Borchardt v Queensland Police Service

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Borchardt v Queensland Police Service [2021] QDC 101

PARTIES:

NATASHA LEE BORCHARDT

(Appellant)

v

QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE

(Respondent)

FILE NO:

256/21

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Richlands Magistrates Court

DELIVERED ON:

10 June 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

28 April 2021.

JUDGE:

Byrne QC DCJ

ORDERS:

1.     Appeal allowed.

2.     The sentences imposed in the Richlands Magistrates Court on 19 January 2021 are vacated.

3.     In their stead the following sentences are imposed:

(i) In respect of the offences of contravene a direction or requirement on 30 April 2020, disqualified driving on 6 August 2020, fail to appear on 19 November 2020, contravene a direction or requirement on 28 November 2020 and disqualified driving on 28 November 2020 the appellant is admitted to probation for a period of two years on the conditions outlined in s 93(1) of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992, and further conditioned that she report to an authorised Corrective Services officer at Inala by 4.00pm on 11 June 2021. 

(ii)      Convictions on each of these offences are not recorded.

4.   In respect of the offence of disqualified driving on 7 December 2020, I order that the appellant be imprisoned for a period of three months, wholly suspended with an operational period of 12 months.  A conviction is recorded.

5.   In respect of each offence of disqualified driving, the appellant is disqualified from holding or obtaining a driver’s licence for a period of two years.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL – s222 Justices Act 1886 – APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE –  ADHERENCE TO THE PRINCIPLES OF OPEN JUSTICE – where material which was before the Magistrate was relied upon in exercising his sentencing discretion – where the fact of the material being provided to the Magistrate prior to the hearing was not made known in an open Court – where the  material relied upon by the sentencing Magistrate was not formally tendered at the hearing – where in exercising his sentencing discretion the Magistrate referred to the material – whether the Magistrate failed to conduct the sentence hearing consistently with the principles of open justice – whether the Court should vacate the sentences imposed by the Magistrate and exercise its sentencing discretion afresh.

LEGISLATION:

Justices Act1886 (Qld)

Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld)

CASES:

Allesch v Maunz (2000) 203 CLR 172

Ballard v Commissioner of Police [2017] QDC 174

Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118

Hay v Commissioner of Police [2016] QDC 358

Hogan v Hinch (2011) 243 CLR 506

House v the King (1936) 55 CLR 409

Johnson v Queensland Police Service [2015] QDC 264

Johnstone v Commissioner of Police [2019] QDC 109

Kentwell v the Queen (2014) 252 CLR 601

McDonald v Queensland Police Service [2018] 2 Qd R 612

Parker v Commissioner of Police [2016] QDC 354

R v Hannan; ex-parte Attorney-General (Qld) [2018] QCA 201

REW v Commissioner of Police [2018] QDC 213

Robinson Helicopter Company Inc v McDermott (2016) 90 ALJR 679

Russell v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Borchardt v Queensland Police Service and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QDC 101
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Borchardt v Queensland Police Service involved the appellant challenging the sentences imposed by the Richlands Magistrates Court. The central issue in this appeal was whether the Magistrate's reliance on undisclosed and untendered documents during the sentencing process violated the principles of open justice. Specifically, the appellant argued that the Magistrate had access to his criminal and traffic histories, which heavily influenced the sentences imposed, but these documents were not formally presented in court, and their existence was not disclosed. This non-compliance with the open justice principle was deemed a fundamental error.

The court examined the sentencing remarks and found that the Magistrate's reference to the appellant's "serious" criminal and traffic histories, without tendering these documents in open court, was a breach of the principles of open justice. This principle is fundamental to the integrity of the judicial process, ensuring transparency and public scrutiny. The court noted that while exceptions to this principle exist, none applied in this case. The failure to properly comprehend the limited seriousness of the criminal history could be considered an error significant enough to warrant appellate intervention. This error might have gone unnoticed had the parties not provided the material for the appeal.

In light of the fundamental error, the Court allowed the appeal, vacated the original sentences, and imposed new sentences. The appellant was admitted to probation for two years with specific conditions, and convictions were not recorded for certain offences. For the offence of disqualified driving on 7 December 2020, the appellant was sentenced to three months imprisonment, wholly suspended with a 12-month operational period, and a conviction was recorded. Additionally, the appellant was disqualified from holding or obtaining a driver's licence for two years for each offence of disqualified driving.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. The sentences imposed in the Richlands Magistrates Court on 19 January 2021 are vacated.

3. In their stead the following sentences are imposed:

(i) In respect of the offences of contravene a direction or requirement on 30 April 2020, disqualified driving on 6 August 2020, fail to appear on 19 November 2020, contravene a direction or requirement on 28 November 2020 and disqualified driving on 28 November 2020 the appellant is admitted to probation for a period of two years on the conditions outlined in s 93(1) of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992, and further conditioned that she report to an authorised Corrective Services officer at Inala by 4.00pm on 11 June 2021.

(ii) Convictions on each of these offences are not recorded.

4. In respect of the offence of disqualified driving on 7 December 2020, I order that the appellant be imprisoned for a period of three months, wholly suspended with an operational period of 12 months. A conviction is recorded.

5. In respect of each offence of disqualified driving, the appellant is disqualified from holding or obtaining a driver’s licence for a period of two years.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Further, the respondent correctly concedes the point raised during the course of the hearing and accepts that there has been a fundamental error in the conduct of the sentence hearing in that it was not conducted according to principles of open justice.Consideration It can be seen from the extracted portions of the sentencing remarks that the appellant’s criminal and traffic histories – both of which he described as “serious” – heavily influenced the sentences imposed. However, while it is obvious that the sentencing Magistrate had both documents before him and relied on them (particularly the traffic history), neither were tendered at the hearing, and there is no record of them on the Court file. This Court had to be provided with copies of each document in order to conduct the appeal. As has been authoritatively observed:“It is the ordinary rule of the Supreme Court, as of the other Courts of the nation, that their proceedings shall be conducted ‘publicly and in open view’. This rule has the virtue that the proceedings of every Court are fully exposed to public and professional scrutiny and criticism, without which abuses may flourish undetected. Further, the public administration of justice tends to maintain confidence in the integrity and independence of the Courts. The fact that Courts of law are held openly and not in secret is an essential aspect of their character. It distinguishes their activities from those of administrative officials, for ‘publicity is the authentic hall-mark of judicial as distinct from administrative procedure’.”[5] (footnotes and citations omitted)[5]Russell v Russell (1976) 134 CLR 495, 520. See also Scott v Scott [1913] AC 417, 434-435; Hogan v Hinch (2011) 243 CLR 506, [20]. There are recognised exceptions to this important principle, but none apply here. This Court has on numerous previous occasions stressed the need for tendered exhibits to be marked and to form part of the Court records.[6] I endorse the observations in those earlier decisions, but the use of material that was not open to scrutiny is more egregious. [6]See for example Johnson v Queensland Police Service [2015] QDC 264; Parker v Commissioner of Police [2016] QDC 354; Hay v Commissioner of Police [2016] QDC 358; Ballard v Commissioner of Police [2017] QDC 174; REW v Commissioner of Police [2018] QDC 213. The need to ensure material relied upon is available in a public way is well illustrated in the present instance. The sentencing Magistrate referred to the criminal history as “serious”. It clearly was not. There had been one prior appearance for offences of wilful damage and trespass on the same date and for an offence of fail to appear on an earlier date (presumably for a traffic offence). The failure to properly comprehend the limited seriousness of the criminal history could arguably amount to an error sufficient to justify appellant intervention, even though the traffic history was undoubtedly serious. This error would have been undetectable had the parties not sensibly provided the material on the appeal.