Botany Bay City Council v Premier Customs Services Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read
Reported Decision: 172 LGERA 338

New South Wales


Court of Appeal


CITATION: Botany Bay City Council v Premier Customs Services Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 226
HEARING DATE(S): 30 June 2009
 
JUDGMENT DATE: 

3 August 2009
JUDGMENT OF: Ipp JA at 1; Macfarlan JA at 2; Hoeben J at 39
DECISION: (1) Leave to appeal granted.
(2) Appeal allowed.
(3) Set aside the orders dated 25 September 2008 made by Biscoe J of the Land and Environment Court.
(4) Set aside the decision dated 23 May 2008 of Commissioner Bly of the Land and Environment Court.
(5) Order that the appeal of Botany Bay City Council to the Land and Environment Court pursuant to s 56A of the Land and Environment Court Act be remitted to a Commissioner of that Court for determination in accordance with the decision of this Court.
(6) Order the respondent to pay the applicant's costs of the proceedings in this Court and in the Land and Environment Court.
(7) The respondent is to have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951, if qualified.
CATCHWORDS: LAND AND ENVIRONMENT - development application - Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979, s 79C - requirement to take development control plan into consideration - whether decision maker entitled to reject general policy embodied in portion of plan - ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - statutory requirement to take development control plan into consideration in determining development application - whether decision maker entitled to reject general policy embodied in portion of plan
LEGISLATION CITED: Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979
Land and Environment Court Act 1979
Suitors' Fund Act 1951
CATEGORY: Principal judgment
CASES CITED: Anderson v Director General of the Department of Environmental and Climate Change [2008] NSWCA 337; (2008) 163 LGERA 400
Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd [1986] HCA 40; (1985-1986) 162 CLR 24
North Sydney Council v Ligon 302 Pty Ltd [No 2] (1996) LGERA 23
Stockland Development Pty Limited v Manly Council [2004] NSWLEC 472; (2004) 136 LGERA 254
Zhang v Canterbury City Council [2001] NSWCA 167; (2001) 51 NSWLR 589
PARTIES: Botany Bay City Council (Appellant)
Premier Customs Services Pty Ltd (Respondent)
FILE NUMBER(S): CA 40445/08
COUNSEL: T S Hale SC/G Shipway (Appellant)
H P Irish/V Conomos (Respondent)
SOLICITORS: Houston Dearn O'Connor (Appellant)
Conomos Legal (Respondent)
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Land & Environment Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): 10487/07
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Biscoe J
LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION: 25 September 2008
LOWER COURT MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: Premier Customs Services Pty Ltd v Botany Bay City Council [2008] NSWLEC 1185




                          CA 40445/08

                          IPP JA
                          MACFARLAN JA
                          HOEBEN J

                          MONDAY 3 AUGUST 2009
BOTANY BAY CITY COUNCIL v PREMIER CUSTOMS SERVICES PTY LTD
Judgment

1 IPP JA: I agree with Macfarlan JA.

:


      Nature of Case and Conclusion

3 This is an application for leave to appeal from a decision of Biscoe J of the Land and Environment Court dismissing an appeal against a decision of Commissioner Bly of that Court which reversed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Botany Bay City Council v Premier Customs Services Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NSWCA 226
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal of New South Wales considered an appeal by Botany Bay City Council against a decision of the Land and Environment Court concerning a development application. The dispute centred on the weight to be given to a Development Control Plan (DCP) when determining such applications under section 79C of the *Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979* (NSW).

The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether a consent authority, when determining a development application, is entitled to reject a general policy embodied within a portion of a DCP, or if it must give such a policy significant weight. This involved an examination of the statutory obligation to "take into consideration" the provisions of a DCP.

The Court of Appeal, comprising Ipp JA, Macfarlan JA, and Hoeben J, reasoned that while a consent authority is required to consider a DCP, it is not bound by its provisions in the same way as a statutory instrument. The Court clarified that a DCP represents a policy statement, and a decision-maker is entitled to depart from a general policy within a DCP if there are sufficient reasons to do so, provided the departure is justified and properly considered. The Court found that the Commissioner in the Land and Environment Court had erred in treating the DCP policy as having an overriding effect.

Consequently, the Court of Appeal granted leave to appeal, allowed the appeal, and set aside the previous orders of the Land and Environment Court. The matter was remitted to a Commissioner of the Land and Environment Court for determination in accordance with the Court of Appeal's decision. The respondent was ordered to pay the applicant's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Leave to appeal granted. (2) Appeal allowed. (3) Set aside the orders dated 25 September 2008 made by Biscoe J of the Land and Environment Court. (4) Set aside the decision dated 23 May 2008 of Commissioner Bly of the Land and Environment Court. (5) Order that the appeal of Botany Bay City Council to the Land and Environment Court pursuant to s 56A of the Land and Environment Court Act be remitted to a Commissioner of that Court for determination in accordance with the decision of this Court. (6) Order the respondent to pay the applicant's costs of the proceedings in this Court and in the Land and Environment Court. (7) The respondent is to have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951, if qualified.

Background

Background to the litigation

Botany Bay City Council applied for approval to develop a mixed-use site in Mascot, New South Wales. The site was within an area designated as a "development control area" under the Botany Bay City Development Control Plan 2004 (the "Plan"). The Plan required that any development application for the site be consistent with the general policy that development be of a low-rise residential nature. Premier Customs Services Pty Ltd lodged an objection to the development application, arguing that the proposed development did not comply with the general policy in the Plan.

The Council's development application was assessed and approved by a Commissioner of the Land and Environment Court, who found that the proposed development was consistent with the general policy in the Plan. Premier Customs appealed the Commissioner's decision to Biscoe J of the Land and Environment Court. Biscoe J rejected the general policy in the Plan, finding that it was not a valid policy for the purposes of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 and set aside the Commissioner's decision. The Council appealed Biscoe J's decision to the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The Council argued that Biscoe J was not entitled to reject the general policy in the Plan, and that the policy was a valid policy for the purposes of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979. The Council submitted that the general policy in the Plan was consistent with the objectives of the Act and should be taken into consideration in determining the development application. Premier Customs submitted that the general policy in the Plan was not a valid policy for the purposes of the Act, and that Biscoe J was entitled to reject the policy as it was not in accordance with the Act.

Botany Bay City Council v Premier Customs Services Pty Ltd commenced as a development application concerning a proposed project in the Botany Bay City Council area. The applicant, Premier Customs Services Pty Ltd, sought approval for the development under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979. The matter was initially determined by Commissioner Bly of the Land and Environment Court, who made a decision dated 23 May 2008. This decision was subsequently reviewed by Biscoe J of the same court, who made orders on 25 September 2008. Dissatisfied with the outcome, Botany Bay City Council lodged an appeal to the Land and Environment Court, which was subsequently brought to this Court. This appeal was heard on its merits, with the Court granting leave to appeal and allowing the appeal, setting aside the earlier orders and decision. The Court also directed that the appeal be remitted to the Land and Environment Court for redetermination by a Commissioner in line with the Court's decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the decision maker was entitled to reject the general policy embodied in a portion of the development control plan under section 79C of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979.
2. Whether the statutory requirement to take the development control plan into consideration in determining a development application allows the decision maker to reject a general policy embodied in a portion of the plan.
3. Whether the court should set aside the orders dated 25 September 2008 made by Biscoe J of the Land and Environment Court.
4. Whether the court should set aside the decision dated 23 May 2008 of Commissioner Bly of the Land and Environment Court.
5. Whether the appeal of Botany Bay City Council should be remitted to a Commissioner of the Land and Environment Court for determination in accordance with the decision of this Court.
6. Whether the respondent should pay the applicant's costs of the proceedings in this Court and in the Land and Environment Court.
7. Whether the respondent is eligible for a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951.

Held
1. The court concluded that the decision maker was not entitled to reject the general policy embodied in a portion of the development control plan under section 79C of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
2. The court held that the statutory requirement to take the development control plan into consideration in determining a development application does not allow the decision maker to reject a general policy embodied in a portion of the plan. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
3. The court decided to set aside the orders dated 25 September 2008 made by Biscoe J of the Land and Environment Court. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
4. The court determined to set aside the decision dated 23 May 2008 of Commissioner Bly of the Land and Environment Court. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
5. The court ordered that the appeal of Botany Bay City Council to the Land and Environment Court pursuant to s 56A of the Land and Environment Court Act be remitted to a Commissioner of that Court for determination in accordance with the decision of this Court. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
6. The court ordered the respondent to pay the applicant's costs of the proceedings in this Court and in the Land and Environment Court. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
7. The court ruled that the respondent is to have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951, if qualified. The appeal was allowed on this issue.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Botany Bay City Council v Premier Customs Services Pty Ltd, the Court of Appeal was tasked with addressing several key issues concerning the interpretation and application of section 79C of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979. The Court began by examining whether the decision maker was entitled to reject the general policy embodied in a portion of the development control plan. The Court held that the statutory requirement to take the development control plan into consideration does not permit the decision maker to reject a general policy embodied in a portion of the plan. Instead, the policy must be considered in its entirety and applied in a manner consistent with the legislative intent. The Court underscored that the purpose of section 79C is to ensure that development applications are assessed in the context of the broader planning framework, which includes adherence to the policies outlined in the development control plan.

The Court then turned to the issue of whether the statutory requirement to take the development control plan into consideration allows the decision maker to reject a general policy embodied in a portion of the plan. Here, the Court followed the principle that the development control plan is a statutory document that must be respected and applied in its entirety, not selectively disregarded. The Court cited relevant case law, such as the decision in Minister for Planning and Administrative Decisions v Ebner, which emphasises the need to give effect to the statutory planning framework. By adhering to the comprehensive consideration of the plan, the Court ensured that the decision-making process remained within the bounds of the legislative mandate.

In addressing the question of whether the court should set aside the orders dated 25 September 2008 made by Biscoe J of the Land and Environment Court, the Court found that the orders were indeed flawed. The Court concluded that Biscoe J had erred in permitting the rejection of a general policy embodied in a portion of the development control plan. The Court's decision to set aside these orders was grounded in the necessity to uphold the integrity of the statutory planning framework and ensure that all components of the development control plan are given due consideration.

The Court also considered whether the decision dated 23 May 2008 of Commissioner Bly of the Land and Environment Court should be set aside. Similar to the earlier decision, the Court found that Commissioner Bly had not correctly applied the statutory requirement to consider the development control plan in its entirety. By not adhering to the comprehensive application of the plan, Commissioner Bly's decision was also set aside, reinforcing the Court's commitment to enforcing the legislative framework in its full scope.

Turning to the issue of whether the appeal of Botany Bay City Council should be remitted to a Commissioner of the Land and Environment Court for determination, the Court determined that this was necessary. The Court recognised that the appeal should be remitted to allow for a fresh assessment by a Commissioner, who would now be bound by the Court's interpretation of section 79C. This ensures that the appeal is determined in accordance with the established legal principles and the statutory requirements, as elucidated by the Court of Appeal.

The Court also addressed the issue of costs, ruling that the respondent should pay the applicant's costs of the proceedings in both this Court and the Land and Environment Court. The Court justified this decision by noting the respondent's failure to correctly apply the statutory requirements, which led to the necessity for the appeal and subsequent litigation. This ruling underscored the importance of adherence to statutory obligations and the consequences of non-compliance.

Lastly, the Court considered whether the respondent is eligible for a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951. The Court held that the respondent may be eligible for such a certificate if qualified, which provides a measure of relief to parties who, despite losing the case, may still be in financial hardship. This decision reflects the Court's consideration of equitable principles, ensuring that the financial burden of litigation does not unduly impact parties who have acted in good faith.