IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIAN DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION No VG 3415 of 1994
BETWEEN:
BLACK HOLE ENTERPRISES PTY LTD
Applicant
-and-
CLASSIC HEIGHTS PTY LTD
Respondent
Coram: Olney J
Place: Melbourne
Date: 26 June 1995
MINUTE OF ORDER
THE COURT ORDERS THAT the application be dismissed with costs.
NOTE:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in
Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIAN DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION No VG 3415 of 1994
BETWEEN:
BLACK HOLE ENTERPRISES PTY LTD
Applicant
-and-
CLASSIC HEIGHTS PTY LTD
Respondent
Coram: Olney J
Place: Melbourne
Date: 26 June 1995
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
On 5 September 1994 the respondent's then solicitors caused to be posted to the registered office of the applicant a Creditor's Statutory Demand for Payment of Debt (the demand) whereby the respondent required payment within 21 days of the sum of $26,894.70 said to be due and payable by the applicant pursuant to an order made by Master Bruce in the Supreme Court of Victoria on 31 August 1994 in proceeding 5692 of 1994.
The applicant admits service of the demand and admits that the sum claimed is due and payable. It has however made application pursuant to s 459G of the Corporations Law for an order that the demand be set aside on the grounds first that it has an off-setting claim against the respondent and second, that there are other reasons why the statutory demand should be set aside.
The scheme of Divisions 2 and 3 of part 5.4 of the Corporations Law is now well known. It is unnecessary to recite the relevant provisions in detail. Upon an application to set aside a statutory demand the Court must determine whether it is satisfied that there is a genuine dispute between the company (the applicant) and the respondent about the existence or amount of a debt to which the demand relates and/or that the company has an offsetting claim (s 459H (1)). Having done that, the Court must then calculate the "substantiated amount" of the demand by subtracting from the "admitted amount" the amount of any "offsetting claim" (s 459H(2)) whereupon it may, depending on the circumstances, either set aside the statutory demand (s 459H(3)), vary the amount of the demand (s 459H(4)) or dismiss the application (s 459L).
The Court may also set aside a statutory demand if it is satisfied that because of a defect in the demand substantial injustice will be caused unless the demand is set aside (s 459J(1)(a)) or there is some other reason why the demand should be set aside (s 459J(1)(b)). The provisions of s 459H have effect subject to s 459J (s 459H(6)).
In this case it is not said that there is any defect in the demand nor is there any dispute between the applicant and the respondent about the existence or amount of the debt to which the demand relates. Accordingly, for the purpose of the statutory formula the admitted…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Black Hole Enterprises Pty Ltd v Classic Heights Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1995] FCA 467
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court assessed whether there was a genuine dispute regarding the debt or an offsetting claim. The applicant's claims included an alleged wrongful eviction, a continuing leasehold interest, and damages from the sale of its goods and equipment. However, the Court found the applicant's evidence insufficient to quantify any offsetting claim. The applicant failed to provide credible evidence supporting the valuation of its business or the loss from the sale of its goods, leading the Court to conclude that the offsetting claim had no quantifiable value. Consequently, the Court held that there was no basis to set aside or vary the demand under sections 459H(3) and 459H(4). The Court also found no improper purpose in the respondent's actions that would warrant setting aside the demand under section 459J(1)(b).
The Court dismissed the applicant's application with costs. The applicant's claims lacked evidentiary support, and the respondent's conduct did not indicate any misuse of the statutory demand process.
Background
Background to the litigation
This matter came before the Federal Court of Australia in response to Black Hole Enterprises' application to set aside a statutory demand for payment of $26,894.70 issued by Classic Heights. The case had previously been heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria, where a decision was made that Black Hole did not have a caveatable interest in the premises, and the caveats were removed. Costs were awarded to Classic Heights, which led to the statutory demand. Black Hole applied to set aside the statutory demand, arguing it had an offsetting claim and other reasons for setting the demand aside.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the statutory demand should be set aside on the grounds that Black Hole has an offsetting claim against Classic Heights.
2. Whether the statutory demand should be set aside for any other reason.
Held
1. The statutory demand should not be set aside on the grounds that Black Hole has an offsetting claim against Classic Heights.
2. The statutory demand should not be set aside for any other reason.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
This case involved an application by Black Hole Enterprises Pty Ltd to set aside a statutory demand issued by Classic Heights Pty Ltd under s 459G of the Corporations Law. Black Hole argued that the statutory demand should be set aside because it had an offsetting claim against Classic Heights that exceeded the amount claimed in the demand, and also for other reasons. Olney J dismissed the application with costs.
Olney J first considered whether Black Hole had established an offsetting claim against Classic Heights that could be quantified in monetary terms. The Court noted that while Black Hole claimed to have a leasehold interest in the premises and that it had been unlawfully evicted, it had not provided any credible evidence to support these claims, particularly regarding the value of its business or any damage it may have suffered. The Court found that there was no basis to conclude that Black Hole had an offsetting claim that could be quantified. Therefore, the Court held that the demand could not be set aside pursuant to s 459H(3).
The Court then considered whether the demand should be set aside for any other reason under s 459J(1)(b). Black Hole argued that the statutory demand was part of an attempt by Classic Heights to dispossess it from the premises and prevent it from pursuing its claims. However, the Court found that Classic Heights had acted consistently with its claim by first attempting to recover arrears of rent and outgoings and then seeking the costs awarded in its favour. The Court held that there was nothing improper in Classic Heights' conduct that would warrant setting aside the demand.
In summary, the Court found that Black Hole had failed to demonstrate an offsetting claim of any quantifiable value and there was no other reason to set the demand aside. The statutory demand was therefore dismissed with costs.