BKCZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

BKCZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2022] AATA 725 (8 April 2022)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):2021/2964      

Re:BKCZ  

APPLICANT

Child Support RegistrarAnd  

RESPONDENT

AndHBVN

OTHER PARTY

Tribunal:Senior Member B. Pola

Date:8 April 2022

Place:Brisbane

DECISION

Pursuant to section 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal affirms the decision of the Social Security and Child Support Division, dated 13 April 2021.

...........................[SGD]...............................

Senior Member Belinda Pola

Names used in this published decision are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (here in referred to as the “Collection Act”).

Catchwords –

CHILD SUPPORT – objection to care percentage change – special circumstances – reasonable action – interim care determination – point in time – actual care – Federal Court parenting orders – COVID-19 Lockdowns – COVID-19 border closures – decision affirmed

Legislation -

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases -
Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
F v LP (Child Support) [2015] AATA 321
Shi v Migration Agent Review Authority [2008] HCA 31

Secondary Materials -

Guides to Social Policy Law, Child Support Guide, Version 4.57, released 1 July 2021

REASONS FOR DECISION

Belinda Pola, Senior Member
8 April 2022

BACKGROUND

1.       The Applicant, BKCZ (or the “mother”), has brought an application to the Tribunal to review a decision dated 13 April 2021 of the Social Security and Child Support Division (here in referred to as the “SSCSD”) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (here in referred to as the “Tribunal”). The Respondent in this matter is the Child Support Registrar (here in referred to as the “CSR”). The Other Party, HBVN (or the “father”), in this matter is the other party joined in this application.

2.       The mother and father are the parents of two minor children, aged 16 years and 14 years. The two children predominantly reside with their mother in Queensland, with the father of the two children residing in Western Australia.

3.       The existing percentage of care determinations with respect to care provided by the mother and the father were determined in accordance with parenting orders of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia dated 8 April 2013 and amended on 17 December 2013 (here in referred to as the “parenting orders”)[1].

[1] Exhibit R2, page 2, paragraph 8; and Exhibit O1, pages 4 to 8.

4.       The parenting orders provide for the father to have care of the two children for at least 10 days during Term 1, 2 and 3 school holidays, and for half the Christmas/New Year holidays on an alternate…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BKCZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 725
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review of a child support assessment by the Child Support Registrar, brought before the court by the applicant, BKCZ, against the Child Support Registrar. The dispute centred on the Registrar's decision to depart from the standard child support formula assessment, which had been previously reviewed.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Registrar had erred in departing from the standard child support assessment, and if so, whether the court should substitute its own assessment or remit the matter back to the Registrar. Specifically, the court had to consider the application of section 117 of the *Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1998* (Cth), which permits departure from the standard assessment in certain circumstances, and the principles governing the exercise of such discretion.

The court's reasoning focused on the evidence presented regarding the capacity of the parties and the needs of the child. It applied the principles established in case law concerning the interpretation and application of section 117, emphasising that a departure from the standard assessment requires compelling reasons and that the court must be satisfied that the departure is just and equitable. The court considered whether the Registrar had properly weighed all relevant factors, including the financial circumstances of both parents and the best interests of the child, in reaching their decision.

Ultimately, the court found that the Registrar had not erred in their decision to depart from the standard assessment. Consequently, the court made orders affirming the Registrar's decision and dismissed the application for review.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a review of a decision made by the Social Security and Child Support Division (SSCSD) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) regarding a change in care percentage determinations for two minor children. The mother and father of the children, BKCZ and HBVN respectively, have been subject to parenting orders since 2013, which outlined the care arrangements for their children. According to these orders, the children were to spend certain periods during school holidays with their father in Western Australia, while primarily residing with their mother in Queensland.

In March 2020, due to the COVID-19 pandemic and the subsequent border closures between Queensland and Western Australia, the parents mutually agreed that the children could not travel to Western Australia for the scheduled school holidays. On 22 March 2020, the mother notified the Child Support Agency of this change in care arrangements, resulting in a new care percentage determination of 89% for the mother and 11% for the father, effective from 8 April 2020. The father objected to this decision on 3 May 2020, leading to a review by the SSCSD of the AAT on 13 April 2021. The SSCSD set aside the objection decision and determined that there had been no change in the care of the children from 8 April 2020.

The mother subsequently applied for a second review of this decision with the General Division of the AAT, which heard the matter on 22 March 2022. The Tribunal determined it was reasonable to hold a hearing by telephone, considering the nature of the matter and the individual circumstances of the parents and their geographic locations. The Tribunal received submitted written evidence from all parties as outlined in the Exhibit Register.

The Tribunal found that the father had taken reasonable action to ensure compliance with the parenting orders for the July 2020 and September 2020 school holiday periods, and that the mother's claims regarding the cost of quarantine arrangements were unsubstantiated. The Tribunal also found that the border restrictions and quarantine requirements in place during the April 2020 school holidays were of a temporary and non-permanent nature.

Based on these findings, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the SSCSD of the AAT, dated 13 April 2021, maintaining the care percentages applied in the assessment at 14% for HBVN and 86% for BKCZ from 8 April 2020.

BKCZ, the mother, lodged an application for a second review with the General Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AATA), challenging a decision of the Social Security and Child Support Division (SSCSD) of the AATA dated 13 April 2021. The SSCSD decision was in relation to the mother's objection against a decision made by the Child Support Registrar on 29 April 2020. The Registrar's decision had revoked the existing care percentage determinations of 86% to the mother and 14% to the father, and established new care percentages of 89% to the mother and 11% to the father, with effect from 8 April 2020. The matter was heard in Brisbane on 22 March 2022 by phone with all parties appearing and making oral submissions. The Tribunal affirmed the earlier decision of the SSCSD.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What was the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and the state border restrictions on the care arrangements for the children?
2. Did the father take reasonable action to ensure compliance with the care arrangements in place, as stipulated in section 51(1) of the Assessment Act?
3. Were there any special circumstances, as defined in the Child Support Guide, that justified the Tribunal to determine a single percentage of care, rather than two percentages of care, as stipulated in sections 51(2) to (4) of the Assessment Act?
4. Should the Tribunal adopt a point-in-time approach in determining the care percentage, or consider the actual care of the children during the care period?
5. Did the mother's claims about the cost of quarantine arrangements upon the children's return to Queensland substantiate her claims that the children could not travel to Western Australia for the July 2020 and September 2020 school holidays?

Held
1. The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and the state border restrictions on the care arrangements for the children was that the children could not travel to Western Australia for the April 2020 school holidays due to the closure of state borders. The Tribunal found that this was of a temporary/non-permanent nature.
2. The father took reasonable action to ensure compliance with the care arrangements in place, as stipulated in section 51(1) of the Assessment Act. He provided notice to the mother, made flight bookings, complied with border restrictions, and informed the mother of quarantine arrangements.
3. There were no special circumstances, as defined in the Child Support Guide, that justified the Tribunal to determine a single percentage of care, rather than two percentages of care, as stipulated in sections 51(2) to (4) of the Assessment Act.
4. The Tribunal adopted a point-in-time approach in determining the care percentage, considering the pattern of care the parents had in the past care period up to the date of notification of the change, and the pattern of care that the parents are likely to have in the care period after the date of notification.
5. The mother's claims about the cost of quarantine arrangements upon the children's return to Queensland for the July 2020 and September 2020 school holidays did not substantiate her claims that the children could not travel to Western Australia. The Tribunal found that the mother did not provide evidence to support her claims regarding the cost of quarantine arrangements.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began its analysis by considering the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and the state border restrictions on the care arrangements for the children. The Tribunal found that the border closures and restrictions were temporary and did not result in a permanent change in the care pattern for the children. The Tribunal concluded that there had been no change in the care of the children from 8 April 2020, and therefore, the existing care percentages should remain at 14% for the father and 86% for the mother.

Next, the court examined whether the father took reasonable action to ensure compliance with the care arrangements in place, as stipulated in section 51(1) of the Assessment Act. The Tribunal found that the father took reasonable action to comply with the parenting orders by providing the mother with notice of the flight bookings, complying with the Western Australian government restrictions, and seeking exemption passes for his children to cross the state border. The Tribunal also noted that the father went out of his way to inform the mother of quarantine arrangements in Queensland, in correspondence with her when seeking to comply with the parenting orders.

Regarding the special circumstances, the court found that they were not established in the present application per the definition provided in the Child Support Guide. The Tribunal concluded that special circumstances may include circumstances that relate to the child directly as well as circumstances that relate to another individual, to the extent that those circumstances also relate to the child. In this case, the Tribunal found that the father's actions were reasonable and did not warrant the determination of a single percentage of care.

The court then considered whether the Tribunal should adopt a point-in-time approach in determining the care percentage, or consider the actual care of the children during the care period. The Tribunal concluded that the circumstances of this case justified a point-in-time approach with respect to the application of sections 49 and 50 of the Assessment Act. The Tribunal found that it was open to the Tribunal to consider the pattern of care the parents actually had in the care period, given the care period is retrospective.

Finally, the court examined the mother's claims about the cost of quarantine arrangements upon the children's return to Queensland for the July 2020 and September 2020 school holidays. The Tribunal found that the mother's evidence did not substantiate her claims with respect to the extent and cost (if any) relating to quarantine arrangements upon her children's return to Queensland. The Tribunal concluded that there were no similar border restrictions in place for the July 2020 and September 2020 school holidays, as were in place for the April 2020 school holidays.

In conclusion, the court found that the father took reasonable action to ensure compliance with the care arrangements in place, and that there were no special circumstances that warranted the determination of a single percentage of care. The Tribunal adopted a point-in-time approach in determining the care percentage, and found that the mother's claims about the cost of quarantine arrangements upon the children's return to Queensland were unsubstantiated. Therefore, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the Social Security and Child Support Division, dated 13 April 2021, that is, no permanent change in the care pattern for the children occurred on 22 March 2020, and that the care percentages applied in the assessment should remain at 14% to the father, and 86% to the mother from 8 April 2020.