Bizannes v AAI Limited t/as GIO

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 

Citation:

Bizannes v AAI Limited t/as GIO [2023] NSWPIC 135

Claimant: Tom Bizannes
insurer: AAI Limited t/as GIO
SENIOR Member: Brett Williams
DATE OF DECISION: 29 March 2023

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; miscellaneous claims assessment; claimant suffered injury while alighting from a bus at a bus stop; whether for the purposes of section 3.1 the injury resulted from a motor accident in this State; consideration of sections 1.9, 1.4 and 3.1; whether inference can be drawn as to reason for actions of passenger in front of claimant where there was a gap of between two to four feet between the stairs of the bus and the curb; Seltsam Pty Limited v McGuiness; James Hardie & Coy Pty Limited v McGuiness, McLennan v Nominal Defendant, State of New South Wales v Fuller-Lyons, Nominal Defendant v Hawkins, Leach v The Nominal Defendant and Toll Pty Ltd v Harradine applied; Held – where it was found that the bus had been parked at an angle to the curb, and that the distance between the bottom step of the bus and the curb was between two to four feet, and having regard to the apparent logic of events, inference drawn that the passenger in front of the claimant stopped on the bottom step of the bus as he was alighting, and stepped back, because he perceived the gap between the step and the curb and needed to judge the distance between either the step and the road or the step and the curb, before alighting from the bus; the effective cause of the incident was a combination of the position in which the bus had been brought to a stop and the actions of the passenger when confronted with the gap; one proximate cause of the injury was the driving of the bus; injury was a result of both the driving of the bus and a dangerous situation caused by the driving of the bus; the injury was caused during both the driving of the bus and a dangerous situation caused by the driving of the bus; the injury fell within the terms of section 1.9 and resulted from a “motor accident”; having established that his injury results from a motor accident in this State, the claimant is entitled to statutory benefits under Part 3; section 3.1(1) has been satisfied.

determinations made:

Certificate

The findings of the assessment of this dispute are as follows:

1. For the purposes of s 3.1 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 the injury to the claimant's left ankle on 8 May 2019 resulted from a motor accident in this State.

REASONS FOR DECISION

BACKGROUND

  1. Tom Bizannes suffered an injury to his left ankle on 8 May 2019 when he was alighting from a bus at Central Station (injury). He subsequently made a claim for personal injury benefits (statutory benefits) under part 3 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the MAI…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bizannes v AAI Limited t/as GIO and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPIC 135
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Bizannes v AAI Limited t/as GIO, the plaintiff, Bizannes, sought to establish whether the injury he sustained while alighting from a bus qualified as a motor accident under the Motor Accidents Injuries Act 2017. The defendant, AAI Limited trading as GIO, contested the claim, arguing that the injury did not result from a motor accident as defined by the legislation. The dispute was heard by the court, which was tasked with determining whether the injury Bizannes suffered fell within the parameters of a motor accident under the Act.

The central legal issue before the court was to ascertain whether Bizannes’ injury resulted from a motor accident in accordance with section 3.1 of the Motor Accidents Injuries Act 2017. The court had to interpret the relevant sections of the Act, particularly sections 1.9, 1.4, and 3.1, and determine if the injury was caused by the driving of the bus and a dangerous situation created by the driving of the bus. This required an examination of the circumstances surrounding the incident, including the position of the bus, the gap between the bus steps and the curb, and the actions of the passenger in front of Bizannes.

The court found that the bus had been parked at an angle to the curb, resulting in a gap of between two to four feet between the bottom step of the bus and the curb. Considering the logical sequence of events, it was inferred that the passenger in front of Bizannes stopped on the bottom step and stepped back because he perceived the gap and needed to judge the distance before alighting. The court concluded that the effective cause of the incident was a combination of the position in which the bus had been brought to a stop and the actions of the passenger when confronted with the gap. Thus, the injury resulted from both the driving of the bus and a dangerous situation caused by the driving of the bus, satisfying the criteria under section 1.9 of the Act. The court held that the injury was a result of the motor accident, and Bizannes was entitled to statutory benefits under Part 3 of the Motor Accidents Injuries Act 2017.

Having established that the injury resulted from a motor accident in this State, the court determined that Bizannes is entitled to statutory benefits under Part 3 of the Act. Section 3.1(1) was thus satisfied, and the court ruled in favour of Bizannes.

Background

Background to the litigation

The claimant in this case, Bizannes, suffered an injury while alighting from a bus at a bus stop. The bus had been parked at an angle to the curb, creating a gap of between two to four feet between the stairs of the bus and the curb. The claimant attempted to step down from the bus but tripped and fell, resulting in the injury. The nature of the incident and the circumstances under which the injury occurred were central to the dispute. The bus driver had driven the vehicle and parked it at the bus stop, and the gap between the bus and the curb was a result of the bus being parked at an angle.

This case came before the court for the purpose of assessing the claimant's entitlement to statutory benefits under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. The matter was considered on the basis of the facts as presented and the arguments made by both parties. The claimant sought to establish that the injury resulted from a motor accident within the meaning of the Act. The court was required to determine whether the injury fell within the scope of the statutory provisions and if the claimant was entitled to the benefits provided under Part 3 of the Act.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether for the purposes of section 3.1 the injury resulted from a motor accident in this State.
2. Whether the injury resulted from a dangerous situation caused by the driving of the bus.
3. Whether the injury fell within the terms of section 1.9 and resulted from a “motor accident” as defined by the Act.

Held
1. The court concluded that the injury resulted from a motor accident in this State for the purposes of section 3.1.
2. The court determined that the injury resulted from a dangerous situation caused by the driving of the bus.
3. The court held that the injury fell within the terms of section 1.9 and resulted from a "motor accident" as defined by the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the claimant's injury, which occurred while alighting from a bus at a bus stop. The primary issue was whether the injury resulted from a motor accident in this State under section 3.1 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. The court also examined whether the injury resulted from a dangerous situation caused by the driving of the bus and whether it fell within the terms of section 1.9, which defines a "motor accident."

In addressing these issues, the court applied the provisions of sections 1.9, 1.4, and 3.1 of the Act. The court reasoned that the bus had been parked at an angle to the curb, resulting in a gap of between two to four feet between the bottom step of the bus and the curb. Given this information and the logical sequence of events, the court inferred that the passenger in front of the claimant stopped on the bottom step of the bus and stepped back because he perceived the gap and needed to judge the distance before alighting.

The court drew on several precedents to support its reasoning. In Seltsam Pty Limited v McGuiness, James Hardie & Coy Pty Limited v McGuiness, McLennan v Nominal Defendant, State of New South Wales v Fuller-Lyons, Nominal Defendant v Hawkins, Leach v The Nominal Defendant, and Toll Pty Ltd v Harradine, the court considered the circumstances leading to the injury and the role of the bus driver's actions. The court found that the effective cause of the incident was a combination of the position in which the bus had been brought to a stop and the actions of the passenger when confronted with the gap.

One proximate cause of the injury was the driving of the bus, as it created a dangerous situation by causing the gap between the step and the curb. The court concluded that the injury was a result of both the driving of the bus and the dangerous situation caused by the driving of the bus. Given this finding, the injury fell within the terms of section 1.9 and resulted from a "motor accident." Having established that the claimant's injury results from a motor accident in this State, the court held that section 3.1(1) has been satisfied, entitling the claimant to statutory benefits under Part 3 of the Act.