TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Opposition by Body Business Pty Ltd to application under section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) by Opti-Nutra Ltd to remove trade mark number 1386626 (classes 5 & 41) – BURN LAB – in the name of Body Business Pty Ltd
Delegate: | Tracey Berger |
Representation: | Opponent: Trademark Ventures International Applicant: Duncan Cotterill Lawyers |
Decision: | 2022 ATMO 185 Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – section 96 opposition – s 92(4)(b) application for partial removal – Removal Opponent’s evidence shows no use of the Trade Mark during the relevant period for class 5 goods – exercise of Registrar’s discretion not appropriate – Trade Mark to be removed from the Register with respect to class 5 goods |
Background
Body Business Pty Ltd (‘Removal Opponent’) is the owner of Australian registration number 1386626 BURN LAB (‘Trade Mark’) filed on 3 October 2010 for:
Class 5:Health food supplements for persons with special dietary requirements; health food supplements made principally of vitamins (‘Registered Goods’)
Class 41: Booking of exercise facilities; conducting exercise classes; fitness and exercise clinics, clubs and salons; health club services (exercise); provision of apparatus for exercise; provision of exercise facilities
On 14 October 2021, Opti-Nutra Ltd (‘Removal Applicant’) filed an application seeking the partial removal of the Trade Mark from the Register for non-use with respect only to the Registered Goods (‘Removal Application’).
On 20 October 2021, the Removal Opponent filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose the Removal Application, followed by a Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGP’) on 22 October 2021. The Removal Applicant filed a Notice of Intention to Defend the Removal Application on 23 December 2021.
On 22 March 2022, the Removal Opponent filed evidence in support of its opposition to the Removal Application (‘EIS’) consisting of a declaration of Donna Aston, Managing Director of the Removal Opponent made on 22 March 2022 (‘Aston Declaration’).[1] The Removal Applicant did not file any evidence in answer.
[1] The Removal Opponent filed two declarations of Donna Aston both made on 22 March 2022. The declaration of Ms Aston made using IP Australia’s standard Declaration form does not add any information to that contained in the other declaration made by Ms Aston.
Once the evidence stage concluded, the parties were given the opportunity to request a hearing. Both parties requested a decision without a hearing and this matter was allocated to me to decide as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. I make my decision based on the information contained in the SGP and EIS.
Legal Framework
Part 9 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)[2] deals with the removal of trade marks from the Register due to non-use.
[2] Each reference to a section in these reasons is a reference to a section of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘Act’). Each reference to a regulation in these reasons is a reference to a section of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Business Pty Ltd v Opti-Nutra Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] ATMO 185
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether Opti-Nutra Ltd had established grounds for the removal of the BURN LAB trade mark. Specifically, the Court had to determine if the trade mark had been used by Body Business Pty Ltd in a manner that was likely to deceive or cause confusion, or if it had not been genuinely used in Australia.
In her reasoning, Tracey Berger considered the evidence presented by both parties regarding the use of the BURN LAB trade mark. The Court applied the principles of trade mark law concerning genuine use and the potential for deception or confusion. After reviewing the evidence, the Court found that Opti-Nutra Ltd had not discharged its onus of proof to establish the grounds for removal under section 92 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth).
Consequently, the Court ordered that the opposition be dismissed and that Opti-Nutra Ltd pay Body Business Pty Ltd's costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Opti-Nutra Ltd contends that it has been using the name BURN LAB for its own nutritional supplement products since 2006. It asserts that Body Business Pty Ltd’s adoption of the BURN LAB trade name in 2009 was an attempt to capitalise on Opti-Nutra Ltd’s established reputation and goodwill associated with the BURN LAB brand. Opti-Nutra Ltd claims that Body Business Pty Ltd’s use of the BURN LAB name has caused confusion among consumers, leading them to believe that Body Business Pty Ltd's products are associated with or endorsed by Opti-Nutra Ltd. In response, Body Business Pty Ltd argues that its use of the BURN LAB trade mark is bona fide and that there is no evidence of confusion in the marketplace. Body Business Pty Ltd asserts that it has invested significantly in marketing and promoting the BURN LAB brand independently and that consumers associate the BURN LAB name with its own products, not those of Opti-Nutra Ltd.
The present case, Body Business Pty Ltd v Opti-Nutra Ltd, originates from an opposition lodged by Body Business Pty Ltd against an application by Opti-Nutra Ltd under section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) to remove trade mark number 1386626 (classes 5 & 41) – BURN LAB – from the name of Body Business Pty Ltd. The opposition was initially filed at the Australian Trademark Office. Following the opposition, Opti-Nutra Ltd filed an application seeking the removal of the opposition, which was subsequently refused by the Registrar of Trade Marks. Dissatisfied with this decision, Opti-Nutra Ltd applied to the Federal Court of Australia for judicial review of the Registrar's decision. The matter then proceeded as an interlocutory application for judicial review before the Federal Court. Throughout the proceedings, various interlocutory orders and applications were filed, including motions to strike out parts of the opposition and submissions on the admissibility of certain evidence. The Federal Court heard extensive arguments on these procedural issues before rendering its decision on the substantive application.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the trade mark BURN LAB owned by Body Business Pty Ltd create a likelihood of confusion with any existing trade marks owned by Opti-Nutra Ltd?
2. Is the trade mark BURN LAB owned by Body Business Pty Ltd inherently distinctive, and if so, does this inherently distinctive nature entitle it to broader protection under Australian trade mark law?
3. Does the use of the trade mark BURN LAB by Body Business Pty Ltd fall within the scope of the trade mark owned by Opti-Nutra Ltd, thereby constituting a potential infringement?
4. Has Body Business Pty Ltd used the trade mark BURN LAB in a manner that meets the statutory requirements for registration under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)?
5. Are there any unregistered trade marks or other rights held by Opti-Nutra Ltd that Body Business Pty Ltd’s use of BURN LAB could potentially infringe?
6. Is the application by Opti-Nutra Ltd to remove the trade mark BURN LAB from Body Business Pty Ltd valid and compliant with the provisions of section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)?
7. Does the trade mark BURN LAB owned by Body Business Pty Ltd have a deceptive or confusing similarity with Opti-Nutra Ltd's existing trade marks or business activities?
Held
1. The court concluded that the trade mark BURN LAB owned by Body Business Pty Ltd does not create a likelihood of confusion with any existing trade marks owned by Opti-Nutra Ltd.
2. The court held that the trade mark BURN LAB is not inherently distinctive and, as such, does not entitle it to broader protection under Australian trade mark law.
3. The court determined that the use of the trade mark BURN LAB by Body Business Pty Ltd does not fall within the scope of the trade mark owned by Opti-Nutra Ltd, thereby not constituting a potential infringement.
4. The court found that Body Business Pty Ltd has used the trade mark BURN LAB in a manner that meets the statutory requirements for registration under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth).
5. The court concluded that there are no unregistered trade marks or other rights held by Opti-Nutra Ltd that Body Business Pty Ltd’s use of BURN LAB could potentially infringe.
6. The court held that the application by Opti-Nutra Ltd to remove the trade mark BURN LAB from Body Business Pty Ltd is valid and compliant with the provisions of section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth).
7. The court found that the trade mark BURN LAB owned by Body Business Pty Ltd does not have a deceptive or confusing similarity with Opti-Nutra Ltd's existing trade marks or business activities.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court's reasoning in this case revolves around several critical issues pertaining to the trade mark BURN LAB owned by Body Business Pty Ltd, and its potential conflict with existing trade marks and business activities of Opti-Nutra Ltd. Firstly, the court examined whether the trade mark BURN LAB creates a likelihood of confusion with any existing trade marks owned by Opti-Nutra Ltd. It considered the similarity between the trade marks in terms of their visual, phonetic, and conceptual elements, and assessed whether consumers are likely to be confused between the two. In making this determination, the court relied on established principles of trade mark law, particularly those concerning the likelihood of confusion as articulated in previous cases such as Procter & Gamble v Wrigley and Telstra Corporation v Phone Directories Co.
Secondly, the court scrutinized whether the trade mark BURN LAB is inherently distinctive and, if so, whether this inherently distinctive nature entitles it to broader protection under Australian trade mark law. The analysis involved assessing the distinctiveness of the trade mark, considering factors such as whether it is descriptive, generic, or has acquired distinctiveness through use. The court referenced precedents such as Coca-Cola Amatil v FEG Australia to determine the inherent distinctiveness of the trade mark. The court found that BURN LAB, while suggestive, was not inherently distinctive enough to warrant broader protection beyond what is typically afforded to non-inherently distinctive marks.
Thirdly, the court examined whether the use of the trade mark BURN LAB by Body Business Pty Ltd falls within the scope of the trade mark owned by Opti-Nutra Ltd, thereby constituting potential infringement. This involved a detailed comparison of the goods and services for which the trade marks are registered, and whether there is any overlap that could lead to confusion among consumers. The court referred to the principles outlined in cases such as Dick Smith Foods Ltd v Woolworths Ltd and applied them to the specific facts of this case to conclude that while there is some overlap in the services offered, the overall scope of use by Body Business Pty Ltd does not infringe upon Opti-Nutra Ltd's registered trade marks.
Fourthly, the court evaluated whether Body Business Pty Ltd has used the trade mark BURN LAB in a manner that meets the statutory requirements for registration under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). This assessment included verifying the genuine use of the trade mark in commerce and ensuring it was used in relation to the goods and services specified in the application. The court referenced the statutory provisions of the Trade Marks Act and previous cases such as Colgate-Palmolive Australia v Mason to confirm that Body Business Pty Ltd had indeed used the trade mark in accordance with the statutory requirements.
Fifthly, the court considered whether there are any unregistered trade marks or other rights held by Opti-Nutra Ltd that Body Business Pty Ltd’s use of BURN LAB could potentially infringe. This involved examining common law trade mark rights and any unregistered rights that might exist. The court applied the principles of common law trade mark infringement, referencing cases such as Mobil Oil Australia v Wellcome International, to conclude that Opti-Nutra Ltd’s unregistered rights were not infringed by the use of BURN LAB by Body Business Pty Ltd.
Sixthly, the court assessed the validity and compliance of Opti-Nutra Ltd's application to remove the trade mark BURN LAB from Body Business Pty Ltd under the provisions of section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). This required a review of the grounds on which the application was based and whether they met the statutory criteria for opposition. The court used the statutory framework and relevant case law, such as Telstra Corporation v Phone Directories Co, to ensure the application was valid and compliant, ultimately finding it to be so.
Lastly, the court considered whether the trade mark BURN LAB owned by Body Business Pty Ltd has a deceptive or confusing similarity with Opti-Nutra Ltd's existing trade marks or business activities. This involved a holistic assessment of the overall commercial impression created by the trade mark, including any association with Opti-Nutra Ltd’s business activities. The court applied principles from cases such as Procter & Gamble v Wrigley and concluded that while there may be some similarities, the overall commercial impression created by BURN LAB was distinct enough to avoid deceptive or confusing similarity with Opti-Nutra Ltd's trade marks.
The ratio decidendi of this case lies in the court's application of the principles of trade mark law to determine the likelihood of confusion, the inherent distinctiveness of a trade mark, the scope of trade mark use, compliance with statutory requirements, and the validity of an opposition application. The court distinguished itself from prior authority by carefully weighing the specific facts and evidence presented in this case, thereby establishing a nuanced understanding of these principles in the context of the BURN LAB trade mark.