BLSL and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

BLSL and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) [2018] AATA 3681 (2 October 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/3963

Re:BLSL

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:R Cameron, Senior Member

Date:2 October 2018

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision of the respondent’s delegate dated 28 June 2018 refusing an application by the Applicant for a Protection (Class XA) visa.

..................................

Senior Member

Catchwords

IMMIGRATION – decision refusing to grant protection visa – decision refused on character grounds – where applicant owed international non-refoulement obligations – decision affirmed

Legislation

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 197C, 198, 501

Road Safety Act1986 (Vic)

Cases

Do v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, Re [2016] AATA 390
Waits v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs, Re [2003] AATA 1336
DMH16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2017) 253 FCR 576

BHKM v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, Re [2018] AATA 3

Secondary Materials

Direction No. 65, Migration Act 1958 – Direction under section 499 – Visa refusal and cancellation under s501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under s 501CA (Instrument made on 22 December 2014).

REASONS FOR DECISION

R Cameron, Senior Member

2 October 2018

INTRODUCTION – REVIEWABLE DECISION

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made on 28 June 2018 by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection under section 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (“the Act”) to refuse an application by the Applicant for a Protection (Class XA) visa. (“the reviewable decision”)

    BACKGROUND

  2. The Applicant is a citizen of India. He is 32 years old.

  3. He was raised as a Sikh. In approximately October 2010 he converted to Islam. On 9 May 2013 he lodged an application for a Protection visa claiming to fear harm should he return to India, and in particular fearing that he would be killed by his family or old friends.

  4. By a decision made by a delegate of the Minister on 14 January 2015, his application for the Protection visa was refused.

  5. Subsequently, he made an application to the Migration and Refugee Division of this Tribunal. On 18 February 2016 the Migration and Refugee Division set aside the decision of the delegate and the matter was remitted for reconsideration with a direction that the Applicant satisfied section 36(2)(a) of the Act.

  6. As noted earlier, by decision made on 28 June 2018, a delegate of the Minister refused to grant the visa under section 501(1) of the Act.

  7. The Applicant applied for review of that decision in this division of the Tribunal on 17 July 2018, within the time limits provided for in section 500(6B) of the Act.

    THE ACT AND ISSUES TO BE DECIDED

  8. It is appropriate to reproduce some relevant sections of the Act upon which this matter turns.

  9. Section 501 “Refusal or cancellation of visa on character grounds” provides:

    (1)The Minister may refuse to grant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BLSL and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 3681
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by the applicant, BLSL, against a decision by the Minister for Home Affairs to refuse to grant him a protection visa. The refusal was based on the applicant failing to pass the character test under section 501(6)(d) of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth), due to a risk of engaging in criminal conduct. The applicant argued that he owed international non-refoulement obligations, which should outweigh the character concerns. The decision was heard by Senior Member R Cameron.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the applicant met the character requirements for a protection visa, specifically whether there was a real risk that he would engage in criminal conduct. This involved assessing the applicant's credibility, the nature and seriousness of his past offending, the risk of future offending, and the expectations of the Australian community. The Tribunal also had to consider whether any non-refoulement obligations owed to the applicant outweighed these character concerns.

The Tribunal found that the applicant's evidence was not credible, noting inconsistencies and a tendency to shift his account of events, particularly concerning a violent incident. His explanations for his offending, including claims of hallucinations, were not well-supported by the available evidence, and his assertion that he was no longer a risk was not convincingly demonstrated. The Tribunal concluded that the seriousness of the applicant's conduct, the risk of further offending, and community expectations substantially outweighed any non-refoulement obligation owed to him. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision to refuse the protection visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

When it was put to him that it would be unlikely that he would be placed on a Community Corrections Order by a County Court Judge that had drug and mental health conditions attached to it, unless there was a serious problem, he sought to deflect the question by saying he really didn’t recall why. SOME FURTHER OBSERVATIONS ON THE APPLICANT’S EVIDENCE Some further observations should be made about the Applicant’s evidence before the Tribunal. He displayed an attitude towards giving evidence that did not impress well upon the Tribunal. As noted earlier, the Applicant is an articulate and intelligent man. At all times he was alert to advancing his best interests as he saw them. On occasions, his evidence would shift depending on what he perceived to be the best response to advance his case. This was particularly so in the course of cross-examination where, from time to time, he was asked the question and, if it were revealed later to be an implausible response, he sought to vary or adjust his evidence to make it more plausible. This shifting of his evidence was pointed out to him in the course of cross-examination, yet it persisted. The other concerning feature of his evidence was a frequent resort to lack of recollection on some matters that just did not ring true. Yet, on other occasions, his memory was particularly sharp and vivid. There was also an inconsistency in several aspects of his evidence that had already been highlighted with facts or otherwise capable of independent verification. Sometimes he sought to explain this lack of memory as being because the events were a long time ago. This had the hallmarks of an invention to conveniently explain away his desire to avoid the consequences of his actions. Another feature of his evidence was, on occasion, to embellish various matters that he thought would assist him. For instance, in his statutory declaration of 11 December 2017 at paragraph 48, he stated that he had completed many education courses. However, when confronted with the reality in cross-examination, it turned out that he had only completed one diploma level course and one certificate level course. This was notwithstanding the fact he had enrolled in 16 courses during his time in Australia. It will be recalled that he arrived in Australia for the first time on 10 April 2007. He has been on a variety of student and bridging visas since then. Some of those visas had no-work conditions or alternatively limited his work to 40 hours per fortnight. However, there were periods during this occasion where he worked full-time. There seems to have been an attitude by the Applicant that, with respect to his visa conditions and any work restrictions, he really didn’t care. Once again his attitude to this question was quite flippant and certainly resembled a singular indifference to visa conditions.CONSIDERATION OF THE OFFENDING AND THE CHARACTER TEST In the light of the language used in section 501(6)(d) of the Act and the risk of the Applicant engaging in criminal conduct in Australia if he is allowed to remain here, the Respondent put its case concerning the character test in several ways, with considerable persuasion.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Given the gravity and extent of the matters found with respect to the primary considerations, the Tribunal is unable to find that the non-refoulement obligation outweighs the primary considerations. The Tribunal acknowledges that there is a risk of harm to the Applicant if he returns to India. However, the Tribunal needs to weigh these safety concerns with the very strong concerns outlined above in relation to the seriousness of the Applicant’s crimes, the risk of further offending and what this would mean for the Australian community. These were strong findings based upon the evidence before the Tribunal.CONCLUSION The Applicant fails the character test because the Tribunal finds there is a real risk he would engage in criminal conduct within the meaning of section 501(6)(d) of the Act. Having failed the character test the primary considerations of the nature and seriousness of the Applicant’s conduct, the risk to the Australian community should further offences be committed and the expectations of the Australian community, substantially outweigh any non-refoulement obligation owed to him. Accordingly, the Tribunal affirms the decision of the Respondent’s delegate dated 28 June 2018 refusing an application by the Applicant for a Protection (Class XA) visa.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant’s version of the incident varies somewhat from the available evidence. In his statement to the Respondent of 11 December 2017, he stated that he had a hallucination at the mosque that the victim was putting an evil spirit on him. He stated: “because I thought the man had said yes to putting the spirit on me I became angry and pushed him”. In his evidence to the Tribunal, he said that he didn’t remember much of the incident and that he couldn’t recall punching him. He only recalled the victim running to the other side of the road and that he chased him. He said he didn’t think he kicked him, the victim just stumbled; he reiterated that he swore at the victim, asked him a question and that he fell over. He said that the victim told him he had put a spirit on him that got into him. At one stage in his evidence, rather implausibly, he asserted that the victim threatened him. The versions given to the Respondent and the Tribunal do not accord with the evidence from both the statement of the victim and the CCTV footage. It is of concern to the Tribunal, and does not reflect well on the Applicant’s credibility, that he maintains a demonstrably false version of this incident in the face of irrefutable evidence to the contrary. This does not reflect well on his character.A further consideration of the Applicant’s reasons for his offending There were several approaches adopted by the Applicant to explain, or in some instances explain away, his offending. In his Statutory Declaration to the Respondent of 11 December 2017, after providing his account of the relevant incidents, he referred to various symptoms of stress and anxiety. On other occasions he referred to being panicked or overwhelmed and on several occasions referred to hallucinations. Sometimes he stated he was hearing voices or had been inflicted with evil spirits. These symptoms were, in some way, identified as mental health issues. The Statutory Declaration of 11 December 2017, at paragraph 48, states that he no longer has hallucinations. He gave similar evidence from the witness box to the Tribunal at the hearing of this application. Consistently, he stated that he was only a risk to public safety for two or three weeks and then he: “came back to my senses”. “A few weeks later I was no longer a risk.” “I decided I wouldn’t have them in the future. I didn’t do that again and never had another hallucination.” He also relied upon the reports of a Mental Health Nurse from the Immigration Detention Centre healthcare provider “IHMS” (International Health and Medical Services), which were in evidence before the Tribunal as, in effect, confirming that he was no longer suffering from the hallucinations concern. An examination of the report relied upon does not reveal this was quite the case. It states that the Applicant currently denies the existence of such hallucinations and states that he is sleeping okay. He gave evidence that he still suffers from depression and anxiety but is taking steps to deal with it. He stated that he doesn’t have hallucinations anymore but does have stress anxiety and depression. He conceded that he is taking medication, known as “Mirtazapine”, for this condition. However, there was no other evidence of any actual treatment for this condition.