Blattman and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

Blattman and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 184 (18 February 2019)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:           2018/2776

Re:Fabian Blattman

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Dr L Bygrave, Member

Date:18 February 2019

Place:Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

.............................[sgd]...........................................

Dr L Bygrave, Member

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – “reasonable and necessary supports” – spinal cord injury termed as C6/C7 tetraplegic – whether the Applicant is entitled to receive transport funding under the “no disadvantage principle” – Applicant was in receipt of a mobility allowance prior to becoming a NDIS participant – whether the Tribunal has jurisdiction to review the decision under review – the decision under review is affirmed.

LEGISLATION

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

CASES

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) [1979] AATA 179; (1979) 2 ALD 634.

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities
The Council of Australian Governments Intergovernmental Agreement
National Disability Insurance Agency, Operational Guideline

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr L Bygrave, Member

18 February 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Mr. Fabian Blattman, is 60 years old. He has a spinal cord injury, termed as a C6/C7 tetraplegic, which is the result of an off-road trail bike accident in 1978. He resides alone in a house owned by Housing NSW in Sydney and is employed full-time at Spinal Cord Injuries Australia.

  2. Mr. Blattman became a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (the NDIS or Scheme) on 8 December 2016. He has had NDIS plans approved and dated 8 December 2016, 7 December 2017, 5 March 2018, 12 March 2018 and 7 May 2018.

  3. On 3 April 2018, a representative for Mr. Blattman requested a review of his NDIS plan dated 12 March 2018 because he was not “funded sufficiently”.[1]

    [1] Exhibit T-T12.

  4. On 7 May 2018, an internal review by the National Disability Insurance Agency (the NDIA) determined Mr. Blattman would receive additional funding for personal care but no funding for transport support (the internal review decision).[2]

    [2] Exhibit T-T2.

  5. On 15 May 2018, Mr. Blattman applied to the NDIS Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) for review.

  6. Pursuant to section 103 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (the Act), the Tribunal has jurisdiction to review the internal review decision.

  7. The matter was heard in Sydney on 24 January 2019. Mr. Blattman did not have legal representation; he attended the hearing in person and gave oral evidence with the support of Mr. Tony Jones, Advocacy Services Manager at Spinal Cord Injuries Australia.

    ISSUES

  8. The issues for determination by the Tribunal are:

    ·whether level 3 transport funding (in the amount of $3,456 per annum) for Mr. Blattman is a “reasonable and necessary support” as set out in subsection 34(1) of the Act; and

    ·if not, whether Mr. Blattman is entitled to receive…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Blattman and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 184
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr. Blattman to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for review of a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). The dispute centred on whether Mr. Blattman, who has a C6/C7 tetraplegia, was entitled to receive funding for transport as a "reasonable and necessary support" under the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). Mr. Blattman had previously received a mobility allowance before becoming an NDIS participant and argued he should continue to receive transport funding under a "no disadvantage principle."

The Tribunal was required to determine two primary legal issues. Firstly, whether the transport funding sought by Mr. Blattman constituted a "reasonable and necessary support" in accordance with the NDIS legislation. Secondly, if it did not, whether Mr. Blattman was entitled to receive such funding based on the "no disadvantage principle," given his prior receipt of a mobility allowance.

The Tribunal found that the transport support requested by Mr. Blattman did not meet the criteria for "reasonable and necessary support" as defined by the NDIS rules and the Act. The evidence indicated that Mr. Blattman could independently drive his modified private vehicle, which was the most cost-effective, time-efficient, and safest method for him to travel to work and for social engagements. While the NDIA had previously provided transport funding, their explanations for discontinuing it were unsubstantiated. Regarding the "no disadvantage principle," the Tribunal noted the COAG Agreement's commitment to ensuring participants were not disadvantaged during the transition to the NDIS. However, Mr. Blattman provided no evidence that he had suffered any disadvantage, either financially or in his social and economic participation, since the transport funding ceased.

Consequently, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the transport funding was a reasonable and necessary support. Furthermore, as Mr. Blattman had not demonstrated any disadvantage arising from the cessation of this funding, the Tribunal affirmed the NDIA's decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In relation to transport, rules 7.21 and 7.22 of the Support Rules state:The NDIS will be responsible for:(a)supports for a person that enable independent travel, including through personal transport-related aids and equipment, or training to use public transport; and(b)modifications to a private vehicle (i.e. not modifications to public transport or taxis); and(c)the reasonable and necessary costs of taxis or other private transport options for those not able to travel independently.7.22 The NDIS will not be responsible for:(a)ensuring that public transport options are accessible to a person with disability, including through the funding of concessions to people with disability to use public transport; or(b)compliance of transport providers and operators with laws dealing with discrimination on the basis of disability, including the Disability Standards for Accessible Public Transport 2002; or(c)transport infrastructure, including road and footpath infrastructure, where this is part of a universal service obligation or reasonable adjustment (including managing disability parking and related initiatives).EVIDENCE Mr. Blattman provided a written statement dated 16 January 2019 in which he described his disabilities as:Physically I am affected from the shoulders down both motor and sensory. Finger function is lost and my arms are partially paralysed. My trunk and legs are totally paralysed. Due to my trunk paralysis I have affected breathing, loss of bladder and bowel control and body core temperature regulating issues, not being able to sweat to cool down in hot weather and poor circulation makes it harder to warm up in colder weather. I have mobility by using a manual wheelchair. I have support worker assistance at home for personal care and domestic duties and require assistance to overcome physical barriers out in the community (steep ramps, accessing public transport and graded inclines on pathways and any access where only stairs exist).[3][3] Exhibit A1. Mr. Blattman is employed full-time at Spinal Cord Injuries Australia. Both in his written statement and his oral evidence to the Tribunal, Mr. Blattman explained that his main means of travel from his home to his workplace is by his privately-owned motor vehicle. He paid for modifications to this vehicle in 2009, which enables him to drive independently. Mr. Blattman told the Tribunal that his commute by car takes one hour each way in travel time and costs $60 per week in fuel, on average.[4] By comparison, if Mr. Blattman used public transport to travel between his home and workplace, this would take more than 90 minutes and cost $71.10 per week.[5] He also uses his car to visit family and friends on weekends. Mr. Blattman uses accessible taxis with the NSW Taxi Subsidy Scheme to attend hospital appointments and some social engagements where it is not convenient to drive and/or park.[4] Exhibit A4.[5] Exhibit A5. Mr. Blattman confirmed at the Tribunal hearing that he is able to drive his vehicle independently. He is also able to transfer into and out of his car independently, although he is assisted into his car each morning by his support worker and, if available, he receives assistance from a colleague to transfer in and out of his vehicle at work.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In view of my findings at paragraphs 34 and 35 above, that the support does not meet the requirements in rules 5.1 and 7.21 of the Support Rules, I am not satisfied that the support is appropriately funded through the NDIS.Conclusion For the reasons set out above, I am not satisfied that level 3 transport funding for Mr. Blattman is a “reasonable and necessary support” as set out in subsection 34(1) of the Act. I now consider whether Mr. Blattman is entitled to receive transport funding under the “no disadvantage principle” because he was in receipt of mobility allowance prior to becoming a participant in the NDIS.Is Mr. Blattman entitled to receive transport funding under the “no disadvantage principle”? In written submissions dated 3 August 2018, Mr. Jones wrote that:For [NDIS] participants who have moved from Mobility Allowance to transport funding as an NDIS participant, it has always been broadly understood to be a like- for-like transfer.[15][15] Applicant’s Grounds of the Appeal, dated 3 August 2018, page 2. In response, the NDIA submitted that this would mean that any NDIS participant who has transitioned from the Commonwealth mobility allowance would be paid transport funding support, irrespective of whether this meets the statutory criteria for a reasonable and necessary support. In particular, the Agency stated that:irrespective of whether the “no disadvantage principle” has any statutory force or is merely exhortatory, at its highest, it does not mean that the Applicant (or any applicant) is entitled to support that would not otherwise be payable under the NDIS… [16][16] Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 10 October 2018, para 72. The Council of Australian Governments Intergovernmental Agreement for the NDIS Launch (the COAG Agreement) made on 7 December 2012 contained the following provisions:Continuity of Support60 COAG has committed to provide continuity of support to people with disability currently receiving services to ensure that they are not disadvantaged in the transition to a NDIS…63 Where the NDIS takes on responsibility for providing continuity of supports for a person under paragraph 62 above the Agency will work with the person to develop a transition strategy for that person. This strategy will:(a)ensure no disadvantage in a person’s outcomes — the supports provided by the NDIS will enable the person to achieve at least the same level of social and economic participation (or undertake the same range of activities) as enabled by their previously provided support; and(b)the period of this transition will depend on the person’s circumstances and the type of support being provided, and the extent to which there are alternative supports to transition to.[17][17] See accessed 1 February 2019. Of most relevance to this issue, Mr. Blattman provided no evidence to the Tribunal that he has been disadvantaged (financially or otherwise) by not receiving transport support funding since 7 May 2018. In particular, there was no evidence or submissions to the Tribunal at the hearing that Mr. Blattman has not been able “to achieve at least the same level of social and economic participation (or undertake the same range of activities) as enabled by [his] previously provided support” (as provided in paragraph 63(a) of the COAG Agreement) since he has become an NDIS participant or since transport support funding ceased on 7 May 2018.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Neither Dr. Nier nor Mr. Quach gave evidence at the Tribunal hearing. Ultimately, however, this was not an issue because it is undisputed that the most appropriate way for Mr. Blattman to travel between his home and workplace is by his modified private motor vehicle. This means of travel is the least expensive, most time efficient, and safest for Mr. Blattman’s health in terms of his ability to control and regulate his core body temperature.CONSIDERATION Before I consider the issues for determination, it is appropriate to briefly review the history of transport support funding paid to Mr. Blattman in his NDIS plans dated 8 December 2016, 7 December 2017, 5 March 2018 and 12 March 2018. At the Tribunal hearing, the NDIA was asked to explain why Mr. Blattman was provided a transport support budget in his NDIS plans from 8 December 2016 to 12 March 2018 before this support was removed on 7 May 2018. This is because the internal review decision dated 7 May 2018 gave an extremely limited explanation for the decision and the evidence showed that Mr. Blattman’s circumstances of independent driving between his home and workplace had remained constant over this period of time (and indeed, remains constant until now). In other words, there was confusion about why the NDIA had provided transport support funding over a period of 17 months and then decided to stop the funding. In summary, I can only say the explanations put forward by the NDIA at the Tribunal hearing were speculative and not substantiated by any documentation. Perhaps the most beneficial explanation is that the NDIA knew Mr. Blattman was in receipt of mobility allowance prior to becoming a participant in the NDIS and decided to provide some financial support for his transport costs before “phasing out” this support. I note that this “policy” decision by the NDIA is not explained in the documents before the Tribunal and Mr. Blattman’s oral evidence to the Tribunal was that the NDIA did not communicate this process to him either in writing or verbally. Although the changing position of the NDIA has generated confusion for Mr. Blattman, this is not the issue for determination by the Tribunal. Rather, my consideration below must examine whether transport funding for Mr. Blattman is a “reasonable and necessary support” consistent with subsection 34(1) of the Act and, if not, whether Mr. Blattman is entitled to receive transport funding under the “no disadvantage principle” because he was in receipt of a mobility allowance prior to becoming a NDIS participant. I make the following findings of fact based on the evidence before the Tribunal:·Mr. Blattman was in receipt of mobility allowance prior to becoming a NDIS participant on 8 December 2016. As a NDIS participant, Mr. Blattman is not eligible to receive mobility allowance.·Mr. Blattman is able to independently access and drive his personal motor vehicle, which has been modified. He commutes between his home and workplace using his motor vehicle because this is the least expensive, most time efficient and safest way for him to travel. He also uses his car for social engagements (seeing family and friends) on a weekend. ·Mr. Blattman uses accessible taxis with the NSW Taxi Subsidy Scheme to attend hospital appointments and some social engagements.·From 8 December 2016 to 7 May 2018, Mr. Blattman used transport funding support provided through his NDIS plan to pay for petrol and minor servicing costs.