Bob Wickham v Quality Bakers Australia trading as Buttercup Bakeries

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

INDUSTRIAL LAW - termination of employment - redundancy agreement negotiated between Union and employer and not formalised before applicant made redundant - employees not informed of negotiations - procedure unsatisfactory - respondent proves valid reason based on operational requirements - application dismissed.

Industrial Relations Act 1988 Sections 170EA, 170 EE

BOB WICKHAM V. QUALITY BAKERS AUSTRALIA trading as BUTTERCUP BAKERIES

WI 154 of 1994

Before:   Linkenbagh J.R.

Place :   Perth

Date of hearing:   12 October and 10 November 1994

IN THE INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COURT

OF AUSTRALIA  

Matter No. WI 154 of 1994

BETWEEN

Bob Wickham
  Applicant

AND

Quality Bakers
  Australia Limited
  trading as Buttercup
  Bakeries

Respondent

COURT:        LINKENBAGH J.R.

PLACE:         PERTH

DATE:            12 October and 10 November, 1994

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

This is an application pursuant to Section 170EA of the Industrial Relations Act, 1988. The applicant is a 59 year old man and was a Bread Carter at the Malaga Bakery working a regular Monday to Friday shift, commencing at 2 a.m. when his employment was terminated on 13 May, 1994. He had been in the same job for about 18 years and in May, 1994 was earning $391.75 per week, after tax, and usually did a few hours overtime. The respondent paid the applicant $10,125 on termination, being the equivalent of 26 weeks pay, and also paid his other entitlements.

The Application was filed on 27 May, 1994, and it seeks reinstatement and/or compensation. Section 170 EE (8) of the Act has the effect that the amendments to Section 170 EE which came into effect on 30 June, 1994 apply to this Application, limiting the available remedies to reinstatement, or 6 months remuneration under the terms of the relevant Award, which is the Breadcarters (Metropolitan) Award No. 35 of 1963, which is made under a law of Western Australia. The applicant argued that he should be reinstated, and that is the primary remedy available in these proceedings. Compensation should only be considered where reinstatement is, in the opinion of the Court, impracticable (Section 170 EE (2)).

The Court finds the facts as follows:

  1. From October, 1993 the respondent engaged in a review of bread delivery customers, as many were thought to be uneconomical, particularly those who purchased less than 50 units per week. By 29 April 1994 a decision was made to put off two runs, with another two to go by June, and a Supervisor who had left was not replaced.

  1. Between 7 January, 1994 and 9 May 1994 212 uneconomical customers were identified.

  1. Between July 1993 and May 1994 the number of bread round ds from the bakery reduced from 53 to 47. Three carters resigned and were not replaced and three, including the appellant, were made redundant.

  1. As a result of the reduction in the number of rounds, the remaining rounds were reorganised, and the workload on the round serviced by the applicant was increased. The respondent's supervisors doubted whether the applicant would be able to manage the increased workload…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bob Wickham v Quality Bakers Australia trading as Buttercup... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1994] IRCA 178
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Bob Wickham, a long-term employee of Quality Bakers Australia trading as Buttercup Bakeries, filed an application against his employer after being made redundant. The application was lodged under Section 170EA of the Industrial Relations Act 1988 and sought either reinstatement or compensation. Wickham, who had been working as a Bread Carter at the Malaga Bakery for approximately 18 years, was terminated on 13 May 1994, receiving a redundancy package equivalent to 26 weeks' pay. The case was heard by Linkenbagh J.R. in the Industrial Relations Court of Australia in Perth.

The primary legal issues the Court needed to decide were whether Wickham's termination was unjust and whether the redundancy process was handled appropriately. Specifically, the Court needed to assess the validity of the redundancy process, the adequacy of communication between the employer, the union, and the employees regarding the redundancy negotiations, and whether the termination was justified based on operational requirements. The Court also had to consider whether Wickham's termination was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable under the circumstances.

The Court found that the redundancy process was flawed due to inadequate communication between the union and the employees. Although the union and the employer had drafted a redundancy agreement, it was never formalised, and employees, including Wickham, were not informed of the negotiations or the impending redundancies. Despite these shortcomings, the Court concluded that the employer had a valid reason for the redundancies based on operational requirements. The Court noted that Wickham received a generous redundancy payment, equivalent to the maximum compensation the Court could have awarded. Therefore, the Court found that Wickham's termination was not harsh, unjust, or unreasonable.

As a result, the Court dismissed Wickham's application. The Court acknowledged the procedural shortcomings but ultimately upheld the employer's right to make redundancies based on operational needs. The failure of both the employer and the union to adequately communicate with the employees was noted as a significant flaw in the process, but it did not affect the validity of the employer's operational justification for the redundancies.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established