Bit Badger Pty Ltd v Cunich

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND

Brisbane  No. 188 of 1994

Before the Hon Justice White

[Bit Badger Pty Ltd v. Cunich]

BETWEEN:

BIT BADGER PTY LTD
  Plaintiff

AND:

MICHAEL RAYMOND CUNICH
  Defendant

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - WHITE J

Judgment delivered 04/06/1996

CATCHWORDS      LANDLORD and tenant - wh. lease relieves tenant of liability for loss from fire due to tenant's negligence - insurance.

Counsel:Mr W Sofronoff QC for the plaintiff

With him Mr J Bond

Mr P Lyons QC for the defendant

With him Mr P Applegarth

Solicitors:Feez Ruthning for the plaintiff

Quinlan Miller & Treston for the defendant

Hearing Date:   10 February 1995

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND

No. 188 of 1994

[Bit Badger Pty Ltd v. Cunich]

BETWEEN:

BIT BADGER PTY LTD
  Plaintiff

AND:

MICHAEL RAYMOND CUNICH
  Defendant

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - WHITE J

Judgment delivered 04/06/1996

The plaintiff as landlord has commenced a writ action dated 11 February 1994 against the defendant as tenant for damages for the cost of reinstating a building and loss of rent occasioned by fire allegedly due to the default of the defendant.  By order of Moynihan SJA made pursuant to O.39 r.12 certain questions have been heard separately.  The plaintiff has filed a statement of facts and documents which the court is to take into account when answering the questions posed.
           The plaintiff is the registered owner of certain land on which was erected a building at 183 Wellington Road, East Brisbane.  By a registered lease dated 5 March 1991 the plaintiff demised to the defendant those premises and land for a term of three years commencing on 23 February 1991 and terminating on 22 February 1994.  The defendant carried on the business, inter alia, of importing, assembling, wholesaling and retailing furniture and ancillary articles at the premises.
           On or about 31 July 1991 the plaintiff renewed a contract of insurance with NZI Insurance Australia Limited ("the insurer") pursuant to which the insurer agreed to provide the plaintiff with insurance cover in respect of the premises, inter alia, for fire cover.  That contract was for the period 31 July 1991 to 31 July 1992.  The defendant was not a co-insured with the plaintiff under the contract of insurance.  Pursuant to the lease the defendant paid to the plaintiff a variable charge in each accounting period which included amounts paid by the plaintiff for insurance premiums for insurance of the premises against fire.
Assumed Facts
           On the evening of 4 June 1992 the defendant was working at a workbench in the building using a grinder to sharpen drill bits when sparks caused by that process ignited used rags kept in the vicinity of the workbench.  Prior to that date the defendant and his employees had used mineral turpentine and woodfill in carrying out their work in the building.  The plaintiff alleges that the air in the building around the workbench where the grinding was carried out was filled with flammable fumes.  This allegation is denied by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bit Badger Pty Ltd v Cunich and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1996] QSC 100
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bit Badger Pty Ltd, as the landlord, brought a lawsuit against Michael Raymond Cunich, the tenant, to recover damages for the cost of repairing a building and lost rent after a fire allegedly caused by the tenant's negligence. The court was required to decide whether the lease implied a term relieving the tenant of liability for loss from fire due to the tenant's negligence, if the landlord's receipt of insurance moneys had fully indemnified the landlord, and whether the lease excluded the landlord's right to recover damages from the tenant caused by the fire due to the tenant's negligence. The court examined the lease terms, the insurance contract, and relevant authorities from Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and the United States. The court found that the lease did not imply a term relieving the tenant of liability for loss from fire due to the tenant's negligence, nor did it fully indemnify the landlord against the tenant's negligence. The court also found that the lease did not exclude the landlord's right to recover damages from the tenant caused by the fire due to the tenant's negligence. The court held that the tenant remained liable for the fire damage caused by his negligence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established