BMS v Pharmacy Board of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

BMS v Pharmacy Board of Australia [2021] QCAT 369

PARTIES: BMS

(applicant)

v

PHARMACY BOARD OF AUSTRALIA

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

OCR 017-20

MATTER TYPE:

Occupational regulation matters

DATE OF ORDERS:

21 May 2021

DATE OF REASONS:

15 November 2021

HEARING DATE/S:

20 and 21 May 2021

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Judge Allen QC, Deputy President
Assisted by:
Ms C Ashcroft
Mr M Lock
Dr G Neilson

ORDERS:

1. The decision of the Pharmacy Board of Australia on 17 December 2019, pursuant to section 178 of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law(Queensland), to impose conditions on the applicant’s registration, is set aside and substituted with a decision, pursuant to section 179(2)(a) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law(Queensland), to take no action in relation to the matter.

2. The decision of the Pharmacy Board of Australia on 5 November 2020, pursuant to section 125(5) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law(Queensland), to refuse to grant the application to remove conditions on the applicant’s registration is set aside and substituted with a decision, pursuant to section 125(5) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law(Queensland), to grant the application to remove the conditions on the applicant’s registration.

3. The decision of the Pharmacy Board of Australia on 4 February 2021, pursuant to section 126(1) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law(Queensland), to change conditions imposed on the applicant’s registration, is set aside and substituted with a decision, pursuant to section 127(2) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law(Queensland), to remove the conditions on the applicant’s registration.

4.   The Tribunal’s decisions have effect from 21 May 2021.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – HEALTH CARE PROFESSIONALS – PHARMACEUTICAL CHEMISTS – LICENSES AND REGISTRATION – where the applicant is registered as a pharmacist – where the Pharmacy Board of Australia made decisions resulting in imposition of conditions on the applicant’s registration – where the conditions were imposed after the Board formed a reasonable belief that the applicant suffered from an impairment – whether the practitioner suffers from an impairment

Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland), s 3, s 3A, s 4, s 5, s 125, s 126, s 127, s 178, s 179
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 20

Coppa v Medical Board of Australia [2014] NTSC 48
DYB v Medical Board of Australia [2019] NSWCATOD 162
George v Rockett (1990) 170 CLR 104
Mahboub v Medical Board of Australia [2020] QCAT 459
Medical Board of Australia v Wong [2015] QCAT 439

Qasim v Health Care Complaints Commission [2015] NSWCA 282

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

M Anthony of The Association of Professional Engineers, Scientists and Managers, Australia

Respondent:

L Nixon of Turks Legal

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. The applicant is a registered pharmacist.  During the period from 30 March 2017 until 4 February 2021, the Pharmacy Board of Australia (Board) made various decisions affecting the registration of the applicant and having the effect of suspending his registration for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BMS v Pharmacy Board of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QCAT 369
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of BMS v Pharmacy Board of Australia involved a pharmacist whose registration had been subject to conditions imposed by the Pharmacy Board of Australia. The Board had formed a reasonable belief that the applicant suffered from an impairment, specifically an Alcohol Use Disorder, which affected or was likely to affect their capacity to practice. The primary issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant indeed suffered from such an impairment. The case was heard and determined by the Tribunal, which decided to set aside the Board's decisions and remove all conditions on the applicant's registration.

The Tribunal considered several pieces of evidence, including the applicant's breathalyser test results which showed no alcohol consumption during the period in question, and the reports of two doctors, Dr Prior and Dr Stimming. Dr Stimming, a consultant psychiatrist, diagnosed the applicant with an Alcohol Use Disorder of Moderate Severity, a conclusion that was pivotal to the Board's decision to impose conditions on the applicant's registration. However, the Tribunal found that Dr Stimming's diagnosis was based on erroneous pathology data, which led to an incorrect conclusion. The Tribunal was also critical of the Board's failure to consider all relevant evidence, including the breathalyser test results, before making its decision.

The Tribunal's reasoning led to the conclusion that the Board's decisions were flawed and not supported by the evidence. The Tribunal set aside the Board's decisions and substituted them with decisions to remove all conditions on the applicant's registration. The Tribunal's decisions were made in accordance with the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland) and took effect from 21 May 2021. This decision highlights the importance of accurate and comprehensive evidence in health practitioner regulation matters and the need for decision-makers to consider all relevant evidence before making a decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision of the Pharmacy Board of Australia on 17 December 2019, pursuant to section 178 of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland), to impose conditions on the applicant’s registration, is set aside and substituted with a decision, pursuant to section 179(2)(a) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland), to take no action in relation to the matter.

2. The decision of the Pharmacy Board of Australia on 5 November 2020, pursuant to section 125(5) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland), to refuse to grant the application to remove conditions on the applicant’s registration is set aside and substituted with a decision, pursuant to section 125(5) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland), to grant the application to remove the conditions on the applicant’s registration.

3. The decision of the Pharmacy Board of Australia on 4 February 2021, pursuant to section 126(1) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland), to change conditions imposed on the applicant’s registration, is set aside and substituted with a decision, pursuant to section 127(2) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland), to remove the conditions on the applicant’s registration.

4. The Tribunal’s decisions have effect from 21 May 2021.

Background

Background to the litigation

At the conclusion of the hearing on 21 May 2021, the Tribunal decided to make orders setting aside the operative decisions of the Board and substituting decisions which had the effect of removing all conditions on the applicant’s registration. These are the reasons for that decision.Background The applicant first obtained registration as a pharmacist in 2009. To provide necessary context for a consideration of the application to review later decisions of the Board, it is necessary to recount the applicant’s notification history and refer to some earlier decisions of the Board which are not the subject of the application to review. In late March and early April 2016, the applicant was employed as a locum pharmacist at a pharmacy in a small rural Victorian town. On 7 April 2016, a police officer made a telephone notification to the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPRA) that during the preceding 2 to 3 weeks, he had received six complaints from persons about the applicant:(a)“he was a bit distracted/crazy/eccentric in shop”;(b)“possible smell of cannabis in the shop while he was there”;(c)two complaints of “error in dispensing medications”;(d)“medical practitioner, he stated to her how easy it was to use codeine for things it isn’t supposed to be used for (eg crushing it up)”;(e)“after hours someone heard broken glass – he said he wasn’t sure, he said he thought someone had broken in, that he hadn’t done it himself.” The police officer reported that he had introduced himself to the applicant who “seemed nervous and shaky and his sentences did not flow – seemed irrational.” On 8 April 2016, an inspector from the Victorian Pharmacy Authority made an unannounced visit to the pharmacy and an audit of controlled drugs did not reveal any discrepancies. On 16 May 2016, a response by the applicant’s legal representatives advised that the applicant denied being intoxicated at work and had not been made aware of any dispensing error at the pharmacy. On 23 June 2016, the Board decided to take no further action on the basis the notification was lacking in substance. From mid-November 2016 until early February 2017, the applicant was employed as a locum pharmacist at a pharmacy in a regional city in South Australia and residing in cabin accommodation at a cabin park. The pharmacy was one of a chain of pharmacies in South Australia and other states of Australia. On 24 February 2017, a professional services manager employed by the pharmacy chain (presumably in a national or state head office and certainly not at the pharmacy where the applicant had worked) made a complaint to AHPRA about the applicant to the following effect:(a)On 3 February 2017, the manager of the pharmacy where the applicant was employed phoned her to advise that the applicant “was unwell and may have been intoxicated” and had been sent home from work that and the previous day.(b)On 7 February 2017, she travelled to the pharmacy and [name redacted in the copy of the complaint in evidence] “mentioned a couple of times she had smelt alcohol on his breath”. The pharmacist in charge could not confirm this as due to religious reasons she has little exposure to alcohol. The pharmacist in charge mentioned that the applicant’s work had been good, and he was fine with the customers except until the previous week when she sent him home. The applicant did have some unusual ways and had some odd discussions with staff.(c)On 17 February 2017, she received an email from someone at the cabin park alleging that the applicant’s cabin contained illicit drugs, scales and at least six mobile phones and it was rumoured that he was dealing drugs whilst living there.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Board did not challenge the accuracy of breath testing logs completed by the applicant’s employer from 12 May 2020 through to 18 May 2021 recording the results of breathalyser testing of the applicant on each day he attended work. The applicant tested nil for BAC on each and every occasion. Evidence of Dr Stimming A consideration of the evidence of Dr Stimming was crucial to a determination of the application to review. Dr Stimming’s diagnoses of an Alcohol Use Disorder provided the basis for the Board’s finding of a reasonable belief as to the applicant’s impairment. Dr Stimming interviewed the applicant on 6 February 2019 and supplied a report to AHPRA dated 22 February 2019. The applicant denied any substance abuse whilst working. He said he had only smoked cannabis ten times in his life with one week in the past where he smoked more often. He denied any alcohol use since Christmas 2018. Before that he said he would drink four beers in the evening socially with friends on two nights a week. He denied any concerns with his alcohol intake. He denied any amphetamine use. He said he had used LSD once in his life, many years ago. He denied any opioid use other than prescribed analgesics after a neck injury in 2011. His history of, and treatment for, depression was discussed. Dr Stimming noted the previous notification to AHPRA in April 2016 as “complaints about his behaviour, tripping over stock and odd conversations about the ‘ease of obtaining and crushing cocaine[14]’.”[14]Repeating the same error as Dr Prior- see footnote 1. Dr Stimming noted the results of urine drug pathology briefed to her. It later transpired they included data regarding someone other than the applicant necessitating a supplementary report I will refer to later. She also noted as follows:16.3 Pathology testing of hair sample on the 20 December 2018, urine and blood samples on the 28 December 2018 did not show any substances of concern. Carbohydrate Deficient Transferrin (CDT) levels were raised suggesting exposure to alcohol but not raised high enough to indicate probable recent alcohol excess. Liver and haemopoetic [sic] results did not suggest compromised functioning from excessive alcohol use. In her summary, Dr Stimming referred, inter alia, to:(a)the examination occurring because of the applicant’s failure to comply with conditions on his registration including attending urine and hair drug testing and engaging in appropriate treatment with a medical practitioner with expertise in addiction medicine;(b)the substance of the notification on 24 February 2017; and(c)Dr Prior’s diagnosis. The rest of Dr Stimming’s summary and conclusions in her report dated 22 February 2019 was essentially unchanged in her supplementary report dated 18 July 2019, provided after she had been briefed with corrected pathology data. It is therefore convenient to move to the summary and conclusions as expressed in the latter report:7.4 In examining the Pathology results summary date 12 June 2019 (AHPRA # PD19/373894), of the urine tests submitted, most were performed mid morning and five urine tests were significantly positive for alcohol with concentrations greater than 0.05 g%. It is at these levels that there is greater cognitive dysfunction from alcohol intoxication and that the risk of driving is exponentially elevated. In addition, [the applicant] missed 22 urine tests.7.5 It is reasonable to speculate that [the applicant] may have missed some of these urine tests as he may have been still intoxicated with alcohol, or recovering from the after effects of alcohol use such as a hang over. It is also reasonable to assume that when he missed a urine test there may have been a positive or undesirable result.7.6 It is telling that at times [the applicant’s] urine was significantly positive for alcohol (> 0.05 g%) during week day mornings, suggesting that if he was working as a pharmacist at that time he may have been impaired by alcohol intoxication or the effects of alcohol from the night before.7.7 Analysis of the pathology summary for 2018 showed that his urine tests were significantly positive for alcohol, or he missed tests in nine months of the year except from February, April and July 2018, suggesting this is a chronic and long standing problem.7.8 In conclusion, taking a longitudinal approach, and examining pathology evidence it is still my opinion that [the applicant] has a physical or mental impairment, disability, condition or disorder (including substance abuse or dependence), namely Alcohol Use Disorder Moderate Severity (DSM5, 2013). It is still my opinion that his Cannabis Use Disorder is in sustained remission and that his recurrent Major Depressive disorder is currently in remission. It is also my opinion that this mental disorder of Alcohol Use Disorder would detrimentally affect or is likely to detrimentally affect his capacity to practice the profession.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 6 February 2019, the applicant underwent a health assessment by Dr Andrea Stimming, consultant psychiatrist, who diagnosed an Alcohol Use Disorder Moderate Severity that would or be likely to detrimentally affect the applicant’s capacity to practise the profession. Dr Stimming’s report dated 22 February 2019 and her supplementary report dated 18 July 2019[2] will be discussed further later in these reasons.[2]A decision of the Board on 2 May 2019 to refer the applicant to a Health Panel was rescinded on 21 June 2019 after it was discovered Dr Stimming had been erroneously briefed with pathology data relating to someone other than the applicant. Dr Stimming was briefed to provide a supplementary report based on correct data.The operative decisions of the Board On 17 December 2019, the Board, after considering submissions of the applicant regarding proposed action[3], decided to revoke the suspension of the applicant’s registration and also decided to impose conditions on the applicant’s registration pursuant to section 178 of the National Law. In its letter of 23 December 2019 advising the decision, the Board stated that it had formed a reasonable belief that the applicant had a health impairment that detrimentally affected, or was likely to detrimentally affect, the applicant’s capacity to practise his profession. The Board identified the impairment as one of Alcohol Use Disorder of Moderate Severity. The conditions imposed on the applicant’s registration provided for:(a)limitations on practice:(i) the applicant could only practise in place/s of practice approved by the Board;(ii) the applicant could not be the only pharmacist on site;(iii) the applicant could only practise between 7am and 6pm;(iv) the applicant could not exceed 24 hours of practice a week;(v) the applicant could not undertake any after hours or on-call work;(b)breath alcohol testing before and after each and every period of practice and as otherwise directed; and(c)treatment with a general practitioner and a consultant psychiatrist with expertise in addiction medicine, an addiction medicine specialist, or a medical officer in an Alcohol and Other Drugs Service. [3]In response to a letter from the Board to the applicant dated 23 October 2019 advising the applicant of a decision of the Board on 19 September 2019. On 20 January 2020, the applicant filed in the Tribunal an application to review the decision of the Board to impose conditions on his registration. On 5 November 2020, the Board decided, pursuant to section 125(5) of the National Law, to refuse the applicant’s application to the Board to remove the conditions on his registration. On 4 February 2021, the Board decided, pursuant to section 126(1) of the National Law, to change the conditions on the applicant’s registration by deleting the requirements that:(a)the applicant could only practise between 7am and 6pm;(b)the applicant could not exceed 24 hours of practice a week;(c)the applicant could not undertake any after hours or on-call work;(d)the applicant be breath tested after each period of practice; and(e)the applicant be treated by any practitioner other than a general practitioner.The law

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established