JURISDICTION : DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CIVIL
LOCATION: PERTH
CITATION: BMW AUSTRALIA FINANCE LIMITED -v- NELSON [2010] WADC 36
CORAM: STAVRIANOU DCJ
HEARD: 19, 20, 21 & 22 OCTOBER, 3 & 18 DECEMBER 2009
DELIVERED : 24 MARCH 2010
FILE NO/S: CIV 556 of 2005
BETWEEN: BMW AUSTRALIA FINANCE LIMITED (ACN 007 101 715)
Plaintiff
AND
GRAHAME BRETT NELSON
Defendant
Catchwords:
Contract - Hire purchase - Notices pursuant to Hire Purchase Act 1959, s 13(1), s 13(3) - Effect of overstatement
Contract - Hire purchase - Service of notice pursuant to s 13(1), s 13(3) of Hire Purchase Act 1959
Contract - Hire purchase - Whether owner's conduct harsh and unconscionable - Hire Purchase Act 1959, s 13, s 15, s 16, s 24
Estoppel - Promissory estoppel - General principles of promissory estoppel - Representations must be clear and unambiguous - Reliance - No estoppel
Legislation:
Hire Purchase Act 1959, s 13, s 15, s 16, s 24
Result:
Judgment for the plaintiff
Counterclaim dismissed
Representation:
Counsel:
Plaintiff: Mr R A C Cullen & Ms H K Nore
Defendant: Mr K C Staffa
Solicitors:
Plaintiff: Cullen Babington Hughes
Defendant: Staffa Lawyers
Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):
Austotel Pty Ltd v Franklins Self‑Serve PtyLtd (1989) 16 NSWLR 582
Commonwealth v Verwayen (1990) 170 CLR 394
Equipment Investments Pty Ltd v M J Dowthwaite & Co Pty Ltd (1969) 16 FLR 23
Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Kett & Ors [1993] 9 SR (WA) 65
Nelson v BMW Australia Finance Ltd [2009] WASCA 13
Waltons Stores (Interstate) Ltd v Maher (1998) 164 CLR 387
STAVRIANOU DCJ:
Introduction
In September 1999 Mr Nelson entered into a hire purchase agreement ("the agreement") under which BMW Australia Finance Limited ("BMW") financed his purchase of a new car.
BMW claims that in 2004 Mr Nelson breached his payment obligations pursuant to the agreement. It repossessed the car and sold it.
BMW claims $25,694.10 plus interest pursuant to the agreement.
Mr Nelson claims that BMW's conduct was harsh and unconscionable. He alleges that because notices given pursuant to the Hire Purchase Act 1974 were inaccurate and not properly served BMW cannot recover any amount from him. He makes numerous allegations concerning its conduct.
Mr Nelson further alleges that BMW's resale of the car did not result in the best price which could reasonably have been obtained.
Mr Nelson counterclaims for payment of all money paid by him to BMW. He also claims aggravated and exemplary damages.
The facts
In 1999 Mr Nelson decided to purchase a new car. He went to a car yard and spoke to a salesman, Mr James Denny. After agreeing price Mr Nelson was referred to Mr Dennis Smallwood to arrange finance. Mr Denny and Mr Smallwood were servants or agents of BMW.
On 21 September 1999 the agreement was signed.
Pursuant to the agreement, Mr Nelson was required to pay BMW 60 monthly instalments of $1,305.88 and a final payment of $47,000.
The total amount…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read BMW Australia Finance Limited v Nelson and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] WADC 36
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether BMW's notice to Nelson was in compliance with the statutory requirements of the Hire Purchase Act 1959, specifically under sections 13(1) and 13(3). It was also necessary to consider whether the misstatement of the arrears had any effect on the enforceability of the agreement or the rights of the parties. Additionally, the court needed to assess if there was any basis for promissory estoppel to apply in this situation.
The court found that BMW's notice to Nelson did not precisely state the arrears of instalments as required by section 13(1) of the Act, as it included collection costs and did not account for payments made by Nelson. However, the court held that this did not preclude BMW from recovering monies due under the agreement upon repossession. The court cited Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Kett & Ors [1993] 9 SR (WA) 65, where it was established that failure to serve a Third Schedule Notice does not prevent the owner from recovering monies due. Furthermore, the court noted that a breach of section 13 in relation to a Third Schedule Notice does not have any civil law consequences under the Act. The court also dismissed Nelson's claim of promissory estoppel, finding that the representations made by BMW were not clear and unambiguous, and there was no reliance by Nelson that could form the basis of an estoppel.
The court ordered that BMW was entitled to recover the outstanding amount of $1,929.26 from Nelson, along with any other sums due under the hire purchase agreement. The court further ordered that the vehicle be delivered to BMW.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
If an owner fails to serve a Third Schedule Notice the owner is not precluded from recovery of monies due under the agreement upon repossession: Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Kett & Ors [1993] 9 SR (WA) 65 at 66 per Sadleir DCJ. A breach of s 13 in relation to a Third Schedule Notice does not by any provision of the Act involve any civil law consequences. It may be wrongful to the extent that a hirer has an action for breach of statutory duty: Else‑Mitchell and Parsons, "Hire Purchase Law", 4th ed (1968) at 114. The Third Schedule to the Act requires the notice to:1.Identify the agreement.2.Advise the hirer of the owner's intention to retake possession if payment of the arrears is not made by a certain date.3.Provide a statement of the total amount payable.4.Provide a statement of the amount paid or provided by the hirer to a specified date.5.Provide a statement of the arrears under the agreement to a specified date. Mr Nelson contends that the notice did not comply with s 13(1) of the Act. He submits that the notice must precisely state the arrears of instalments and the misstatement of the arrears has deprived him of his statutory rights. It is alleged that the amount of the arrears of instalments was wrong because it exceeded the amount owed. It is further alleged that it included claims for alleged costs and fees for which no written demand had been served and was not for monies due. The notice relied upon states the arrears to 21 July 2004 to be $3,341.16. That sum included an amount of $461.90 related to collection costs and did not take account of the $650 paid on 1 July 2004 and $300 paid on 22 July 2004. Ms Lowers explained that the $300 was not taken into account in the notice because the notice had been issued at 1.10 pm and the banking was done at 3.30 pm. She did not know of the $300 when the notice was issued by her. The sum of $461.90 comprised amounts particularised as follows:23 February 2000: Dishonour fees $1.1022 December 2000: Dishonour fees $1.1022 January 2001: Dishonour fees $1.106 February 2001: Dishonour fees $10.0022 February 2001: Dishonour fees $1.1016 August 2001: Collection costs $150.008 January 2003: Dishonour fees $2.507 May 2003: Collection costs $29.507 May 2003: Collection costs $265.50Total$461.90 At the commencement of the trial BMW's claim included the sum of $461.90. Mr Nelson's case is that as there had been no written demand the claim could not succeed. Ultimately the claim was abandoned by BMW. The transaction report shows that as at 21 October 2003 the only sum outstanding was $1,305.88 (the instalment due on that date). By that date Mr Nelson had paid $461.90 which had been credited against the collection costs. BMW accepted that it had applied $461.90 paid by Mr Nelson to collection costs instead of being applied to reduce the balance of instalments. Accordingly, $1,929.26 was due as at 22 July 2004 calculated as:Amount stated in notice $3,341.16Less dishonour & collection costs $461.90Less payments not credited $950.00Balance$1,929.26