Blue Sky Private Equity Limited v Crawford Giles Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

BLUE SKY PRIVATE EQUITY LIMITED v CRAWFORD GILES PTY LTD & ORS

[2012] SASC 28

Reasons for Decision of The Honourable Justice Gray

29 February 2012

EQUITY - TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES - APPLICATIONS TO COURT FOR ADVICE AND AUTHORITY - PETITION OR SUMMONS FOR ADVICE - GENERALLY

EQUITY - TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES - APPLICATIONS TO COURT FOR ADVICE AND AUTHORITY - PETITION OR SUMMONS FOR ADVICE - PARTICULAR CASES

Trustee of a unit trust seeks declarations, directions and advices from the Court with respect to questions that have arisen in the conduct and management of the trust - where declarations, directions and advices sought relate to the conduct of the former trustee and whether that trustee had validly declared a distribution and further whether there had been any valid redemption or partial redemption of units - advice sought as to how the current trustee is to proceed.

Held: declarations, advices and answers given.

Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 206(1); Trustee Act 1936 (SA) s 90, s 91 and s 92; Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA) s 69; Trustee Act 1925 (NSW) s 63, referred to.
Macedonian Orthodox Community Church St Petka Inc v His Eminence Petar Diocesan Bishop of Macedonian Orthodox Diocese of Australia and New Zealand (2008) 237 CLR 66; Re Magarey Farlam Lawyers Trust Accounts (No 3) (2007) 96 SASR 337; David Securities Pty Ltd v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1992) 175 CLR 353; Pavey & Matthews Pty Ltd v Paul (1987) 162 CLR 221; Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation (1988) 164 CLR 662; Strang v Owens (1925) 42 WN (NSW) 183; In re Diplock [1948] Ch 465; Ministry of Health v Simpson [1951] AC 251; In re Musgrave [1916] 2 Ch 417; Youyang Pty Ltd v Minter Ellison Morris Fletcher (2003) 212 CLR 484; Farrow Finance Co Ltd (in liq) v ANZ Executors & Trustee Co Ltd (1997) 23 ACSR 521; Re Magarey Farlam Lawyers Trust Accounts (2007) 99 SASR 40; Hughes v NM Superannuation Pty Ltd (1993) 29 NSWLR 653, considered.

BLUE SKY PRIVATE EQUITY LIMITED v CRAWFORD GILES PTY LTD & ORS
[2012] SASC 28

Civil

GRAY J.

  1. In this proceeding the plaintiff, Blue Sky Private Equity Ltd, the trustee of a unit trust, the Professional Capital Investments Equities Trust, seeks declarations, directions and advices pursuant to sections 90, 91 and 92 of the Trustee Act 1936 (SA)[1] and the inherent jurisdiction of the Court with respect to questions that have arisen in the conduct and management of the Trust.

    [1]    See also Rule 206(1) of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA).

  2. Crawford Giles Pty Ltd as trustee of the Runamuck Superannuation Fund, Julie Giles as trustee of 4 Iron Enterprises Trust and David Giles are unitholders in the Trust.  They are described together as the Giles Group in these reasons.  They are interested parties who have appeared…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Blue Sky Private Equity Limited v Crawford Giles Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASC 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Blue Sky Private Equity Limited, as trustee of the Professional Capital Investments Trust, filed an application to the court seeking declarations, directions, and advice regarding the conduct and management of the trust. The former trustee, PCI Equity Pty Ltd, had been placed in liquidation, and Blue Sky was appointed as the new trustee by the Supreme Court of South Australia. The application primarily sought clarification on whether the former trustee had validly declared a distribution and whether there had been any valid redemption or partial redemption of units within the trust.

The central legal issue was whether the former trustee, PCI Equity, had correctly declared a distribution and whether the redemption or partial redemption of units had been validly executed. This involved interpreting the trust's constitution, particularly the clauses related to the redemption of units and the manager's obligations. The court needed to ascertain if the actions taken by the former trustee complied with the trust deed and if the new trustee, Blue Sky, was correctly positioned to proceed with the trust's administration.

The court examined the constitution of the trust and the specific clauses governing the redemption of units. It concluded that the former trustee's actions regarding the redemption of units were in line with the trust deed, as long as certain conditions were met, such as the value of units and the manager's discretion in specific circumstances. The court provided detailed directions on how Blue Sky should proceed with the trust's management, including the preparation of necessary documents and the handling of redemption requests. Additionally, the court ordered that the costs of the application be borne by the trust fund, as it was deemed appropriate for all parties to contribute.

In summary, the court provided the necessary declarations and advice to Blue Sky, ensuring that the trust could be properly managed going forward. The directions given were intended to clarify the trust's administration and facilitate the orderly handling of unit redemptions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Before coming to discuss the advice and directions sought, it is necessary to trace the general history of the matter. Background The Professional Capital Investments Trust was established and governed by a constitution dated July 2005. The former trustee and manager of the trust was PCI Equity Pty Ltd. That company is now in liquidation. On 31 March 2009, Blue Sky was appointed as trustee of the trust by order of the Supreme Court of South Australia. PCI Equity, the former trustee, was newly incorporated for the purpose of acting as trustee of the trust. Its initial directors were Nick Barbato and Kevin Chin. Mr Chin resigned as the director on 31 August 2006. Mr Barbato continued thereafter as sole director until PCI Equity was placed in liquidation. The constitution contained provision for a custodian. The role of the custodian, Australian Equity Trustee Ltd, was to receive all investment monies, to hold the assets of the fund and to distribute income. Mr Barbato terminated the role of the custodian in December 2007. The Australian Financial Services licence of PCI Equity was restricted to provision of financial advice and dealings in financial products with wholesale investors. It was a condition of the licence that PCI Equity hold a minimum of $50,000.00 in surplus liquid funds. An information memorandum was used to promote the trust. This memorandum set out an investment strategy and investment criteria whereby the trust would invest in five to 12 Australian Securities Exchange listed Australian companies and two to three private Australian companies, would invest no more than 15 per cent of the portfolio in one company and would retain a minimum of between five and ten per cent of the portfolio in cash. The constitution serves as the trust deed of the trust. The trust is a fixed unit trust. There are no different rights attaching to units in the trust. All units rank equally and are of equal value. The constitution provided for the appointment of a fund administrator. MacKenzie Coultas Funds Administration were appointed as fund administrator on 31 May 2005. The role of the administrator included maintaining a register of unitholders, processing redemption requests and preparing unit price calculations. The Australian Securities Investments Commission began investigating PCI Equity for purported breaches of its Australian Financial Services licence and of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). In June 2007, following the investigation, PCI Equity provided an enforceable undertaking to the Commission. Thereafter PCI Equity continued to operate under the enforceable undertaking until it was replaced as trustee by the plaintiff, Blue Sky. The enforceable undertaking required PCI Equity to prepare and circulate a second information memorandum setting out the trust’s investments as at the date of the memorandum, setting out how the unit price would be calculated once per week, stating that the fund had limited liquidity and informing all unitholders that they should have the intention to invest in the fund for a period of at least five years.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GRAY J
Counsel for the Giles Group also drew the Court’s attention to the reasons of Sheller JA in the Full Court of the New South Wales Supreme Court in Hughes v NM Superannuation Pty Ltd, where his Honour observed:[46] …It is I think well-established that, where the terms of a trust document in the context of events which have happened reasonably lead to a trustee to seek administrative advice from the Court as to its meaning and how it should be administered, all parties properly joined should have their appropriate costs out of the Fund.[46] Hughes v NM Superannuation Pty Ltd (1993) 29 NSWLR 653, 671. Conclusion I make the declarations, answer the questions raised, give advice and directions and make orders as to costs as set out in these reasons. I direct that the trustee prepare minutes of order to give effect to the foregoing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GRAY J

Clause 10 of the constitution concerns redemption of units, and relevantly provides:10 Redemption of Units10.1 Manager Will Repurchase or Redeem UnitsSubject to the succeeding provisions of this clause 10, the Manager hereby convenants that it will during the continuance of the Trust at the rerquest of a Unitholder repurchase from such Unitholder, or at the option of the Manager cause the redemption of, the Units to which such request relates at the Repurchase Price calculated in accordance with the provisions of this Constitution provided that:(a) the Manager may in its sole discretion refuse to repurchase or cause to be redeemed Units in the Trust to a value of less than the Minimum Withdrawal unless the aggregate Unit Value of the total number of Units in the Trust held by the requesting Unitholder is less than the Minimum Unitholding and the request relates to all of the Units held;(b) where the repurchase or redemption pursuant to a request by a Unitholder would result in the value of the total number of Units held by that Unitholder being less than the Minimum Unitholding the Manager shall be entitled without request from the Unitholder to repurchase or cause to be redeemed the balance of the Units in the Trust held by the Unitholder; and(c) the Manager may in its sole discretion for a period of no more than 60 days or such longer period as the Manager considers reasonable refuse to repurchase or cause to be redeemed Units where such repurchase or redemption within that period would result in the Manager or the Trust having insufficient funds or such repurchase or redemption would otherwise prejudice the interests of the remaining Unitholders.10.2 Manner of Request(a)The Withdrawal Request shall specify the number or dollar amount and Units required to be redeemed or repurchased and shall be made in any one of the following ways:(1)In writing in such form as from time to time is prescribed by the Manager and delivered to any office of the Manager or any other place agreed to in writing by the Manager;(2)In such other manner as is from time to time prescribed by the Manager.(b) A Withdrawal Request may not be withdrawn or revoked except with the written approval of the Manager.10.3Receipt of NoticeThe Units comprised in the Withdrawal Request shall be repurchased by the Manager or at the option of the Manager caused to be redeemed not later than sixty days following receipt of the Withdrawal Request (which shall be the time of actual receipt of the Withdrawal Request is received before 12.00 noon on a Business Day, or the commencement of business on the next following Business Day if received on a day which is not a Business Day or after 12.00 noon on a Business Day) provided that if the cheque for the Subscription has not been honoured and the proceeds of that cheque have not been received, the Managermay [sic], notwithstanding clause 10.1 and 10.2, at its sole discretion refuse to repurchase, cause a redemption or redeem (as the case may be) or distribute income in relation to those Units until the Business Day following the day upon which such cheque is honoured by the Bank on which it was drawn and the proceeds of that cheque received.10.4 Proceeds of Repurchase or Redemption(a) Subject to the provisions of clause 10.5, on repurchase or redemption (as the case may be) the Manager shall in respect of each Unit comprised in the Withdrawal Request pay or cause to be paid to the Unitholder an amount equal to the Repurchase Price applicable to the Unit as at the time the Manager next calculates the Net Assets following receipt by the Manager of the Withdrawal Request.(b) If there is any undistributed income entitlement of the Unitholder standing to the credit of the Unitholder in the Accounts (that is, a distribution to be made under clause 8.2(a) or 8.2(b) but not yet paid under clause 8.2(c)) in respect of the Units comprised in the Withdrawal Request, such entitlement shall remain credited to the Unitholder and be distributed to the Unitholder in accordance with the provisions of this Constitution notwithstanding that the Unitholder has ceased to be the holder of the relevant Units.(c) The Manager shall be entitled to deduct from the moneys payable to the Unitholder in accordance with clause 10.4(a) and clause 10.4(b) any fees or other moneys unpaid by the Unitholder in their capacity as Unitholder to the Manager and the total amount to be paid to the Unitholder for all the Units specified in the Withdrawal Request shall be rounded downward to the nearest cent.10.5Repurchase or Redemption(a) Where the Units specified in the Withdrawal Request are being repurchased, the Manager shall pay to the Unitholder the moneys referred to in clause 10.4 out of the Manager’s own funds.(b) Where the Units specified in the Withdrawal Request are being redeemed, the Manager shall:(1)pay (or cause to be paid) to the Unitholder (or to the Manager for the account of the Unitholder on the terms of clause 10.5(f) all or part of the moneys referred to in clause 10.4 out of the Net Assets of the Trust (or if there shall be any unpaid fees or other moneys owed by the Unitholder to the Manager to pay those moneys to the Manager for its own benefit and the balance to the Unitholder or to the Manager for the account of the Unitholder on the terms of clause 10.5(f)) and the Manager shall ensure that a sufficient amount of the Assets are available in Cash to enable such payment to be made; and/or(2)distribute (or cause to be distributed) to the Unitholder or to hold on behalf of the Unitholder such Assets as the Manager shall specify having a value (ascertained in accordance with clause 17) equivalent to the moneys referred to in clause 10.4 or the balance of such moneys where a payment is also made in accordance with clause 10.5(b)(1) (less the amount of any unpaid fees or other moneys owed by the Unitholder to the Manager, which shall be paid to the Manager in Cash) in such manner as the Manager determines.and the Manager shall use reasonable endeavours to ensure that after such redemption the Trust will retain sufficient Assets to meet any commitments of the Trust.(c) Upon receiving a direction in accordance with clause 10.5(b), the Custodian shall pay to the Unitholder (or to the Manager for the account of the Unitholder, where applicable) the moneys referred to in clause 10.4 having, if necessary, realised such of the Assets as have been for the purpose specified in writing by the Manager, distribute to the Unitholder the Assets specified by the Manager or hold the Assets specified by the Manager for the benefit of the Unitholder (as the case requires).(d) If the moneys paid or Assets distributed to the Unitholder shall have been furnished from the Net Assets pursuant to clause 10.5(b), redemption of the Units is effective on the day when payment of such moneys is deemed by clause 22.2(b) to have been made or the Assets are so distributed, and the Units shall not be released, but this shall not restrict the right of the Manager to create additional and/or to issue further Units of the Trust.(e) If the moneys paid to the Unitholder shall have been provided wholly out of the funds of the Manager pursuant to clause 10.5(a), repurchase of the Units in respect of which the moneys so provided have been paid is effective on the day when payment of such moneys is deemed by clause 22.2(b) to have been made, and the Manager shall be entitled to the benefit of the Units and may at any time thereafter resell each of such Units in accordance with the terms of this Constitution.(f) Where the Custodian pays all or part of the moneys referred to in clause 10.4 to the Manager for the account of the Unitholders pursuant to clause 10.5(b)(1) out of the Net Assets, the Manager shall hold such moneys exclusively for the benefit of the respective Unitholders entitled to such moneys and shall remit those moneys to the Unitholders as soon as practicable, (but in any event not later than the expiration of the period referred to in clause 10.3).10.6Entry in RegisterOn repurchase or redemption the Manager shall make an appropriate entry in the Register specifying the number of Units in the Trust which have been repurchased or redeemed.10.7Redemption of Units Held by Manager(a)Notwithstanding that the Manager has repurchased any Units itself, the Manager shall be entitled at all times and from time to time to request that redemption of Units to the benefit of which it is entitled by virtue of the provisions of this Constitution.(b)The provisions of this clause 10 shall apply so far as they are applicable and unless otherwise provided elsewhere in this Constitution in respect of all or any of the Units held by the Manager in respect of which a redemption request is made.10.8Suspension of Obligation to RepurchaseThe obligations of the Manager to repurchase or redeem Units in the Trust from a Unitholder pursuant to the preceding provisions of this Constitution relating to or howsoever concerning the repurchase or redemption of Units from Unitholders shall be suspended if the Trust shall be terminated provided that notwithstanding termination of the Trust the Manager shall be obliged to redeem or repurchase Units where the request for redemption or repurchase shall have been received prior to the date of termination of the Trust.Declarations