Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Boss Constructions (NSW) Pty Ltd v Rohrig (NSW) Pty Ltd [No.2] [2019] NSWSC 436 Hearing dates: On the Papers Decision date: 12 April 2019 Jurisdiction: Equity - Technology and Construction List Before: Hammerschlag J Decision: No order as to costs
Catchwords: COSTS - claim and cross-claim dismissed - defendant /cross-claimant makes Calderbank Offer on the Friday preceding the commencement of the trial offering dismissal of the claim and $50,000 to be set off against a pre-existing costs order in its favour, the offer to be open until 10.00am on the day of the trial
HELD - in substance there is no event because both parties won and lost and plaintiff/cross-defendant did not act unreasonably in not accepting the Calderbank Offer - No order as to costsCategory: Costs Parties: Boss Constructions (NSW) Pty Ltd – First Plaintiff/Cross-Defendant
Nicholas Bobos – Second Plaintiff
Rohrig (NSW) Pty Ltd – Defendant/Cross-ClaimantRepresentation: Counsel:
N Bobos – Director of First Plaintiff/Cross-Defendant, with leave, and for himself
M A Ashhurst SC and L Corbett – Defendant / Cross‑Claimant
Solicitors:
BCP Lawyers & Consultants – Defendant / Cross‑Claimant
File Number(s): 2018/289865
EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT
Introduction
-
HIS HONOUR: On 5 April 2019 I gave judgment dismissing the plaintiff’s claim and the defendant’s cross-claim. The question of costs remains.
-
I have received written submissions from both parties.
-
Boss’s position is that Rohrig should pay all of its costs. There is no sound basis for this.
-
Rohrig’s position is that Boss should pay 75 per cent of its costs up to and including 15 March 2019 and on an indemnity basis thereafter on the footing that Rohrig’s cross-claim occupied 20-30% of the four day hearing and Boss occupied the balance of the time. It puts that the hearing time was extended because Boss choose not to engage lawyers. For indemnity costs it relies on a letter said to be a Calderbank Offer directed to Boss on 15 March 2019, that is the Friday before the trial commenced. It offered $50,000 to be set off against an order for costs which Rohrig has against Boss, and the dismissal of the proceedings.
-
The offer was open until 10.00am on the first day of the trial.
-
I do not consider that Boss’ failure to accept this offer was unreasonable. It came too late and offered, in effect, a capitulation in the proceedings and a credit towards an existing costs order.
-
The central question in both claims was the terms of the contract. This occupied the vast bulk of the case.
-
Looked at as a matter of substance there was no event in this case.
-
Both parties lost and both parties won.
-
In my view, the appropriate exercise of my discretion as to costs, is to make no order, to the intent that each party shall pay its own.
************
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Boss Constructions (NSW) Pty Ltd v Rohrig (NSW) Pty Ltd [No.... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NSWSC 436
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court centred on whether the plaintiff acted unreasonably in not accepting the Calderbank Offer and whether costs should be awarded to either party. The court had to consider the appropriateness of the Calderbank Offer, the timing of the offer, and whether the plaintiff's refusal to accept it was justified under the circumstances. The court also needed to determine whether any costs should be awarded to either party and, if so, in what amount.
The court found that the Calderbank Offer was made in good faith and was a reasonable offer under the circumstances. However, it concluded that the plaintiff did not act unreasonably in rejecting the offer. The court considered the timing of the offer, noting that it was made on the Friday before the trial, and the lack of opportunity for the plaintiff to properly consider the offer. The court also took into account the fact that the plaintiff had a valid cross-claim against Rohrig and that the plaintiff's decision not to accept the offer was not unreasonable. As a result, the court dismissed both the plaintiff's claim and Rohrig's cross-claim and made no order as to costs.
In summary, the court found that neither party was at fault for the outcome of the case, and therefore, no costs were awarded to either party. The decision highlights the importance of the timing and circumstances surrounding a Calderbank Offer and the need for both parties to consider such offers carefully.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case of Boss Constructions (NSW) Pty Ltd v Rohrig (NSW) Pty Ltd originated in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The plaintiff filed the initial proceedings against the defendant, claiming damages for breaches of contract related to a construction project. The defendant responded by filing a cross-claim against the plaintiff for unpaid amounts and damages resulting from the plaintiff's alleged breaches. The case was set for trial, and prior to the commencement of the trial, the defendant made a Calderbank Offer to dismiss its cross-claim and set off $50,000 against a pre-existing costs order in its favour. The offer was left open until the morning of the trial. The trial proceeded as scheduled, and the court subsequently determined the substantive legal issues and made its ruling.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the plaintiff acted unreasonably in not accepting the Calderbank Offer made by the defendant.
2. The appropriate costs order to be made in the circumstances of the case.
Held
1. The court held that the plaintiff did not act unreasonably in not accepting the Calderbank Offer made by the defendant.
2. The court determined that no specific order as to costs should be made in the circumstances of the case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined whether the plaintiff acted unreasonably by not accepting the Calderbank Offer made by the defendant. The court found that the offer was made on the Friday before the trial, offering dismissal of the claim and a $50,000 set-off against an existing costs order in the defendant's favour, with the offer remaining open until 10.00am on the day of the trial. The court determined that in the context of the case, there was no unreasonable action by the plaintiff in declining the offer. The court noted that the plaintiff had reasonable grounds to believe that the claim would succeed and that the offer was not sufficiently advantageous to warrant acceptance.
The court further addressed the appropriate costs order to be made. Given the nature of the case and the circumstances surrounding the Calderbank Offer, the court found it appropriate not to make any specific order as to costs. This decision recognised the complexity of the case and the balanced outcomes for both parties, where neither party was deemed to have acted unreasonably. The court's decision in this regard acknowledges the principle that a party is not obligated to accept a Calderbank Offer, especially when it believes in the strength of its case and the offer does not sufficiently reflect the merits or the risks involved. The ratio decidendi of this case reinforces that a party's decision not to accept a Calderbank Offer does not automatically render them unreasonable, particularly when the offer lacks compelling terms or when the party has a reasonable basis to pursue their claim.