| IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA | Not Restricted |
AT MELBOURNE
COMMERCIAL COURT
S CI 2016 02044
| BODYCORP REPAIRERS PTY LTD (ACN 068 589 408) | Plaintiff |
| v | |
| ANUNZIATO ENZO MAISNO (also known as Michael Maisano and Michal Mason) & ORS | Defendant |
---
JUDGE: | RIORDAN J |
WHERE HELD: | MELBOURNE |
DATE OF HEARING: | 29 SEPTEMBER 2016 |
DATE OF RULING: | 29 SEPTEMBER 2016 (Ex tempore) |
CASE MAY BE CITED AS: | BODYCORP REPAIRERS PTY LTD v MAISNO (No 10) |
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2016] VSC 599 |
---
PRACTICE — Constitution of court — Judges — Disqualification for bias — Test of bias — Objective standard applied — Professional relationship between judge and a legal practitioner defendant in the proceeding – Relevance of party’s preference for another judge.
---
APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Plaintiff | Mr P G Nash QC with Dr G Boas | Templeton Fox Rothschild |
| For the Fourth and Fifth Defendants For the Second and Eighth Defendants For the Third Defendant | Mr C G Madder Mr N P De Young Mr A R Kirby | Moray and Agnew Minter Ellison Colin Biggers & Paisley |
HIS HONOUR:
This is an application made this morning by senior counsel for the plaintiff that I should recuse myself from hearing summary dismissal applications brought by various defendants. The plaintiff in this proceeding principally seeks to set aside a judgment of this Court given on 4 September 2013. There are eight defendants to the proceeding, including the third defendant, a Queen’s counsel and a member of the Victorian Bar, who appeared on behalf of the fourth defendant at the original trial.
At the commencement of the hearing, I disclosed the fact that, over the years that I was at the Victorian Bar, I have known the third defendant on a professional basis in that I was opposed to him and acted for different parties in litigation on a few occasions, the number of which I could not specifically recall. He had not been my junior and we had not acted for the same party. As an incident of that relationship I would see him from time to time around chambers and say ‘hello’ in passing. However, I have not had a social relationship with the third defendant. I have not been to his house nor has he been to mine.
Mr Nash QC relied upon those facts to support an application that I should recuse myself. Whether or not a judge should disqualify himself from hearing a case on the ground of bias, either actual or ostensible, requires an objective appraisal of the materials before the court. The fact that a party may have a subjective apprehension of bias is not of itself sufficient to warrant or require the disqualification of a judge.
The test to be applied is whether, objectively assessed, there is material before the court to support a conclusion of actual bias on the part of the judge (for which in this case the plaintiff did not contend) or a reasonable apprehension by parties or a member of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bodycorp Repairers Pty Ltd v Maisano (No 10) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] VSC 599
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the prior professional relationship between Justice Brereton and Maisano constituted a ground for disqualification. The court examined the established legal test for judicial bias, focusing on whether there was a reasonable apprehension of partiality. The court recognised that the test is objective, meaning that the focus is on the perception of an ordinary, informed, and educated observer rather than the actual state of the judge’s mind. The court considered the relevance of Bodycorp’s preference for another judge, noting that while a party’s preference alone is not determinative, it may be a factor in assessing the reasonable apprehension of bias.
The court concluded that the prior professional relationship between Justice Brereton and Maisano did not create a reasonable apprehension of bias. The court reasoned that the relationship was not recent or intimate, and there was no evidence of ongoing communication or interaction between the judge and Maisano since the prior matter. The court held that an ordinary, informed, and educated observer would not perceive a partiality in Justice Brereton’s decision-making. The court also noted that Bodycorp’s preference for another judge was not sufficient to establish bias on its own. Consequently, the application for disqualification was dismissed.
The final orders of the court were that the application for Justice Brereton’s disqualification was dismissed, and the matter proceeded with Justice Brereton presiding over the case. The court’s decision highlighted the importance of the objective standard in assessing judicial bias and the limited relevance of a party’s preference for another judge in such assessments.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.