Box v State Transit Authority of NSW

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

CITATION:Box v State Transit Authority of New South Wales [2005] NSW WCC PD 29

APPELLANT:  Lindsay Box

RESPONDENT:  State Transit Authority of New South Wales

INSURER:Railcover

FILE NUMBER:  WCC10839-2003

DATE OF REGISTRAR’S DECISIONS:           7 and 15 June 2004

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  3 May 2005

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION:                Appeal against decisions of Registrar; failure to give reasons for decision; failure to use best endeavours to bring the parties to a settlement.

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Acting Deputy President Robin Handley

HEARING:On the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant: Bale Boshev Lawyers

Respondent: Sparke Helmore Lawyers

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL: The decision of the Registrar acting as an Arbitrator, dated 15 June 2004, is revoked. The matter is remitted to an Arbitrator to be appointed by the Registrar, for determination afresh, including using his or her best endeavours to effect a settlement, as required by section 355(1) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998, in accordance with these reasons.

No order is made as to the costs of this appeal.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

1.On 22 June 2004, Lindsay Box (‘the Appellant’) sought leave to bring an ‘Appeal Against Decision of Arbitrator’ in the Workers Compensation Commission (‘the Commission’) against decisions by the Registrar dated 7 and 15 June 2004.

2.The Respondent to the Appeal is the State Transit Authority of New South Wales (‘the Respondent’).

3.Mr Box was born on 27 May 1949 and is aged 55. He has worked as an electrician for the State Transit Authority since about 1972. Mr Box suffered several injuries to his left shoulder in the course of his employment and his claim for compensation in respect of those injuries was settled by agreement dated 26 October 2000. On 23 January 2001, he also suffered a work-related injury to his right shoulder. On 18 February 2003, Mr Box lodged a further claim for workers compensation in respect of left and right arm injuries. On 6 June 2003, he lodged an ‘Application to Resolve a Dispute’ with the Commission. At a teleconference with the parties on 17 September 2003, an Arbitrator made directions by consent, including the following:

“(1)   That the Applicant discontinues his Application so far as it relates to the Left Arm.

(2)   The Application, so far as it relates to the Right Arm is continued including for AMS [Approved Medical Specialist] referral purposes.”

4.On 10 November 2003, Mr Box was examined by an Approved Medical Specialist (‘AMS’), Professor Robin Higgs, an Orthopaedic Surgeon. In a Medical Assessment Certificate of Permanent Impairment issued by the Commission on 16 January 2004, Professor Higgs concluded that Mr Box suffers from the following conditions:

·    “Right-sided post-traumatic acromio-humeral impingement syndrome that has been treated by arthroscopic acromioplasty. The acromio-humeral impingement syndrome is associated with acromial spur formation.

·    Severe degenerative osteoarthritis of the left gleno-humeral joint.”

5.Professor Higgs stated the following opinion:

“I have formed the opinion that the Worker…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Box v State Transit Authority of NSW and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWWCCPD 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Box v State Transit Authority of NSW involved an appeal by Lindsay Box against decisions made by the Registrar of the Workers Compensation Commission. The Respondent was the State Transit Authority of New South Wales. Mr Box, who had been an electrician for the Respondent since 1972, lodged a claim for workers' compensation following injuries to his right shoulder in January 2001. The dispute centred on the compensation awarded for the permanent impairment resulting from the injury. The key issues in the appeal were whether the Registrar provided sufficient reasons for her decision, whether she considered all relevant considerations and documentation, and whether she failed to observe mandatory procedures outlined in the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998.

The court first considered whether an appeal against the Registrar's decision could proceed. The Appellant's appeal was lodged within the 28-day period, satisfying the threshold requirements of the Act. The Registrar’s decisions of 7 and 28 June 2004 were found not to be appellable. However, regarding the decision of 15 June 2004, the court found that the Registrar, acting as an Arbitrator, had made an error of law by not providing adequate reasons for her decision and by not attempting to bring the parties to a settlement. The Registrar's Certificate of Determination did not contain an adequate statement of reasons for the decision, and thus, the decision was revoked. The matter was remitted to an Arbitrator for determination afresh, including using best endeavours to effect a settlement. No order was made as to the costs of this appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Lindsay Box, an electrician for the State Transit Authority of New South Wales, suffered injuries to his left shoulder in the course of his employment, which were settled by agreement in 2000. On 23 January 2001, Box suffered a work-related injury to his right shoulder. In February 2003, he lodged a claim for workers compensation regarding injuries to his left and right arms. An Approved Medical Specialist (AMS) assessed Box's injuries, concluding a 30% loss of full and normal function of the right upper limb. The AMS attributed 10% permanent loss of efficient use of the right arm at or above the elbow to the injury on 23 January 2001. The Registrar issued a Certificate of Determination on 15 June 2004, ordering the Respondent to pay Box $8000 in compensation and his costs.

On 22 June 2004, Box appealed the Registrar's decisions of 7 and 15 June 2004. The appeal was heard by Acting Deputy President Robin Handley on the papers. The appeal was filed within 28 days of the Registrar's decisions and met the threshold requirements of section 352 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998. The Respondent argued that the appeal should be dismissed, as there was no provision for appealing the Registrar's decisions. The Appellant argued that the Registrar failed to provide sufficient reasons for her decision, did not consider all relevant documentation, and did not afford the parties an opportunity to settle the dispute.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. In relation to the Decision of 7 June 2004 as amended by the further Decision of 28 June 2004, whether the Registrar provided sufficient reasons for her decision, whether she considered and/or took into account all relevant considerations and documentation and demonstrated dealing with the substantial issues upon which the decision turns, and whether she failed to observe mandatory procedures outlined in section 328 of the 1998 Act.
2. In relation to the Decision of 15 June 2004, whether the Appellant can appeal against the medical assessment pursuant to section 327(3)(a) or (b) of the 1998 Act.
3. Whether the Appellant has been denied procedural fairness.
4. Whether an appeal can be made against the decision of the Registrar.

Held
1. In relation to the Decision of 7 June 2004 as amended by the further Decision of 28 June 2004, the court held that the Registrar provided sufficient reasons for her decision, she considered and took into account all relevant considerations and documentation, and she did not fail to observe mandatory procedures outlined in section 328 of the 1998 Act.
2. In relation to the Decision of 15 June 2004, the court held that the Appellant cannot appeal against the medical assessment pursuant to section 327(3)(a) or (b) of the 1998 Act.
3. The court held that the Appellant has not been denied procedural fairness.
4. The court held that an appeal can be made against the decision of the Registrar.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the Appellant's appeal against decisions of the Registrar, focusing on the sufficiency of reasons provided, the applicability of procedural fairness, and the availability of appeal against the Registrar's decisions. Firstly, the court noted that the Registrar's decisions of 7 and 28 June 2004 were not subject to appeal, as there is no provision under the 1998 Act for such appeals. The court found that the Registrar's decisions were made in accordance with the Act and the Rules, and the Appellant's submissions did not establish the existence of grounds for appeal under section 327(3) of the 1998 Act. Regarding the decision of 15 June 2004, the court found that the Registrar, acting as an Arbitrator, erred in law by failing to provide adequate reasons for her decision and by not attempting to settle the dispute before determining it. This failure was analogous to the error identified in Vogel v Eagle Landscapes Pty Ltd [2005] NSW WCC PD 10, where the Registrar similarly failed to provide reasons and afford the parties an opportunity to settle. Consequently, the court revoked the decision of the Registrar dated 15 June 2004 and remitted the matter to an Arbitrator for a fresh determination, including efforts to settle the dispute. The court did not find a denial of procedural fairness as the Appellant's submissions were unclear, and it declined to award costs to either party, considering the circumstances of the appeal and the fortuitousness of the Appellant's success in relation to the decision of 15 June 2004.