Bonfoal Pty Limited v Botany Bay City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION: BONFOAL PTY LIMITED v. BOTANY BAY CITY COUNCIL [1998] NSWLEC 282 (11 November 1998) [1998] NSWLEC 33
PARTIES: BONFOAL PTY LIMITED v. BOTANY BAY CITY COUNCIL [1998] NSWLEC 282 (11 November 1998)
FILE NUMBER(S): 10417 of 1998
CORAM: Cowdroy J
KEY ISSUES: :-
LEGISLATION CITED: Evidence Act, 1995
CASES CITED: Berk v Woollahra Municipal Council (1992) 76 LGRA 138 ;
in Cacalot Pty Limited v Sydney City Council (1996) 90 LGERA 424 ;
The Queen v Watson; Ex parte Armstrong (1976) 136 CLR 248;
in Livesey v The New South Wales Bar Association (1983) 151 CLR 288;
Vakauta v Kelly (1989) 167 CLR 568;
Laws v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal (1990) 170 CLR 70;
Webb v The Queen (1993-1994) 181 CLR 41;
Goktas v Government Insurance Office of New South Wales (1993) 31 NSWLR 684;
Webb v The Queen (supra) at p 47;
R. v Sussex Justices; Ex parte McCarthy, [1924] 1 K.B. 256;
Berk v Woollahra Municipal Council ;
in Cacalot Pty Limited v Sydney City Council
DATES OF HEARING: 10 November 1998
DATE OF JUDGMENT:
11/11/1998
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:
Mr D Wilson Barrister
Mr T O'Connor Solicitor


JUDGMENT:

Background Facts

1. Orders were made this morning in these proceedings and I agreed to provide reasons later to-day. I now do so. The orders which I made are set in the final paragraphs of this judgment.

2. This is an application for the disqualification of Assessor Bly and Assessor Murrell (“the assessors”) from further hearing Class 1 proceedings. The proceedings arise out of the refusal by Botany Bay City Council (“the Council”) to grant approval to a development application lodged by Bonfoal Pty Limited (“the Applicant”) in respect of a proposed concrete batching plant at premises located in Coward Street, Mascot (“the site”). The application for disqualification arises out of alleged perceived bias or alternatively denial of procedural fairness.

3. The hearing commenced before the assessors in this Court on 6 November 1998. On that day it was proposed that a view be held at 11.00 am upon the site on 9 November 1998.

4. The assessors arrived by taxi at the site at 11.00 am as arranged. Mr Wilson, counsel for the Applicant was present and the solicitor representing the Council, Mr O’Connor arrived shortly thereafter. A View took place at the site and of adjoining premises known as Caterair. In addition, a View was held of the surrounding area and two cars were used. One car contained Assessor Murrell and two representatives of the Applicant, the other car contained Assessor Bly, Mr O’Connor, Mr Wilson and a driver employed by the Applicant. No objection was raised by any party to such arrangement.

5. Following the conclusion of the View it was necessary for the parties to return to the city to resume the hearing. Accordingly the vehicles returned to the site. Mr O’Connor alighted from the car in which he had been travelling and returned…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bonfoal Pty Limited v Botany Bay City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] NSWLEC 282
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Bonfoal Pty Limited v Botany Bay City Council, the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales was tasked with determining whether two assessors, Assessor Bly and Assessor Murrell, should be disqualified from further proceedings in a case involving a proposed concrete batching plant development application. The application was lodged by Bonfoal Pty Limited, and the Botany Bay City Council had refused the approval. The case revolved around the alleged bias or denial of procedural fairness by the assessors during a site view that occurred without the presence of the Council's representative.

The legal issues before the Court were whether the assessors' conduct during the site view amounted to a breach of natural justice or procedural fairness, and if the procedural defect could be rectified during the ongoing hearing. The Council argued that the assessors' deviation from the planned route to inspect another concrete batching plant without their representation constituted a breach of natural justice. They contended that the assessors' observations during this unarranged visit, and their subsequent discussions with the Applicant's counsel, created a reasonable apprehension of bias. Bonfoal Pty Limited, on the other hand, argued that any procedural defect could be remedied during the hearing and that the assessors' conduct did not amount to a breach of natural justice.

The Court held that the assessors' conduct did indeed breach the principles of natural justice. The Court found that it was fundamental for both parties to be represented or present before the decision maker at all times. The assessors' decision to split up and conduct a site view without the presence of the Council's representative created a situation where suspicion could arise that the decision maker could be compromised. Furthermore, the deliberate deviation to inspect another site without the Council's presence or representation, and the observations made during this visit, created a reasonable apprehension of bias. The Court concluded that the procedural defect was such that it could not be rectified during the hearing and that the assessors should be disqualified from further proceedings.

In conclusion, the Court ordered that Assessor Bly and Assessor Murrell be disqualified from further hearing proceedings in the case. The parties were granted liberty to approach the Registrar to obtain fresh hearing dates, and the question of costs was reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established