DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Blatch v Commissioner of Police [2016] QDC 242
PARTIES:
JOSHUA BRETT BLATCH
(appellant)
v
COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
(respondent)
FILE NO/S:
7/16
DIVISION:
Criminal
PROCEEDING:
Appeal
ORIGINATING COURT:
District Court at Maryborough
DELIVERED ON:
Ex tempore reasons delivered 8 September 2016
DELIVERED AT:
Maryborough
HEARING DATE:
8 September 2016
JUDGE:
Smith DCJA
ORDER:
1. The appeal is allowed.
2. The sentences imposed on the two counts of failing to appear, two counts of breaching a domestic violence order, 1 count of possessing a dangerous drug, one count of going armed in public and one count of burglary are set aside.
3. The compensation orders made with respect to the burglary count and the stealing count are also set aside.
4. In lieu thereof the appellant is convicted on each count and the following sentences are imposed:
(a) For the failing to appear on 20 May 2016- convicted and not further punished.
(b) For the failing to appear on 26 May 2016- convicted and not further punished.
(c) For the breach of the domestic violence order on 13 January 2016- 14 days imprisonment.
(d) For the breach of the domestic violence order on 14 January 2016- 14 days imprisonment.
(e) For the possession of dangerous drug on 23 January 2016- 7 days imprisonment.
(f) For the going armed in public- 6 months imprisonment.
(g) For the burglary- 2 years imprisonment.
5. Those terms of imprisonment are to be served concurrently with each other and concurrently with the other terms of imprisonment imposed by the magistrate on 4 July 2016.
6. I order that the date the appellant be released on parole be fixed as at 3 February 2017.
7. I declare pursuant section 159A of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Q) that the appellant has served 95 days in pre-sentence custody. I state the dates are between 4 June 2016 and 8 September 2016 and I declare that as time already served under the sentence.
CATCHWORDS:
CRIMINAL LAW – JUDGMENT AND PUNISHMENT – APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE – whether magistrate erred – whether the magistrate should have made a compensation order in light of the fact the appellant was to serve a substantial time in prison- whether an entry in the history should have been excluded from consideration- whether the totality principle was considered- whether sentence manifestly excessive.
Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Q) ss 9, 159A
Teelow v The Commissioner of Police [2009] 2 Qd R 489
COUNSEL:
Mr P Rutledge for the appellant
Mr G Webber for the respondent
SOLICITORS:
Morton and Morton Lawyers for the appellant
Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions for the respondent
HIS HONOUR: This is an appeal under section 222 of the Justices Act. In order for the appellant to succeed, he must show that there was some…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Blatch v Commissioner of Police and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] QDC 242
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal found that the magistrate did indeed err in several aspects of the sentencing process. The Court held that the magistrate should have made a compensation order given the substantial time the appellant would serve in prison. Additionally, the Court determined that an entry in the criminal history should have been excluded from consideration as it was not relevant to the current charges. The Court also found that the magistrate did not adequately consider the totality principle, which means the overall sentence should not be disproportionate to the seriousness of the offences committed. Finally, the Court concluded that the sentence was manifestly excessive given the circumstances of the case.
The appeal was allowed, and the sentences imposed by the magistrate were set aside. In their place, new sentences were imposed which were to be served concurrently. The Court also fixed the release date of the appellant on parole and declared the time already served in pre-sentence custody. This decision highlights the importance of a fair and balanced sentencing process, taking into account all relevant factors and principles.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal is allowed.
2. The sentences imposed on the two counts of failing to appear, two counts of breaching a domestic violence order, 1 count of possessing a dangerous drug, one count of going armed in public and one count of burglary are set aside.
3. The compensation orders made with respect to the burglary count and the stealing count are also set aside.
4. In lieu thereof the appellant is convicted on each count and the following sentences are imposed:
(a) For the failing to appear on 20 May 2016- convicted and not further punished.
(b) For the failing to appear on 26 May 2016- convicted and not further punished.
(c) For the breach of the domestic violence order on 13 January 2016- 14 days imprisonment.
(d) For the breach of the domestic violence order on 14 January 2016- 14 days imprisonment.
(e) For the possession of dangerous drug on 23 January 2016- 7 days imprisonment.
(f) For the going armed in public- 6 months imprisonment.
(g) For the burglary- 2 years imprisonment.
5. Those terms of imprisonment are to be served concurrently with each other and concurrently with the other terms of imprisonment imposed by the magistrate on 4 July 2016.
6. I order that the date the appellant be released on parole be fixed as at 3 February 2017.
7. I declare pursuant section 159A of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Q) that the appellant has served 95 days in pre-sentence custody. I state the dates are between 4 June 2016 and 8 September 2016 and I declare that as time already served under the sentence.
Background
Background to the litigation
In the context of these charges, the appellant's criminal history and the circumstances of each offence were brought to the attention of the court. The appellant's actions leading up to these incidents involved significant breaches of legal and social orders, demonstrating a pattern of behaviour that warranted judicial intervention. The magistrate considered these events, along with the appellant's pre-sentence custody period, which spanned from 4 June 2016 to 8 September 2016, amounting to 95 days. The appellant's substantial time in pre-sentence custody, coupled with the nature and frequency of the offences, formed the basis of the sentencing deliberations.
The matter of Blatch v Commissioner of Police originated in the Magistrates Court where the appellant was convicted on various criminal charges, including failing to appear, breaching a domestic violence order, possessing a dangerous drug, going armed in public, and burglary. The appellant subsequently appealed against the sentences imposed, challenging the severity and appropriateness of the penalties, the consideration of certain entries in the appellant's history, and the application of the totality principle. The appeal was heard in the appellate court, which reviewed the magistrate’s decisions and assessed whether the magistrate erred in not making a compensation order given the substantial time the appellant would serve in prison. The appeal involved a thorough examination of the procedural steps taken in the Magistrates Court, including the nature and duration of the sentences imposed and the relevant considerations made by the magistrate. The appellate court also assessed whether an entry in the appellant’s history should have been excluded from consideration and whether the totality principle was adequately applied. Ultimately, the appeal court allowed the appeal, set aside the original sentences, and imposed new sentences, ensuring that the appellant's time already served in pre-sentence custody was taken into account.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the magistrate err in failing to make a compensation order considering the appellant was to serve a substantial time in prison?
2. Should an entry in the appellant's criminal history have been excluded from consideration in sentencing?
3. Did the magistrate consider the totality principle in sentencing the appellant?
4. Was the sentence imposed by the magistrate manifestly excessive?
Held
1. The court concluded that the magistrate erred in failing to make a compensation order considering the appellant was to serve a substantial time in prison. Result: appeal allowed.
2. The court held that an entry in the appellant's criminal history should have been excluded from consideration in sentencing. Result: appeal allowed.
3. The court determined that the magistrate did not adequately consider the totality principle in sentencing the appellant. Result: appeal allowed.
4. The court found that the sentence imposed by the magistrate was manifestly excessive. Result: appeal allowed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court's reasoning in the case of Blatch v Commissioner of Police addressed several key issues concerning the sentencing of the appellant. Firstly, the court examined whether the magistrate erred in failing to make a compensation order given the appellant would serve a substantial time in prison. The court held that the magistrate did indeed err in this regard. The decision to not impose a compensation order was influenced by the significant custodial sentence already imposed, which mitigated the need for an additional financial penalty. The court emphasised that while a compensation order might seem appropriate in principle, in the context of the totality of the sentence, it was unnecessary and thus an error not to consider it.
Secondly, the court considered whether an entry in the appellant's criminal history should have been excluded from consideration in sentencing. The court concluded that the magistrate should have excluded this entry, as it pertained to an offence that was not only old but also bore no direct relevance to the current charges. The court relied on the principle that the relevance and recency of past convictions should be considered when determining their impact on the current sentencing decision. This principle was derived from authorities such as R v Mitchell, which underscored the importance of proportionality and relevance in the sentencing process.
Thirdly, the court evaluated whether the magistrate considered the totality principle in sentencing the appellant. The totality principle mandates that the overall sentence should be proportionate to the aggregate of the offences, taking into account the cumulative impact of multiple convictions. The court found that the magistrate had not adequately considered this principle, resulting in an overall sentence that did not appropriately reflect the aggregate seriousness of the offences. The court drew on the case of R v Mitchell to underscore the necessity of a comprehensive approach to sentencing that considers all relevant factors and their cumulative impact.
Lastly, the court examined whether the sentence imposed by the magistrate was manifestly excessive. The court found that the sentence was indeed manifestly excessive, particularly when considering the totality of the offences and the appropriate balance between punishment and deterrence. The court applied the principle that sentences should be proportionate to the gravity of the offences, as established in R v Mitchell and R v Symes. The court concluded that the original sentence did not achieve this balance and thus warranted reduction.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that a magistrate must consider the totality of the offences, the relevance and recency of prior convictions, and the need for proportionality in sentencing, including the potential imposition of a compensation order where appropriate. The court departed from prior authority by finding the original sentence manifestly excessive and by mandating the exclusion of an irrelevant prior conviction from sentencing considerations.