Blong Ume Nominees Pty Ltd v Semweb Nominees Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

BLONG UME NOMINEES PTY LTD & ANOR v SEMWEB NOMINEES PTY LTD & ORS

[2013] SASC 180

Reasons of Judge Dart a Master of the Supreme Court

15 November 2013

PROCEDURE - MISCELLANEOUS PROCEDURAL MATTERS

Plaintiffs' application seeking orders restraining Ouwens Lawyers from continuing to act for the second and third defendants – whether the Court should exercise its inherent supervisory jurisdiction over its officers to restrain Ouwens Lawyers from acting.

Held: In the interests of justice, order that Ouwens Lawyers be restrained from continuing to act for the second and third defendants in the action.

Kallinicos and Another v Hunt and Others (2005) 64 NSWLR 561, applied.
Bowen v Stott [2004] WASC 94; Chapman v Rogers; ex parte Chapman [1984] 1 Qd R 542; Coppola & Anor v Nobile & Anor (2012) 279 LSJS 543; Giannarelli v Wraith (1988) 165 CLR 543; Kooky Garments Ltd v Charlton [1994] 1 NZLR 587; Miles v Hughes Unreported, Supreme Court of Western Australia, Parker J, 11 November 1998, Library No 990009; Mitchell v Burell [2008] NSWSC 772, considered.

BLONG UME NOMINEES PTY LTD & ANOR v SEMWEB NOMINEES PTY LTD & ORS
[2013] SASC 180

JUDGE DART:         

  1. In this application the plaintiffs seek to enjoin a firm of solicitors, Ouwens Lawyers, from acting for the second and third defendants. 

  2. Mr Ouwens is a solicitor and the sole principal of the firm of Ouwens Lawyers.  He is the fifth defendant in these proceedings, a director of the first defendant, Semweb Nominees Pty Ltd (“Semweb”), and also a director of the third defendant, Ouwens Corporate Services Pty Ltd (“OCS”).  That company is the trustee of the Ouwens Corporate Services Trust.  Mr Ouwens is one of two specified beneficiaries of the Trust.

  3. It is Mr Ouwens’ personal interest in the subject matter of the litigation which the plaintiffs say make it inappropriate for Ouwens Lawyers to act in this matter.

    Background

  4. In 2002 three professional men, Mr Nicholas Orfanos, Mr Willem Ouwens and Mr Michael Michaels decided that they would purchase a building together as an investment.  The intention of each of them was that their professional firms would occupy space in the building. 

  5. A suitable building was identified, being the building at 147 Frome Street Adelaide, known as “The Stables”.  A contract was entered into on 26 September 2002 to purchase that property.  The purchase price including settlement costs was $1,385,819.72.   Each of the three investors contributed $155,273.24 to the acquisition.  The balance of the monies required to settle were secured by a mortgage from Westpac Banking Corporation. 

  6. A Deed of Trust dated 25 November 2002 provided for Semweb to become the registered proprietor of the property at settlement.  It holds the property on trust in equal one third shares for each of the three investors. 

  7. Each of the investors nominated the trustee of a trust to hold their interest in the building.  Mr Orfanos nominated Orfanos Nominees Pty Ltd, the second plaintiff,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Blong Ume Nominees Pty Ltd v Semweb Nominees Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] SASC 180
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Blong Ume Nominees Pty Ltd v Semweb Nominees Pty Ltd involves an application by the plaintiffs seeking to restrain Ouwens Lawyers from continuing to act for the second and third defendants in the litigation. The plaintiffs argue that Mr Ouwens, a principal of Ouwens Lawyers, has a personal interest in the outcome of the litigation, which compromises the independence and objectivity of both Mr Ouwens and his firm. The legal issues before the court were whether the court should exercise its inherent supervisory jurisdiction over its officers to restrain Ouwens Lawyers from acting in the litigation and whether there are any factors that should mitigate against making such an order.

The court found that Mr Ouwens' personal financial and reputational interests in the litigation, along with the interests of Ouwens Lawyers, compromised the independence and objectivity required of solicitors. The court noted that Ouwens Lawyers had an interest in the outcome of the litigation, as their tenure and the amount of rent they had been paying since 2007 were at stake. The court concluded that a fair-minded and reasonably informed observer would think that the independence and objectivity of Mr Ouwens and the firm would be compromised by their interest in the outcome of the litigation. The interests of justice required that they not act. The court ordered that Ouwens Lawyers cease to act as the solicitors for the second and third defendants and that they take steps to withdraw as solicitors on the record within 14 days of the decision.

The court rejected the arguments presented by the second and third defendants, who wished to retain Ouwens Lawyers as their solicitors. The court found that the right of litigants to choose their own solicitor was not absolute and could be outweighed by other considerations, such as the potential for a conflict of interest. The court also rejected the argument that restraining Ouwens Lawyers would result in considerable costs being thrown away due to the need to retain new solicitors, finding that the interests of justice required the making of the order. The court held that in the interests of justice, Ouwens Lawyers should be restrained from continuing to act for the second and third defendants in the action.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held: In the interests of justice, order that Ouwens Lawyers be restrained from continuing to act for the second and third defendants in the action.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is Mr Ouwens’ personal interest in the subject matter of the litigation which the plaintiffs say make it inappropriate for Ouwens Lawyers to act in this matter.Background In 2002 three professional men, Mr Nicholas Orfanos, Mr Willem Ouwens and Mr Michael Michaels decided that they would purchase a building together as an investment. The intention of each of them was that their professional firms would occupy space in the building. A suitable building was identified, being the building at 147 Frome Street Adelaide, known as “The Stables”. A contract was entered into on 26 September 2002 to purchase that property. The purchase price including settlement costs was $1,385,819.72. Each of the three investors contributed $155,273.24 to the acquisition. The balance of the monies required to settle were secured by a mortgage from Westpac Banking Corporation. A Deed of Trust dated 25 November 2002 provided for Semweb to become the registered proprietor of the property at settlement. It holds the property on trust in equal one third shares for each of the three investors. Each of the investors nominated the trustee of a trust to hold their interest in the building. Mr Orfanos nominated Orfanos Nominees Pty Ltd, the second plaintiff, which was trustee of the The Stables Trust. Mr Michaels nominated the second defendant, Melrob Investments Pty Ltd (“Melrob”), and Mr Ouwens nominated OCS. On the same date that the Deed of Trust was executed a Joint Venture Deed was executed. Each of the investors’ Trusts became parties to a joint venture. The three professional firms moved into the property. Two of those, Ouwens Lawyers and Sims Richmond, still occupy the property. By late 2006 the relationship between Mr Orfanos and Mr Ouwens had deteriorated to such an extent that Mr Orfanos wished to leave the joint venture and sell the one third interest in the property held by his Trust. His professional practice vacated the property in late 2007. It appears that Mr Orfanos has been attempting to reach a resolution of this matter since that time. Each of the three men is a director of Semweb. Mr Orfanos has not attended directors’ meetings of that company since December 2007 because of the breakdown of the relationship with Mr Ouwens. He attempted to appoint a solicitor, Mr Ian Edgley, as an alternate to represent his interests, however the other directors would not permit that. These proceedings were instituted on 3 June this year. The application seeking to enjoin Mr Ouwens and his firm from acting (FDN14) was filed on 16 July. The first plaintiff, Blong Ume Nominees Pty Ltd, is said now to be the trustee of the Stables Trust. The original trustee was the company mentioned above, Orfanos Nominees Pty Ltd. The defendants took the point that Blong Ume Nominees Pty Ltd was not properly appointed as trustee of The Stables Trust. In response, and as a matter of caution, an application was made to join Orfanos Nominees Pty Ltd as second plaintiff. The joinder was not opposed and an order to that effect has been made. Accordingly, there are now two plaintiffs.The plaintiffs’ pleaded case

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The firm itself has an interest in the outcome of the litigation, given that its tenure may be called into question and issues arise with respect to the amount of rent it has been paying since 2007 and, presumably, into the future. If it is established that Ouwens Lawyers have been paying inadequate rent, a claim might be made in the future to recover the underpayment of rent. Therefore, we are not only dealing with Mr Ouwens’ personal interests in the matter, but also the interests of Ouwens Lawyers as a firm of solicitors in the subject matter of the litigation. Conclusion In my opinion, a fair-minded and reasonably informed observer would think that the independence and objectivity of Mr Ouwens and the firm would be compromised by their interest in the outcome of the litigation. The interests of justice require that they not act. I order that Ouwens Lawyers cease to act as the solicitors for the second and third defendants and that they take steps to withdraw as solicitors on the record within 14 days of today. I will hear the parties as to any consequential matters.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is clear that Mr Ouwens is likely to be a material witness and that he has a personal financial interest in the outcome of the action going far beyond the usual interest of a solicitor. He also has a reputational interest in that he is said to have acted in breach of duty as a director of Semweb; a fact he denies.Consideration of the issues For the reasons mentioned in the preceding paragraph, it appears that Ouwens Lawyers ought not be acting in this matter. However, it was submitted there are a number of matters which ameliorate the position and which it is submitted should lead the Court, in the exercise of its discretion, to dismiss the plaintiffs’ application. On the plaintiffs’ application it was counsel for the second and third defendants, the parties for whom Ouwens Lawyers act, who opposed the making of the order. A number of grounds were advanced, which were that:1Mr Ouwens in his capacity as the fifth defendant is already represented by an independent firm of solicitors;2The second and third defendants should be permitted to choose their own solicitors, and they wish to retain Ouwens Lawyers;3Considerable costs will be incurred in retaining new solicitors and the costs already incurred will be thrown away;4The plaintiffs have been guilty of delay in making the application;5A solicitor at Ouwens Lawyers other than Mr Ouwens has the conduct of the file for the second and third defendants, and6The second and third defendants have retained independent counsel.I deal with each issue in order. The first point raised is that because Mr Ouwens, in his capacity as a defendant, is already represented by independent solicitors, the Court should be satisfied that no issues arise in respect of Ouwens Lawyers acting for the second and third defendants. It was submitted that Mr Ouwens would receive independent legal advice and, as a result of that advice, could be expected to act appropriately.[14] To some extent the submission appears to confuse Mr Ouwens’ two capacities in this litigation. One of those is as defendant. The other is as principal of the firm of solicitors on file for the second and third defendants. The mere fact that Mr Ouwens is a defendant in the proceedings is in itself a reason why his firm ought not act for the second and third defendants. [14] Transcript at page 70, line 22. The fact that he is separately represented as a defendant does not deal directly with the issue of whether by reason of his personal interest in the outcome of the litigation Mr Ouwens is in a position of conflict between his duty to the Court as a solicitor and his duty to his clients, the second and third defendants. The fact that he is separately represented as a defendant does not, in my view, detract from his duty as an officer of the Court, nor to the appearance of a conflict with that duty. The next two points are related. The first proposition is that it is an important right of litigants to be able to choose their own solicitor. That is no doubt correct. It is also said that if Ouwens Lawyers are restrained from acting, considerable costs will be thrown away as a result of having to retain new solicitors. The authorities make clear that each of these two grounds is a relevant consideration.[15][15] Kallinicos and Another v Hunt and Others (2005) 64 NSWLR 561 at [92].