BLUE & WHITE BARRA PTY LTD v SOLLEY
[2001] SASC 194Full Court: Perry, Williams and Martin JJ
PERRY J. The appellant was the plaintiff in proceedings in the District Court in which it sued the respondent to the appeal, Robert James Solley for damages for negligence.
At the relevant time, the appellant was the owner of a fish farm which it conducted in a large shed at Murray Bridge. On 9 May 1998 a fire occurred which substantially damaged the shed and the equipment in it associated with the fish farming operation. It was common ground at the trial, and the learned trial judge so found, that the fire began in an electrical switchboard.
The respondent is, and was at the time, an electrician carrying on business at Murray Bridge under the name “Robert Solley Electrical”. When the fish farm was established by the appellant, the respondent performed all the electrical work, including the installation of the switchboard and the wiring associated with the conversion of the premises, which had previously been used for other purposes. Subsequently, on the instructions of the appellant, the respondent modified some of the electrical installation, and from time to time attended to maintenance work. No other electrician performed any electrical work in the premises once they had been converted for use as a fish farm.
Although the precise cause of the fire remains unknown, the appellant contended that on the balance of probabilities it must have been occasioned by faulty electrical work performed by the respondent.
The learned trial judge upheld the respondent’s defence of the proceedings and dismissed the appellant’s claim. In case his finding as to liability was disturbed on appeal, notwithstanding his dismissal of the claim, the learned trial judge proceeded to assess damages.
The appellant appeals against the learned trial judge’s findings on the issue of liability and also as to the assessment of damages. The respondent cross-appeals on the issue of damages alone.
In order to understand the arguments raised on the appeal, it is necessary to explain the manner in which the fish farm was set up, more particularly the nature of the electrical work performed by the respondent.
The appellant company was incorporated in 1996 by Maxwell White and Preston Nourse, both of whom became directors of the company.
Mr White had experience as a builder and manufacturer. He was described by the learned trial judge as a “practical, hands-on man”. When he perceived what he thought to be an opening for the development of an aquaculture business for the farming of barramundi, he persuaded Mr Nourse to invest much of the initial capital. On the evidence, it appears that of the two directors it was Mr White who had most to do with the physical setting up of the business and the management of its operation.
In 1996, the appellant leased the shed at Murray Bridge in which the business was established. Previously it had been used as a poultry shed.
To adapt it for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Blue & White Barra Pty Ltd v Solley No. Scciv-00-1034 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] SASC 194
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the evidence surrounding the electrical installation performed by the respondent, which included the installation of two switchboards, wiring for heaters and pumps, and the installation of a diesel generator. The evidence suggested that the fire began in switchboard “A”, but the precise cause of the fire remained unknown. The appellant argued that the fire was caused by faulty electrical work performed by the respondent, while the respondent denied any fault on his part.
The court found that the respondent was not at fault in relation to the selection of materials, design, or layout of the electrical work performed. The court also found that the respondent’s account of an incident on April 28, 1998, was more credible than the appellant’s account, and therefore did not find that the respondent was at fault for any actions taken on that day.
The court considered the possible causes of the fire, including ingress of pollution, ageing of insulation, damage by rodents and vermin, corrosion, component fatigue or breakage, and overheating due to loose connections, contact wear, pollution, overloading, or lack of ventilation. The court found that none of the possible causes could be identified as more likely than another, and that it was not possible to deduce, as a matter of common knowledge, that the fire was caused by some wiring defect due to negligence on the part of the respondent.
The court also considered the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur, but found that the occurrence of the fire was outside the experience of a lay person and that the evidence did not establish that such an occurrence ordinarily does not occur without negligence. The court concluded that the principle of res ipsa loquitur was inapplicable in this case.
The Full Court dismissed the appeal and cross-appeal, upholding the trial judge’s decision that the appellant had not made out its case on liability. The court found that the evidence fell short of identifying a cause attributable to fault on the part of the respondent that was more likely than other possible causes, at least one of which would not have involved fault on his part. The court did not consider it necessary to deal with the appeal and cross-appeal on the question of damages.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: PERRY J, MARTIN J