Bonim Stanmore Pty Limited v Marrickville Council

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES LAND AND ENVIRONMENT COURT

CITATION:     Bonim Stanmore Pty Limited  v Marrickville Council [2007]  NSWLEC 497

PARTIES:
APPLICANT
Bonim Stanmore Pty Limited

RESPONDENT
Marrickville Council

FILE NUMBER(S):     11460  of       2005

CATCHWORDS: Appeal :- Remittal of Hearing, [2006] NSWLEC 771

LEGISLATION CITED:
Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979

CASES CITED:

CORAM:        Hoffman C

DATES OF HEARING:          10/07/2007

EX TEMPORE DATE:           10 July 2007

LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES

APPLICANT
Mr I Hemmings, barrister
Instructed by Mr G. Farland
of Landerer and Co.

RESPONDENT
Mr Galasso, SC
Instructed by Mr Christmas
of Marrickville Council

JUDGMENT:

THE LAND AND
ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES

Hoffman C

10 July 2007

11460 of 2005                 Bonim Stanmore Pty Limited v Marrickville Council

JUDGMENT

  1. This is an appeal No. 11460 of 2005 between Bonim Stanmore Pty Limited with Cavendish Holt Pty Limited v Marrickville Council. The judgment (2006) NSWLEC 771 has been remitted following a s 56A review by his Honour Justice Biscoe in judgment (2007) NSWLEC 286. In that decision his Honour found of the six grounds raised only one error of law had occurred. It related to para 62 of the original judgment which stated,

    “In coming to a conclusion on this matter I bear in mind that the proposal is far in excess of that size and creates a new traffic generator on a main road that carries about 24,000 vehicles per day.  Unlike the club, the supermarket would generate traffic in peak periods, not out of peak.  It would cause through additional turning movements a reduction in the efficiency of the main road that in the future must carry ever more traffic.”

  2. The words the subject of error was the last clause, “that in the future must carry ever more traffic.”  His Honour found in his review that whilst part of the Court-appointed traffic expert Mr Pindar’s evidence was,

    “On a matter of public interest it is wrong to put a traffic generator such as the proposal on a main road due to the need to keep such thoroughfares free flowing and as safe as possible.”

  3. Included in that paragraph of evidence at the end was the words in contention

    “especially with future growth of traffic in mind.” 

  4. There had been later than that statement a joint report in Exhibit G by Mr Pindar and the applicant’s traffic expert, Mr Bertacco, about traffic volumes on Stanmore Road and they had agreed the recent trend of traffic volumes was down, not ever-increasing, although no details on this were tendered.  At this remittance the applicant handed up an affidavit by Mr K W Dobinson showing the source of the expert’s joint statement.  It contained a graph showing traffic volumes on Stanmore Road peaked in 1996 at 29,957 vehicles per day and by 2005 it had declined to 22,969 vehicles per day. 

  1. Also, during oral examination in the original hearing Mr Pindar had indicated he had asked the applicant to investigate growth of traffic volumes on Stanmore Road in relation to the proposed traffic lights for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bonim Stanmore Pty Limited v Marrickville Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWLEC 497
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Bonim Stanmore Pty Limited v Marrickville Council was heard by the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, specifically by Hoffman C on July 10, 2007. The applicant, Bonim Stanmore Pty Limited, was appealing a decision made by the council regarding a planning matter. The legal representative for the applicant was Mr. I. Hemmings, a barrister, while the council was represented by Mr. Galasso, SC. The matter in question was related to the approval of a new supermarket on a main road, which was opposed by local residents due to concerns about traffic flow and safety.

The legal issues the court had to decide centered on the accuracy of the judgment made in the previous case (2006) NSWLEC 771 and whether there was an error of law in the decision. Specifically, the court had to examine the evidence provided by the traffic expert, Mr. Pindar, and determine if there was a mistake in attributing future traffic growth to Stanmore Road. The applicant had submitted an affidavit from Mr. K. W. Dobinson that showed a decline in traffic volumes on Stanmore Road, which contradicted the expert's earlier statements.

The court's reasoning and outcome were that there was indeed an error of law in the previous judgment, specifically in the interpretation of the traffic expert's evidence. However, the court found no reason to change the orders in the original judgment (2006) NSWLEC 771, as the planning issue was determinative in its own right, independent of the traffic matters. The court dismissed the appeal and returned the exhibits handed up to the parties.

In summary, the court found that there was an error of law in the original judgment but determined that the planning issue was the primary factor in the decision. The appeal was dismissed, and the exhibits were returned to the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established