Boral Resources (SA) Ltd v Rick Martin Nominees Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

BORAL RESOURCES (SA) LTD  v  RICK MARTIN NOMINEES PTY LTD (No 2)

[2012] SASC 192

Reasons of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court

18 October 2012

CORPORATIONS

Corporations – application to wind up company for insolvency – dispute on who is to be appointed as liquidator – after originating process issued company placed into administration and then wound up by a resolution of its creditors – motion at creditor meeting to appoint nominee of plaintiff as liquidator defeated and administrator left as liquidator – deducing wishes of creditors from analysis of voting at the meeting – other factors on exercise of Court’s discretion – held existing liquidator to be appointed as liquidator on order for winding up by the Court – back-dating of the commencement of the winding up.

BORAL RESOURCES (SA) LTD  v  RICK MARTIN NOMINEES PTY LTD (No 2)
[2012] SASC 192

JUDGE LUNN:

Reasons on appointment as liquidator

Definitions

  1. In these reasons:

    “The company” is the defendant, Rick Martin Nominees Pty Ltd;
    “Boral” is the plaintiff, Boral Resources (SA) Pty Ltd, which is the second to largest unrelated creditor of the defendant and is owed about $604,227;[1]
    “RGM” is Ricky Gordon Martin, who until its winding up was the sole director and the secretary of the company;
    “HSM” is Hugh Sutcliffe Martin, a chartered accountant and an official liquidator, who has been the administrator and the liquidator of the company;
    “DRM” is Desmond Robert Munro, a chartered accountant and an official liquidator, who is Boral’s nominee to be the liquidator of the company;
    “Milagro” is Milagro Pty Ltd, which is a company associated with RGM and which is a creditor of the company for at least $1,056,345;
    “ATO” is the Australian Taxation Office, which is a creditor of the company for $632,328.

    [1]    In these reasons all monetary amounts are stated only in terms of dollars and ignoring any additional cents.

    Background history

  2. On 15 June 2012 Boral instituted this action seeking the winding up of the company on the grounds of its presumed insolvency by reason of its failure to comply with a statutory demand for $368,082 served on it by Boral.  WorkCover SA, a creditor of the company for $228,118, filed a notice supporting the application for the winding up of the company.

  3. At the first hearing in this action on 17 July 2012 a solicitor for the company, against the opposition of Boral, obtained an adjournment for the company to pursue further finance.  The hearing was adjourned to 31 July 2012.

  4. On 30 July 2012 HSM was appointed to be the administrator of the company pursuant to s 439A of the Corporations Act 2001 (“the Act”).  Persons associated with RGM indicated to HSM that they would be prepared to put forward a guarantee which would be the basis of a DOCA[2] to enable the company to continue to trade.

    [2]    Deed of Company Arrangement.

  5. At the hearing on 31 July 2012 HSM attended in person as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Boral Resources (SA) Ltd v Rick Martin Nominees Pty Ltd (No... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASC 192
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Boral Resources (SA) Ltd v Rick Martin Nominees Pty Ltd (No 2), Boral Resources (SA) Ltd, a creditor of Rick Martin Nominees Pty Ltd, sought to have the company wound up on the grounds of insolvency. The dispute centered on who should be appointed as the liquidator of the company, with Boral advocating for its nominee, Desmond Robert Munro, and the existing administrator, Hugh Sutcliffe Martin, continuing in the role. The Court had to decide on the appropriate liquidator for the company and the date from which the winding up would commence, with implications for the recovery of undue preferences.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether to replace the existing liquidator, Hugh Sutcliffe Martin, with Boral's nominee, Desmond Robert Munro. The Court considered the wishes of the creditors as expressed through their voting at a creditor meeting, where the motion to replace HSM was defeated. The Court also weighed other factors pertinent to the exercise of its discretion, including the potential additional costs and complications if DRM was appointed, and the likelihood of recovering undue preferences.

The Court concluded that the interests of the company's creditors as a whole would be best served by allowing Hugh Sutcliffe Martin to continue as the liquidator. The Court rejected Boral's application to replace HSM, finding no evidence to suggest that HSM would not properly conduct the winding up. The Court also determined that the winding up would commence on the date of the issue of the originating process, 15 June 2012, for the purposes of calculating the "relation-back day."

The Court ordered that Hugh Sutcliffe Martin be appointed as the liquidator of Rick Martin Nominees Pty Ltd and that the winding up would commence on 15 June 2012. This decision was based on the creditors' wishes, the potential for significant additional costs if DRM was appointed, and the need to ensure the efficient and cost-effective winding up of the company.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

In these reasons:“The company” is the defendant, Rick Martin Nominees Pty Ltd;“Boral” is the plaintiff, Boral Resources (SA) Pty Ltd, which is the second to largest unrelated creditor of the defendant and is owed about $604,227;[1]“RGM” is Ricky Gordon Martin, who until its winding up was the sole director and the secretary of the company;“HSM” is Hugh Sutcliffe Martin, a chartered accountant and an official liquidator, who has been the administrator and the liquidator of the company;“DRM” is Desmond Robert Munro, a chartered accountant and an official liquidator, who is Boral’s nominee to be the liquidator of the company;“Milagro” is Milagro Pty Ltd, which is a company associated with RGM and which is a creditor of the company for at least $1,056,345;“ATO” is the Australian Taxation Office, which is a creditor of the company for $632,328.[1] In these reasons all monetary amounts are stated only in terms of dollars and ignoring any additional cents.Background history On 15 June 2012 Boral instituted this action seeking the winding up of the company on the grounds of its presumed insolvency by reason of its failure to comply with a statutory demand for $368,082 served on it by Boral. WorkCover SA, a creditor of the company for $228,118, filed a notice supporting the application for the winding up of the company. At the first hearing in this action on 17 July 2012 a solicitor for the company, against the opposition of Boral, obtained an adjournment for the company to pursue further finance. The hearing was adjourned to 31 July 2012. On 30 July 2012 HSM was appointed to be the administrator of the company pursuant to s 439A of the Corporations Act 2001 (“the Act”). Persons associated with RGM indicated to HSM that they would be prepared to put forward a guarantee which would be the basis of a DOCA[2] to enable the company to continue to trade. [2] Deed of Company Arrangement. At the hearing on 31 July 2012 HSM attended in person as the administrator and sought an adjournment so that he could continue to investigate the affairs of the company and to hold a first meeting of the creditors in the administration on 7 August 2012. This was opposed by Boral. I granted the adjournment until 7 August 2012 and immediately after the first meeting of creditors had been held. On 7 August 2012 HSM reported to the first meeting of creditors on the arrangements which he was making for the sale of the company’s assets and that there were ongoing negotiations with RGM and his associates concerning a DOCA. Mr Stewart, the proxy for Boral at that meeting, moved that HSM be replaced as administrator by DRM, but the motion was defeated with six creditors totalling $900,354 voting in favour and 57 creditors totalling $2,637,188 voting against it.[3] Boral did not take any legal action under ss 600A-600C of the Act to challenge the defeat of this motion. [3] The motion was seconded by the proxy for the ATO, but the ATO then voted against the motion. Those voting against the motion included Milagro and others associated with RGM.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

There was a conflict of opinion between HSM and DRM about what would be the additional costs if DRM was now appointed to be the liquidator. DRM suggested it would only be the costs of him and his staff reading the working papers of HSM. That is the most optimistic view on the topic, but experience suggests that there may well be unexpected complications which will increase those costs. There is no way of accurately assessing what those additional costs will be, but they could well be significant. Conclusion On the evidence there is no basis to infer that HSM will not properly conduct the winding up of the company to its conclusion. Boral has rights under the Act to challenge the acts of HSM as the liquidator if it believes that he has not properly pursued claims against those previously standing behind the company. While Boral, which voted in favour of replacing HSM by DRM, stands to benefit to a greater extent because of the amount of its debt if the liquidator of the company can effect significant recoveries from those previously standing behind the company, the interests of the smaller creditors who favoured appointing HSM are not to be ignored. The overall costs of the winding up are likely to be significantly less if HSM continues the liquidation to its conclusion. In any event, there is a real prospect there will be no dividend payable to the non‑priority creditors of the company. I consider that on balance the interests of the creditors of the company as a whole will be best served by HSM continuing to be the liquidator of the company and not being replaced by DRM.Date of commencement of winding up The date of the commencement of the winding up is significant for the ascertainment of the “relation-back day” as defined in s 9 of the Act. The earlier the commencement date, the greater is the potential for the recovery of undue preferences by the liquidator which occurred within six months of the commencement of the winding up. If the company was not already in a voluntary winding up, by virtue of s 513A(3) of the Act and the definition of relation-back day in s 9, the relation‑back day would be calculated on a commencement of the winding up on the date of the issue of the originating process, which was 15 June 2012. However, the issue is complicated because s 513A(a) of the Act provides:If the Court orders under section … 459A … that a company be wound up, the winding up is taken to have begun or commenced: (a) if, when the order was made, a winding up of the company was already in progress - when the last-mentioned winding up is taken because of this Division to have begun or commenced; … There are further complications under ss 513B and 513C of the Act as to calculating what is the commencement date of a winding up where at the date of the winding up order by the Court, a company is already in a voluntary winding up by virtue of a resolution of its creditors passed in an administration. It is not necessary to go into these complications. The commencement of such a winding up here by an order of the Court would be significantly later than 15 June 2012.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established