BM Alliance Coal Operations Pty Ltd v le Roux (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

INDUSTRIAL COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

BM Alliance Coal Operations Pty Ltd v le Roux (No 2) [2024] ICQ 20

PARTIES:

BM ALLIANCE COAL OPERATIONS PTY LTD

(appellant)

v
JACQUES LE ROUX, CHIEF INSPECTOR OF COAL MINES, RESOURCES, SAFETY AND HEALTH QUEENSLAND

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

C/2023/44

C/2023/45

PROCEEDING:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

13 November 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

4 March 2024, 6 March 2024, 12 March 2024, 13 March 2024

MEMBER:

Davis J, President

ORDER:

1.   The stays ordered of each of the two directives are maintained until further order.

2.   By 4.00 pm on 20 November 2024, the appellant file and serve written submissions as to the appropriate orders on the appeal including costs.

3.   By 4.00 pm on 27 November 2024, the respondent file and serve written submissions in reply.

4.   The parties have leave to file, before 4.00 pm on 4 December 2024 an application for leave to make oral submissions on final orders.

5.   In the absence of any application the question of final orders will be determined on any written submissions received and without further oral hearing.

CATCHWORDS:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – WORK HEALTH AND SAFETY – DUTIES AND LIABILITIES – DUTIES – RISK ASSESSMENT AND SAFE SYSTEM OF WORK – where the appellant is a coal mine operator – where the appellant operates a coal mine at Peak Downs – where the coal mine is subject to lightning activity in storm season – where the appellant instigated a Trigger Action Response Plan (TARP) which prescribed actions to be taken in the event of lightning – where Level 1 conditions were lightning within 60 to 30 kilometres from the mine – where Level 2 conditions were lightning within 30 kilometres to 16 kilometres from the mine – where Level 3 conditions were lightning less than 16 kilometres from the mine – where the TARP provided for certain Heavy Mobile Equipment (HME) to continue operating notwithstanding Level 3 conditions – where the respondent is the chief inspector of Coal Mines, Resources, Safety and Health – where the respondent directed the appellant that work by certain HMEs should cease at Level 2 – where the appellant appealed the directive – where the HMEs operated as a Faraday cage in the event they were struck by lightning – whether the HMEs operated as a perfect Faraday cage – whether there were avenues of conductivity into the HME – whether there was unacceptable risk of an electrical charge affecting a mine worker in HME – where it is recognised that a lightning strike may cause tyres on a HME to burst – where it is accepted that will not occur if the tyres are filled with nitrogen – whether procedures in place to ensure nitrogen-filling are sufficient – whether there is an unacceptable risk

Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999 (Qld), s 6, s 7, s 18, s 21, s 29, s 30, s 31, s 33, s 34, s 41, s 42, s 62, s 166, s 168,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BM Alliance Coal Operations Pty Ltd v le Roux (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ICQ 20
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

BM Alliance Coal Operations Pty Ltd has appealed against a directive issued by Jacques le Roux, the chief inspector of Coal Mines, under the Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999 (CMSH Act). The directive mandates that work by certain Heavy Mobile Equipment (HME) should cease when lightning is detected within 30 kilometres of the Peak Downs Coal Mine, which is operated by BM Alliance. The appeal arises from the interpretation and application of safety standards and risk management procedures in the context of severe weather conditions at the mine, particularly concerning lightning strikes. The BM Alliance argued that the Heavy Mobile Equipment (HME) operated as a Faraday cage, effectively protecting against electrical charges from lightning strikes, and that the procedures in place ensured the tyres were filled with nitrogen, mitigating the risk of tyre explosions. The central legal issues revolved around whether the HME truly functioned as a perfect Faraday cage, whether there were any avenues of conductivity into the HME that could pose a risk to workers, and whether the procedures to ensure tyre nitrogen filling were adequate to prevent unacceptable risks. The court had to determine whether the directive issued by the chief inspector was justified under the CMSH Act, considering the safety measures already in place by BM Alliance.

The court examined the specific safety procedures and policies implemented by BM Alliance, including the Trigger Action Response Plan (TARP) and the Severe Weather Policy. It assessed the effectiveness of these measures in mitigating the risks associated with lightning strikes, particularly focusing on the Faraday cage functionality of the HME and the adequacy of tyre nitrogen filling procedures. The court also considered the statutory obligations of the chief inspector under the CMSH Act to ensure the safety of workers and the broader compliance framework in place. The analysis included a review of expert evidence and technical assessments regarding the safety mechanisms in place and their efficacy. Ultimately, the court found that while BM Alliance had implemented a comprehensive set of safety measures, there were still significant risks that warranted the intervention of the chief inspector. The directive to cease work by certain HMEs at Level 2 conditions was deemed necessary to prevent unacceptable risks to mine workers, despite the existing safety protocols.

The court upheld the directive issued by the chief inspector, maintaining that the risks identified justified the intervention. The appeal was dismissed, and the stays on the directives were maintained pending further submissions on final orders. The court ordered that written submissions be filed by both parties regarding the appropriate final orders, including costs, and allowed the possibility of oral submissions if leave was applied for. In the absence of such an application, the final orders would be determined based on the written submissions. This decision underscores the importance of stringent safety measures in high-risk environments and the role of regulatory oversight in ensuring compliance with safety standards.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The stays ordered of each of the two directives are maintained until further order.

2. By 4.00 pm on 20 November 2024, the appellant file and serve written submissions as to the appropriate orders on the appeal including costs.

3. By 4.00 pm on 27 November 2024, the respondent file and serve written submissions in reply.

4. The parties have leave to file, before 4.00 pm on 4 December 2024 an application for leave to make oral submissions on final orders.

5. In the absence of any application the question of final orders will be determined on any written submissions received and without further oral hearing.

Background

Background to the litigation

BM Alliance Coal Operations Pty Ltd (BM) appeals against a directive given by Jacques le Roux who is the chief inspector of Coal Mines, given under the provisions of the Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999 (CMSH Act).Background BM is a coal mine operator[1] which operates the Peak Downs Coal Mine situated south-east of Moranbah in the Bowen Basin. As already observed, Mr Jacques le Roux is the chief inspector of Coal Mines.[2][1] Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999, s 21.[2] Appointed pursuant to the Resources Safety and Health Queensland Act 2000. The Bowen Basin can be subject to violent electrical storms. This raises safety issues. Pursuant to its obligations under the CMSH Act, BM has:(a)appointed a Site Senior Executive (SSE) for the mine, Mr Michael Thomas;[3] and(b)ensured that the SSE has developed and implemented a Safety and Health Management System for the mine (SHMS).[4] [3] Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999, s 41(1)(d).[4] Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999, s 41(1)(e). Part of the SHMS for the Peak Downs Mine are safety procedures which apply to work being conducted during severe weather events including electrical storms and other lightning activity. The relevant safety procedures are prescribed by BM in the BMA Coal PRO Severe Weather Management (BMA-PRO-0078, Version 5.3, 3 June 2022) (the Severe Weather Policy). With the Severe Weather Policy is a Trigger Action Response Plan (TARP), which concerns actions to be taken in the event of lightning (the Lightning TARP) and a Site Severe Weather TARP (Severe Weather TARP). Both the Lightning TARP and the Severe Weather TARP operate around triggers identified as “levels”. These levels are defined by reference to the distance lightning strikes are detected from Peak Downs Mine. The levels are:(a)Level 1 - Lightning within 60-30km from Peak Downs Mine;(b)Level 2 – Lightning within 30km-16kim from Peak Downs Mine; and(c)Level 3 – Lightning less than 16km from Peak Downs Mine. What is in contention is the management during lightning activity of certain Heavy Mobile Equipment (HME) which operates on rubber tyres, as opposed to metal tracks. There are two concerns. The first is the prospect of the HME being struck by lightning and some of that electrical charge passing into a person within the vehicle. Secondly, it is common ground that a HME operating on air-filled rubber tyres is in danger if struck by lightning, as the tyres are vulnerable to explosion, leading to a loss of control of the vehicle. The answer to this problem is to fill the tyres with nitrogen rather than air which contains oxygen. This avoids the tyres exploding. Pursuant to his obligations under the CMSH Act, Mr Thomas, as the SSE, has sought to address those concerns in the Severe Weather Policy and the associated TARPs. Mr le Roux formed the view that, notwithstanding the operation of the Severe Weather Policy and the associated TARPs, risk of injury to a person[5] may reach an unacceptable level.[6] Upon forming that view, Mr le Roux gave the directives which effectively alter the operation of the Lightning TARP.[7][5] Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999, s 18; see paragraph [24] of these reasons. [6] Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999, s 29; see paragraph [26] of these reasons.[7] Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999, s 166; see paragraph [40] of these reasons.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.