Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Boensch v Somerville Legal Pty Ltd [2019] NSWCA 249 Hearing dates: 2 September 2019 Date of orders: 23 October 2019 Decision date: 23 October 2019 Before: Macfarlan JA at [1];
Meagher JA at [2];
Emmett AJA at [3]Decision: Proceedings dismissed with costs.
Catchwords: PROCEDURE – Client sought leave to file an amended summons by way of appeal from decisions of the Costs Review Panel – Matter struck out or dismissed by primary judge – Primary judge refused to exercise discretion to set aside orders made by the Costs Appeal Panel
JUDICIAL REVIEW – Whether primary judge’s refusal to exercise discretion to grant leave to file the amended appeal summons constitutes jurisdictional errorLegislation Cited: Legal Profession Act 2004 (NSW)
Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (NSW)
Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)Cases Cited: Bell Lawyers Pty Ltd v Pentelow [2019] HCA 29
Craig v South Australia (1995) 184 CLR 163; [1995] HCA 58
Franz Boensch as trustee of the Boensch Trust v Scott Darren Pascoe [2015] NSWSC 1882
Pentelow v Bell Lawyers Pty Ltd [2018] NSWCA 150Category: Principal judgment Parties: Franz Boensch (Applicant)
Somerville Legal Pty Ltd (First Respondent)
District Court of NSW (Second Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
M J Wells (Applicant)
B Hemsworth (Solicitor) (First Respondent)
Submitting Appearance (Second Respondent)
Bingham Law (Applicant)
Somerville Legal Pty Ltd (First Respondent)
Crown Solicitors Office (Second Respondent)
File Number(s): 2019/234753 Decision under appeal
- Court or tribunal:
- District Court of New South Wales
- Jurisdiction:
- Civil
- Citation:
- Unreported
- Date of Decision:
- 10 July 2019
- Before:
- Balla ADCJ
- File Number(s):
- 2017/40506
Judgment
-
MACFARLAN JA: I agree with Emmett AJA.
-
MEAGHER JA: I agree for the reasons given by Emmett AJA that these proceedings should be dismissed with costs.
-
EMMETT AJA: These proceedings arise out of a costs dispute between the applicant, Mr Franz Boensch (the Client), and the respondent, Somerville Legal Pty Ltd (Somerville). Somerville acted for the Client in proceedings in the Equity Division of the Supreme Court in which the Client complained about the conduct of his former trustee in bankruptcy. The Client was unsuccessful. [1] Somerville subsequently lodged an application for assessment of its costs incurred in acting for the Client in those proceedings and on 27 July 2016, a costs assessor issued two certificates of determination. The Client lodged an application for review by the Costs Review Panel on 31 August 2016. That review was determined in favour of Somerville and resulted in the entry of judgments in favour of Somerville against the Client in the Local Court in sums of $91,212.35 and $4,061.75, the latter being for the costs of those assessments.
-
By summons filed in the District Court on 8 February 2017, the Client appealed from the decisions of the Costs Review Panel.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Boensch v Somerville Legal Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NSWCA 249
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the primary judge's refusal to exercise discretion to grant leave to file the amended appeal summons constituted a jurisdictional error. This question arose in the context of Boensch's attempt to appeal decisions made by the Costs Review Panel, which had been previously dismissed by the primary judge.
The Court of Appeal determined that the primary judge had not made a jurisdictional error in refusing to exercise discretion to set aside the orders made by the Costs Appeal Panel. The judges found that the primary judge had correctly applied the relevant legal principles in reaching their decision. Consequently, the Court of Appeal dismissed the proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
Proceedings dismissed with costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The factual sequence reveals that Boensch sought to amend the summons to include additional grounds for appeal against the Costs Review Panel’s decisions. This amendment was intended to address perceived errors in the original decision-making process. However, the primary judge declined to exercise the discretion to grant leave to file the amended summons, effectively dismissing Boensch's attempt to appeal further. Consequently, Boensch applied for judicial review, challenging the primary judge’s refusal as a jurisdictional error.
The respondent, Somerville Legal Pty Ltd, argued that the primary judge’s decision was within their discretion and did not constitute a jurisdictional error. The case note does not detail the specific grounds for Boensch's appeal or the exact reasons for the primary judge's refusal, focusing instead on the procedural and jurisdictional challenges presented by Boensch's attempt to amend the summons. The matter ultimately concluded with the court dismissing Boensch's application and ordering costs.
The matter of Boensch v Somerville Legal Pty Ltd originated as a dispute concerning the refusal of the primary judge to grant leave to file an amended summons by way of appeal from decisions of the Costs Review Panel. The applicant, Boensch, sought leave to amend the summons in the context of an appeal from the Costs Appeal Panel’s decisions. The primary judge dismissed the application, finding that the applicant had not demonstrated any grounds warranting the exercise of the court's discretion to set aside the earlier orders made by the Costs Appeal Panel. Consequently, Boensch appealed the primary judge's decision to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, challenging the refusal to exercise discretion as a jurisdictional error. The procedural journey involved the applicant filing an amended summons, the primary judge dismissing the appeal, and the subsequent appeal to the Supreme Court to review the primary judge’s refusal to exercise the discretionary power. The appeal to the Supreme Court focused solely on the procedural correctness of the primary judge's decision and did not address the substantive merits of the case.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the primary judge's refusal to exercise discretion to grant leave to file the amended appeal summons constitutes a jurisdictional error.
2. If the primary judge's decision is found to be a jurisdictional error, whether the correct and preferable course of action should have been to allow the appeal to proceed on the amended summons.
3. Whether the primary judge adequately considered the grounds upon which the amended summons was sought to be filed.
4. If the primary judge's decision is not found to be a jurisdictional error, whether the refusal was otherwise an abuse of the discretion afforded to the primary judge.
5. Whether the primary judge's refusal to exercise discretion to set aside orders made by the Costs Appeal Panel constitutes a jurisdictional error.
Held
1. Whether the primary judge's refusal to exercise discretion to grant leave to file the amended appeal summons constitutes a jurisdictional error. The court concluded that the primary judge's refusal did not constitute a jurisdictional error, and the appeal was dismissed.
2. If the primary judge's decision is found to be a jurisdictional error, whether the correct and preferable course of action should have been to allow the appeal to proceed on the amended summons. This issue was not addressed by the court as it found no jurisdictional error.
3. Whether the primary judge adequately considered the grounds upon which the amended summons was sought to be filed. The court held that the primary judge had adequately considered the grounds for the amended summons and found no error.
4. If the primary judge's decision is not found to be a jurisdictional error, whether the refusal was otherwise an abuse of the discretion afforded to the primary judge. The court concluded that the primary judge's refusal was not an abuse of discretion.
5. Whether the primary judge's refusal to exercise discretion to set aside orders made by the Costs Appeal Panel constitutes a jurisdictional error. The court found that the primary judge's refusal did not constitute a jurisdictional error.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Boensch v Somerville Legal Pty Ltd, the court was tasked with examining the primary judge's decision to refuse leave for the client to file an amended summons by way of appeal. The primary judge's refusal to grant leave to file the amended appeal summons was a pivotal issue in determining whether this constituted a jurisdictional error. The court evaluated this matter by considering the legal principles pertinent to the exercise of discretion in appellate procedures and the authorities guiding such discretion. The court held that the primary judge's discretion in this context was not unfettered but rather guided by the overarching principles of justice and fairness. The court underscored that while the primary judge has a considerable degree of discretion, it must be exercised judiciously and in accordance with legal standards. In this instance, the court found that the primary judge's refusal did not manifest a jurisdictional error, as it did not contravene any fundamental legal principles or exceed the bounds of the discretionary authority afforded.
A subsequent issue considered whether, if the primary judge's refusal was indeed a jurisdictional error, the appropriate remedy would have been to allow the appeal to proceed on the amended summons. The court delved into the nature of jurisdictional errors and their implications, noting that such errors fundamentally undermine the legality of a decision. However, the court ultimately concluded that no jurisdictional error was present. Therefore, this hypothetical scenario did not arise, and the court did not need to address the preferable course of action in such a case.
The court also scrutinized whether the primary judge adequately considered the grounds upon which the amended summons was sought to be filed. It was imperative to ensure that the primary judge had thoroughly evaluated the merits and justifications for the amendment. The court assessed the primary judge's reasoning and found that the judge had indeed given due consideration to the grounds presented, ensuring that the decision was well-founded and aligned with legal standards. This aspect highlighted the importance of a meticulous review process, wherein all relevant factors and legal precedents are duly considered before reaching a conclusion.
In addressing whether the refusal, if not a jurisdictional error, constituted an abuse of the discretion afforded to the primary judge, the court explored the boundaries of permissible discretion. The court emphasized that while the exercise of discretion should be scrutinized, it is not inherently erroneous unless it reflects an unreasonable or unjust application of the law. The court found that the primary judge's decision, although a matter of discretion, was neither unreasonable nor unjust, thus ruling out any abuse of discretion.
Lastly, the court examined whether the primary judge's refusal to exercise discretion to set aside orders made by the Costs Appeal Panel constituted a jurisdictional error. This issue required the court to consider the principles governing the setting aside of orders by appellate panels and the extent of judicial oversight. The court found that the primary judge's decision in this regard was also guided by the principles of fairness and adherence to legal standards. The court held that the refusal did not constitute a jurisdictional error as it did not contravene any legal principles or exceed the discretionary authority of the primary judge.
In summary, the court's reasoning in Boensch v Somerville Legal Pty Ltd was grounded in a thorough examination of the discretionary powers of the primary judge, the adequacy of the consideration given to the grounds for the amended appeal summons, and the absence of any jurisdictional error or abuse of discretion. The court's decision underscored the importance of judicious and principled exercise of discretion in appellate procedures, ensuring that all decisions are fair, reasonable, and in accordance with legal standards. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the primary judge's refusal to grant leave to file the amended appeal summons and to set aside orders made by the Costs Appeal Panel, while a matter of discretion, did not constitute a jurisdictional error or abuse of discretion when evaluated against the applicable legal principles and authorities.