JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: DOG ACT 1976 (WA)
CITATION: BLACK and CITY OF CANNING [2015] WASAT 143
MEMBER: MR P McNAB (SENIOR MEMBER)
HEARD: DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS
DELIVERED : 16 DECEMBER 2015
FILE NO/S: CC 897 of 2015
BETWEEN: ANNE BLACK
Applicant
AND
CITY OF CANNING
Respondent
Catchwords:
Local government Animals Inconsistency of laws Interrelationship between town planning scheme and Dog Act 1976 (WA) Whether laws inconsistent with each other Whether town planning scheme overrides Dog Act 1976 (WA) Held: laws were not inconsistent Both regulatory laws capable of operating concurrently and cumulatively Dogs required application for exemption Town planning scheme dealt with land use Town planning principles contemplated ordinary domestic keeping of animals as pets or as a hobby as ancillary to residential use Companion animals Dogs Local law prescribing maximum number of dogs in residential area Exemption sought for keeping of five dogs Factors to be considered for exemption Good Tribunal and public administration required best and most current information available Matter had yet to be properly evaluated at first instance Matter remitted for reconsideration by City of Canning Words and phrases: 'Kennel'
Legislation:
City of Canning Town Planning Scheme No 40
Dog Act 1976 (WA), s 26, s 26(3)
Planning Act 1982 (SA)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 31(1), s 60(2)
Waterworks Act 1932 (SA)
Result:
Extension of time granted
Matter remitted for reconsideration
Summary of Tribunal's decision:
Only two dogs may be kept in the City of Canning unless the City approves otherwise. The applicant, Ms Black, wanted to keep five dogs at her residential premises. The City refused her application on the grounds that to do so would avoid a prohibition on the 'Kennel' use of land. The prohibition was found in the City's town planning scheme. The City argued that the discretion appearing in the Dog Act 1976 (WA) to permit the keeping of more than two dogs was, in effect, illusory, as the town planning scheme governed the fate of Ms Black's application.
The Tribunal disagreed. There was clear authority at the highest level that demonstrated that separate laws directed at planning controls and the regulation of dogs were capable of operating concurrently (and cumulatively). Each law had a distinct purpose. They could both comfortably work together in the same field.
Moreover, the City's consideration of the matter had apparently ignored other authority which showed that planning controls contemplated that the ordinary domestic keeping of animals as pets or as a hobby was ancillary to residential use of land. If so, a prohibition on 'Kennel' land use in residential areas would have no application to Ms Black.
Good public administration required the Tribunal to consider the 'best and most current information available' to it. The information before the Tribunal was out of date. Further, the City having been sidetracked into erroneously considering planning issues, was yet to consider the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Black and City Of Canning and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] WASAT 143
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The SAT considered whether the two sets of laws were inconsistent and whether they could operate concurrently and cumulatively. The SAT noted that the town planning scheme dealt with land use and contemplated the ordinary domestic keeping of animals as pets or as a hobby as ancillary to residential use. The SAT found that the laws were not inconsistent and that both sets of laws could operate concurrently and cumulatively. The SAT also noted that the City of Canning's town planning scheme did not prescribe a maximum number of dogs in a residential area, but rather dealt with land use and contemplated the ordinary domestic keeping of animals as pets or as a hobby as ancillary to residential use.
The SAT concluded that the matter had yet to be properly evaluated at first instance and that the matter ought to be remitted to the City of Canning for reconsideration. The SAT emphasised the importance of good public administration and the need for decision-makers to have regard to the best and most current information available when making a decision. The SAT also noted that the Tribunal had published three decisions in the area of dog exemptions and that sufficient general indicia had emerged to indicate the type of considerations that primary decision-makers (that is, local authorities) ought to be having regard to in this regulatory area.
The SAT made the following orders: the time for commencement of the proceeding was extended until the date of filing, the City of Canning was invited to reconsider its decision, and the matter was to return for directions in the Tribunal on a specified date. The SAT's decision emphasised the importance of good public administration and the need for decision-makers to have regard to the best and most current information available when making a decision.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr. McNab argued that the town planning scheme allowed for the ordinary domestic keeping of animals as pets or for a hobby, which should permit him to keep five dogs. The City of Canning, however, maintained that the Dog Act 1976 (WA) set a limit on the number of dogs that could be kept in residential areas and that this limit should be adhered to. The Tribunal examined the interrelationship between the town planning scheme and the Dog Act 1976 (WA) to determine if both laws could operate concurrently and cumulatively. It was found that the laws were not inconsistent with each other, and dogs required an application for exemption regardless of the town planning scheme's provisions.
The Tribunal emphasised the importance of good tribunal and public administration, which required the best and most current information available when making decisions. It was noted that the matter had yet to be properly evaluated at first instance, and the City of Canning had not considered all relevant factors in its decision-making process. Therefore, the Tribunal decided to remit the matter for reconsideration by the City of Canning, ensuring that the decision was made on reasonably up-to-date material and that all relevant considerations were taken into account. The Tribunal also highlighted that local authorities should structure their primary decision-making and subsequent case in the Tribunal around the emerging indicia of considerations that should be taken into account in this regulatory area.
This matter, Black and City of Canning, came before the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT) as a result of a review application under the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA). The applicant, Mr Black, sought a review of a decision made by the City of Canning, a local government authority, which had denied his application for an exemption to keep five dogs in his residential property. The City of Canning had based its decision on its local town planning scheme, which prescribed a maximum number of dogs allowed in residential areas. Mr Black argued that the town planning scheme was inconsistent with the Dog Act 1976 (WA), and that the two sets of laws could not operate concurrently. The matter was remitted to the City of Canning for reconsideration by the SAT, which found that the matter had not been properly evaluated at first instance and that the best and most current information had not been considered by the City of Canning. The Tribunal highlighted the importance of good public administration and the need for decision-makers to have regard to the best and most current information available. The matter was to return for directions in the Tribunal on a specified date.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is there an inconsistency between the town planning scheme and the Dog Act 1976 (WA)?
2. Does the town planning scheme override the Dog Act 1976 (WA)?
3. Are the town planning scheme and the Dog Act 1976 (WA) capable of operating concurrently and cumulatively?
4. What factors should be considered for an exemption to keep a certain number of dogs in a residential area?
5. What information should be taken into account by the Tribunal when making a decision?
6. Is the Tribunal required to have regard to the best and most current information available when making a decision?
7. Should the matter be remitted to the City of Canning for reconsideration under s 31 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA)?
8. What considerations should the City of Canning take into account in its reconsideration of the exemption application?
Held
1. There is no inconsistency between the town planning scheme and the Dog Act 1976 (WA).
2. The town planning scheme does not override the Dog Act 1976 (WA).
3. The town planning scheme and the Dog Act 1976 (WA) are capable of operating concurrently and cumulatively.
4. Factors to be considered for an exemption to keep a certain number of dogs in a residential area include the ordinary domestic keeping of animals as pets or as a hobby as ancillary to residential use and companion animals.
5. The Tribunal should take into account the best and most current information available when making a decision.
6. The Tribunal is required to have regard to the best and most current information available when making a decision.
7. The matter should be remitted to the City of Canning for reconsideration under s 31 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA).
8. The City of Canning should take into account the factors identified by the Tribunal in its reconsideration of the exemption application.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
However, the Tribunal must make the correct and preferable decision on the material known to it at the time of the review. That material should be reasonably up‑to‑date. In Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31; (2008) 235 CLR 286 Kirby J counselled as follows (at [41], emphasis added):When making a decision, administrative decision-makers are generally obliged to have regard to the best and most current information available. This rule of practice is no more than a feature of good public administration. When, therefore, the Tribunal elects to make 'a decision in substitution for the decision so set aside', as the Act permits, it would be surprising in the extreme if the substituted decision did not have to conform to such a standard. In McLeod, I said at [58] and [59]:The Tribunal has now published three decisions in the area of dog exemptions [cases referred to in the decision] and it is respectfully suggested that sufficient general indicia have now emerged to indicate the type of considerations that primary decision-makers (that is, local authorities) ought to be having regard to in this regulatory area. Thus, in the ordinary case, the Tribunal would expect any respondent Council to structure both their primary decision-making and their subsequent case in the Tribunal around such indicia.Where a respondent has not done so it might be a proper case for the matter to be initially sent back for reconsideration by the local authority under s 31 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA).Accordingly, because the matter should be assessed 'on the best and most current information available' and then be evaluated properly (in the first instance by the Council itself), the matter ought, as McLeod suggests, to be remitted to the respondent for reconsideration, such reconsideration to be, of course, consistent with these reasons. For the reasons given above, the Tribunal makes the following orders:1.Pursuant to r 10 of the State Administrative Tribunal Rules 2004 (WA), the time for commencement of this proceeding is extended until the date of filing, namely, 15 June 2015.2.Pursuant to s 31(1) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), the respondent is invited to reconsider its decision.3.The matter is to return for directions in the Tribunal on 22 January 2016.I certify that this and the preceding [38] paragraphs comprise the reasons for decision of the State Administrative Tribunal.___________________________________MR P McNAB, SENIOR MEMBER