BKCZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

BKCZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2024] AATA 2359 (10 July 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/2964

Re:BKCZ

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndHBVN

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member B. Pola

Date:10 July 2024

Place:Brisbane

The decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal dated 13 April 2021 is set aside pursuant to sub-section 43(1)(c)(i) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), and in substitution it is determined:

(a)the existing percentage of care determination is revoked pursuant to section 54G(1) of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) with effect from 7 April 2020;

(b)a determination is made pursuant to sub-sections 50(1) and (2) of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) that from 7 April 2020 to 6 October 2020, the percentage of care is 14% to the Other Party, and 86% to the Applicant; and

(c)a determination is made pursuant to sub-sections 50(1) and (2) of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) that from 7 October 2020 to 6 April 2021, the percentage of care is 7% to the Other Party, and 93% to the Applicant.

..................................[SGD]......................................

Senior Member B. Pola

Catchwords

CHILD SUPPORT – remittal from Federal Court of Australia – review of Social Services and Child Support Division decision – where arrangements for care of children affected by COVID-19 pandemic – whether change of pattern of care took place – where actual care to be considered – where Other Party had taken reasonable steps to comply with existing arrangements – change of pattern of care occurred – decision set aside and substituted

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)
Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth)
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)
Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)

Cases
Child Support Registrar v BKCZ [2023] FCA 1109
Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Child Support Registrar v DQFY [2023] FCA 601 (7 June 2023)

Secondary Materials

Child Support Guide

Names used in this published decision are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)-16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth).

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member B. Pola

10 July 2024

  1. The matter before this Tribunal is the reconsideration of an application to review a decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal dated 13 April 2021, on remittal from the Federal Court of Australia pursuant to orders made by Justice Thomas on 18 September 2023.

    Background

  2. The Applicant (or “BKCZ”, or “Mother”) and the Other Party (or “HBVN”, or “Father”) are the separated parents of two children born in 2006 and 2007 (herein referred to as “the children”). The Applicant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BKCZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 2359
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a review of a decision by the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, remitted from the Federal Court of Australia. The dispute involved separated parents, BKCZ (the Applicant/Mother) and HBVN (the Other Party/Father), regarding the percentage of care for their two children, born in 2006 and 2007. Existing parenting orders stipulated that the children primarily resided with the Applicant, with the Other Party having specific periods of care. A change in care arrangements occurred in March 2020 due to COVID-19 border closures, preventing the children from travelling to Western Australia for school holidays.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether a change in the pattern of care had taken place from 22 March 2020, and consequently, whether the existing percentage of care determinations should be revoked. The Tribunal was required to consider the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the agreed care arrangements and to determine the actual care arrangements in light of the circumstances. The Tribunal was also bound by the orders of the Federal Court on remittal.

The Tribunal found that a change in the pattern of care occurred from 22 March 2020, when both parents mutually agreed that the children would not travel to Western Australia for the Term 1 school holidays due to border closures. The Tribunal considered the relevant provisions of the Assessment Act, specifically sections 54G, 54F, and 54H, concerning the revocation of care determinations. It was satisfied that the existing care percentage determinations were made under section 50 of the Assessment Act, which deals with situations where a responsible person has had a pattern of care. The Tribunal accepted the Applicant's evidence that she had care of the children for the entirety of 2020 due to the pandemic, travel restrictions, and quarantine reasons, and that the Other Party had not advanced claims for make-up time at the hearing.

The Tribunal set aside the original decision and substituted a new percentage of care determination, reflecting the actual care arrangements during the relevant period.

Background

Background to the litigation

The matter before this Tribunal is the reconsideration of an application to review a decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal dated 13 April 2021, on remittal from the Federal Court of Australia pursuant to orders made by Justice Thomas on 18 September 2023.Background The Applicant (or “BKCZ”, or “Mother”) and the Other Party (or “HBVN”, or “Father”) are the separated parents of two children born in 2006 and 2007 (herein referred to as “the children”). The Applicant in this matter resides in Queensland and the Other Party resides in Western Australia. Parenting orders were issued by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia on 8 April 2013, and were amended on 17 December 2013 (herein referred to as the “Parenting Orders”). The Respondent (or the “Child Support Registrar”) was notified of these orders on 24 April 2013. The Parenting Orders provide for the Other Party to have care of the children for at least 10 days during the Term 1, 2 and 3 school holidays, and 21 days over the Christmas/New Year holidays, and at all other times the children are in the care of the Applicant[1].[1] Exhibit R3, page 7, paragraph 24 to 26, and 28-31, and Annexure A. From 20 January 2016, the Respondent recorded the existing percentage of care determination as 86% to the Applicant and 14% to the Other Party. On 22 March 2020, it was agreed between the Applicant and the Other Party by way of text messages exchanged between both parties, that the children would not be travelling to Western Australia due to border closures as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic and restrictions on interstate travel[2]. [2] Exhibit TR1, T6, page 49. On the same day, the Applicant informed the Child Support Agency of a change in the pattern of care of the children, stating, “… Due to covid 19 the kids will not be going to WA for school holidays, so care will change by 10 days at this stage, but could be more. Therefore his care is reduced by 10 days…”[3].[3] Exhibit TR1, T5, page 40. On 29 April 2020, the Other Party disputed the change in care arrangements on the basis that state borders were closed and the flights he had purchased for his children had been cancelled, and he had no choice in the matter. The Other Party advised the Child Support Agency that, “… he was due to have the children from the 08/04/2020 and they were not due to go back until Monday 20/04/2020 as she was not able to get flights…”[4]. [4] Exhibit TR1, T5, page 46. On 29 April 2020, an Authorised Review Officer (herein referred to as an “ARO”) of the Respondent made a percentage of care decision (herein referred to as the “original decision”) that revoked the existing percentage of care determinations for both children with effect from 7 April 2020, and made a new percentage of care determination with effect from 8 April 2020, of 89% care to the Applicant and 11% to the Other Party. Whilst it was not explicitly stated in the new percentage of care determination, it appears that this determination was for a period of 12 months[5].[5] Exhibit TR1, T8, pages 51 to 54.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant gave oral evidence at the hearing in support of her position. The Applicant spoke about the uncertain situation during the COVID-19 pandemic[18]: BKCZ: … in general terms, 2020 was the year of COVID. I was very unsure of what's going on and where, and I did the best I could in a situation of not knowing what was going on and (indistinct words)… Just generally that I had care of (indistinct) for the year of 2020 due to COVID. I did (indistinct) the best interests of the children; travel quarantine reasons and a whole lot of other reasons, hard border closures in WA versus us in Queensland. There's no dispute that they were with me…”[18] Transcript, p 8, lines 1-5; and 21-30.Summary of Other Party’s evidence at remittal hearing The Other Party gave oral evidence at the hearing in support of his position. The Other Party spoke about make-up time that he claims could have taken place with respect to the care of the children during the relevant time[19]:HBVN: … I think there's two arguments here; there's the point in time with the care, but there's also the argument from my side which was make-up time could have been made up – which could have been made up. So it’s over the 12 months is the period of time where it could have been made up over the next school holidays or the Christmas holidays. There was ample opportunity and it was never done…”[19] Transcript, p 8, lines 39-46; p 9, lines 1-6. With respect to the Father’s original claims regarding the care of their children, specifically, spending nights in care at the home of their maternal grandparents every second week, no such claims were advanced during the course of the AAT2 hearing and the remittal hearing (noting the Father was provided with the opportunity to make opening submissions and to clarify any aspect of his evidence he has given to the Tribunal)[20]. With respect to this claim, the Tribunal makes no finding, given the lack of supporting evidence and the failure of the Father to advance such claims at the hearing of the AAT2 decision in addition to this remittal hearing.[20] Exhibit TR1, T10, page 70.Consideration The Tribunal accepts that it is appropriate to address the issues raised by His Honour Justice Thomas on remittal of this matter, and that the Tribunal is bound by Justice Thomas’ orders, which reflect His Honour’s judicial consideration of the application before the Tribunal[21]. [21] Rule 39.11(3) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth). Further, the AAT Act requires the Tribunal to consider the redetermination of an application in accordance with the directions of the Court[22]. [22] Section 44(5) of the Administrative Appeals Act 1975 (Cth).Was there a change in the pattern of care? The Tribunal finds that there was a change to the pattern of care from 22 March 2020, when it was mutually agreed between the Applicant and the Other Party that the children would not travel to Western Australia for the Term 1 holiday in April 2020 (being 8 April 2020 to 18 April 2020 (10 nights)). This is discussed more fulsomely in the reasons which follow.Should the existing percentage of care determinations be revoked?

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 4 of the Collection Act defines a “care percentage decision” to be:“…care percentage decision means a decision as to the particulars of an administrative assessment, or as to the particulars of a notional assessment, to the extent that the decision involves (wholly or partly):(a)a determination of a person’s percentage of care for a child that was made under a provision of Subdivision B of Division 4 of Part 5 of the Assessment Act; or(b)a determination relating to a person that has effect, under section 54K of that Act, as if it were a determination made under such a provision…” The Tribunal must consider both sections 49 and 50 of the Assessment Act in considering the remitted matter with respect to each parent. The provisions of the Act are:“… 49Determination of percentage of care—responsible person has had etc. no pattern of care for a child(1) This section applies if:(a) either of the following applies:(i) an application is made under section 25 or 25A for a parent to be assessed in respect of the costs of the child;(ii) a parent is taken under section 73A to have had a relevant dependent child from a day specified in that section;and the Registrar is satisfied that a responsible person for the child has had, or is likely to have, no pattern of care for the child during such period (the care period) as the Registrar considers to be appropriate having regard to all the circumstances; or(b) both of the following apply:(i) the determination of a responsible person’s percentage of care for a child that was made under this section or section 50 is revoked or suspended under Subdivision C of this Division, except under paragraph 54FA(3)(b) or 54HA(3)(b);(ii) the Registrar is satisfied that the responsible person has had, or is likely to have, no pattern of care for the child during such period (the care period) as the Registrar considers to be appropriate having regard to all the circumstances.(2) The Registrar must determine the responsible person’s percentage of care for the child during the care period.(3) The percentage of care determined under subsection (2) must be 0%, unless section 51 applies in relation to the responsible person…”“… 50 Determination of percentage of care—responsible person has had etc. a pattern of care for a child (1) This section applies if:(a)either of the following applies:(i) an application is made under section 25 or 25A for a parent to be assessed in respect of the costs of the child;(ii) a parent is taken under section 73A to have had a relevant dependent child from a day specified in that section;and the Registrar is satisfied that a responsible person for the child has had, or is likely to have, a pattern of care for the child during such period (the care period) as the Registrar considers to be appropriate having regard to all the circumstances; or(b)both of the following apply:(i) the determination of a responsible person’s percentage of care for a child that was made under section 49 or this section is revoked or suspended under Subdivision C of this Division, except under paragraph 54FA(3)(b) or 54HA(3)(b);(ii) the Registrar is satisfied that the responsible person has had, or is likely to have, a pattern of care for the child during such period (the care period) as the Registrar considers to be appropriate having regard to all the circumstances.(2) The Registrar must determine the responsible person’s percentage of care for the child during the care period.(3) The percentage determined under subsection (2) must be a percentage that corresponds with the actual care of the child that the Registrar is satisfied that the responsible person has had, or is likely to have, during the care period.(4) Subsection (3) does not apply if section 51 applies in relation to the responsible person…”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

With respect to the Father’s original claims regarding the care of their children, specifically, spending nights in care at the home of their maternal grandparents every second week, no such claims were advanced during the course of the AAT2 hearing and the remittal hearing (noting the Father was provided with the opportunity to make opening submissions and to clarify any aspect of his evidence he has given to the Tribunal)[20]. With respect to this claim, the Tribunal makes no finding, given the lack of supporting evidence and the failure of the Father to advance such claims at the hearing of the AAT2 decision in addition to this remittal hearing.[20] Exhibit TR1, T10, page 70.Consideration The Tribunal accepts that it is appropriate to address the issues raised by His Honour Justice Thomas on remittal of this matter, and that the Tribunal is bound by Justice Thomas’ orders, which reflect His Honour’s judicial consideration of the application before the Tribunal[21]. [21] Rule 39.11(3) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth). Further, the AAT Act requires the Tribunal to consider the redetermination of an application in accordance with the directions of the Court[22]. [22] Section 44(5) of the Administrative Appeals Act 1975 (Cth).Was there a change in the pattern of care? The Tribunal finds that there was a change to the pattern of care from 22 March 2020, when it was mutually agreed between the Applicant and the Other Party that the children would not travel to Western Australia for the Term 1 holiday in April 2020 (being 8 April 2020 to 18 April 2020 (10 nights)). This is discussed more fulsomely in the reasons which follow.Should the existing percentage of care determinations be revoked? Subdivision C of Division 4 of Part 5 of the Assessment Act provides for circumstances where existing percentage of care determinations must or may be revoked. The operation of the statute is that section 54F of the Assessment Act applies if section 54G of the Assessment Act does not apply; and section 54H of the Assessment Act applies if sections 54F and 54G of the Assessment Act do not apply. Consequently, the Tribunal must first consider whether section 54G of the Assessment Act has application. Section 54G of the Assessment Act deals with the revocation of a determination made under section 50 of the Assessment Act where a parent has had a pattern of care “that is less than regular care of the child”. The phrase “regular care” is defined in sub-sections 5(1) and (2) of the Assessment Act as being “at least 14% but less than 35%”.Does section 54G of the Assessment Act apply? The Tribunal is satisfied the existing care percentage determinations between the Applicant and the Other Party were made pursuant to section 50 of the Assessment Act. This is more fulsomely detailed by the Tribunal in the latter reasons of this decision. Having established this, the Tribunal can consider the remaining relevant provisions of sub-section 54G(1)(b) to (d) of the Assessment Act, that is whether the:(a)Other Party has had less than 14% care of the children;(b)Applicant has made the children available to the Other Party; and (c)Applicant notified the Registrar that the Other Party had less than regular care within a reasonable period.