BMF v Commissioner of Victims Rights

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read


Civil and Administrative Tribunal

New South Wales

Case Name: 

BMF v Commissioner of Victims Rights

Medium Neutral Citation: 

[2016] NSWCATAD 144

Hearing Date(s): 

27 May 2016

Date of Orders:

6 July 2016

Decision Date: 

6 July 2016

Before: 

M Riordan, Senior Member

Decision: 

1. The application for administrative review with respect to financial support is dismissed.
2. The decision of the Senior Assessor dated 15 April 2016 is set aside. In substitution for that decision the following decision is made:
“The applicant is eligible for a Category C recognition payment in the sum of $5,000.”

Catchwords: 

Victims Rights and Support – administrative review – jurisdiction of the Tribunal – grievous bodily harm

Legislation Cited: 

Victims Support and Rehabilitation Act 1996
Victims Rights and Support Act 2013
Victims Rights and Support Regulation 2013
Administrative Decisions Review Act 1997

Cases Cited: 

Project Blue Sky v Australian Broadcasting Authority 194 CLR 355
R v Donovan [1934] 2 KB 498
BXB v Commissioner of Victims Rights [2015] NSWCATAD 173
BMF v Commissioner of Victims Rights [2016] NSWCATAD 54
Haoui v Regina [2008] NSWCCA 209
AM v R [2012] NSWCCA 203

Texts Cited: 

Statutory Interpretation in Australia (8th Edition, Pearce and Geddes)

Category: 

Principal judgment

Parties: 

BMF (Applicant)
Commissioner of Victims Rights (Respondent)

Representation: 

Solicitors:
Women’s Legal Services NSW (Applicant)
Victims Services (Respondent)

File Number(s): 

1610197

Publication Restriction: 

A non-publication Order is made under s 64 (1) of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (No. 2) (NSW) in respect of the names of private individuals, and other information which might identify them.

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. In these proceedings, which were commenced by an Application for Administrative Review (‘the Application”) filed on 26 February 2016, the applicant sought administrative review of a decision made by a delegate of the Respondent in respect of an Application for Victims Support that was lodged by the applicant (known by the pseudonym ‘BMF’).

  2. BMF was not legally represented in relation to her Application for Victims Support. However, she is legally represented in relation to her current Application for Administrative Review by Women’s Legal Services NSW.

  3. This Tribunal’s powers in relation to an application for administrative review are governed by s 63 of the Administrative Decisions Review Act 1997 (NSW) (“the ADR Act”), which provides:

    (1) In determining an application for an administrative review under this Act of an administratively reviewable decision, the Tribunal is to decide what the correct and preferable decision is having regard to the material then before it, including the following:

    (a)  any relevant factual material,

    (b)  any applicable written or unwritten law.

    (2)  For this purpose, the Tribunal may exercise all of the functions that are conferred or imposed by any relevant legislation on the administrator who made the decision.

    (3) In determining an application for the administrative review of an administratively reviewable decision, the Tribunal may decide:

    (a)  to affirm the administratively reviewable decision, or

    (b)  to vary the administratively reviewable decision, or

    (c)  to set aside the administratively reviewable decision and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BMF v Commissioner of Victims Rights and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWCATAD 144
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, BMF, sought an administrative review of a decision made by the Commissioner of Victims Rights, regarding eligibility for financial assistance. The dispute was heard in the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT). The primary legal issue was whether BMF was eligible for a recognition payment of $5,000 under the Victims Rights and Support Act 2013, having suffered grievous bodily harm as a result of domestic violence. The secondary issue was the appropriate compensation for various expenses claimed by BMF, such as storage fees, hotel invoices, and phone charges.

The Tribunal examined the evidence presented by BMF, which included her reliance on previous claims and submissions to establish her psychological injury and the 'eggshell psyche' doctrine. BMF argued that the delay in the decision-making process and the ongoing domestic violence had aggravated her existing distress and impacted her health and well-being. The Tribunal found that BMF was the primary victim of an act of violence, as confirmed by the Commissioner of Victims Rights, and approved a Category C recognition payment of $5,000. However, the Tribunal also found that some of the expenses claimed by BMF did not arise directly from the act of violence and were therefore not payable under the Victims Support Scheme.

The Tribunal set aside the decision of the Senior Assessor and substituted it with a new decision, which approved the recognition payment of $5,000 but denied some of the expenses claimed by BMF. The Tribunal's reasoning was based on the evidence presented and the applicable provisions of the Victims Rights and Support Act 2013 and the Victims Rights and Support Regulation. The outcome of the case was that BMF was eligible for a recognition payment of $5,000, but some of her claimed expenses were not payable under the Victims Support Scheme.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for administrative review with respect to financial support is dismissed.

2. The decision of the Senior Assessor dated 15 April 2016 is set aside. In substitution for that decision the following decision is made:

“The applicant is eligible for a Category C recognition payment in the sum of $5,000.”

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In support of the recognition payment, BMF’s solicitors submitted:…7. The Applicant also confirms her reliance on injury, as established by previous Victims Support claims before NCAT, and detailed in submissions on her behalf at the hearing of 27 May 2016, to establish her pre-existing level of psychological injury and the ‘eggshell psyche’ as applied in a finding of grievous bodily harm pursuant to the Act in the matter of BWL v Commissioner of Victims Rights [2015] NSWCATAD 235.8. While it is not advanced that (BMF’s) pregnancy to the perpetrator is (?) to the act of violence – it is a compounding circumstance arising out of their intimate relationship and domestic violence and separation that has further aggravated her existing distress at the abuse and that has had an impact on matters including her homelessness following the end of the relationship and of the perpetrators…9. The Applicant submits that there is sufficient evidence on which the Tribunal can be satisfied to the requisite standard of proof in such administrative decisions that she can establish the ‘really serious’ level of injury required to establish that she is a victim of an act of violence and eligible for a Category C payment of $5000.Further submissions and evidence submitted by BMF On 23 June 2016, BMF sent an email to the Registrar, in which she complained that her matter had been ongoing since January 2016 and that the Respondent had delayed it. She stated that she has had no place to live for the last seven months and that she had been in and out of hospital. She concluded:…I have been very patient but can’t be waiting any longer under my circumstances I need a date when the decision will be made I can’t wait any longer can the registrar email a date when matter will be finalised… On 29 June 2016, BMF wrote to the Tribunal in the following terms:My name is (BMF) and I have endured pain and suffering through this court proceeding. The long process and duration period has put a big toll to my health and this pregnancy. The domestic violence has impacted my life significantly and I am quite traumatised by this. I have made a lot of sacrifices to have this baby, especially due to my medical conditions. My ex-partner wanted me to abort this pregnancy and I believe he now wants custody (of) the baby. The hospital is doing everything to protect me and the child. My ex-partner’s father nearly pushed me over recently.This claim has been ongoing since January 2016. I have been through reviews with Victims Services and NCAT for a lengthy time. I first had a listing and then a hearing on 27 May 2016 where I ended up having an anxiety attack and ended up in hospital. It was adjourned then got postponed to 10th June 2016. My solicitor went away on holidays and then it was adjourned and submissions were given to the Tribunal. I rang to follow through the matter on 23rd June and was advised to write a letter or email. On Monday I rang and my calls were terminated by David and Mary. Then I attended the Tribunal as receptionist wouldn’t allow me to talk to the manager. On 28th June I spoke to Lilly and told her my situation and she wrote down and signed that I will be given a date when the matter will be finalised. I waited all day and called but no outcome was given. I have been in and out of hospital with complications and stress during this court matter.I am asking for a positive outcome and to finalise the matter because of my financial losses. I need financial backing to make preparations for my baby which I have been so far unable to make. Due to these circumstances please provide me with a date when the matter will be made with a decision. I need to be induced very soon as I am needing answers with a positive result…

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Application for Administrative Review was initially listed for hearing before Senior Member McAteer of this Tribunal on 8 April 2016, when the Senior Member made the following orders in relation to financial assistance:1. The matter is remitted under s 65 (1) of the Administrative Decisions Review Act 1997.2. The Commissioner of Victims Rights is to determine the matter and notify the applicant by 22 April 2016.3. If the applicant is satisfied with the Commissioner’s decision she should notify the Tribunal of this by 30 April 2016.4. The proceedings are adjourned until 27 May 2016.5. Section 58 documents and submissions are to be filed by the respondent by 13 April 2016.6. Any further material to be submitted by the applicant is to be submitted by 20 May 2016.Decision at First Instance (Financial Support) On 14 April 2016, the Respondent determined the application for financial support. The Assessor determined that BMF was the primary victim of an act of violence and approved payment of financial assistance for immediate needs in relation to storage fees of $257.00. The Notice of Decision states that cl 8 of the Victims Rights and Support Regulation (“the Regulation”) provide for financial assistance of up to $5,000, subject to proof that the expenses claimed were incurred as a direct result of the act of violence. In this matter, BMF claimed expenses totalling $9,3634.88, comprising: Storage fees ($257); Rental assistance (arrears in the sum of $2,600); Hotel invoices ($5,290.67); Room charges ($3,190); Phone charges ($1,818.45); Credit Card debt ($4,089.43); and a Transport NSW Fine ($200). In relation to the rental assistance claim, the Assessor determined that the evidence indicated that both BMF and the alleged offender were liable for the rental arrears as the lease was in both names and that by 5 January 2016 neither party lived at the property. Further, the Hospital’s clinical notes dated 5 January 2016 evidenced that BMF was:…not at risk of harm from partner, has ended relationship and partner not interested in a relationship with her or future child. The Assessor determined that rental expenses may be approved where the victim and alleged offender lived together and the applicant fled violence in order to remain safe, but that this was not the current scenario. The claim for rental assistance was therefore declined. In relation to the claim for hotel fees, the Assessor determined, relevantly:18. It is clear that at some point the applicant and the alleged offender had a professional-client relationship prior to the act of violence. Sometime after, the relationship progressed and the applicant understood that she and the alleged offender were in an intimate personal relationship.19. Ordinarily, assistance if provided to help the applicant remove themselves from the company or presence of the alleged offender. As the majority of the hotel accommodation expenses and invoices are for the provision of professional services to the alleged offender, these expenses could more appropriately be characterised as business expenses.20. In relation to the invoices for 1 and 3 November they are in the alleged offender’s name and accordingly are not payable.21. Bearing in mind that the act of violence occurred sometime in November 2015, I am mindful that the invoices dated 13, 15 and 22 November 2015 might flow from the act of violence. For this reason, these expenses are deferred pending further information from the applicant. Could the applicant explain whether she stayed on these dates with the alleged offender or whether she stayed on her own to flee the alleged offender?22. Whilst this is a difficult situation for the applicant, it is not the intention of the Victims Support Scheme to provide financial assistance for a situation where the applicant shared time with the alleged offender. Expenses that might be considered must flow from the act of violence. Accordingly, I am not able to approve some of these expenses as they do not arise as a direct result of the act of violence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established