Blow Bar Co Pty Limited v McGann (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Blow Bar Co Pty Limited v McGann (No 3) [2018] FCA 980

File number: NSD 1896 of 2017
Judge: ROBERTSON J
Date of judgment: 2 July 2018
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – interlocutory application for summary judgment in respect of the following causes of action: passing off; misleading and deceptive conduct; unconscionable conduct and breach of a confidentiality agreement – in the alternative, interlocutory application to strike out paragraphs of the amended statement of claim on the basis that those paragraphs failed to state the material facts on which the applicants relied  
Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law, being Sch 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), s 21

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 31A

Cases cited:

Blow Bar Co Pty Ltd v McGann [2018] FCA 293

Natural Waters of Viti Ltd v Dayals (Fiji) Artesian Waters Ltd [2007] FCA 200; 71 IPR 571

Nutrientwater Pty Ltd v Baco Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 2; 265 ALR 140

O’Brien v Komesaroff [1982] HCA 33; 150 CLR 310

Spencer v Commonwealth of Australia [2010] HCA 28; 241 CLR 118

White Industries Australia Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2007] FCA 511; 160 FCR 298

Date of hearing: 25 June 2018
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Copyright and Industrial Designs
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 23
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr R Notley with Ms T Harris-Roxas
Solicitor for the Applicants: Rigby & Klaus
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms R White
Solicitor for the Respondents: K&L Gates

ORDERS

NSD 1896 of 2017
BETWEEN:

BLOW BAR CO PTY LIMITED

First Applicant

LEIGH DOLE PTY LIMITED AS TRUSTEE FOR THE DOLE FAMILY TRUST

Second Applicant

AND:

TIMOTHY MCGANN

First Respondent

TIMOTHY MCGANN AS TRUSTEE FOR THE MCGANN FAMILY TRUST

Second Respondent

TNCD PTY LIMITED

Third Respondent

JUDGE:

ROBERTSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 JULY 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Paragraphs [32]-[37], [66]-[81], [82]-[98], [99]-[107] and [108]-[123] of the Amended Statement of Claim are struck out, with leave to replead.  The repleading should incorporate the deletion of [40]-[65] of the Amended Statement of Claim concerning breach of copyright and the addition of the particulars provided at [6]-[12] of the letter from the applicants’ solicitors dated 21 June 2018 (Exhibit B).

2.In relation to costs, within 7 days of the date of these orders, the respondents are to file and serve short written submissions, limited to 3 pages, dealing with the costs orders for which they contend in respect of the respondents’ interlocutory application filed on 31 May 2018.  Within 14 days of the date of these orders, the applicants are to file and serve their corresponding short written submissions, also limited to 3 pages.

3.In the parties’ written submissions pursuant to order 2 above, they are to indicate their agreement or otherwise with the following timetabling orders:

(i)Within 14 days of the date of these orders, the applicants file and serve a Further Amended Statement of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Blow Bar Co Pty Limited v McGann (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 980
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Blow Bar Co Pty Limited v McGann (No 3) involved an interlocutory application for summary judgment concerning causes of action related to passing off, misleading and deceptive conduct, unconscionable conduct, and breach of a confidentiality agreement. Additionally, the applicants sought to strike out certain paragraphs of the amended statement of claim, asserting that they failed to state material facts on which the applicants relied. The applicants also sought an order to stay their claim to rectify a Shareholders Agreement until a company, Blow Bar Co Barangaroo Pty Ltd (in liquidation), was joined as a party to the proceedings.

The legal issues before the court included whether the applicants' claims should be summarily dismissed and if certain paragraphs of the amended statement of claim should be struck out for failing to state the requisite material facts. Another issue was whether the applicants should be required to join Blow Bar Co Barangaroo Pty Ltd (in liquidation) as a party before proceeding further.

The court examined the evidence presented, including affidavits and particulars of the amended statement of claim, and identified discrepancies in the documents tendered. The court noted that the correct version of the amended statement of claim was eventually supplied, but the incorrect version was not considered. The court found that certain paragraphs of the amended statement of claim, including those concerning the fit out of the premises and the materials and colours used, were matters of primary fact and should be included in the statement of claim. The court also determined that the most efficient course of action was to direct the applicants to join Blow Bar Co Barangaroo Pty Ltd (in liquidation) as a respondent.

In its decision, the court struck out specific paragraphs of the amended statement of claim, with leave to replead, and directed the applicants to join the additional respondent. The court also ordered the parties to submit short written submissions on costs and to agree on a timetable for further procedural steps, including mediation and a case management hearing. The court reserved the decision on costs and dismissed the interlocutory application otherwise.

The court's orders included the striking out of certain paragraphs of the amended statement of claim with leave to replead, directives for the applicants to join the additional respondent and file a further amended statement of claim, and a timetable for mediation and further hearings. The parties were also required to submit written submissions on costs and agree on the procedural timetable. Costs were reserved for further determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Paragraphs [32]-[37], [66]-[81], [82]-[98], [99]-[107] and [108]-[123] of the Amended Statement of Claim are struck out, with leave to replead. The repleading should incorporate the deletion of [40]-[65] of the Amended Statement of Claim concerning breach of copyright and the addition of the particulars provided at [6]-[12] of the letter from the applicants’ solicitors dated 21 June 2018 (Exhibit B).

2. In relation to costs, within 7 days of the date of these orders, the respondents are to file and serve short written submissions, limited to 3 pages, dealing with the costs orders for which they contend in respect of the respondents’ interlocutory application filed on 31 May 2018. Within 14 days of the date of these orders, the applicants are to file and serve their corresponding short written submissions, also limited to 3 pages.

3. In the parties’ written submissions pursuant to order 2 above, they are to indicate their agreement or otherwise with the following timetabling orders:

(i) Within 14 days of the date of these orders, the applicants file and serve a Further Amended Statement of Claim.

(ii) Within 14 days of the date of these orders, the applicants join Blow Bar Co Barangaroo Pty Ltd (in liquidation) as a respondent.

(iii) Within 28 days of the date of these orders, the respondents file and serve a Defence to the Further Amended Statement of Claim and any Cross-Claim.

(iv) Within 35 days of the date of these orders, the applicants file and serve any Reply to the Defence and their Defence to any Cross-Claim.

(v) The proceedings be referred to mediation before a Registrar of the Court or before a private mediator, such mediation to take place no later than September 2018.

(vi) The matter be listed for a further Case Management Hearing at 9.30 am on 10 October 2018.

4. The respondents’ interlocutory application filed on 31 May 2018 otherwise be dismissed.

5. Costs reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The interlocutory application also sought an order that the applicants’ claim to rectify the Shareholders Agreement, being an agreement between Blow Bar Co Barangaroo Pty Ltd, Leigh Dole Pty Ltd as trustee for the Dole Family Trust and Timothy McGann as trustee for the McGann Family Trust, be stayed until Blow Bar Co Barangaroo Pty Ltd (in liquidation), a company said to have joint entitlement to the claimed relief, is joined as a party to the proceedings. This issue narrowed on the written submissions filed on behalf of the applicants. The applicants said that they intended to make an application to join Blow Bar Co Barangaroo Pty Ltd (in liquidation) but intended to do so after the respondents had filed a Defence. The applicants submitted that the admissions or denials made by the respondents in respect of the Shareholders Agreement may be relevant to the issue of whether or not Blow Bar Co Barangaroo Pty Ltd (in liquidation) should be joined to these proceedings and, the applicants submitted, it may be that the position of the liquidator, who presently neither consented to nor opposed the company being joined in the proceedings, changed in light of those admissions or denials.Evidence The respondents read two affidavits sworn by Ms Simone Mitchell, the first dated 31 May 2018 and the second 20 June 2018. Counsel for the applicants tendered two documents which were marked as exhibits. There was initial confusion as to the correct identification of an attachment to a letter from the applicants’ solicitors dated 21 June 2018 to the solicitors for the respondents (Exhibit B), which attachment did not form part of the tender by counsel for the applicants. It appeared that nobody in the courtroom could say with any certainty which proposed Further Amended Statement of Claim had been attached and that the document handed up by counsel for the respondents was not the correct version. I then handed back the disputed document to counsel. The correct version was supplied after the hearing was adjourned. It then appeared to be accepted that counsel for the respondents had unintentionally handed up the incorrect document. In any event, I was asked to proceed by reference only to the Amended Statement of Claim dated 19 April 2018 and I have done so. The document mistakenly handed up, and returned to counsel, is not in evidence and I do not take it into account. It is the correct version which now forms part of Exhibit B. It is appropriate to reproduce paragraphs 32 to 37 of the Amended Statement of Claim and thereafter the particulars provided by the applicants by the 21 June 2018 letter that is Exhibit B.32.For the purposes of this pleading, the fit out of Bronte Blow Bar is the combination of the following:a.the type of materials used for the floors, walls, cabinetry, benchtops, fixtures and fittings in the Bronte Blow Bar;b.the colour of the floors, walls, ceiling, cabinetry, benchtops, fixtures and fittings in the Bronte Blow Bar; andc.the type and colour of the furniture and equipment used in the Bronte Blow Bar.33.For the purposes of this pleading, the fit out of the Premises is the combination of the following:a.the type of materials used for the floors, walls, cabinetry, benchtops, fixtures and fittings in the Premises;b.the colour of the floors, walls, ceiling, cabinetry, benchtops, fixtures and fittings in the Premises; andc.the type and colour of the furniture and equipment used in the Premises.34.The type of materials used for the floors, walls, cabinetry, benchtops, fixtures and fittings of the Premises are the same as, or substantially the same as, or similar to, the type of materials used for the floors, walls, cabinetry, benchtops, fixtures and fittings of the Bronte Blow Bar.35. The colour of the floors, walls, ceiling, cabinetry, benchtops, fixtures and fittings of the Premises is the same as, or substantially the same as, or similar to, the colour of the floors, walls, ceiling, cabinetry, benchtops, fixtures and fittings of the Bronte Blow Bar.36.The type and colour of the furniture and equipment used in the Premises is the same as, or substantially the same as, or similar to, the type and colour of the furniture used in the Bronte Blow Bar.37.By reason of the matters pleaded at paragraphs 34 to 36 above, the fit out of the Premises is the same as, or substantially the same as, or similar to, the fit out of the Bronte Blow Bar.The particulars were as follows: 6. With respect to paragraph 32(a) of the ASOC, the materials referred to are:a. white subway tiles with black grout;b. concrete;c. marble;d. mirrored splashbacks;e. track lighting;f. iron shelving and fittings; andg. laminate cabinetry. 7. With respect to paragraph 32(b) of the ASOC, the colours referred to are:a. white;b. grey;c. black; andd. brass.8.With respect to paragraph 32(c) of the ASOC, the type and colour of the furniture and equipment referred to (sic):a. black bar stools;b. black appliances and tools, such as hair dryers and hair brushes;c. black leather pouches to hold tools;d. hair and make-up menu on large black board;e. food and drink menus on white paper attached to small clipboards; andf. mirrored coasters.9. With respect to paragraph 33(a) of the ASOC, the materials referred to are:a. white subway tiles with black grout;b. concrete;c. marble;d. mirrored splashbacks;e. track lighting;f. iron shelving and fittings; andg. laminate cabinetry.10. With respect to paragraph 33(b) of the ASOC, the colours referred to are:a. white;b. grey;c. black; andd. brass.11.With respect to paragraph 33(c) of the ASOC, the type and colour of the furniture and equipment referred to is:a. black bar stools;b. black appliances and tools, such as hair dryers and hair brushes;c. black leather pouches to hold tools;d. hair and make-up menu on large black board;e. food and drink menus on white paper attached to small clipboards; andf. mirrored coasters.12.With respect to paragraphs 34 to 36 of the ASOC, in both Bronte Blow Bar and the Premises there are:a. white subway tiles with black grout;b. concrete bench tops and marble bench tops;c. black painted ceilings;d. black track lighting;e. black iron shelves and black iron glass racks above the bar;f. mirrored splash backs;g. black tapware;h. black metal fittings;i. black bar stools;j. black appliances and tools, such as hair dryers and hair brushes;k. black leather pouches to hold tools;l. hair and make-up menu on large black board;m. food and drink menus on white paper attached to small clipboards; andn. mirrored coasters.In my opinion, in the circumstances of this case, these are matters of primary fact and should be included in the statement of claim.ConsiderationSummary dismissal

Decision

Reasons for decision

As to the issue set out at [6] above, in my view, the most efficient and economical way through what now appears to concern substantially procedural niceties, is to direct the applicants now to join Blow Bar Co Barangaroo Pty Ltd (in liquidation) as a respondent. On reading the respondents’ pleadings, the liquidator will be well placed to decide whether or not he wishes to take an active part in the proceedings. Conclusion and orders The interlocutory application sought an order that the applicants pay the respondents’ costs of and incidental to the interlocutory application on an indemnity basis, such costs to be payable forthwith. In submissions, the parties indicated that they wished to be heard in relation to costs. To that end, within 7 days of the date of these orders, the respondents are to file and serve short written submissions, limited to 3 pages, dealing with the costs orders for which they contend. Within 14 days of the date of these orders, the applicants are to file and serve their corresponding short written submissions, also limited to 3 pages. The Court’s present intention is to deal with the question of costs on the papers. In their short written submissions the parties are also to indicate their agreement or otherwise with the following timetabling orders:(i)Within 14 days of the date of these orders, the applicants file and serve a Further Amended Statement of Claim. (ii)Within 14 days of the date of these orders, the applicants join Blow Bar Co Barangaroo Pty Ltd (in liquidation) as a respondent. (iii)Within 28 days of the date of these orders, the respondents file and serve a Defence to the Further Amended Statement of Claim and any Cross-Claim. (iv)Within 35 days of the date of these orders, the applicants file and serve any Reply to the Defence and their Defence to any Cross-Claim. (v)The proceedings be referred to mediation before a Registrar of the Court or before a private mediator, such mediation to take place no later than September 2018.(vi)The matter be listed for a further Case Management Hearing at 9.30 am on 10 October 2018.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is appropriate to reproduce paragraphs 32 to 37 of the Amended Statement of Claim and thereafter the particulars provided by the applicants by the 21 June 2018 letter that is Exhibit B.32.For the purposes of this pleading, the fit out of Bronte Blow Bar is the combination of the following:a.the type of materials used for the floors, walls, cabinetry, benchtops, fixtures and fittings in the Bronte Blow Bar;b.the colour of the floors, walls, ceiling, cabinetry, benchtops, fixtures and fittings in the Bronte Blow Bar; andc.the type and colour of the furniture and equipment used in the Bronte Blow Bar.33.For the purposes of this pleading, the fit out of the Premises is the combination of the following:a.the type of materials used for the floors, walls, cabinetry, benchtops, fixtures and fittings in the Premises;b.the colour of the floors, walls, ceiling, cabinetry, benchtops, fixtures and fittings in the Premises; andc.the type and colour of the furniture and equipment used in the Premises.34.The type of materials used for the floors, walls, cabinetry, benchtops, fixtures and fittings of the Premises are the same as, or substantially the same as, or similar to, the type of materials used for the floors, walls, cabinetry, benchtops, fixtures and fittings of the Bronte Blow Bar.35. The colour of the floors, walls, ceiling, cabinetry, benchtops, fixtures and fittings of the Premises is the same as, or substantially the same as, or similar to, the colour of the floors, walls, ceiling, cabinetry, benchtops, fixtures and fittings of the Bronte Blow Bar.36.The type and colour of the furniture and equipment used in the Premises is the same as, or substantially the same as, or similar to, the type and colour of the furniture used in the Bronte Blow Bar.37.By reason of the matters pleaded at paragraphs 34 to 36 above, the fit out of the Premises is the same as, or substantially the same as, or similar to, the fit out of the Bronte Blow Bar.The particulars were as follows: 6. With respect to paragraph 32(a) of the ASOC, the materials referred to are:a. white subway tiles with black grout;b. concrete;c. marble;d. mirrored splashbacks;e. track lighting;f. iron shelving and fittings; andg. laminate cabinetry. 7. With respect to paragraph 32(b) of the ASOC, the colours referred to are:a. white;b. grey;c. black; andd. brass.8.With respect to paragraph 32(c) of the ASOC, the type and colour of the furniture and equipment referred to (sic):a. black bar stools;b. black appliances and tools, such as hair dryers and hair brushes;c. black leather pouches to hold tools;d. hair and make-up menu on large black board;e. food and drink menus on white paper attached to small clipboards; andf. mirrored coasters.9. With respect to paragraph 33(a) of the ASOC, the materials referred to are:a. white subway tiles with black grout;b. concrete;c. marble;d. mirrored splashbacks;e. track lighting;f. iron shelving and fittings; andg. laminate cabinetry.10. With respect to paragraph 33(b) of the ASOC, the colours referred to are:a. white;b. grey;c. black; andd. brass.11.With respect to paragraph 33(c) of the ASOC, the type and colour of the furniture and equipment referred to is:a. black bar stools;b. black appliances and tools, such as hair dryers and hair brushes;c. black leather pouches to hold tools;d. hair and make-up menu on large black board;e. food and drink menus on white paper attached to small clipboards; andf. mirrored coasters.12.With respect to paragraphs 34 to 36 of the ASOC, in both Bronte Blow Bar and the Premises there are:a. white subway tiles with black grout;b. concrete bench tops and marble bench tops;c. black painted ceilings;d. black track lighting;e. black iron shelves and black iron glass racks above the bar;f. mirrored splash backs;g. black tapware;h. black metal fittings;i. black bar stools;j. black appliances and tools, such as hair dryers and hair brushes;k. black leather pouches to hold tools;l. hair and make-up menu on large black board;m. food and drink menus on white paper attached to small clipboards; andn. mirrored coasters.In my opinion, in the circumstances of this case, these are matters of primary fact and should be included in the statement of claim.ConsiderationSummary dismissal