boyle and the Estate of Ada I Power (Deceased)
(appellants)
v.

Townsville City Council
(respondent)

FILE NO: LAC2003/0009
DIVISION: Land Appeal Court of Queensland
PROCEEDING: Appeal from a decision of the Land Court in the matter of determination of compensation consequent upon the acquisition of land for sewerage purposes pursuant to the Acquisition of Land Act 1967
ORIGINATING COURT: Land Court of Queensland
DELIVERED ON: 27 October 2004
DELIVERED AT: Townsville
HEARD AT: Townsville
MEMBERS: Justice Cullinane
Mr JJ Trickett, President
Mrs CAC MacDonald, Member
ORDERS: 1. The appeal is dismissed.
2. The appellants pay the respondent's costs to be assessed.
CATCHWORDS:

RESUMPTION AND ACQUISITION OF LAND —TOWN PLANNING — PLANNING SCHEMES AND INSTRUMENTS — STRATEGIC PLANS — DEVELOPMENT CONTROL PLANS — DETERMINATION OF COMPENSATION — where Authority resumed land for sewerage purposes — whether Land Court erred in methods of valuation of land

Integrated Planning Act (1997) Qld
Local Government (Planning and Environment) Act (1990) Qld, s. 5.1(6A),

Weightman v Gold Coast City Council (2002) 121 LGERA 161, considered
Spencer v The Commonwealth (1907) 5 CLR 418, cited

APPEARANCES: Mr PJ Lyons QC with him Mr RS Jones for the appellants
Mr CL Hughes SC with him Mr RM Needham for the respondent
SOLICITORS: Wilson, Ryan & Grose for the appellants
Suthers Taylor for the respondent
  1. This is an appeal by landowners against the decision of the Land Court on 19 December 2002 awarding compensation of $511,957.18, following the taking of land for sewerage purposes.

Background

  1. Mercia E Boyle and the Estate of Ada I Power (deceased) (the appellants) were the owners of a vacant parcel of land fronting Yule Street on Magnetic Island, with an area of 13.812 ha (the subject land), situated about 1.3 km north-west of Picnic Bay.  On 3 November 2000, the Townsville City Council (the respondent) resumed the whole of that land for sewerage purposes.

  2. The appellants' claim for compensation (as amended) was for $689,458.21, comprising land $675,000, valuation fees $6,875 and legal fees $7,583.21.  The respondent's final valuation before the Court was for $475,000.  The Land Court's determination of compensation at $511,957.18, included the value of the land taken at $497,500 and the agreed disturbance items of $14,457.18.

  3. The appellants' notice of appeal contained seven grounds of appeal, contending that various findings by the Land Court were contrary to law and/or against the evidence and the weight of evidence.  The appellants assert that the compensation for the land resumed should be assessed at $725,000, or alternatively $620,000, or $554,000.

  4. The subject land was described in detail in paragraph [4] of the decision of the Land Court:

    "The subject land is severed almost centrally by a gully system running north to south then extending laterally (generally east-west) near to the Yule Street frontage.  Falling away from mountainous areas which lie externally to the north, the areas of highest elevation on the subject land are…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Boyle and Power v Townsville City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] QLAC 94
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Boyle and Power v Townsville City Council, the Court was asked to determine the appropriate compensation for land resumed by the respondent for sewerage purposes. The dispute centred on the methods used by the Land Court to value the land. The appellants, Boyle and Power, challenged the valuation methods adopted by the Land Court, particularly the use of in globo sales evidence and hypothetical development exercises.

The legal issues before the Court were whether the Land Court had erred in its methods of valuation, particularly the reliance on in globo sales evidence and the hypothetical development exercises. The Court was tasked with assessing the persuasiveness of the evidence provided by the various experts, including the valuers and engineers, to determine the appropriate compensation.

The Court found that the Land Court had not erred in its valuation methods. While the Court did not make definitive findings on the evidence of development costs, it considered the evidence of Mr Flanagan, the engineer for the respondent, to be generally more persuasive. The Court also concluded that the Land Court's primary method of valuation, direct comparison with sales of in globo land, was appropriate and supported by the evidence. The Court adopted Mr Duncan's in globo valuation, which resulted in a total land value of $497,500.

The Court dismissed the appeal and ordered that the appellants pay the respondent's costs to be assessed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

2. The appellants pay the respondent's costs to be assessed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Land Court concluded that a group title subdivision development could be designed which did not conflict with the Strategic Plan or the DCP. However, as the claimants' conceptual plan did not constitute an acceptable group title subdivision development proposal, any hypothetical development valuation exercise based on that plan was of no assistance. Nor was the Court able to relate the evidence of gross realisation or of development costs from the claimants' conceptual plan to the type of group title subdivision which would be capable of being approved. While declining to make findings relating to the evidence of the various experts about development costs, the Court considered the evidence of Mr Flanagan, the engineer for the respondent, to be generally more persuasive. The Valuation Evidence Before the Land Court, both valuers, Mr Eales for the claimants and Mr Duncan for the respondent, had adopted the process of direct comparison with sales of in globo land as the primary method of valuation and each of them had checked the result by means of hypothetical development exercises. Mr Eales had arrived at an in globo valuation of $675,000, attributing $70,000 per ha to the 5.2 ha on the eastern severance and $36,000 per ha to the 8.612 ha on the western severance. His hypothetical development check valuation, based on the concept plan discussed earlier, resulted in a valuation of $680,000. Further valuations were made during the hearing based on Park Residential plans prepared by Mr Flanagan. From a 12 lot subdivision concept with 11 lots on the eastern severance and the balance area as one lot, Mr Eales arrived at a land value of $785,000. Mr Duncan arrived at an in globo valuation of $475,000 by direct comparison with sales, attributing $57,500 per ha to the 5.35 ha on the eastern severance, $30,000 per ha to 5 ha on the western severance and $5,000 per ha to 3.462 ha of timbered drainage corridors and natural buffer. During the hearing, he also carried out hypothetical development exercises based on Mr Flanagan's concept plans, agreeing with Mr Eales that the 12 lot Park Residential concept yielding 11 lots on the eastern severance and a large balance lot on the western severance, produced the more economically viable result. The resulting land value was $490,000 generally supported his primary valuation. Mr Duncan also considered a hypothetical development exercise similar to that carried out by Mr Eales based on the claimants' concept plan. Mr Duncan's conclusion was that the in globo values adopted by Mr Eales in his primary approach of $70,000 per ha for the eastern severance and $36,000 per ha for the balance area, could not be supported. After considering in detail the in globo sales evidence used by each of the valuers in arriving at their primary valuations, the Land Court adopted Mr Duncan's in globo valuation of $57,500 per ha for the 5.35 ha eastern severance (which the Court thought to be generous), based on its highest and best use as Park Residential development and increased his assessment to $190,395 for the western severance as one large rural residential lot, to arrive at a total of $498,020. This equates to an in globo value of approximately $36,000 per ha, and when applied to the 13.812 ha of the subject land, results in a rounded figure of $497,500. This was the value of the land ultimately determined by the Land Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established