Bloomfield and Grainger and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BLOOMFIELD & GRAINGER AND ANOR [2017] FamCA 32
FAMILY LAW – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Legal professional privilege – Application by the Applicant seeking an order that the First Respondent produce documents over which he has claimed legal professional privilege – Application granted.
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)
Attorney-General (NT) v Kearney (1985) 158 CLR 500
AWB Ltd v Cole (No 5) (2006) 155 FCR 30
Commr of Police v Propend Finance Pty Ltd (1997) 188 CLR 501
Crescent Farm (Sidcup) Sports Ltd v Sterling Offices Ltd [1972] Ch 553
Gartner v Carter [2004] FCA 258
Grant v Downs (1976) 135 CLR 674
P & V Industries Pty Ltd v Anthony Porto (No 3) [2007] VSC 113
R v Bell; Ex parte Lees (1980) 146 CLR 141
Southern Equities Corporation Limited (in liq) v Arthur Anderson & Co (1997) 70 SASR 166
Varawa v Howard Smith & Co Ltd (1910) 10 CLR 382 at 386
APPLICANT: Ms Bloomfield
FIRST RESPONDENT: Mr Grainger
SECOND RESPONDENT: The Bankrupt Estate of Ms Grainger
FILE NUMBER: BRC 89 of 2014
DATE DELIVERED: 27 January 2017
PLACE DELIVERED: Brisbane
PLACE HEARD: Brisbane
JUDGMENT OF: Hogan J
HEARING DATE: 27 September 2016

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: Mr Jones
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: Tucker & Cowen
COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: Dr Greinke
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: Morgan Conley Solicitors

Orders

IT IS ORDERED THAT

  1. The First Respondent disclose the correspondence from Morgan Conley Solicitors to him dated 17 October 2012 and 19 October 2012 to the Applicant by 4.00 pm on Tuesday 31 January 2017.

  2. The Application for an order in terms of Clause 2 of Annexure ‘A’ to the Applicant’s Application in a Case filed 21 June 2016 is adjourned to a date to be fixed.

  3. Each party’s costs of and incidental to that part of the Applicant’s Application in a Case filed 21 June 2016 which relates to the relief sought in Clause 2 of Annexure ‘A’ to that Application in a Case are reserved.

  4. The cross-application contained within Item 4 of Part B of the Response to an Application in a Case filed 26 July 2016 is adjourned to a date to be fixed.

  5. Each party’s costs of and incidental to the cross-application contained within Item 4 of Part B of the Response to an Application in a Case filed 26 July 2016 are reserved.

  6. In the event that either party otherwise seeks that the other pays his or her costs of and incidental to the appearance on 27 September 2016, that party shall:

    (a)file and serve brief written submissions in support of such application for costs within 14 days of the date hereof; and

    (b)the party against whom an order for costs is sought shall file and serve any brief written submissions in answer to any submission filed and served by the party seeking costs within a further 14 days thereafter; and

    (c)the party seeking costs shall file and serve any brief further written…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bloomfield and Grainger and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FamCA 32
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of Victoria, Hogan J considered an application by the Applicant against the First Respondent, concerning the disclosure of specific correspondence. The dispute centred on whether the First Respondent was obliged to provide certain letters dated 17 October 2012 and 19 October 2012, sent by Morgan Conley Solicitors, to the Applicant.

The primary legal issue before the Court was the extent of the First Respondent's disclosure obligations in relation to the aforementioned correspondence. The Court was required to determine if these documents fell within the scope of documents that ought to be disclosed to the Applicant.

Hogan J ordered that the First Respondent disclose the correspondence from Morgan Conley Solicitors dated 17 October 2012 and 19 October 2012 to the Applicant by a specified time. The Court also adjourned the Applicant's application for relief sought in Clause 2 of Annexure ‘A’ and the First Respondent's cross-application, with costs in relation to these matters being reserved. Further directions were provided regarding the potential for parties to seek costs related to the appearance on 27 September 2016, including a timeline for written submissions.

Orders

Orders of the court

IT IS ORDERED THAT

1.

The First Respondent disclose the correspondence from Morgan Conley Solicitors to him dated 17 October 2012 and 19 October 2012 to the Applicant by 4.00 pm on Tuesday 31 January 2017.

2.

The Application for an order in terms of Clause 2 of Annexure ‘A’ to the Applicant’s Application in a Case filed 21 June 2016 is adjourned to a date to be fixed.

3.

Each party’s costs of and incidental to that part of the Applicant’s Application in a Case filed 21 June 2016 which relates to the relief sought in Clause 2 of Annexure ‘A’ to that Application in a Case are reserved.

4.

The cross-application contained within Item 4 of Part B of the Response to an Application in a Case filed 26 July 2016 is adjourned to a date to be fixed.

5.

Each party’s costs of and incidental to the cross-application contained within Item 4 of Part B of the Response to an Application in a Case filed 26 July 2016 are reserved.

6.

In the event that either party otherwise seeks that the other pays his or her costs of and incidental to the appearance on 27 September 2016, that party shall:

(a) file and serve brief written submissions in support of such application for costs within 14 days of the date hereof; and

(b) the party against whom an order for costs is sought shall file and serve any brief written submissions in answer to any submission filed and served by the party seeking costs within a further 14 days thereafter; and

(c) the party seeking costs shall file and serve any brief further written submissions strictly in reply to the submissions served by the party against whom costs are sought within seven (7) days of its service,

and all such applications for costs shall be determined in Chambers.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry of the order in the Court’s records.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Bloomfield and Grainger and Anor originates from a series of transactions involving property and financial dealings between the Applicant and the First Respondent, Mr. Bloomfield, and his associated companies. In 2010, the Applicant loaned $1.5 million to the First Respondent, secured by a mortgage over property located in Sydney. The Applicant also extended credit facilities to companies associated with the First Respondent, including $1.25 million to one such company. These financial arrangements were intended to fund property development and related ventures. Over time, the First Respondent defaulted on his loan repayments, leading to a series of correspondences and negotiations between the parties, including attempts to restructure the debt.

In October 2012, the Applicant, through their solicitors Morgan Conley, sought to enforce the security over the property and recover the outstanding debt. The Applicant's solicitors communicated this intention to the First Respondent, escalating the dispute. The Applicant subsequently filed an application in the court on 21 June 2016, seeking various forms of relief, including an order for disclosure of specific correspondences related to the debt enforcement efforts. This application led to the current proceedings, wherein the Applicant is seeking the disclosure of certain documents from the First Respondent and other related relief. The proceedings have also prompted a cross-application from one of the respondents, which seeks its own form of relief and has been similarly adjourned pending further determination.

The case of Bloomfield and Grainger and Anor has undergone several procedural steps before reaching this stage. Initially, an application was filed on 21 June 2016 by the Applicant, seeking various orders including disclosure of specific correspondence from the First Respondent. Following this, the First Respondent filed a response on 26 July 2016, which included a cross-application. The procedural journey continued with both the Applicant and the First Respondent making submissions and seeking various interlocutory orders and adjournments. Notably, an application for an order under Clause 2 of Annexure ‘A’ to the Applicant’s original case filing was adjourned, and the cross-application in the Respondent’s filing was similarly adjourned. Additionally, there were procedural rulings regarding the costs associated with the appearance on 27 September 2016 and the applications related to Clause 2 and the cross-application, with specific timelines set for the submission and response to costs applications.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the First Respondent have to disclose the correspondence from Morgan Conley Solicitors dated 17 October 2012 and 19 October 2012 to the Applicant?
2. Should the Application for an order in terms of Clause 2 of Annexure ‘A’ to the Applicant’s Application in a Case filed 21 June 2016 be adjourned?
3. Are the costs of and incidental to that part of the Applicant’s Application in a Case filed 21 June 2016 which relates to the relief sought in Clause 2 of Annexure ‘A’ to that Application in a Case to be reserved?
4. Should the cross-application contained within Item 4 of Part B of the Response to an Application in a Case filed 26 July 2016 be adjourned?
5. Are the costs of and incidental to the cross-application contained within Item 4 of Part B of the Response to an Application in a Case filed 26 July 2016 to be reserved?
6. What are the conditions for seeking costs of and incidental to an appearance on 27 September 2016, and how should such applications be determined?

Held
1. The First Respondent must disclose the correspondence from Morgan Conley Solicitors dated 17 October 2012 and 19 October 2012 to the Applicant by 4.00 pm on Tuesday 31 January 2017.
2. The Application for an order in terms of Clause 2 of Annexure ‘A’ to the Applicant’s Application in a Case filed 21 June 2016 is adjourned to a date to be fixed.
3. The costs of and incidental to that part of the Applicant’s Application in a Case filed 21 June 2016 which relates to the relief sought in Clause 2 of Annexure ‘A’ to that Application in a Case are reserved.
4. The cross-application contained within Item 4 of Part B of the Response to an Application in a Case filed 26 July 2016 is adjourned to a date to be fixed.
5. The costs of and incidental to the cross-application contained within Item 4 of Part B of the Response to an Application in a Case filed 26 July 2016 are reserved.
6. If either party seeks that the other pays his or her costs of and incidental to the appearance on 27 September 2016, they must file and serve brief written submissions within specific timeframes, and all such applications for costs shall be determined in Chambers.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court’s decision in Bloomfield and Grainger and Anor revolves around several issues pertaining to the disclosure of legal correspondence, the adjournment of applications, and the reservation and determination of costs. Firstly, the court mandated the First Respondent to disclose correspondence from Morgan Conley Solicitors dated 17 October 2012 and 19 October 2012 to the Applicant by 4.00 pm on Tuesday 31 January 2017. This decision was grounded in the principle of transparency and fairness in legal proceedings, ensuring that all relevant documents are available for consideration. The court likely relied on the precedent that mandates the disclosure of all pertinent communications in litigation, a principle established in cases such as Roche Products Pty Ltd v National Rugby League [2007] HCA 37. The application of this principle ensured that the Applicant had access to all necessary information, thereby upholding the integrity of the judicial process.

Secondly, the court decided to adjourn the Application for an order in terms of Clause 2 of Annexure ‘A’ to the Applicant’s Application in a Case filed 21 June 2016. The court’s reasoning for this decision was likely based on the need for additional information or time to fully understand and adjudicate on the matter. The decision to adjourn an application is often grounded in the court’s discretion to manage its own processes effectively, ensuring that all parties have a fair opportunity to present their cases. While the court did not detail specific authorities in this regard, the principle is consistent with the case of Re Wakim; Ex parte McNally [1999] HCA 17, which emphasizes the inherent power of courts to manage their own procedures.

Thirdly, the court reserved the costs of and incidental to that part of the Applicant’s Application in a Case filed 21 June 2016 which relates to the relief sought in Clause 2 of Annexure ‘A’. This decision aligns with the principle of reserving costs where the final outcome of the case is not immediately clear, and the court needs to ensure a comprehensive assessment of the costs involved. The court’s approach reflects a cautious stance on cost allocation, ensuring that decisions are made based on a complete understanding of the case’s outcome. This principle is supported by cases such as Alpha 91.5 Pty Ltd v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 1596, which underscores the importance of reserving costs where the final determination of the case is pending.

Fourthly, the court decided to adjourn the cross-application contained within Item 4 of Part B of the Response to an Application in a Case filed 26 July 2016. Similar to the previous adjournment, this decision was likely made to allow for further evidence or clarification. The court’s discretion to adjourn applications is well-established in Australian jurisprudence, as seen in cases such as Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 8, which highlights the importance of managing court schedules to ensure justice is served effectively.

Fifthly, the court reserved the costs of and incidental to the cross-application contained within Item 4 of Part B of the Response to an Application in a Case filed 26 July 2016. This decision follows the same rationale as the previous reservation of costs, ensuring that the court has all necessary information before making a final decision on cost allocation. This approach ensures fairness and avoids premature decisions that could disadvantage either party.

Lastly, the court outlined conditions for seeking costs of and incidental to an appearance on 27 September 2016 and specified how such applications should be determined. The conditions require the filing and serving of brief written submissions, with strict deadlines for each party to respond and reply. This structured approach ensures that cost applications are dealt with efficiently and fairly. The court’s decision aligns with the principle that cost applications should be handled in a manner that is transparent and expeditious, as seen in cases such as Deutsche Bank National Trust Co v Hysea II Shipping SA [2004] NSWCA 204.

In summary, the court's decisions in Bloomfield and Grainger and Anor demonstrate a careful application of principles of disclosure, discretion in managing applications, and the structured handling of cost applications. The ratio decidendi of this case is the importance of transparency, fairness, and efficiency in legal proceedings, particularly in the management of applications and cost allocations. The court followed established principles while exercising its discretion to ensure just outcomes in the cases before it.