Blue Sky Private Equity Limited (Trustee) v PCI Equity Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Blue Sky Private Equity Limited (Trustee) v PCI Equity Pty Limited
[2010] FCA 1270

Citation: Blue Sky Private Equity Limited (Trustee) v PCI Equity Pty Limited [2010] FCA 1270
Parties: BLUE SKY PRIVATE EQUITY LIMITED ACN 125 223 958 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE PROFESSIONAL CAPITAL INVESTMENTS EQUITIES TRUST v PCI EQUITY PTY LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 112 529 227, NICOLA BARBATO, MACKENZIE COULTAS FUNDS ADMINISTRATION PTY LTD ACN 112 760 095 and AMERICAN HOME ASSURANCE COMPANY ABN 67 007 483 267
File number: SAD 86 of 2010
Judge: MANSFIELD J
Date of judgment: 19 November 2010
Date of hearing: Heard on the papers
Date of last submissions: 3 November 2010
Place: Adelaide
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: No catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 41
Counsel for the Plaintiff: B Roberts
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Kain C + C
Counsel for the Third Defendant: MF Blue QC
Solicitor for the Third Defendant: Gilchrist Connell

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

SAD 86 of 2010

BETWEEN:

BLUE SKY PRIVATE EQUITY LIMITED ACN 125 223 958 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE PROFESSIONAL CAPITAL INVESTMENTS EQUITIES TRUST
Plaintiff

AND:

PCI EQUITY PTY LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 112 529 227
First Defendant

NICOLA BARBATO
Second Defendant

MACKENZIE COULTAS FUNDS ADMINISTRATION PTY LTD ACN 112 760 095
Third Defendant

AMERICAN HOME ASSURANCE COMPANY ABN 67 007 483 267
Fourth Defendant

JUDGE:

MANSFIELD J

DATE OF ORDER:

19 NOVEMBER 2010

WHERE MADE:

ADELAIDE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.   Subject to order 2 herein, the third defendant’s application to strike out certain paragraphs of the plaintiff’s amended statement of claim be dismissed.

2.   The plaintiff is given leave to file and serve a further amended statement of claim in terms of its present amended statement of claim but incorporating:

2.1the proposed amendments in the terms provided in the document entitled ‘Plaintiff’s Proposed Amendments to its Amended Statement of Claim’ filed 20 October 2010;

2.2amendments to paragraphs [94.2.1] and or [79.4] specifying which clause of the Constitution dated 1 July 2005 it claims has been breached with respect to appointing an approved valuer;

2.3amendments to paragraph [94.2.3] specifying which regulations it claims have been breached;

2.4amendments to paragraph [98] specifying which sections of Part 7.8 Division 2 Subdivision A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) it claims have been breached and specifying how the third defendant is a responsible entity within the meaning of ASIC Regulatory Guide 133.4

3.   There be no order for costs of the application.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

SAD 86 of 2010

BETWEEN:

BLUE SKY PRIVATE EQUITY LIMITED ACN 125 223 958 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE PROFESSIONAL CAPITAL INVESTMENTS EQUITIES TRUST
Plaintiff

AND:

PCI EQUITY PTY LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 112 529 227
First Defendant

NICOLA BARBATO
Second…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Blue Sky Private Equity Limited (Trustee) v PCI Equity Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 1270
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Blue Sky Private Equity Limited (Trustee), the plaintiff, filed a claim against PCI Equity Pty Limited, the first defendant, and others, in the Federal Court of Australia. The plaintiff alleges that the first defendant breached the Constitution, the Act, and the Regulations, and committed a breach of trust in two specific transactions. The plaintiff also alleges that the third defendant breached an Agreement in implementing the redemption of units and the payment to the investor on behalf of the first defendant, as both transactions were contrary to the requirements of the Constitution and the Act. The defendants moved to strike out the plaintiff's statement of claim, arguing that it was not adequately pleaded. The legal issues for the court to decide were whether the plaintiff's statement of claim was sufficient and whether the court should strike out the statement of claim or any part of it.

The court considered the principles to be applied in considering the third defendant’s motion. The court noted that it should proceed with caution before striking out a statement of claim, or any part of it, and that the function of pleadings is to state with sufficient clarity the case that must be met. The court also noted that the third defendant contended that the statement of claim was flawed because it did not plead material facts which would constitute a breach or breaches by it of a specific term or terms of the Agreement. The court found that the statement of claim did not provide sufficient details to support the allegations against the third defendant, and that the plaintiff had not pleaded that the third defendant was responsible for the correctness of the valuation for the purposes of the redemption. The court also found that the statement of claim did not identify which provisions of the Constitution or the Act were breached by the third defendant or how.

The court held that the statement of claim was not adequately pleaded and that the third defendant's motion to strike out the statement of claim should be granted. The court ordered that the plaintiff's statement of claim be struck out in its entirety.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In summary, with respect to both of these transactions, it is alleged that the first defendant breached the Constitution, the Act, the Regulations, and committed a breach of trust. Further it is alleged that the third defendant breached the Agreement in implementing the redemption of the Christie units at the value paid and by implementing the payment to the investor on behalf of the first defendant, as both transactions were contrary to the requirements of the Constitution and the Act. CONSIDERATION There is no issue about the principles to be applied in considering the third defendant’s motion. The Court should proceed with caution before striking out a statement of claim, or any part of it: Murex Diagnositics Australia Pty Limited v Chiron Corporation (1995) 55 FCR 194. In Banque Commerciale SA, En Liquidation v Akhil Holdings Limited (1990) 169 CLR 279 at 286, Mason CJ and Gaudron J said:The function of pleadings is to state with sufficient clarity the case that must be met. In this way, pleadings serve to ensure the basic requirement of procedural fairness that a party should have the opportunity of meeting the case against him or her and, incidentally, to define the issues for decision. (Reference omitted.)Weinberg J in McKellar v Container Terminal Management Services Ltd (1999) 165 ALR 409 at 417-421 has considered the terms of O 11 of the FC Rules and usefully discussed a number of decisions dealing with O 11. I respectfully adopt his Honour’s observations. Consequently, in considering the adequacy of the pleadings, the Court will adopt a sensible and robust approach. Paragraph [94] in essence contains two main allegations. The first allegation is that the third defendant was in breach of the Agreement as, while administering the Trust, the redemption payment was made without a valuation in conformity with the Constitution, and specifically the unit price calculation undertaken by the third defendant which was contrary to the requirements of the Constitution. The proposed amendments provide particulars that, had the unit price calculation been undertaken in accordance with the Constitution, the carrying value of the Firewire investment should have been reduced by $3,820,659 or 23 cents per unit before the redemption was paid, as particularised in the expert report of Mark Vartuli dated 30 September 2010. The second allegation is that the third defendant was in breach of the Agreement as it failed to inform the second defendant in writing, as required by clause 8.2 of the Agreement, that the payment of the redemption amount to Christie was without a valuation in breach of the Constitution and the Act. The third defendant contends that [94] is flawed because it really complains that the first defendant was responsible for the valuation of the net assets of the Trust, and that the plaintiff has not anywhere pleaded that the third defendant was responsible for the correctness of that valuation for the purposes of the redemption. It further complains that [94] does not plead material facts which would constitute a breach or breaches by it of a specific term or terms of the Agreement. It raises the following particular complaints in relation to each sub-paragraph of [94] and the sub-paragraphs cross-referenced therein:·[94.1.1] and [94.1.2] do not correlate with the contractual obligations pleaded in respect of the clauses identified in [94.1.3], namely 5.2, 5.3(e) and 5.3(m); and that those sub-paragraphs do not plead that third defendant was obligated to obtain a valuation from an approved valuer prior to paying out a redemption, or how it was required under the Constitution to prepare a unit price calculation or how the price was calculated contrary to the Constitution;·[94.2.1] and [79.4] do not plead any obligation to appoint an approved valuer, and [94.2.1] and [79.8] do not plead how unit holders were treated unequally and unfairly or how the first defendant did not exercise its powers in the best interests of the Trust; ·[94.2.2] and [82.1] do not plead how the first defendant acted dishonestly, unfairly or had inadequate resources or was incompetent;·[94.2.3] does not plead how the redemption was in breach of s 993C of the Act; ·[94.3] does not identify what provision of the Constitution was breached by the third defendant or how;·[94.4] does not identify which of the 11 requirements of s 912A of the Act was breached by the third defendant or how;·[94.5] does not identify which of the 6 obligations imposed by reg 7.8.02(1) of the Regulations was breached by the third defendant or how;·[94.6] to [94.8] are irrelevant because there is no plea of an obligation imposed by clauses 6.3(i), 6.1(a) or 6(c); and·[94.9] and [94.10] do not plead how the third defendant acted negligently.