Borcherdt v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Borcherdt v Commissioner of Taxation [2014] FCA 56

Citation: Borcherdt v Commissioner of Taxation [2014] FCA 56
Appeal from: RJ Borcherdt & GP Scott Trading as Nymboida Native Timbers v Commissioner of Taxation [2011] AATA 939
Parties: RJ BORCHERDT & GP SCOTT TRADING AS NYMBOIDA NATIVE TIMBERS and ROBERT JOHN BORCHERDT v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
File number: QUD 90 of 2012
Judge: COLLIER J
Date of judgment: 11 February 2014
Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – appeal from Administrative Appeals Tribunal – respondents purchased fuel for use in sawmilling and farming businesses – respondents claimed diesel fuel credits and diesel tax credits under Energy Grants (Credits) Scheme 2003 (Cth) and Fuel Tax Act 2006 (Cth) – question as to whether fuel supplier existed – no reliable record kept by respondents of fuel use – Commissioner of Taxation disallowed claims for diesel fuel credits and diesel tax credits – s 14ZZK(b) Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) – Tribunal affirmed decision of Commissioner of Taxation – whether Tribunal bound to take into account conduct of Commissioner of Taxation in regard to obligation to act as a model litigant – whether Tribunal failed to take into account relevant considerations – whether Tribunal took into account considerations it was bound not to take into account – whether Tribunal improperly adopted approach and standard of proof applicable to civil litigation – whether Tribunal required to accept evidence in absence of evidence to the contrary – whether Tribunal erred in application of an administrative penalty – distinction between error of law and error of fact – absence of specific reference to material by Tribunal not conclusive of a failure to take material into account or inadequacy of reasons – reasons of Tribunal to be considered as a whole to ascertain whether relevant issues addressed – Tribunal not required to accept evidence in absence of evidence to contrary – Tribunal not required to consider evidence on standard other than balance of probabilities – Tribunal did not err in respect of administrative penalties
Legislation: Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 33(1), 44(1)
Energy Grants (Credits) Scheme Act 2003 (Cth)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140(1)
Fuel Tax Act 2006 (Cth)
Products Grants and Benefits Administration Act 2000 (Cth) ss 25, 26, 27
Migration Act 1958 (Cth)
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) s 14ZZK
Cases cited: Blackwood Hodge (Aust) Pty Ltd v Collector of Customs (NSW) (No 2) (1980) 3 ALD 38 cited
Comcare v Forbutt [2000] FCA 837 cited
Gauci v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1975) 135 CLR 81 cited
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298 cited
Military Rehabilitation & Compensation Commission v SRGGGG (2005) 215 ALR 459; [2005] FCA 342 cited
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 cited
Politis v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1988) 16 ALD 707 cited
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; ex parte Durairajasingham (2000) 168 ALR 407; [2000] HCA 1 cited
Date of hearing: 6 February 2013
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Borcherdt v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 56
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The respondents in Borcherdt v Commissioner of Taxation were Mr Borcherdt and his business partner, Mr Glen Scott, who conducted a sawmilling business in northern New South Wales. The Commissioner of Taxation disallowed the applicants' claims for diesel fuel credits and diesel tax credits in respect of fuel sourced from Action Fuels, a company that supplied fuel to the applicants. The applicants sought review of the Commissioner's decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The Tribunal affirmed the Commissioner's decision and dismissed the applicants' review application. The applicants appealed to the Federal Court of Australia.

The applicants argued that the Tribunal failed to take into account the Commissioner's obligation to act as a model litigant, relevant considerations, and the standard of proof applicable to civil litigation. The applicants also argued that the Tribunal took into account considerations it was bound not to take into account and erred in the application of administrative penalties.

The court held that the Tribunal was not required to take into account the Commissioner's obligation to act as a model litigant. The court also held that the Tribunal did not fail to take into account relevant considerations, as the Tribunal's reasons addressed the relevant issues. The court held that the Tribunal did not adopt the approach and standards applicable to civil litigation and that the Tribunal was not required to consider evidence on a standard other than the balance of probabilities. The court held that the Tribunal did not err in the application of administrative penalties.

The court dismissed the applicants' appeal and remitted the matter to the respondent to allow a claim for $11,105.30, in accordance with the respondent’s concession before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The application was otherwise dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The matter be remitted to the respondent to allow a claim for $11,105.30, in accordance with the respondent’s concession before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

2. Otherwise the application be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The background facts to this appeal are set out in some detail in the reasons for decision of the Tribunal, to which I now turn.Background facts Mr Borcherdt and his business partner, Mr Glen Scott, conducted a sawmilling business in northern New South Wales trading under the business name “Nymboida Native Timbers” from around 2004 until 2008. During the life of the partnership Mr Borcherdt acted as managing partner, including managing financial and administrative matters as well as all the relationships with suppliers. Mr Borcherdt also conducted a separate sawmilling business and a farming business on his own property in northern New South Wales under the names Arbee Timbers and Arbee Agriculture. The businesses of Mr Borcherdt and the partnership used heavy machinery, generators, vehicles, pumps, chain-saws and other machinery, all of which required fuel. Mr Borcherdt gave evidence before the Tribunal that he had obtained fuel to operate this plant and equipment from a local fuel distributor in Coutts Crossing (ie BP Coutts), and from an entity called “Action Fuels”. In respect of this fuel Mr Borcherdt and the partnership claimed diesel fuel credits and diesel tax credits available under the Energy Grants (Credits) Scheme Act 2003 (Cth) and the Fuel Tax Act 2006 (Cth). The taxation period under review for Nymboida Native Timbers was 1 October 2004 – 31 March 2008 while the period under review for Mr Borcherdt’s businesses was 1 January 2006 – 31 March 2008. The Commissioner conducted an audit in relation to the claims of the businesses for fuel tax credits and grants. In the final analysis the Commissioner took no issue with the fuel obtained from BP Coutts, however in relation to the fuel obtained from Action Fuels the Commissioner concluded (in summary) that:·there was a serious question as to whether Action Fuels actually existed; and·in any event, no reliable record had been kept by the applicants of how much fuel was used for eligible uses by the partnership or Mr Borcherdt’s own businesses. The Commissioner did not accept the applicants’ claims for diesel fuel credits and diesel tax credits in respect of fuel sourced from Action Fuels. Accordingly, the Commissioner issued amended notices of assessment which identified significant tax shortfalls, and imposed penalties on the applicants. The applicants sought review by the Tribunal of the objection decisions of the Commissioner.Proceedings in the Tribunal The Tribunal noted that Mr Scott was not familiar with events associated with the management of Nymboida Native Timbers. It also observed that “Action Fuels” was “a shadowy outfit” in that no one appeared to be able to produce evidence of its existence. It appears that Mr Borcherdt became aware of Action Fuels when one day on his property he met two men, Mr Greg McArdle and Mr Paul Collins, whose interests included a fuel supply business known as Action Fuels. In relation to Mr Borcherdt’s evidence the Tribunal noted further that after discussions between Messrs Borcherdt, McArdle and Collins:[10]… They reached an agreement that Action Fuels would commence supplying fuel from its depot (which Mr Borcherdt thought might have been located in Tamworth) that would be paid for in a contra deal through the supply of logs by the Partnership and Mr Borcherdt. Mr Borcherdt said there was nothing unusual in a contra deal; he said that sort of thing happened all of the time “in the bush”. It was agreed that the price of cut logs would be $250 per cubic metre for the purposes of the agreement. He said that was his understanding of the going rate for cut timber, although it is unclear what research he did before arriving at that figure. It was further agreed that fuel price would not be any higher than the price charged by the BP distributor at Cootes Crossing.[11]At the hearing, Mr Borcherdt claimed the substance of the deal was recorded in a facsimile letter received from Action Fuels on its letterhead, but that letter has never been produced. Indeed, it seems the existence of the letter had not even been disclosed prior to the hearing. That is surprising. In any event, I have no evidence before me recording the terms of the arrangement. I only have the word of Mr Borcherdt.[12]Mr Borcherdt was supplied with a mobile telephone number for Action Fuels but he says he never used it during the life of the agreement. When the agreement concluded, it was suggested to him that the number was disconnected, or had never been connected. When he finally did try to contact Action Fuels on that number in March or April 2009, he was unsuccessful.[13]The circumstances in which the arrangement with Action Fuels came to be established do not ring true. Mr Borcherdt did not seem to know anything else about two strangers with whom he had entered into business without extensive negotiations. It seems most of the discussions in relation to the deal, such as it was, were concluded on the day the men met Mr Borcherdt while they were trespassing on his property. He accepted in cross-examination that he had never heard of the men or their business before, and he was unaware of them having any other customers in the area. Yet he says he was happy to deal with them from that point and told them where the keys to the gate on the property were located so they could commence making deliveries. When challenged on the improbability of all of this, he insisted “that was the way business is done in the bush”.[14]The relationship effectively commenced in March 2006 when a delivery truck began making regular stops by the property to drop off large drums of oil at fuel dumps on the property adjacent to the mobile sawmills. It was unclear from the evidence how many fuel dumps were in existence. Mr Borcherdt initially referred to a fuel dump (in the singular) but as his evidence progressed he came to refer to dumps in the plural. It may be that one explanation for this was that there were several different sites on his property over time because the sites moved. Interestingly, Mr Borcherdt said the delivery trucks never had any trouble finding the sites to make deliveries even though they were not signposted because “people in the bush” were able to read the land and identify where operations were located some distance from the entrance to the property.[15]I have noted Mr Borcherdt’s evidence that he did not have regular contact with anyone from Action Fuels. The delivery vehicles would arrive on a regular basis and drop off barrels of fuel to replenish stocks at the fuel dumps, and they would take the cut logs as payment. They would leave behind any documentation, like delivery notes or invoices, in a receptacle located at the fuel dump. The receptacle also held an exercise book into which the driver would enter the details of the fuel delivery and the amount of logs removed. I note the exercise book has never been produced. Mr Borcherdt surmises that it was removed from the site by Mr McArdle or Mr Collins or someone else from Action Fuels when they came to remove their property (and other evidence of their existence) after they learned the Commissioner was inquiring into the supply arrangement.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally I am not persuaded that the Tribunal erred in respect of administrative penalties to be imposed on the applicants in this case. I do not consider that any of the matters to which the applicants refer in ground of appeal 13 either constitute questions of law upon which the Court can rule or are substantiated on the material before the Court.Conclusion Other than to the extent of the order agreed between the parties varying the decision of the Tribunal, the application should be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicants’ grounds of appeal broadly reflect the questions of law raised in the notice of appeal, and can be summarised as follows:·The Tribunal failed to take into account the fact that the Commissioner had not acted as a model litigant, when the Commissioner was required to do so (Ground 1).·In finding against the applicants in respect of their objection to the Commissioner’s determination, the Tribunal failed to take into account relevant considerations. Grounds 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 10, 11 and 12 list thirty-two such considerations, being general factors (such as certain statutes, the submissions of the parties, the rules of natural justice, “all the evidence and submissions put before it”, “the allowances and concessions made by the respondent”) and specific considerations (including specific legislative requirements such as s 25 to s 27 of the Products Grants and Benefits Administration Act 2000 (Cth), ATO publications, oral advice by the ATO Businessline and pre-trial admissions by the Commissioner, “the unrelenting process of allegation and intimidation by the Commissioner on the performance of Mr Borcherdt as a witness”, and the failure of the Commissioner to present audit staff, files and records).·In finding against the applicants in respect of their objection to the Commissioner’s determination, the Tribunal took into account considerations it was bound not to take into account, namely allegations by the Commissioner of wrong-doing and non-disclosure by the applicants and inferences and/or findings by the Tribunal adverse to the applicants for which there was no evidence or for which more robust, reasonable and uncontested rebuttal evidence was available. Ground 8 lists nineteen such inferences and/or findings.·In finding that the applicants were liable to pay a 75% administrative penalty, the Tribunal failed to take into account ten considerations it was required to take into account, many of which the applicants had identified as similarly relevant to the primary determination of the Tribunal, and which were as follows:a.The Taxation Administration Act 1953 – Schedule 1 (“the TAA-S1”), and Division 284B of the TAA-S1.b.The ATO Practice Statement Law Administration PS LA 2003/3 (“the PSLA2003/3”).c.The ATO Practice Statement Law Administration PS LA 2005/2 (“the PSLA2005/2”).d.The ATO Practice Statement Law Administration PS LA 2006/2 (“the PSLA2006/2”).e. The Miscellaneous Taxation Ruling MT 2008/1 (“MTR2008/1”).f. The ATO booklets provided by the Commissioner to the Applicants.g. The evidence of oral advice from the ATO Businessline to the Applicants.h.The Applicants’ compliance with the legislative requirements, s 25 to s 27 of the Products Grants and Benefits Administration Act 2000 (Cth) and s 382-5 of the TAA, and with oral advice from the ATO Businessline and with published determinations and with ATO booklets.i.The absence of evidence that established that a false or misleading statement in a material particular was made, that this statement resulted in a shortfall, that the Applicants acted with intentional disregard of a taxation law, that the Applicants did not rely upon advice or a statement by the Commissioner, that the treatment by the Applicants does not agree with a general administrative practice. At the first test of these considerations the Tribunal failed to identify a statement that was false or misleading in a material particular that resulted in a shortfall.j.The circumstances in which the administrative penalty may be remitted in full or in part.(Ground 13).·The Tribunal improperly adopted the approach and standards applicable to civil litigation and in particular determined the review on the basis of the balance of probabilities (Ground 14).Consideration