Boman Irani Pty Ltd v St George Bank Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

No. 3758 of 2008

BOMAN IRANI PTY LTD (ACN 006 569 044) & ORS

Appellants

v.

ST GEORGE BANK LIMITED
(ACN 055 513 070)

Respondent

---

JUDGES:

WARREN CJ, NEAVE JA and HARGRAVE AJA

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

21 October 2008

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

4 December 2008

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2008] VSCA 246

---

ILLEGALITY- PUBLIC POLICY- Loan documents required borrower and guarantors to pay bank’s legal costs on an indemnity basis - Costs agreement between bank and its solicitors provided for rebates by reference to annual volume of fees charged - Whether bank required to give credit for rebates when received - Whether arrangements contrary to public policy - Bank required to give credit for rebates - Attempt by bank to recover legal costs without giving credit for rebates contrary to public policy - Hamilton v Haw [1962] VR 215 considered and applied- Rule 63.53 of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2005 (Vic) considered

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
Appellants Dr C L Pannam QC with
Mr S D Hay
Comlaw
Barristers & Solicitors

Respondent

Mr R M Garratt QC with
Mr D L Bailey

Herbert Geer

WARREN CJ:

  1. I have read the draft judgment of Hargrave AJA. For the reasons stated by his Honour, I would dismiss the appeal.

NEAVE JA:

  1. I have had the considerable benefit of reading in draft the reasons for judgment of Hargrave AJA. I agree with his Honour that the arrangements between St George Bank Limited on the one hand, and Pinnacle Investments Pty Ltd and the guarantors on the other, were contrary to public policy under the principle in Hamilton v Haw.[1]  These arrangements contemplated the exaction from Pinnacle and/or the guarantors of legal costs which were not ultimately incurred by St George because it was entitled to a ‘volume rebate’ from its solicitors.

    [1][1962] VR 215.

  1. However, as his Honour has said, the appellants must fail, because the trial judge found that St George was obliged to give credit to Pinnacle and the guarantors for the proportion of the volume rebates it received from its solicitors, which were referable to the particular transaction.

  1. I agree with Hargrave AJA that the Court’s reasons for judgment should be referred to the relevant authorities.

HARGRAVE AJA:

I          OUTLINE OF FACTS AND ISSUES

  1. The various proceedings giving rise to this appeal had a tortuous history.  The proceedings arose out of finance facilities provided by the respondent, St George Bank Limited, (“the bank”) to Pinnacle Investments Pty Ltd.  Pinnacle is a company associated with the interests of Dr Boman Irani.  The obligations of Pinnacle to the bank were guaranteed by Dr Irani, his wife Dr Kermani and companies associated with them (“the guarantors”).  Default was made under the finance facilities and the bank sought to realise its securities and to call upon the guarantee.

  1. In the first proceeding the guarantors made a number of claims against the bank.  The bank counterclaimed seeking declarations that it…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Boman Irani Pty Ltd v St George Bank Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] VSCA 246
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Boman Irani Pty Ltd brought proceedings against St George Bank Ltd in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The dispute arose from the bank's attempt to recover legal costs from the company, pursuant to the terms of a loan agreement. The central issue was whether the bank was entitled to recover the full amount of its legal costs, or whether it was required to credit those costs with rebates received from its own solicitors, as provided for in the bank's costs agreement with those solicitors. The court was required to determine whether the arrangements between the bank and its solicitors were contrary to public policy.

The court found that the terms of the costs agreement between the bank and its solicitors provided for rebates to be applied to the bank's costs, in accordance with the annual volume of fees charged. The court held that the bank was required to credit those rebates when recovering costs from the company. The court held that the bank's attempt to recover legal costs without giving credit for the rebates was contrary to public policy. The court referred to the decision in Hamilton v Haw [1962] VR 215, in which the court held that it would not assist a party who had entered into an illegal agreement to enforce that agreement. The court also considered Rule 63.53 of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2005 (Vic), which provides that a party may not recover costs in an amount greater than that which it has actually incurred.

The court found in favour of the company and ordered the bank to credit the rebates when recovering legal costs. The court held that the bank's attempt to recover costs without giving credit for the rebates was contrary to public policy and that the company was not required to pay those costs in full. The court's decision provides guidance to banks and other lenders on the importance of complying with public policy and ensuring that their arrangements with their own solicitors do not result in an unfair advantage when recovering costs from borrowers.

Background

Background to the litigation

Boman Irani Pty Ltd (the borrower) and its guarantors entered into loan documents with St George Bank Ltd (the bank). The loan documents contained clauses requiring the borrower and guarantors to pay the bank's legal costs on an indemnity basis. Additionally, there was a costs agreement between the bank and its solicitors that provided for rebates to be paid by the solicitors to the bank by reference to the annual volume of fees charged. The bank later sought to recover legal costs from the borrower and guarantors without giving credit for the rebates received from its solicitors. The borrower and guarantors argued that the bank was required to give credit for the rebates when received and that the arrangements were contrary to public policy. They also argued that the bank's attempt to recover legal costs without giving credit for the rebates was contrary to public policy.

The matter came before the court as an appeal from a decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria. The primary judge had found in favour of the borrower and guarantors, holding that the bank was required to give credit for the rebates and that the arrangements were contrary to public policy. The bank appealed the decision, and the appeal was subsequently heard by the court. The court considered the relevant legal principles and authorities, including the decision in Hamilton v Haw [1962] VR 215, and the provisions of Rule 63.53 of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2005 (Vic).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the bank required to give credit for the rebates when received?
2. Were the arrangements between the bank and its solicitors contrary to public policy?
3. Was the bank's attempt to recover legal costs without giving credit for the rebates contrary to public policy?

Held
1. The court held that the bank was required to give credit for the rebates when received.
2. The court held that the arrangements between the bank and its solicitors were not contrary to public policy.
3. The court held that the bank's attempt to recover legal costs without giving credit for the rebates was contrary to public policy.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by considering the first issue, whether the bank was required to give credit for the rebates when received. The court examined the terms of the loan documents and the costs agreement between the bank and its solicitors. The court found that the costs agreement provided for rebates by reference to the annual volume of fees charged. The court concluded that the bank was required to give credit for the rebates when received, as this was a direct consequence of the terms agreed upon in the costs agreement. This holding was based on the principle that parties must adhere to the terms of their contract.

Next, the court addressed the second issue, whether the arrangements between the bank and its solicitors were contrary to public policy. The court considered the nature of the costs agreement and the fact that it was a private arrangement between the bank and its solicitors. The court found that there was no public policy consideration that would render the arrangements contrary to public policy. The court distinguished this case from previous cases where the courts found agreements to be against public policy because they involved illegal activities or undermined the administration of justice.

Finally, the court examined the third issue, whether the bank's attempt to recover legal costs without giving credit for the rebates was contrary to public policy. The court noted that the bank's actions were inconsistent with the terms of the costs agreement, which provided for rebates. The court held that the bank's attempt to recover legal costs without giving credit for the rebates was contrary to public policy because it involved the bank attempting to profit from a breach of its own contractual obligations. The court applied the principle established in Hamilton v Haw [1962] VR 215, which held that a party cannot recover costs where the basis for recovery is inconsistent with the terms of the costs agreement. The court also considered Rule 63.53 of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2005 (Vic), which reinforces the principle that a party cannot recover costs on an indemnity basis if the costs agreement provides for a different basis of recovery. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a bank cannot recover legal costs on an indemnity basis if the costs agreement provides for rebates, and attempting to do so is contrary to public policy.