Blakeney and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements)
Link copied
CaseCopied
27 min read
Full text
Blakeney and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements) [2015] AATA 862 (11 November 2015)
Division
GENERAL DIVISION
File Number(s)
2013/6076
Re
Francese Blakeney
APPLICANT
And
Repatriation Commission
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal
Deputy President J W Constance
Date
11 November 2015
Place
Sydney
The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides that the death of the late Mr Blakeney was defence-caused and that the date of effect of the decision is 15 November 2012.
CATCHWORDS – Veterans’ Entitlements – widow’s pension – whether veteran rendered British nuclear test defence service – smoking – ischaemic heart disease – whether material points to hypothesis connecting death with circumstances of service – reasonable hypothesis – death of Veteran defence-caused – decision under review set aside
Legislation
Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) ss 7, 8, 13, 69, 70 and 120
Statement of Principles concerning Ischaemic Heart Disease, No. 89 of 2007
REASONS FOR DECISION
INTRODUCTION
Mrs Blakeney is the widow of the late Mr Blakeney who served in the Royal Australian Air Force from 1956 until 1976. During his service he was posted to the Base Squadron in Edinburgh in South Australia, which was the Base to which ground personnel were posted for duty at Maralinga. The British Nuclear Testing Program was carried out at Maralinga from February 1957 to November 1958 and for a year from February 1963. During part of this time Mr Blakeney was stationed at the Edinburgh Base. He was posted to Ubon Air Base in Thailand in 1965 when it served as a base for aircraft involved in the Vietnam War.
Mr Blakeney died in 2012. Mrs Blakeney claims that her husband’s death was related to his service in the Air Force. Her claim for a pension under the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) is based on three different aspects of his service – his British nuclear test defence service (being defence service), his service in Thailand (being operational service and therefore eligible war service) and his remaining service in the Air Force (being defence service). Her claim has been refused by the Commission and Mrs Blakeney has applied to this Tribunal for a review of that decision.
For the reasons which follow the decision under review will be set aside and it will be decided that Mr Blakeney’s death was defence-caused.
MATERIAL BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL
Mr Blakeney’s service records
Mr Blakeney was born in 1929. He was a member of the Royal Australian Air Force from 23 February 1956 until 18 August 1976. He served in Thailand from 29 July 1965 until 28 January 1966 during which time Australia was engaged in the Vietnam War.[1]
[1] Exhibit R2 p.1.
Mrs Blakeney’s evidence[2]
[2] Exhibit A1, exhibit R1 p.94 and oral evidence.
Mr and Mrs Blakeney first met in 1972. They married in 1981.
In…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Blakeney and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements... and more:
In the matter of Blakeney and the Repatriation Commission, the court addressed the issue of whether the death of a veteran was caused by his service, specifically in relation to his British nuclear test defence service. The central dispute revolved around whether the veteran's ischaemic heart disease, which ultimately led to his death, was attributable to his service. The case was heard and determined by the Australian court.
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the veteran's ischaemic heart disease and subsequent death were attributable to his service, specifically his British nuclear test defence service. The court had to determine if there was a reasonable hypothesis linking the veteran's ischaemic heart disease to his service, and if so, whether this linked his death to his service.
The court examined the evidence presented, including the veteran's smoking habits and the nature of his service. It found that the veteran had commenced smoking at a young age and smoked heavily, a habit he maintained throughout his service. The court concluded that there was sufficient evidence to form a reasonable hypothesis that the veteran's ischaemic heart disease was connected to his service, and by extension, that his death was also attributable to his service. Given this, the court was not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the veteran's death was not defence-caused. Consequently, the decision of the Repatriation Commission rejecting the claim for a pension was set aside.
In conclusion, the court determined that the veteran's death was defence-caused and set aside the earlier decision of the Repatriation Commission. The court's decision recognised the connection between the veteran's service and his ischaemic heart disease, leading to the conclusion that his death was attributable to his service.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides that the death of the late Mr Blakeney was defence-caused and that the date of effect of the decision is 15 November 2012.
Background
Background to the litigation
On 3 March 2005[25] Dr Reece, Orthopaedic Surgeon, reported:When he was in the armed forces he worked as a fitter and general maintenance. … He worked hard during his time in the armed forces, in the Air Force, doing heavy manual labour as required of him. He did sustain a number of injuries to his shoulders and knees while working in difficult positions and getting some neck discomfort…. He also noted that he did have a number of falls onto both knees but again he never reported any of these incidents during his time and cannot remember specific details about them as they were a very long time ago.…His knees have bilateral patella-femoral crepitus within them consistent with osteoarthritis but there is no effusion and they are stable.… Patrick has evidence of osteoarthritis in multiple areas, neck, shoulders, knees but not particularly in his hips. It is hard to say whether this is directly linked to his injuries sustained in the armed force as he cannot remember specific dates or instances other than the fall onto his right shoulder, however certainly doing heavy manual labour as a young person, as he described to me, and the positions he had to get in regarding all of this could have lead [sic] to the beginning of changes to the joint surfaces consistent with what we find now in a 75 year old gentleman who, despite his arthritis, is reasonably active with no particular loss of function in walking distance or standing or sitting durations.LEGISLATIVE BACKGROUND[25] Exhibit R1 p.65.A. Pension payable to a dependant under Part II of the Act Section 13 provides for the payment of a pension to a widow of a veteran by way of compensation when the death of the veteran was war-caused.War-caused death Section 8 of the Act sets out the circumstances in which the death of a veteran is taken to be war‑caused. The relevant parts of that section are:8 War‑caused death(1)Subject to this section and section 9A, for the purposes of this Act, the death of a veteran shall be taken to be war‑caused if:(a) the death of the veteran arose out of, or was attributable to, any eligible war service rendered by the veteran; Eligible war service includes operational service – subsection 7(1)(a).B. Pension payable to a dependant under Part IV of the Act Section 70 provides for the payment of a pension to a widow of a member of the Forces by way of compensation when the death of the member was defence-caused.Defence-caused death Subsection 70(5) sets out the circumstances in which the death of a member is taken to be defence-caused. The relevant parts of that subsection state:(5) For the purposes of this Act, the death of a member of the Forces … shall be taken to have been defence-caused …… if:(a) the death … arose out of, or was attributable to, any defence service … of the member. Defence service includes British nuclear test defence service – subsection 68(1).C. Standard of proof Section 120 relevantly provides:120 Standard of proof(1)Where a claim under Part II for a pension in respect … of the death of a veteran, relates to the operational service rendered by the veteran, the Commission shall determine … that the death of the veteran was war‑caused, … unless it is satisfied, beyond reasonable doubt, that there is no sufficient ground for making that determination.Note: This subsection is affected by section 120A.(2)Where a claim under Part IV:…(c) in respect of the incapacity … of a member of the Forces, or the death of such a member, relates to British nuclear test defence service rendered by the member… the Commission shall determine … that the death of the member was defence‑caused, … unless it is satisfied, beyond reasonable doubt, that there is no sufficient ground for making that determination…Note 2: This subsection is affected by section 120A. (3)In applying subsection (1) or (2) … in respect of the death of a person, related to service rendered by the person, the Commission shall be satisfied, beyond reasonable doubt, that there is no sufficient ground for determining:…(c)that the death was war‑caused or defence‑caused;as the case may be, if the Commission, after consideration of the whole of the material before it, is of the opinion that the material before it does not raise a reasonable hypothesis connecting the injury, disease or death with the circumstances of the particular service rendered by the person.Note: This subsection is affected by section 120A.(4)Except in making a determination to which subsection (1) or (2) applies, the Commission shall, in making any determination or decision in respect of a matter arising under this Act or the regulations, including the assessment or re-assessment of the rate of a pension granted under Part II or Part IV, decide the matter to its reasonable satisfaction. … (6)Nothing in the provisions of this section, or in any other provision of this Act, shall be taken to impose on:(a)a claimant or applicant for a pension or increased pension, or for an allowance or other benefit, under this Act; or(b)the Commonwealth, the Department or any other person in relation to such a claim or application;any onus of proving any matter that is, or might be, relevant to the determination of the claim or application.Reasonable hypothesis and a Statement of Principles
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Mr Blakeney suffered osteoarthritis in his knees. He had difficulty in kneeling and climbing stairs. As a result of the problems with his knees Mr Blakeney stopped gardening about 1980 and stopped dancing in about 1984. He reduced the amount of walking he did and stopped playing golf regularly at about that time although he continued to play some golf with his grandson. From about 2000 he would only use the stairs in their home when necessary. Generally he experienced greater difficulties with his knees from 2000 onwards.Mr Shirmyer’s evidence[5][5] Exhibit A2 and oral evidence. Mr Shirmyer served with Mr Blakeney in the Air Force in Australia and in Thailand. They both worked as members of ground crews in Thailand; their work was repetitive in nature. Mr Shirmyer recalls Mr Blakeney telling him of an incident on the Ubon Base when Mr Blakeney was involved in a stressful situation. Mr Blakeney was engaged in refuelling an aircraft when an inexperienced worker working with him caused a fire in the hanger. There was a risk that the hanger may have caught fire. Mr Blakeney spoke about this incident for “quite a while.” [6][6] Transcript 12/8/14. Mr Blakeney smoked while he was working at the Ubon Base. On several occasions he told Mr Shirmyer that he was giving up smoking. He would then stop smoking but would resume a short time later. Mr Shirmyer found it difficult to sleep on the Base by reason of the noise of the aircraft. He does not know if Mr Blakeney was affected by the noise. On occasions Mr Blakeney mentioned to Mr Shirmyer that he had served at Maralinga. He referred to the isolation of working there but he did not say what he did, except that he worked as part of a ground crew.Claimant Report completed by Mr Blakeney on 28 January 2005[7][7] Exhibit R1 p.5-6. In this report submitted to the Department of Veterans’ Affairs, Mr Blakeney stated that:·he first started to smoke on a regular basis about 1957;·the reason he started to smoke was “standard habit – everyone was smoking”;·at that time he smoked approximately 20 tailor-made cigarettes and two ounces of tobacco per day;·the amount he smoked did not change after he started smoking;·he permanently stopped smoking on 1 January 1997.Mr Blakeney’s Service Medical Records[8][8] Exhibit A5. An Outpatient Clinical Record of the No.3 R.A.A.F. Hospital dated 5 February 1973 records Mr Blakeney as a non-smoker. The records show that on 9 April 1963 the “R.M.O. Maralinga Village Hospital” made a request for an annual chest x-ray be taken of Mr Blakeney. The report of this x-ray is dated 19 April 1963.[9][9] Exhibit A5 p.57. The records also show that Mr Blakeney received vaccinations at the Maralinga Medical Unit on 16 March 1963, 26 March 1963, 28 March 1963, 16 April 1963, 20 April 1963 and 28 October 1963.[10][10] Exhibit A5 p.67.Reports of Writeway Research Services Pty Ltd Writeway Research Services provided two reports dated 13 March 2014[11] and 5 June 2014[12].[11] Exhibit A3.[12] Exhibit A4.Mr Blakeney’s service
Decision
Reasons for decision
On the basis of the evidence to which I have referred, and in particular the evidence of Mrs Blakeney as to Mr Blakeney’s statements as to the circumstances in which he commenced smoking and the quantity of tobacco consumed, I am not satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the death of Mr Blakeney was not war-caused.CONCLUSION In view of the conclusion I have reached it is unnecessary that I consider the alternative hypothesis put forward on behalf of Mrs Blakeney that:·Mr Blakeney’s repeated lifting and/or his repeated kneeling or squatting caused him to suffer osteoarthritis in his knees; ·the osteoarthritis prevented him from exercising adequately;·his inability to exercise caused him to suffer ischaemic heart disease which caused his death. The decision under review, being the decision of the Repatriation Commission made 1 March 2013 rejecting Mrs Blakeney’s claim for a pension in accordance with the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth), will be set aside. In substitution it will be decided that the death of the late Mr Blakeney was defence- caused and that the date of effect of the decision is 15 November 2012.