WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE REGISTRAR IN RELATION TO COSTS
CITATION:Blain v Burrangong Pet Foods Pty Limited [2006] NSWWCCPD 200
APPELLANT: Matthew Brian Blain
RESPONDENT: Burrangong Pet Foods Pty Limited
INSURER:CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited
FILE NUMBER: WCC19155-03
DATE OF REGISTRAR’S DECISION: 17 May 2005
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 24 August 2006
SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Appeal against the Registrar’s assessment of costs; date at which law is to be applied; fees for investigation report; travel and accommodation; Items 1.01, 2.05, 2.06, 4.08 and 10.01 of Schedule 6 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2003.
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: Acting Deputy President Tydd
HEARING:On the papers
REPRESENTATION: Appellant: McCabe Partners Lawyers
Respondent: Moray & Agnew
ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL: 1. Paragraphs two and four of the decision of the Registrar’s delegate dated 17 May 2005 are revoked and the following orders made in their place:
“2. The Applicant’s costs of the proceedings are assessed at $4860.50.
4. The Respondent is to pay the amount of $4860.50 to the Applicant if those costs have not already been paid.”
2. No order as to costs of the appeal.
BACKGROUND
Prior proceedings
On 8 December 2003, Matthew Brian Blain (‘Mr Blain’) lodged an ‘Application to Resolve a Dispute’ in the Workers Compensation Commission (‘the Commission’), (matter number WCC19155-03). Mr Blain sought lump sum compensation pursuant to section 66 and medical expenses pursuant to section 60 of the Workers CompensationAct 1987 (‘the 1987 Act’) as a result of an injury to his right hand sustained in the course of his employment on 29 August 2002.
Mr Blain named Burrangong Pet Foods Pty Limited (‘Burrangong’) as the Respondent employer. Burrangong lodged a Reply to the application in which it disputed the degree of permanent impairment claimed.
On 5 April 2004, a teleconference was conducted before a Commission Arbitrator who referred Mr Blain to an Approved Medical Specialist (‘AMS’) for assessment in accordance with sections 322 and 323 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (‘the 1998 Act’). The Commission issued the AMS’s assessment contained in a Medical Assessment Certificate (‘MAC’) to the parties on 13 August 2004.
On 1 September 2004 Burrangong’s solicitor advised the Commission, and Mr Blain’s solicitor, that it accepted the AMS’s assessment and requested the cancellation of the teleconference scheduled for 9 September 2004.
On 17 November 2004, the Registrar issued a ‘Certificate of Determination’ ordering Burrangong to pay $1,250.00 to Mr Blain in respect of 1% whole person impairment, as assessed by the AMS and also ordering Burrangong pay Mr Blain’s costs as agreed or assessed.
On 2 December 2004, Mr Blain’s solicitor lodged an ‘Application for Assessment of Costs’ and on 20 December 2004 Burrangong lodged submissions in Reply.
The Registrar’s decision in relation to this application, by her delegate, a Commission Arbitrator, (‘the delegate’) was made on 17 May 2005. The decision is set out as follows:
“1.Pursuant to [sic] Certificate of Determination dated 17 November 2004, the Respondent…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Blain v Burrangong Pet Foods Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] NSWWCCPD 200
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that Blain’s argument regarding procedural fairness was unsubstantiated, as both parties were aware of the issues in dispute and had the opportunity to make submissions. The court held that the Registrar’s delegate did not commit an error of law by not requesting additional documents. Regarding the investigation report, the court determined that the costs claimed for the report were not 'necessarily incurred' as per the Legal Profession Regulation 2002, and thus not recoverable. However, the cost of taking a statement from Blain was deemed necessary and recoverable. As for travel expenses, the court found that the costs for sustenance and accommodation were reasonable and should be allowed.
The court also addressed several specific cost items. For instance, the review of medical reports was deemed not allowable as the certificates provided did not constitute relevant reports. The cost for briefing a factual investigator was disallowed as it was more appropriately claimed under another item. The request for a review of the claim from the insurer was allowed in part, and the costs for preparing for a conference were deemed reasonable. Lastly, the costs associated with instructing an agent to act on the claim were not allowed as they were deemed not reasonable given the availability of alternative, less costly methods of filing and serving documents.
Consequently, the appeal was partly successful. The court revoked certain paragraphs of the Registrar’s decision and substituted new orders, assessing Blain’s costs at $4860.50, which Burrangong Pet Foods Pty Limited was to pay if not already settled. No costs were awarded for the appeal itself.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was initially brought before the Workers Compensation Commission by Matthew Brian Blain's application on 8 December 2003. Following a teleconference and a medical assessment, the Registrar issued a 'Certificate of Determination' on 17 November 2004, which Blain's solicitor challenged by lodging an 'Application for Assessment of Costs' on 2 December 2004. The Registrar's delegate assessed these costs on 17 May 2005, leading to Blain's appeal against the assessment on 1 June 2005. Burrangong opposed the appeal on 17 June 2005. The Acting Deputy President of the Workers Compensation Commission, Elizabeth Tydd, heard the appeal on the papers and delivered a decision on 24 August 2006.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the delegate deny Mr Blain procedural fairness?
2. Did the delegate err in disallowing the costs of disbursements relating to the investigation report?
3. Did the delegate err in disallowing the costs of disbursements relating to Mr Blain’s travel expenses?
4. Are the costs claimed under Item 1.01 allowable?
5. Are the costs claimed under Item 2.05 allowable?
6. Are the costs claimed under Item 2.06 allowable?
7. Are the costs claimed under Item 4.08 allowable?
8. Are the costs claimed under Item 10.01 allowable?
Held
1. The delegate did not deny Mr Blain procedural fairness.
2. The delegate erred in disallowing the costs of disbursements relating to the investigation report.
3. The delegate did not err in disallowing the costs of disbursements relating to Mr Blain’s travel expenses.
4. The costs claimed under Item 1.01 are not allowable.
5. The costs claimed under Item 2.05 are not allowable.
6. The costs claimed under Item 2.06 are allowable at $250.00.
7. The costs claimed under Item 4.08 are allowable at $250.00.
8. The costs claimed under Item 10.01 are not allowable.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The appeal against the Registrar's assessment of costs was heard on the papers by Acting Deputy President Tydd. The issues on appeal related to the delegate's decisions on procedural fairness, the disallowance of certain disbursements, and the allowance of specific costs under various items of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2003. The court examined each issue in light of the relevant legislation and case law, applying the principles of procedural fairness and the specific provisions governing costs in workers compensation matters. The court found that the delegate did not deny procedural fairness as Mr Blain’s solicitor had confirmed consent to the assessment being made on the papers. However, the court found an error of law in the disallowance of costs for the investigation report, allowing only the cost of taking Mr Blain's statement. The disallowance of travel and accommodation costs was found to be incorrect, as it was reasonable for Mr Blain to incur such expenses when travelling for a medical examination. The court did not find error in the disallowance of costs related to Item 1.01 as the certificates claimed did not constitute relevant medical reports. For Item 2.05, the court found no error in disallowing the costs as the investigator was briefed to obtain a witness statement. Regarding Item 2.06, the court found no error in the delegate's assessment, allowing the claim at $250.00. For Item 4.08, the court found no error in the delegate’s assessment, allowing the claim at $250.00. Lastly, for Item 10.01, the court found no error in the delegate's decision to disallow the costs as the means of filing and serving documents could have been done by mail or DX, which are less costly alternatives.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in workers compensation costs assessments, the principles of procedural fairness must be observed, and costs must be necessarily incurred to be allowable. The court must apply the relevant provisions of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2003 and the Legal Profession Regulation 2002 in determining the reasonableness and fairness of the costs claimed. The decision also clarifies the scope and application of specific cost items, particularly those related to disbursements and travel expenses.