BLZQ and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

BLZQ and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 2629 (17 August 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2023/1624

Re:BLZQ

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member I Thompson

Date:17 August 2023

Place:Adelaide

For the reasons set out below, the Tribunal has determined:

Pursuant to s 28(5) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act), the Tribunal declares that the statement given to the Applicant under s 28(1) of the AAT Act does not contain adequate particulars of the reasons for the decision on internal review dated 8 March 2023 pursuant to s 100(6) of the NDIS Act confirming the decision dated 8 November 2022 pursuant to s 33(2) of the NDIS Act to approve the Applicant’s NDIS plan which includes funding of $29,583.40 for 152 hours in the Improved Daily Living budget for the Applicant’s Capacity Building Supports in his NDIS plan (8 November 2022 – 8 November 2023).

Pursuant to s 28(6) of the AAT Act, within 28 days, the Respondent must give the Applicant an additional statement containing further and better particulars of the reasons for the decision with specific reference to the reasons for assessing the amount of therapy supports at 152 hours and funding of $29,583.40 for Improved Daily Living in the Applicant’s Capacity Building Supports in his NDIS plan (8 November 2022 – 8 November 2023).

.............................[Sgnd]...........................................

Member I Thompson

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEUDRE - National Disability Insurance Scheme – applicant requesting reasons for decision – adequacy of the reasons – request for declaration under s 28 (5) AAT Act granted – direction under s 28 (6) AAT Act that the respondent provide an additional statement containing further and better particulars

LEGISLATION

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member I Thompson

17 August 2023

  1. The Applicant, BLZQ, is a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) having been assessed with level 3 autism spectrum disorder and global developmental delay. He is 4 years old, and he resides with his parents. The substantive application concerns his request for increased funding for applied behavioural analysis (ABA) therapy.

  2. A directions hearing was convened to address a request on behalf of BLZQ for an expedited hearing of the review and, secondly, a declaration and a direction under s 28(5) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act) that the Respondent, the National Disability Insurance Agency (the Agency), provide adequate reasons for declining to fund BLZQ’s capacity building supports for an 18-hour weekly ABA therapy program.

  3. The request for an expedited hearing related in part to arrangements for an independent medical examination. Discussions ensued between the parties which led to the withdrawal of that request. The sole, remaining issue for the Tribunal is the request for a declaration and direction pursuant to s 28(5) of the AAT Act.

    BACKGROUND

  4. By letter dated 8 November 2022 the Agency wrote to BLZQ’s parents. Enclosed with the letter…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BLZQ and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 2629
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) concerning a dispute between BLZQ and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). The core of the dispute involved BLZQ's request for a declaration and direction under section 28 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) regarding the adequacy of the reasons provided by the NDIA for its decision on BLZQ's NDIS plan. Specifically, BLZQ sought further and better particulars concerning the funding allocated for capacity building supports.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the NDIA's statement of reasons adequately set out its findings on material questions of fact, referred to the evidence or other material on which those findings were based, and provided adequate particulars of the reasons for its decision, as required by section 28(5) of the AAT Act. The Tribunal was tasked with determining if the NDIA's explanation for the specific amount of capacity building funding, particularly the allocation of 152 hours, was sufficiently detailed and intelligible to allow BLZQ and his family to understand the rationale behind the decision.

The Tribunal found that while the NDIA's internal reviewer had referenced relevant materials and provided general explanations for the decision to affirm the capacity building funding, the reasons provided lacked the necessary specificity regarding the calculation of the 152 hours. The Tribunal noted that the provided explanations did not articulate the rationale for capping the therapeutic intervention at 152 hours, nor did they explain how this figure was derived, leaving BLZQ's family without a clear understanding of the decision-making process. The Tribunal concluded that the absence of this specific rationale rendered the reasons unintelligible in a material respect.

Consequently, the Tribunal granted BLZQ's request for a declaration that the statement of reasons was inadequate and issued a direction under section 28(6) of the AAT Act, requiring the NDIA to provide an additional statement containing further and better particulars concerning the rationale for the allocated hours of capacity building support.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The request for an expedited hearing related in part to arrangements for an independent medical examination. Discussions ensued between the parties which led to the withdrawal of that request. The sole, remaining issue for the Tribunal is the request for a declaration and direction pursuant to s 28(5) of the AAT Act.BACKGROUND By letter dated 8 November 2022 the Agency wrote to BLZQ’s parents. Enclosed with the letter was a copy of his new NDIS plan which had a commencement date of 8 November 2022, a review date of 8 November 2023, and total funded supports of $31,869.23.[1] According to that letter the plan was developed on “review” under s 48 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (NDIS Act) after new information was presented about his disability support needs. The NDIS plan includes a statement of his goals and a breakdown of the funded supports into core supports (total $800) and capacity building supports (total $31,069.23).[1] T-Documents, T14, NDIS Plan Approval dated 8 November 2022, pages 128-141. A written request was lodged on 9 February 2023 for an internal review of the original decision.[2] Within the documentation in the internal review request is a 5-page submission comprising a detailed analysis of BLZQ’s impairments, therapy and education assessments, details of allied health therapies including ABA therapy together with a request for an increase in funding for capacity building supports to $ 90,135.76 to cover the cost of an 18 hour per week ABA program. [2] T-Documents, T10, Section 100 Request (for an internal review) dated 9 February 2023, pages 91-95. The Agency wrote to BLZQ’s parents by letter dated 8 March 2023 with the outcome of the internal review.[3] The outcome was confirmation of the original decision. The request for funding of $ 90,135.76 for “early intensive behaviour intervention (EIBI)” was declined. The internal reviewer’s reasons for rejecting the request were explained in some detail. [3] T-Documents, T1A, Outcome of Internal Review Request dated 8 March 2023, pages 7-8. Having received the Agency’s internal review outcome letter, a request was made promptly by BLZQ’s solicitor, by email dated 8 March 2023 to the internal reviewer, for a statement of reasons for the decision. The email gave notice of a request under s 28(1) of the AAT Act as follows:“Pursuant to section 28 (1) Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), within 28 days, please provide a statement of reasons, noting that the Act requires the NDIA’s decision record to give adequate particulars of findings on material questions of fact; adequate reference to the evidence or other material on which those findings were based; and adequate particulars of the reasons for the decision (see s 28 (5)).The decision record you’ve provided does not meet this standard, but rather appears to comprise a set of generic (template) responses.“ In reply, the Agency’s internal reviewer wrote by letter dated 22 March 2023 to BLZQ’s parents and provided further details in explanation of its internal review decision.[4][4] Your NDIS Internal Review Decision Explained dated 22 March 2023.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal considers that the Agency’s internal reviewer set out adequate particulars of findings on material questions of fact.Section 28(5)(b) AAT Act whether the statement of reasons provides adequate reference to the evidence or other material on which those findings were based The internal reviewer made numerous references to the materials which were relied upon to justify the findings. The internal reviewer listed the sixteen documents that were reviewed. Some of those documents are concerned with the Agency’s operational guidelines and pricing arrangements. Three of the documents relate to national guidelines for developmental, early childhood and inclusion support services for children. The reports of speech pathology and psychology assessments of BLZQ were included amongst the materials reviewed. Both of the internal reviewer’s letters dated 8 March 2023 and 22 March 2023 include specific references to those materials in explanation of particular aspects of the internal review decision The Tribunal is satisfied that the statement of reasons includes adequate reference to the evidence and the material on which its findings were based. Section 28(5)(c) AAT Act whether the statement of reasons provides adequate particulars of the reasons for the decision The explanations for the decision to affirm the amount of capacity building funding can be located in both of the letters written by the internal reviewer. In the letter dated 8 March 2023 the following explanation appears: –“While the NDIS is aware that [BLZQ] needs additional assistance to increase his ability, [BLZQ] capacity building budget has funding of 152 hours ($29,583.48) for developing multidisciplinary capacity that complies with the best practice key principles (listed under Materials Reviewed, item 6). This budget can be used for therapy supports that best assist [BLZQ] to achieve his goals at the NDIS pricing arrangements (listed under Materials Reviewed, item 7) which already takes into account of travel across [BLZQ’S] environments and is inclusive of parental training as well as to up skill carers and educators.[BLZQ’S] capacity building budget can be utilised for his therapists to continue liaising by providing strategies and recommendations to his educators to further support his inclusion at kindergarten, providing [BLZQ] with comparable opportunities for social participation with his peers. The funding in the capacity building budget is to be used across the full plan period. Therefore, you need to ensure you manage the budget and set a monthly amount against [BLZQ’S] capacity building budget, to provide him with the necessary support until the plan reassessment.”[7][7] T-Documents, T1A, Outcome of Internal Review Request dated 8 March 2023, page 11. In the letter dated 22 March 2023 an explanation is provided about the rationale for the approved funding. The letter includes this passage about value for money written by the internal reviewer: –“There is a material difference in cost for these supports. The support requested is $90,135.76 and the current support, where information given indicates [BLZQ] is making positive progress, is $29,583.48. The information available to me did not differentiate how the additional support will further develop [BLZQ’s] independence or substantially improve life stage outcomes in a way that was specific to [BLZQ].”[8][8] Your NDIS Internal Review Decision Explained dated 22 March 2023, page 2.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal is satisfied that the statement of reasons includes adequate reference to the evidence and the material on which its findings were based. Section 28(5)(c) AAT Act whether the statement of reasons provides adequate particulars of the reasons for the decision The explanations for the decision to affirm the amount of capacity building funding can be located in both of the letters written by the internal reviewer. In the letter dated 8 March 2023 the following explanation appears: –“While the NDIS is aware that [BLZQ] needs additional assistance to increase his ability, [BLZQ] capacity building budget has funding of 152 hours ($29,583.48) for developing multidisciplinary capacity that complies with the best practice key principles (listed under Materials Reviewed, item 6). This budget can be used for therapy supports that best assist [BLZQ] to achieve his goals at the NDIS pricing arrangements (listed under Materials Reviewed, item 7) which already takes into account of travel across [BLZQ’S] environments and is inclusive of parental training as well as to up skill carers and educators.[BLZQ’S] capacity building budget can be utilised for his therapists to continue liaising by providing strategies and recommendations to his educators to further support his inclusion at kindergarten, providing [BLZQ] with comparable opportunities for social participation with his peers. The funding in the capacity building budget is to be used across the full plan period. Therefore, you need to ensure you manage the budget and set a monthly amount against [BLZQ’S] capacity building budget, to provide him with the necessary support until the plan reassessment.”[7][7] T-Documents, T1A, Outcome of Internal Review Request dated 8 March 2023, page 11. In the letter dated 22 March 2023 an explanation is provided about the rationale for the approved funding. The letter includes this passage about value for money written by the internal reviewer: –“There is a material difference in cost for these supports. The support requested is $90,135.76 and the current support, where information given indicates [BLZQ] is making positive progress, is $29,583.48. The information available to me did not differentiate how the additional support will further develop [BLZQ’s] independence or substantially improve life stage outcomes in a way that was specific to [BLZQ].”[8][8] Your NDIS Internal Review Decision Explained dated 22 March 2023, page 2. The problem with these explanations is the lack of specific rationale for fixing the number of hours of therapy at 152. The explanations do not provide the clarity which should be available to enable an understanding of why the therapies and interventions are set and capped at 152 hours. The explanations identify materials which the internal reviewer relied upon. They address BLZQ’s personal circumstances, goals and progress, the involvement of his family, the involvement of other service systems, they identify a rationale for various best practice interventions applicable in early childhood supports and early behavioural interventions. They address criteria in s 34(1)(c), (d), (e), & (f) of the NDIS Act. Nowhere, however, do they indicate and explain why funding is allocated for 152 hours as opposed to, for example, 120 hours or 180 hours, or some other number of hours. The figure of 152 hours has no context and no explanation. BLZQ’s family is left none the wiser about the rationale for setting the maximum number of hours at 152. The rationale is not to be found in the correspondence. All that can be discerned is that the requested amount of 18 hours per week is considered excessive, and that the current amount of therapy at 9 hours per week is considered excessive. What cannot be discerned is the reasoning process to justify slightly less than 3 hours per week of therapeutic intervention. There is an assertion that funding for 152 hours accords with best practice key principles set out in National Guidelines, Best Practice in Early Childhood Intervention, ECIA National Guidelines-Best Practice in ECI by ECIA (listed by the internal reviewer under Materials Reviewed, item 6 ). Those guidelines provide “universal principles” about early childhood early intervention. They do not drill down into specific detail about specific hours for an individual child. The way in which the number of hours was calculated for BLZQ is highly material to understanding the reasons for the decision. Otherwise, those reasons are not intelligible.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Agency also noted that it filed a statement of issues prior to the commencement of the alternative dispute resolution process in the Tribunal and that statement should be of assistance in providing understanding of the reasons for the reviewable decision. CONSIDERATION The Agency’s original decision is the decision dated 8 November 2022 pursuant to s 33 (2) of the NDIS Act to approve the statement of participant supports in BLZQ’s NDIS commencing on 8 November 2022. The funding for capacity building supports comprises $31,069.23 of which $29,583.48 is allocated for “improved daily living”with the explanation written in the plan that:“This funding is for capacity building - early childhood supports. To achieve the best outcomes it is important that these supports are delivered within the home and community by early childhood professionals. These professionals should have a Bachelors degree or higher and have registration or membership with relevant professional bodies, such as an occupational therapist, speech pathologist, physiotherapist, psychologist, social worker, early childhood teacher and developmental educator.Professionals should use a best practice model, all working together as a team with your family to pursue your goals for [BLZQ] and preferably using a key worker model. It is expected the supports are delivered in line with the NDIS Commissions NDIS Practice Standards and Quality Indicators for Early Childhood Supports, the NDIS Code of Conduct and the NDIS Pricing Arrangement and Price Limits.”[6][6] T-Documents, T14, NDIS Plan Approval dated 8 November 2022, page 140. Section 33 (3) of the NDIS Act states that the supports that will be funded or provided under the NDIS “may be specifically identified in the plan or described generally, whether by reference to a specified purpose or otherwise”. The description for the “improved daily living” component in BLZQ’s plan is a general description of the nature and purpose of the approved supports. The funding is for capacity building in early childhood supports with a general reference to the qualifications of the practitioners providing the support and a brief, broad description of the standards and model of practice to be applied. It does not purport to identify the particular supports with specificity, and it is not required to do so. The plan includes substantial details about BLZQ’s plan goals and supports which might be provided to him in pursuing and achieving those goals. Section 28 (1) of the AAT Act states:“Request for statement of reasons Subject to subsection (1AAA), if a person makes a decision in respect of which an application may be made to the Tribunal for a review, any person (in this section referred to as the applicant) who is entitled to apply to the Tribunal for a review of the decision may, by notice in writing given to the person who made the decision, request that person to give to the applicant a statement in writing setting out the findings on material questions of fact, referring to the evidence or other material on which those findings were based and giving the reasons for the decision, and the person who made the decision shall, as soon as practicable but in any case within 28 days after receiving the request, prepare, and give to the applicant, such a statement. “