Bondlake Pty Ltd v the Owners - Strata Plan No 60285

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Bondlake Pty Ltd v The Owners - Strata Plan No 60285 [2005]  NSWCA 35

FILE NUMBER(S):
41007/04

HEARING DATE(S):               24 February 2005

JUDGMENT DATE: 02/03/2005

PARTIES:
Bondlake Pty Ltd - Appellant
The Owners - Strata Plan No 60285 - Respondent

JUDGMENT OF:       Handley JA Giles JA McColl JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court - Equity Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          ED  1844/03

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Pearlman AJ

COUNSEL:
S Wheelhouse SC & L Docker - Appellant
P Whitford SC & J Lazarus - Respondent

SOLICITORS:
Deutsch Partners Lawyers Pty Ltd - Appellant
Snelgrove Boyle Neilson - Respondent

CATCHWORDS:
Contract - whether void for illegality - Strata Schemes Management Act 1996 - "initial period" when developer controls owners corporation prior to lot owners having control - s 113(1)(b) prohibits owners corporation from incurring a debt for an amount exceeding the amount then available for repayment of the debt from administrative fund or sinking fund - owners corporation entered into caretaker agreement under which fee was payable - incurred a debt - nothing in funds - whether prohibition on entering into contract meant it was void for illegality - question of construction of s 113 - gave claim over against original which presupposed owners corporation was liable for the debt - qualified sanction for contravention - unlikely invalidity intended - invalidity could operate harshly on innocent persons - on proper construction, not void.  D

LEGISLATION CITED:

DECISION:
(1)  Appeal allowed;  (2)  Set aside the declaration and order for costs made by Pearlman AJ on 5 November 2004;  (3)  Summons filed on 12 March 2003 dismissed;  (4)  Respondent pay the costs of the summons and the appeal and have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if otherwise qualified.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA  41007/04
ED  1844/03

HANDLEY JA
GILES JA
McCOLL JA

Wednesday 2 March 2005

BONDLAKE PTY LTD v THE OWNERS - STRATA PLAN No 60285

Judgment

  1. HANDLEY JA:  I agree with Giles JA.

  2. GILES JA: Pearlman AJ declared void a contract, described as a caretaker agreement, for the provision of services in the management of a strata title building. The principal question in this appeal is whether the contract was vitiated for illegality by reason of s 113(1)(b) of the Strata Schemes Management Act 1996 (“the Act”).

  3. At the material time s 113 of the Act, which has since been amended, provided -

    “113      Restrictions on powers of owners corporation during initial period

    (1)An owners corporation must not, during the initial period, do any of the following things unless the owners corporation is authorised to do so by an order of the Board under section 182:

    (a)alter any common property or erect any structure on the common property otherwise than in accordance with a strata development contract,

    (b)incur a debt for an amount that exceeds the amount then available for repayment of the debt from its administrative fund or its sinking fund,

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bondlake Pty Ltd v the Owners - Strata Plan No 60285 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWCA 35
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a dispute between Bondlake Pty Ltd (the appellant) and the Owners – Strata Plan No 60285 (the respondent owners corporation). The core of the disagreement revolved around a caretaker agreement entered into by the owners corporation during its "initial period," as defined by the *Strata Schemes Management Act 1996* (NSW). The owners corporation argued that the agreement was void for illegality due to a breach of section 113(1)(b) of the Act, which restricts the owners corporation from incurring debts exceeding available funds during this period. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The primary legal issue before the court was the construction of section 113(1)(b) of the *Strata Schemes Management Act 1996*. Specifically, the court had to determine whether entering into a contract that resulted in the owners corporation incurring a debt, when there were insufficient funds in the administrative or sinking funds for repayment, rendered that contract void for illegality. This involved considering whether the prohibition in section 113(1)(b) impliedly invalidated such contracts, or if the statutory remedies provided for contravention were exhaustive.

The court reasoned that section 113(1)(b) prohibited the owners corporation from incurring a debt beyond its available funds during the initial period. However, the Act also provided specific remedies for contravention, including the ability for the owners corporation to recover amounts from the original owner as a debt under section 113(2)(a). The court found it unlikely that the legislature intended for such contracts to be automatically void, particularly given that invalidity could operate harshly on innocent third parties. The existence of specific recovery mechanisms and defences within section 113 suggested a qualified sanction rather than outright invalidity. Therefore, on a proper construction of the Act, the caretaker agreement was not void for illegality.

Consequently, the appeal was allowed. The declaration and order for costs made by the primary judge were set aside, and the summons filed by the respondent was dismissed. The respondent was ordered to pay the costs of the summons and the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Appeal allowed; (2) Set aside the declaration and order for costs made by Pearlman AJ on 5 November 2004; (3) Summons filed on 12 March 2003 dismissed; (4) Respondent pay the costs of the summons and the appeal and have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if otherwise qualified.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The first annual general meeting of the respondent was held on 30 June 1999. The managing agent was appointed for a future period. Nothing occurred with respect to the caretaker agreement.The decision of Pearlman AJ Pearlman AJ held that the appellant had “incurred a debt” within s 113(1)(b) of the Act upon entering into the caretaker agreement, because it had come under an unavoidable obligation to pay at least the $7,828.57 and in her Honour’s view also the $84,042 and contingently the fees for further years. She rejected the contention that no debt had been incurred because of Parklane’s undertaking and its payment of the $7,828.57. Her Honour held that, s 113(1)(b) otherwise applying, the caretaker agreement was entered into in breach of that provision. After a discussion of principles relevant to vitiation of a contract for illegality, her Honour held that s 113(1)(b) impliedly prohibited the contract whereby the owners corporation incurred the debt and that the legislative intention was that the contract should be void and unenforceable. Her Honour’s reasons in this respect were -“68 I turn first to the language of the Act. Section 113 is couched in terms of prohibition; that is, it provides that an owners corporation ‘must not’ do certain things. One of the “things” that are prohibited is for an owners corporation to incur a debt. If it is accepted, as I think it must be, on the authority of Hawkins v Bank of China, that an owners corporation incurs a debt when it subjects itself to an unavoidable obligation to pay a sum of money at a future time, then it follows that the ‘thing’ that is prohibited by s 113(1)(b) is a contract that has that effect, that is, a contract whereby the owners corporation subjects itself to such an unavoidable obligation. I do not think it is possible to disassociate the incurring of a debt from the contract whereby the debt is incurred. It is not therefore to the point that another provision of the Act (s 13) permits an owners corporation to enter into a caretaker agreement; a contract, whether it be a caretaker agreement or some other type of contract, will be impugned by s 113(1)(b) if, by its terms and within the meaning of s 113(1)(b), an owners corporation incurs a debt. In my opinion, it follows that, in prohibiting an owners corporation from incurring a debt, s 113(1)(b) impliedly prohibits the contract whereby the owners corporation incurs that debt. Hence, the Act affects the contract in the second of the ways identified by Gibbs ACJ in Yango Pastoral v First Chicago. 69 The language and scope of s 113 is also critical for the legal consequences of contravention of the prohibition. Section 113 does not prescribe a penalty for contravention, but it does provide a remedy. An owners corporation may recover the debt from the original owner pursuant to s 113(2)(a). But nothing in the language of s 113 suggests that that is the only legal consequence or that recovery is the only legal remedy. It is true that the recovery of the amount as a debt and the defence provided to an original owner in s 113(4) are both predicated on a contract being in existence, but s 113(5) cannot be ignored. That subsection contemplates other remedies being available. It is clear and unambiguous in its terms, and it must be given work to do. Hence, I conclude that what is intended, by the language and scope of s 113, is that, whilst recovery of the amount as a debt is an available remedy, unenforceability of a contract made in breach of its provisions is also an available legal consequence. 70 In my opinion, the obvious public purpose of s 113 points to the intention of the legislature that a contract contravening its provisions will be void and unenforceable. The mischief that s 113 intends to avoid is the casting of onerous obligations upon future lot owners. That mischief can be effectively avoided only if no such burden can be cast upon them. One way to achieve that, in a case of contravention of s 113(b)(1), is the recovery of the amount as a debt. But that remedy may not be sufficient. The original owner may not be in existence, or it may not have the means to meet the debt, or it may have a defence under s 113(4). Another way to achieve the avoidance of the mischief is to render the contravening contract void and unenforceable. In my opinion, s 113 contemplates such a legal consequence. 71 I have not lost sight of the fact that rendering the caretaker agreement void and unenforceable will result in a considerable sanction upon the defendant, innocent in the sense that it is not the contravening party. It will lose what is no doubt a valuable commercial right. But that sanction is not, in my opinion, out of proportion to the purpose and object of the Act in protecting lot owners. The necessity for that protection is thrown into stark relief by the facts of this case. Here, the caretaker agreement casts a significant burden upon lot owners. The debt incurred is significant (it involves an annual amount of at least $84,042) and the obligation to pay it continues for a significant period of time (up to 20 years).”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At the material time s 113 of the Act, which has since been amended, provided -“113 Restrictions on powers of owners corporation during initial period(1)An owners corporation must not, during the initial period, do any of the following things unless the owners corporation is authorised to do so by an order of the Board under section 182: (a)alter any common property or erect any structure on the common property otherwise than in accordance with a strata development contract,(b)incur a debt for an amount that exceeds the amount then available for repayment of the debt from its administrative fund or its sinking fund,(c)appoint a strata managing agent to hold office for a period extending beyond the holding of the first annual general meeting of the owners corporation,(d) borrow money or give securities.(2)An owners corporation may recover from the original owner: (a)as a debt, any amount for which the owners corporation is liable because of a contravention of subsection (1) (b), together with the expenses of the owners corporation incurred in recovering that amount, and(b)as damages for breach of statutory duty, any loss suffered by the owners corporation as a result of any other contravention of subsection (1).(3)An owner may recover, as damages for breach of statutory duty, any loss that has been suffered by the owner as a result of a contravention of subsection (1) (other than paragraph (b)).(4)It is a defence to an action under this section in debt or for damages if it is proved that the original owner: (a)did not know of the contravention on which the action is based, or(b)was not in a position to influence the conduct of the owners corporation in relation to the contravention, or(c)used due diligence to prevent the contravention.(5)A remedy available under this section does not affect any other remedy.”Facts On 18 May 1999 strata plan no 60285 was registered for the strata title building “The Carlisle” at 105-113 Campbell Street, Surry Hills (“the property”). The respondent was thereby established as the owners corporation for the strata scheme. The property was a refurbished existing building containing 139 apartments, some with car spaces. The developer which carried out the refurbishment, then called D S Parklane Development Pty Ltd (“Parklane”), owned the parcel the subject of the scheme. Parklane had contracted to sell some of the apartments, and in due course sold them all. It was the “original owner” within the meaning of the Act. The Act prescribed as the “initial period” the period commencing on the day on which the owners corporation was constituted and ending on the day on which there were owners of lots the subject of the strata scheme, other than the original owner, the sum of whose unit entitlements was at least one third of the aggregate unit entitlement. With the transfer of lots the subject of the strata scheme, the initial period expired on either 9 or 10 June 1999. A extraordinary general meeting of the respondent was held on 25 May 1999. At that time Parklane was still the owner of all the lots the subject of the strata scheme. The resolutions passed included -“Motion 3Undertaking to pay Owners Corporation outgoingsRESOLVED that the Owners Corporation note the undertaking to pay outgoings by D S Parklane Developments Pty Limited marked Exhibit B and tabled at the meeting for the period from registration of Strata Plan No 60285 until the earlier of:(a) midnight on 30 June 1999; or(b)seven days after D S Parkland Development Pty Limited serves notice on the Owners Corporation that the undertaking will cease.”“Motion 8Caretaker agreementRESOLVED that, according to By-Law 26, the Owners Corporation:(a)enter into the caretaker agreement in or to the effect of the agreement marked Exhibit D and tabled at the meeting; and(b) affix its common seal to the caretaker [sic].”